Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier on the 80th anniversary of the execution of members of the student resistance group White Rose on February 6, 2023, in Munich:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

7 February 2023 · 80th anniversary of the execution of members of the White Rose · Munich, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed a commemoration at Ludwig Maximilian University Munich on the 80th anniversary of the White Rose members' execution in February 1943.
Main themes
White Rose resistance group, Nazi regime opposition, courage and sacrifice, freedom and human dignity, democratic values, individual responsibility, historical remembrance, threats to liberal democracy, student resistance, totalitarianism
Duration
~43 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,203
92nd percentile
Sentences
314
96th percentile
Readability
54
74th percentile
Grade
9.8
19th percentile
Syntax
2.78
20th percentile
Vocabulary
2.25
62nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 34%31%
  • Social 32%30%
  • Geopolitical 25%23%
  • Ceremonial 9%8%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

314 sentences in 65 paragraphs

What compelling, stirring words they were: “Tear apart the cloak of indifference that you have laid around your heart! Decide, before it is too late!” Words that the resistance group the White Rose directed to all Germans at the beginning of 1943. The “Call to All Germans” – it was unequivocal. It was urgent. And above all: It was infinitely brave. Anyone who dared to publicly criticize the terror regime of the National Socialists, anyone who openly called for resistance – and that is exactly what the White Rose did, anyone who dared to do so put their own life at risk and also the freedom of their family and friends.

The members of the White Rose were very much aware of this danger. And yet, since the summer of 1942, they wrote leaflets and circulated them in ever-increasing numbers. “Freedom,” “Down with Hitler,” they also wrote on house facades, at the entrance to this university building. That too was unequivocal. And infinitely brave.

Sophie and Hans Scholl. Christoph Probst. Kurt Huber. Alexander Schmorell. Willi Graf. Hans Leipelt. They all paid for their courage with their lives.

The men and women of the White Rose no longer wanted to remain silent. They wanted action to be taken at last. It was above all a conviction that drove them: that everyone must and can do something. They called on all Germans to finally awaken from lethargy, from indifference, to finally raise their voices, to rise up against the – as it was stated in the third leaflet – “dictatorship of evil.”

Eighty years have passed since the first members of the White Rose were executed. Their resistance, their actions provoked the Nazi regime to the utmost. On February 18, 1943, they fell into the clutches of the authorities – on that day when Joseph Goebbels was to deliver his infamous speech on “total war” at the Berlin Sportpalast. On that February 18, Sophie and Hans Scholl distributed the sixth leaflet here at the university – it was to be the last. They let the remaining copies flutter down into the courtyard. Jakob Schmid, the locksmith and janitor of the university, observed them, detained them, and informed the rector, the SS man Walther Wüst. Sophie and Hans Scholl were handed over to the Gestapo. Shortly thereafter, Christoph Probst was also arrested.

So much courage, so much decency, so much faith in humanistic values was a danger to Hitler’s henchmen that had to be nipped in the bud. Hitler’s blood judge Roland Freisler traveled with his so-called People’s Court from Berlin to Munich and, raging in his fury, imposed the death sentences. Treasonous favoring of the enemy, preparation for high treason, undermining military strength, was the charge. The verdict was meant to deter all who might have similar thoughts or convictions. It was carried out the same day, with the guillotine. A second trial took place a few weeks later in April, against Alexander Schmorell, Willi Graf, the university lecturer Kurt Huber, and eleven other members of the White Rose. Schmorell, Graf, and Huber were also sentenced to death and executed. Hans Leipelt was murdered in 1945.

The trials and the death sentences mocked every right. The National Socialists could break any law, but not those condemned to death. “Long live freedom,” were the last words of Hans Scholl.

Peace, freedom, the dignity of every human being, and the responsibility of each individual – these values guided the White Rose at that time. They are today the foundation of our free democracy. When we come together here today to remember the women and men of the White Rose, we feel: Peace, freedom, the respect for human dignity have been won, fought for, and achieved through sacrifice. But they are by no means self-evident! And yes, our constitution is the answer to arbitrariness and tyranny, but democracy is by no means self-evident either! And it is certainly not guaranteed for eternity. We live in a time when liberal democracies are being increasingly challenged, indeed attacked, from within and from without. This is the great challenge of our time. And it is precisely this challenge that makes the cause for which the White Rose stood so urgently relevant to our present: Their fight for freedom and human dignity concerns us even today. The responsibility of each individual in society: it concerns us even today. This is something that still needs to be discussed.

