Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the thousandth session of the Federal Council on February 12, 2021, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

16 February 2021 · Thousandth session of the Federal Council · Federal Council, Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed the Bundesrat's thousandth plenary session on February 12, 2021, in Berlin, reflecting on federalism and the COVID-19 crisis.
Main themes
German federalism, Bundesrat milestone, COVID-19 pandemic response, federal-state cooperation, democratic governance, crisis management, lockdown and public patience, vaccination and hope, unity in diversity, digitalization and environmental policy
Duration
~23 min
71st percentile
Words
2,711
71st percentile
Sentences
130
75th percentile
Readability
40
37th percentile
Grade
12.7
54th percentile
Syntax
3.08
58th percentile
Vocabulary
2.22
54th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 81%81%
  • Social 10%10%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

130 sentences in 31 paragraphs

Celebrations are rare here, and when they do occur, they are brief. You have set yourselves a lot to accomplish for this anniversary session.

As soon as "Agenda Item 1 – Address by the Federal President" is completed, more than eighty documents are waiting for discussion today alone. Yes, in the Bundesrat, even the thousandth plenary session is primarily a working session. You are faced with the "Proposal for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on a Pilot Scheme for Market Infrastructures Based on Distributed Ledger Technology" and the "Draft Law on the Water Management Expansion of Federal Waterways to Achieve the Management Objectives of the Water Framework Directive."

Such cumbersome terms are sometimes laughed at, but behind them lie significant political issues, such as digitalization or environmental protection. And even to the casual observer, this agenda impressively shows: The Bundesrat is a place of work. A place where, according to Weber's definition of politics, hard boards are drilled, with passion and prudence. A place where work is done for our democracy.

When I speak here today, I reflect on my own experiences and memories. During more than a third of all previous Bundesrat meetings, which amounts to about 350 plenary sessions, I have held various responsibilities – sometimes at the state level, sometimes at the federal level; sometimes in government, sometimes in opposition. Therefore, I know well how urgent federal interests are brought to the Bundesrat and how the frustration over notorious requests for deadline extensions grows in the state and senate chanceries. And I also know, if you allow me, how the world can suddenly look very different once you change sides, for me, for example, from a state chancellery to the Federal Chancellery, and how things cannot move quickly enough, with understanding for further rounds of discussion at the state level sometimes lacking. Anyone who has walked the path in one direction or the other has the advantage of knowing the concerns of both sides. This knowledge helps me greatly in my current role.

The federal structure of the Federal Republic follows a high ethos, but in everyday life, it can sometimes be a challenge. There has been no shortage of voices lamenting the supposed "veto game" and invoking the "ungovernability" of the Republic. The truth is: German federalism is multifaceted and diverse – and this is not the result of any misdevelopments, but was intended. It is the essence of our federal state: Our democracy succeeds not despite the different perspectives, but rather thanks to the interplay and balance of all these legitimate perspectives and interests. Unity in diversity, a common policy from many voices – this order has proven its ability to act more than once, especially in times of crisis.

In times of crisis, the performance of the state is particularly put to the test. In the financial crisis of 2008, in the years-long Euro crisis that followed, in the so-called refugee crisis of 2015, or now for a year in the Corona crisis: In Germany, we always look at the overall state comprising the federal government and 16 states. The federal order is a firm part of our political self-understanding – and protected by the Basic Law through the eternity clause. But especially in crisis times like today, when 16 states respond to the challenge of the epidemic with 16 Corona regulations, German federalism is under intensified scrutiny.

Two waves of the global pandemic have now affected our country. Vaccinations have brought hope since the turn of the year. But the past two months have been a terribly dark time. More than 60,000 people have already fallen victim to the virus in this country. Too many people are suffering from the consequences of the infection, too many must fear for the lives of loved ones, too many mourn relatives and friends.

Economic livelihoods are at risk, shops, hotels, theaters, restaurants, schools, and daycare centers are closed. Daily life has been turned upside down, and this has been the case for months now. The patience of the people is being tested like never before. However, if a third of the population wants even stricter restrictions, while a fifth already feels completely overwhelmed – and support for current policies is waning in both directions – then political leaders face a very, very difficult task – at both the federal and state levels.

Between lockdown and easing, a tough struggle is taking place, not for the first time and again very current this week. And you all feel: The lockdown is taking its toll on us, nerves are frayed.