The most well-known members of the White Rose are undoubtedly Sophie and Hans Scholl, the two siblings after whom the square outside the main building of LMU and the political science institute are named. Many schools in our country bear their name, and especially Sophie Scholl has become an icon in recent years, in books, in films, in social networks.

But the White Rose had more supporters who were equally brave. There was Alexander Schmorell, who came from Russia, whom Hans Scholl met while studying medicine and with whom he wrote the first leaflets. There was Christoph Probst, also an aspiring doctor, who was the only one of the student members of the White Rose who was already married, with family and children. There was Willi Graf, who also wanted to become a doctor. A deeply religious Catholic. There was the philosophy professor Kurt Huber, politically national-conservative, but one of the few university teachers who had the courage not to accept the Gleichschaltung of the universities without objection. There was Traute Lafrenz, a friend of Hans Scholl, also an aspiring doctor, who brought the leaflets to Hamburg. She is the only one from the circle of resistors who is still alive, and it moved me greatly to be able to award her the Federal Cross of Merit a few years ago.

Like-minded individuals joined the Munich group in other university cities, in Ulm, Stuttgart, Saarbrücken, Hamburg. Falk Harnack, Karl Ludwig Schneider, Heinz Kucharski and Margaretha Rothe, Hans and Susanne Hirzel, the aforementioned Hans Leipelt, Heinrich and Wilhelm Bollinger, to name just a few: They were all involved in various ways in spreading the leaflets across Germany.

These brave supporters of the White Rose have often been only casually remembered. I am convinced: They all deserve a larger place in our memory. They all shone with their courage in dark times. They all dreamed of a different, a better Germany.

Yes, the members of the White Rose had dreams, and they were young, very young. To dismiss them as apolitical dreamers, as some have done in the past, would do them no justice whatsoever.

It is true: Hardly any of them were against the Nazi regime from the beginning. When Hindenburg handed power to Hitler on January 30, 1933, most were still teenagers, Sophie and Hans Scholl initially even enthusiastic about Hitler. Kurt Huber was also initially quite taken with the new rulers.

However, the more the regime aimed for total Gleichschaltung and submission of each individual, the more brutally it acted against its opponents, the more horrific the crimes committed in the name of an inhuman racial ideology became, the more the realization matured in these young people about the true state of Germany. And that there was only one means to change anything: to stand up and resist.

They spoke in their leaflets about sabotage at all levels and in all areas of society. The White Rose clearly formulated its goal: “The meaning and purpose of passive resistance is to bring down National Socialism.” The fifth leaflet, finally, that very “Call to All Germans,” is imbued with the conviction that the war, despite all lies and propaganda, was ultimately lost. Some of the medical students had been sanitary soldiers in Russia, just before the defeat at Stalingrad, had seen cruelty beyond imagination, had experienced hell.

Here, in the fifth leaflet, the resistors outline their ideas for a possible post-war order: a federalist Germany in a united Europe. “Freedom of speech, freedom of belief, protection of the individual citizen from the arbitrariness of criminal violent states,” it reads there. And this was the vision of the members of the White Rose for the time after the war, after the Nazi rule. A vision for peace, at the same time a vision for the foundations of the new Europe.

The hope for the future was not accompanied for Hans and Sophie Scholl and all the others by a denial of the present: The White Rose was very clear about the heavy guilt their German contemporaries had incurred. “Everyone is guilty, guilty, guilty!” Even in the summer of 1942, they refuted all those lies that at that time – and for many years after the war – would claim to have known nothing about the crimes against humanity of the Holocaust and the other serious crimes. The murder and persecution of Polish Jews and young nobles, both were denounced by the White Rose. To desperately ask: “Why does the German people behave so apathetically in the face of these most heinous, inhuman crimes?” And: “It does not see and it does not hear.”

The courage to contradict or even to resist was indeed possessed by very few. It was a lonely resistance, a resistance of outsiders, as the historian Wolfgang Benz has written. But there were those who were brave, who came together, who wanted to act together and did act together. They existed in the labor movement, there was the Christian resistance, there was the Kreisau Circle, the Red Orchestra, the members of July 20. There were individual upright people like Georg Elser, there were Jewish women and men who resisted – and indeed also female and male students. And there were the “silent heroines and heroes” who helped the persecuted, hid them, and gave them food.

Young soldiers also sympathized with the White Rose, as we know from a testimony in “Echolot” by Walter Kempowski. One of them reported to Jacob Kronika, a Danish correspondent in Berlin, in detail about the group, three days after the first executions: “The White Rose has probably been stifled in this circle. But only in this circle. The group of young Germans who feel like the executed and arrested in Munich will grow.” He was mistaken, this young soldier. The British were also disappointed, who dropped the “Call to All Germans” millions of times over the cities in western Germany.

It was probably best described as Ricarda Huch saw it after the war. She concluded: “Thousands thought: These young people did what we should have done and did not dare to do.” The vast majority of Germans, however, kept the cloak of indifference wrapped around their hearts. They did not want to see and hear. Because they fanatically believed in Hitler, because they were afraid of the consequences of the truth, most likely because they believed that by functioning inconspicuously, they could at least escape hell personally and survive.

Through newspapers from Switzerland and Sweden, the news of the first executions reached the world public. The world was deeply moved by the events at the Munich University, said Thomas Mann in one of his radio addresses to the Germans from exile. Not least, these addresses of the great writer on the BBC had a strong influence on the White Rose. In June 1943, Thomas Mann erected a monument to the resistance group. “Brave, glorious young people! You shall not have died in vain, you shall not be forgotten.”

Today, eighty years later, we commemorate these young people, their faith in truth and humanity, in freedom – and their indescribable courage to stand up for all of that. We remember, not for the sake of mere retrospection or to place the members of the White Rose on a pedestal of heroes. They were undoubtedly heroes, but: We also look back knowing that the responsibility for our history knows no final point. Our history must serve as a warning for the present and the future. So that what has happened cannot happen again – as the great Primo Levi, himself a survivor of the Holocaust, said.

For us Germans, remembering always involves painful questions anew. They must be painful if we are serious about this responsibility for our history:

How was it possible that what happened, happened? How was it possible that most Germans supported a regime that betrayed all humanity and plunged all of Europe into war, tortured, enslaved, murdered people, that meticulously planned the crime against humanity of the Holocaust and carried it out in administrative division of labor by countless functionaries; how was it possible that most went along, ran along, remained silent?

And one more question arises for us, even if it is hardly truly and honestly answerable: How would I have behaved under such circumstances? How would I act, and would I even act, if I knew that the price for it would be imprisonment, torture, or even death?

These questions are painful, and some remain unanswered, perhaps must remain unanswered in the face of the monstrosity of crimes against humanity committed by Germans. But asking the questions remains important even eighty years after the execution of Hans and Sophie Scholl!

Every generation has its own perspective on the time when Germany sank into the darkest night. It took a long time for us Germans to acknowledge that our country did not free itself from the Nazi tyranny of violence. It was liberated from the outside. The defeat in the war was the condition of our freedom. It would take many years before an inner liberation followed the outer one. Years in which Germany glossed over its own crimes and Nazi elites could continue to exert influence in the state and society. Anyone who wants to get an impression of this should watch the film "The State Against Fritz Bauer" again in the cinema, with Burghart Klaußner in the lead role. It took a long time before we finally confronted the question of why what happened could happen. Until members of the resistance and those who had managed to escape into exile were no longer branded as "traitors." This inner liberation took decades – today it is an indispensable part of our democracy.

Our view today is shaped by the experience that we Germans have been living in a free democracy for decades; in fact, for more than thirty years, all Germans. It was the brave people in the GDR who peacefully resisted and thus brought down the wall. What a tremendous fortune that is: We live united in a democracy. The courage that the White Rose and the other resistance fighters had, had to have, such courage is not needed today.