In such a situation, conflict is unavoidable. What matters to me: The fight against the pandemic must not become a game of hot potato between the levels of government. Let us not forget: Our enemy is not in Brussels or Berlin, not in state chanceries or pharmaceutical companies. Our enemy is the damned virus! To all those who bear political responsibility at the state or federal level or in Europe, I say: If we succeed in the fight against the virus, everyone wins. If we lose it, everyone loses.

In such a century crisis, even the thousandth session of the Bundesrat cannot be an occasion for long pauses. The interplay of politics between the federal government and the states, the cooperation of our state institutions literally decides over life and death in these days. The crisis shows us the strengths of our federal state – but it also exposes its weaknesses. And in the end, it is not only about overcoming a pandemic. It is also about the future of democracy.

Our democracy is not immune to challenges. The image that our state presents as a whole shapes the trust of citizens in democracy, in its institutions and procedures. As much as diversity is lived in the regions, people expect unity in dealing with crises and disasters. Therefore, the trust of the people in these crisis days is not only measured by the performance of individual representatives, but by the interplay of the federal government, states, and municipalities and by the transparent and understandable explanation of decisions. In short: by the common ability to get the pandemic under control.

Whether in the Bundesrat, in the conference of ministers-presidents, at meetings with the Federal Chancellor, or at meetings of specialized ministers – and despite all the passion for the matter – we must never forget one thing: When it comes to the whole, democracy does not confront the citizen in their Bavarian, Thuringian, or Hamburg identity. What matters is the trust of the people in state action as a whole!

Our federal state did not emerge after 1945 in a constitutional political vacuum. Those who engage with German federalism for the first time may primarily recognize historical continuity. Germany has always been a land of lands. Today's Bundesrat undoubtedly takes its model from the Bundesrat that Bismarck once constructed for the North German Confederation and later the Empire. However, that had nothing to do with democracy – on the contrary, it primarily served to secure princely sovereignty against parliamentarism and democratic participation. If one looks more closely at the principles of our constitution, one quickly learns: Name similarity does not mean unbroken historical continuity.

On the contrary, Germany has only gradually approached a successful form of federal order over time, coming closer to a successful way of involving the constituent states in the governance of the whole. The federal order of the German nation-state was long determined by the dominance of Prussia. This order lacked the freedom and the encounter of all states on equal footing – with consequences for the functioning of the overall state. John Röhl writes about the "incompleteness of the Reich construction" of 1871 that the development towards a unified modern constitutional state came to a halt halfway. Some princes even continued to maintain mutual embassies – domestically! – and the Reich was, as Röhl states, partly governed with the methods of foreign policy. The responsibility for the common whole therefore remained underdeveloped, if it even existed.

Even in the Weimar Republic, the federal order remained precarious. For the enemies of the Republic, it was seen as further evidence of weakness. The destruction of Weimar democracy began at the latest in 1932 with the "Prussian coup," a coup against the federal order. The Nazi regime then completely eliminated the federal state. After Gleichschaltung and Nazi dictatorship, the cult of the Führer and the devastation of genocide and war of annihilation emanating from Germany, a federal new beginning was needed, a new start in freedom.

Although the founding of the states before the restoration of a federal state, as well as the strong constitutional position of the states in the Basic Law, were linked to existing influences, our current federalism is primarily an expression of deeply anti-totalitarian and anti-centralist convictions, not only among the Western Allies – especially the Americans applied pressure – but also among the then majority in the Parliamentary Council.

The GDR also consisted of states at its founding in 1949. But as early as 1952, it became evident once again that federalism and dictatorship do not go together. The SED regime dismantled the states and replaced them with centrally controlled districts, according to the principle of the "paternalistic state," which Rolf Henrich described so vividly in 1989. It was part of the democratic revolution and a sign of liberation when, in 1990, even before reunification, the states were revived in East Germany. They found their place in the federal structure of the Federal Republic, and above all: The East German states provided much good, much healing identity in the difficult years after reunification. And this is not just said lightly; I have personally and intensely experienced this in an East German state, where I found my political home for many years.

The federalism of the Basic Law has never been rigid. There have always been shifts in the distribution of competencies and in financial relations, accompanied by an ongoing debate about possible functional improvements. The states tend to complain about a depletion of their competencies, while the federal government wants to have more say and invest in some areas, but is not allowed to. The constitutional goal of equal living conditions in all parts of Germany challenges us as a society just as much as the question of a uniformly good education policy; the latter especially when people are more mobile in their life cycle and increasingly rarely end their professional careers where they began them 45 years ago.