The members of the White Rose, on the other hand, resisted in a dictatorship, against a regime of terror that acted with every conceivable brutality against its opponents; that made fear and terror the principle of rule. This criminal regime, which held human dignity and human life in no regard – even more: that denied people their humanity – had no claim to obedience. It had to be fought.

That was the attitude that united the women and men of the German resistance, however different their motives were. As much as their visions of a new, a better Germany differed. They all grappled with the legitimacy of their actions. Am I allowed to break laws, even commit acts of violence? Am I allowed to violate my faith or my oath of loyalty?

In the end, however, they all came to the conclusion: Those who did not act, who remained silent, tolerated violence as a principle, injustice as normality, the genocide committed by Germany. Those who did not act and remained silent made themselves complicit. Therefore, resistance was not only permitted, it was required. This dictatorship had to be overthrown. That was the conviction that guided the members of the White Rose. They were willing to risk their lives for it.

Anyone who knows this historical background; who knows how high the price for resistance against the Nazi regime often was; who knows this is annoyed when today, in political discourse, the term "resistance" is sometimes used carelessly and historical examples are invoked. Nothing justifies equating protest in a democracy with resistance in a dictatorship!

Our Basic Law guarantees not only the dignity of every individual – one of the most important lessons from the Nazi era. It also guarantees freedom of expression, freedom of assembly, freedom of the press. And these are not just postulates. These freedoms are our constitutional reality. The Constitutional Court ensures that these freedoms are maintained. In our democracy, dissent is not only explicitly possible. It is necessary! Criticism, demonstrations, even protests are part of the essence of democracy. Especially and particularly from minorities; even with means that the majority criticizes, that disturb them, that get on their nerves.

Democracy is the only form of government that inherently includes the discussion of mistakes and misdevelopments. Above all, it is the only form of government in which the possibility of self-correction is part of the legal and political structure. For this, it needs debates and controversies, it needs conflict. Democracy thrives on this!

There is a right to resistance in our democracy only in one case: when it is to be abolished. This has been enshrined since 1968 in Article 20, Paragraph 4 of the Basic Law: "Against anyone who undertakes to abolish this order" – referring to the constitutional order – "all Germans have the right to resist, if no other remedy is possible." Other remedies are democratic protest, legal recourse through the judicial system, free and fair elections, and every form of democratic engagement. All of this, then, is what determines our democratic coexistence today in a very everyday way.

Dissent is necessary in democracy. But there is no right to use violence against democratically made majority decisions. Anyone who today claims a right to resistance against democratic institutions in our country abuses this term; some even abuse the names of those who resisted at the risk of their lives in their identity-driven delusions or nationalistic frenzy. This desecrates the legacy and reputation of all those who sacrificed their lives in resistance against the barbarism of National Socialism.

Our democracy, our society is challenged today like never before. The return of war to Europe and the obvious attempt at a geopolitical reordering along old patterns, along the patterns of the Cold War, but also the consequences of the pandemic and the fight against climate change: We are facing a tremendous upheaval and restructuring.

February 24, 2022, was a turning point. For a year now, this unlawful war has been bringing terrible suffering to the people in Ukraine: destruction, hunger, death, severe human rights violations against women, children, and the elderly. But we are also feeling the consequences of this war, and I do not only mean rising energy prices. This February 24 means for us Germans that the time after the fall of the wall and reunification is over, in which we looked at our neighbors with optimism and full of hope. A time when we believed that freedom and democracy were on the rise everywhere. February 24 has also made us Germans very aware that we must do much more than in the past decades to protect and defend our democracy. What we need is a democracy that is resilient!

It was a scientist from this university in Munich who coined the term "resilient democracy" under the impression of Hitler's dictatorship and the spreading fascism in Europe: Karl Löwenstein. In 1933, the Jewish jurist from this institution was expelled and had to emigrate to the USA; he died fifty years ago.

What does Löwenstein's concept of resilient democracy tell us today? And what does it have to do with Russia's war against Ukraine? This war is a dehumanizing act of aggression, it is land theft, it is the disregard for all principles of international law that are also important to us. This war is fueled by Putin's imperial delusions and the fear of the Kremlin autocracy of democracy. That is also why this war concerns us. It is not only about solidarity with Ukraine – that is primarily the case at the moment – it is also about how we can better protect ourselves and our democracy.

What do I mean by that? This is to be understood quite literally. We Germans also need to rethink. February 24 has already led to a reorientation of our security and defense policy: Together with our alliance partners, we are supporting Ukraine not only humanitarianly and financially but also militarily. This was not without controversy, I know. But it is necessary so that the victims can defend themselves against the perpetrators. It is necessary if we do not want to simply acknowledge the blatant violation of international law by Russia. The massive support of an attacked state with our military material is new in the post-war history of our country. But the situation we are in is also new. What we thought we had left behind has returned. War is back in Europe. We are helping Ukraine, but we are not a party to the war. And yet we must also respond to threats that could affect us and others. A resilient democracy requires a well-equipped and ready-to-defend Bundeswehr due to these new threats. And as a strong country in the middle of Europe, we have a responsibility not only for ourselves but also for our alliance partners. And these partners must be able to rely on us!

We must take external resilience more seriously, but that does not mean that internal resilience has become any less important. German history offers lessons on this:

We cannot remember today the eightieth anniversary of the death of Sophie and Hans Scholl, of Christoph Probst, without also thinking of the ninetieth anniversary of the transfer of power to Hitler in 1933, the beginning of the rule of injustice and violence. And on this date, we must also remember the hundredth anniversary of the Hitler coup in 1923 here in Munich. The Weimar democracy was also destroyed because the instruments for protecting the republic were used far too rarely, because enemies of this democracy sat far too often in the state, judiciary, and police.

In the Federal Republic of Germany, it should not be possible for constitutional opponents to attack democracy from within again. Our democracy has strong instruments at its disposal to fend off attacks from extremists: the possibility of banning unconstitutional parties and associations; fundamental rights are forfeited if they are misused to fight against democracy; the eternity clause, which is intended to exclude the legal abolition of democracy; the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution. And yet, our democracy has also come under greater pressure in recent years.

Right-wing populists and identity extremists have also gained ground in our country. Hatred and incitement are also on the rise in our country, especially online. Our country also knows hatred against minorities. Our country has also been shaken in recent years by racist and anti-Semitic attacks. The murder series of the NSU is unforgettable. The murder of Walter Lübcke in June 2019 is unforgettable. The attack on the fully occupied synagogue in Halle on October 9, 2019, is unforgettable. The right-wing terrorist murders of nine citizens of Hanau in February 2020 are also unforgettable. Only a few months separated these last three bloody acts.

In our country, local politicians, mayors, and members of municipal councils are also being vilified and physically attacked, forced to give up, some even threatened with death. And in our country, there are also unconstitutional right-wing extremist groups that want to overthrow the so-called "system," and the old battle terms of the enemies of democracy, such as "old parties" and "system parties," are experiencing a revival.

All of this worries me. But the concern of the Federal President alone is not enough – not even if many share it. Our conception of resilient democracy cannot and must not be exhausted in the state's prohibition instruments and the concerns of its citizens. Because something else is missing, something very decisive. A resilient democracy needs engaged citizens who are morally clear and steadfast in their political judgment, who stand up for our country, for democracy. It needs citizens who are capable of democracy and see democracy as their own cause. That is the best protection!

I know there are millions of people in our country who do exactly that, who get involved, who help others, who engage in various ways, in clubs, at the fire department, at THW, in churches, trade unions, welfare organizations. Anyone who thinks of more than just themselves, who cares about others, who is not indifferent to misdevelopments in the community, in the region, in the country strengthens the backbone of democracy. I am grateful to each and every one of these wonderful people. It is precisely this commitment that strengthens the cohesion in our society. And it is this cohesion that we need to defend our freedom and our democracy! Looking at the world as it is, I am convinced: We will need even more of this in the coming years!

The longing for freedom and democracy, but also the commitment to freedom and democracy, is great in many parts of the world. I believe this can give us confidence. The Ukrainians show us day by day with their courage and bravery that a democracy can defend itself against such an attack. I am also encouraged that we Europeans are acting together and in solidarity in this crisis. And it is encouraging that the elections in the United States of America and most recently in Brazil have strengthened all those who stand for democracy, for the respect of human dignity and human rights, for international cooperation.