My own political memory also includes two federalism commissions that set out to reform the federal order to achieve a greater and clearer separation of responsibilities between the federal government and the states. In retrospect, I must confess that the great hopes for reform were fulfilled only to a very small extent. Much more significant to me, however, are the great practical joint achievements of the federal government and the states in recent decades. Solidarity in the reconstruction of East Germany and in promoting internal unity rank at the top. We should also recognize the reception and integration of hundreds of thousands of refugees as a testament to the performance of our federal state. And I hope that the management of the Corona pandemic will one day be regarded as a passed test of endurance. The responsible parties at the federal and state levels have it in their hands.

Federalism primarily means the limitation of power. State authority is also divided vertically. That the states have a say in the legislation and administration of the federal government means that hardly anything is completely autonomous and much is decided only by mutual agreement. In short: that no one can govern ruthlessly. Of course, compromises are often lengthy and arduous – especially when there are not just A and B sides, but now nine different color combinations from a total of seven parties. The involvement of the states brings new political constellations and new experiences. The composition of the Bundesrat reflects the political changes in the regions – and this is exactly how it corresponds to the will of the Basic Law.

The Bundesrat, this is my deep conviction, embodies a distinctly democratic, republican interpretation of federalism. It is not the outdated relic of old princely sovereignty. It stands for the parliamentarism and the rule of law of the Basic Law, for democracy, freedom, and the dignity of man! We Germans owe much to our strong, federal, democratic order – and we must take care of this order together.

The past months and years have shown us how vulnerable liberal democracy is. We have witnessed how it is under pressure, how its elected representatives are literally threatened. In America's capital, Washington, insurgents violently occupied both chambers of Congress a few weeks ago. And even here in Germany, last year, in a picture of appalling contempt for democracy, imperial war flags flew on the steps of the German Bundestag.

We see in real life how a minority is trying to discredit our democracy with the tools of digital manipulation and blatant demagoguery. I say very clearly today: As democrats, we must not downplay this and certainly not accept it!

Democracy thrives on strong institutions, for democracy does not mean radical individuality, nor does it mean ruthless majority will. No, democracy means debate and conviction, reason and the will to truth. Democracy means negotiated commonality – and not just between parties and factions, between different political movements. But also between urban and rural areas, between cultures, influences, and needs, between the whole and its individual state parts. Only our institutions create places of democracy where such negotiation can succeed with reason and civility.

Thus, we can look back and assess what a constitutional all-rounder has been created with the Federal Council. It interlinks the federal government and the states, the executive and legislative branches, politics and administration, parties and coalitions. It elects constitutional judges, its president represents the head of state, has its own bench and speaking rights in the Bundestag. The Federal Council brings regional and local interests to Berlin and, a profound change nearly 30 years ago, also into European politics. Much of its work is done quietly. Even in tough conflicts, things are usually very orderly – I was only a witness to one exception in March 2002. And the important mediation committee meets in private and rarely fails to reach a majority-compatible result.

Almost a thousand meetings later, it can be said with justification: The Federal Council has contributed significantly to the stability of German democracy! It is encouraging that despite all challenges, the trust of the people in politics and democracy remains high in this country. We are rightly proud of the strength of our constitution – and it is up to all of us to preserve this strength in the future.

It is good that our debating democracy remains intact even in times of crisis, while our state can also act responsively and powerfully. The Corona crisis shows how fundamentally the federal government and the states depend on each other. And at the center stands the Federal Council, a bulwark of our working democracy.

For seven decades, it has been doing its part, stabilizing our country, often off the big stage. It contributes significantly to the success of our federalism and ensures that not only federal but also European politics fit the realities of life on the ground and resonate with people across the country. Foreign delegations come here to Leipziger Straße to study a functioning form of federalism at the Federal Council.

Mr. President, you can rely on the Federal Council, even if some special sessions particularly challenge you in times of crisis. For this great contribution to the success of our democracy, I would like to sincerely thank all members of the Federal Council and all the staff of the house at this point!

Let us jointly fulfill our responsibility so that those who come after us can celebrate federalism and democracy even at the two-thousandth and three-thousandth plenary session of the Federal Council. Of course, also then, as always, only very briefly – before it goes directly, as it does now, back to work.