This longing for freedom is what drives many brave people today to protest and stand up against the rule of injustice, against dictatorship and oppression. There are still people in our time who resist, even though they are threatened with death, who fight for fundamental freedoms, for the freedom of girls and women, for democratic rights, for press and freedom of expression, in Iran, in Belarus, in Myanmar, in China. And they are also present in Russia. There, too, people dare to oppose and resist Putin's tyranny and his regime – and also against the war.

Resistance often consists of millions of small acts of courage, said Sviatlana Tsikhanouskaya here in Berlin last year. But many of these people risk their freedom and their lives even with such small acts. All of them, these brave women and men, they are the other face of their country, beyond dictatorship and repression. Such resistance from within is often the only hope for a better, a peaceful future – and at the same time the strong and driving motivation. All of this shows us: No one should underestimate this longing for freedom and the power of democracy!

This is where the circle closes to the White Rose. Their fight for peace, freedom, and human dignity, their appeal to each and every individual to take responsibility, that is their legacy and their mandate to us, who live in a democracy.

Margot Friedländer, who survived the Holocaust and, even at an advanced age, tells young people in our country about her fate, Margot Friedländer often says: "It is for you!" That is her great gift to us. I also understand this wonderful sentence as a mandate to us. It is up to us! It is up to us to protect our democracy! It is up to us not only to profess this but also to act accordingly! It is up to us not to be indifferent! It is up to us to see and hear!

And yes, it is up to you, all of you sitting here in front of me, who are young and studying. You will shape the future of our country. One way or another! By looking or by turning away, by doing or by keeping your distance. Do not let anyone convince you that politics is something for careerists and opportunists. If we leave the most important public affairs to the wrong people, nothing good can come of it. Sincerity, humanity, warmth of heart, reason, and responsibility belong in politics, and they are urgently needed there.

So get involved in our democracy! Participate in our democracy! There are so many opportunities! I do not want to say: go vote, you will do that anyway. But get involved in democratic parties, in associations, initiatives, in local politics. Be there for other people!

Beware of those who always know everything, and those whose spectrum of colors is limited to black and white! Be critical, express your opinion! Democracy needs criticism! But also endure ambiguities, that perhaps things are unclear and confusing for a while, and above all: Keep the willingness to accept facts!

Do not listen to loudspeakers, do not believe in seemingly simple solutions! Trust my experience: Complex problems and simple solutions rarely go together, and even more rarely do they lead to good solutions.

Do not shy away from debate! Be combative! But argue with reason and understanding, no matter how passionately you may feel about your cause! Stay curious about other opinions! Never fundamentally exclude the possibility that your counterpart could also be right.

With that, I also say: Seek conversation with people who do not share your views! Yes, I know it and experience it often: It is laborious. It is even terribly exhausting. But democracy needs such debates, as long as they are not characterized by defamation and mockery or even by hatred and incitement. It is worth every effort!

Stand up and contradict when people are attacked in their dignity! Advocate for our country to remain a diverse, open-minded one; a country where people can live together peacefully, regardless of where they come from, what they believe, and whom they love! Stand up against every form of racism, anti-Semitism, and inhumanity! Be attentive! Do not look away when people are at risk of radicalization! Turning a blind eye does not help democracy.

Advocate for your children and grandchildren to find a livable planet! To stop climate change, our country needs you, your ideas, your enthusiasm, your creativity. It needs your willingness and your courage for a truly profound transformation. It needs, no, we also need your impatience!

But please also remember: Democratic decisions will always be based on compromises. And they must be supported by a majority. There is no other way in democracy. Realize your dreams, with all the freedoms and opportunities that our democracy grants! But also give something back! The future of democracy depends not only on others but also on you – each and every one of you!

Ladies and gentlemen, dear students, our country needs you, our democracy needs you: engaged, passionate, resilient democrats! Our country needs democrats who see and hear, who speak and act!

Honor the legacy and memory of the White Rose in the best way I can imagine: Help ensure that no young people in Germany ever have to sacrifice their lives for freedom and humanity again.