Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier on the change of judges at the Federal Constitutional Court – Dismissal and honoring of Wilhelm Schluckebier as well as the appointment of Josef Christ on the 1st of ...

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

6 December 2017 · Change of judges at the Federal Constitutional Court (dismissal of Wilhelm Schluckebier and appointment of Josef Christ) · Schloss Bellevue, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed a ceremony at Schloss Bellevue on 1 December 2017 to dismiss judge Wilhelm Schluckebier from and appoint Josef Christ to the Federal Constitutional Court.
Main themes
Federal Constitutional Court judge transition, dismissal of Wilhelm Schluckebier, appointment of Josef Christ, judicial career recognition, constitutional law, religious freedom jurisprudence, fundamental rights, rule of law
Duration
~14 min
47th percentile
Words
1,622
47th percentile
Sentences
70
46th percentile
Readability
44
47th percentile
Grade
12.5
51st percentile
Syntax
3.23
76th percentile
Vocabulary
2.26
65th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 61%61%
  • Ceremonial 24%24%
  • Social 14%14%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

70 sentences in 16 paragraphs

Welcome to Schloss Bellevue! It is wonderful to have you here. The so-called changes in judges at the Federal Constitutional Court are the reason we see each other more often at Bellevue – at least that is what I was told, Mr. Voßkuhle. I think it is a beautiful prospect! Not the change of judges itself, at least not for everyone, but the fact that we meet here more frequently. And you – dear Mr. Voßkuhle – told me just a few days ago, when we met here, that the appointments and dismissals of judges of the Federal Constitutional Court are perceived as a "high mass" and that the judges like to come here. Today, if I may stay in the vernacular, we are celebrating this high mass, because you – dear Mr. Schluckebier – are leaving the court and because I will soon appoint you – dear Mr. Christ – as a judge of the Federal Constitutional Court.

Dear Mr. Schluckebier, the fact that I am retiring you today makes one thing clear to me: We have both gotten a bit older, even if we may both feel younger than we are. Because we know each other a little from our days in Giessen, there at the law faculty of Justus Liebig University. You were then an assistant at the chair for constitutional and administrative law with Professor Kisker. And I, if I may say this somewhat casually, was with his legal antithesis, Helmut Ritter, from whom I later went to your later colleague Brun-Otto Bryde. And even though our professional paths then developed differently, I believe we laid the foundation in Giessen, at the then certainly underestimated law faculty. A foundation that has certainly helped and supported us throughout our legal and political lives. But honestly, dear Mr. Schluckebier, could you have imagined back then that we, as officeholders of two constitutional organs, would come together today on this occasion at Schloss Bellevue? I certainly could not.

Before you were appointed as a judge of the Federal Constitutional Court in 2006, you had already had an impressive, particularly varied, and certainly highly interesting legal career. Activities as a judge in civil and criminal jurisdiction in the judiciary of the state of Hesse alternated with assignments to other judicial institutions or in the administration: to the Federal Prosecutor General in Karlsruhe, to the Federal Constitutional Court as a research assistant to the Federal Constitutional Court judges Wand and Träger, or to the Federal Chancellery. After professional positions as a judge, you held offices as a public prosecutor, initially as a senior public prosecutor at the Federal Court of Justice, later as a federal prosecutor. And from 1999, you were a member of the Fifth Criminal Senate as a judge at the Federal Court of Justice.

You once described your career as follows: In your studies, you were fascinated by public law, during your clerkship by civil law. And later, for 16 years, you were essentially neither in one nor the other field, but rather active in criminal law. And that is why the then President of the Federal Constitutional Court, Papier, was pleased at your inauguration about the criminal law expertise with which you were to enrich the court.

However, the distribution of business did not assign you a criminal law department in the Fundamental Rights Senate, the First Senate of the Federal Constitutional Court. You were responsible as a reporting judge for cases in the areas of corporate law, banking, stock exchange and securities law, insurance law, school law, and the law of open asset questions. And you had to familiarize yourself in Karlsruhe with the fundamental right of freedom of belief and confession. And this is a matter in which our increasingly secularized society questions much that was previously accepted. With the increased immigration of people with other religions, we are also confronted with questions of freedom of religious practice that are controversial in some areas. And you have recently commented on this in an interview that I read. Both developments become evident when I mention just a few cases in which you were the reporting judge: In 2007, the Berlin ethics education was to be decided, in 2009 you had to deal with the exemptions for slaughter without stunning, the shechita.

And in the same year, it was about the constitutional protection of Sundays and public holidays, specifically the Berlin Shop Opening Law, which allowed Sunday business openings far beyond what was previously permitted.

Finally, in 2015, a decision had to be made regarding the Islamic headscarf of teachers in school instruction and the relevant regulations at that time in the state law of North Rhine-Westphalia.

In addition, you have handled an incredible number of other important cases, such as those concerning the freedom of private schools, squeeze-outs in corporate law, or Good Friday as a silent holiday in Bavaria. It would exceed today's framework if I were to even attempt to provide a small overview of the over 4,300 decisions you have prepared.

Those who know you praise your calm, unpretentious manner, your humor. If one were to name a characteristic that particularly defines you, it would be – alongside your certainly excellent legal knowledge – your exemplary judicial restraint. But you also embody all the other virtues of a judge: integrity, humility, balance, and composure. These virtues are also evident, especially in the heated disputes over legal questions – which is always the case when it comes to such emotional matters as religion or school. The Süddeutsche Zeitung rightly characterized you once as a "rule-of-law thinking man with balance." That you do not conceal your convictions despite all your restraint, you have always made clear in dissenting opinions, for example, on the occasion of the decision on the Federal Criminal Police Office Act last year.

In times like these, one cannot emphasize enough the value of our rule-of-law institutions and how indispensable an independent constitutional jurisdiction is. However, independence does not only require institutional safeguards. It is also crucial that personalities emerge who demonstrate the independence of the constitutional court, or rather, who live this independence every day. It has always been possible to select judicial personalities who are independent, opinionated, and at the same time constitutionally steadfast. I know this from my encounters with constitutional judges in previous offices, and I see it today in my encounters with you.

Recently, a sociological article appeared in the Juristenzeitung that attempted to analyze the relationships within the Second Senate – also and especially from a political perspective. This may initially be a cause for amusement, but it also shows: The constitutional court has – of course – a politically perceived role, and its judges are also perceived as "homines politici." Whether such an analysis does justice to the structures, the interactions of the judges among themselves and with society, your deliberations and discussions, remains to be seen by me and will also remain to be seen by you. It is not surprising that the investigation ultimately only confirms that there are preconceptions among judges just as there are among any jurists, which, however, all fall under the high standards of professionalism that apply at the Federal Constitutional Court, and therefore it is not preconception, but legal expertise, argumentation, and persuasiveness that decide.

You are about to enter your well-deserved retirement. I am sure that in the future, despite your restraint, we will hear your comments on legal topics. But you will surely also have more time for hiking and for your engagement as an ambassador of the Diemelsee Nature Park – which I know – your old home. And perhaps the Karlsruher SC will win in the future even when you are in the stadium! It will certainly be a fulfilling time. And for this, I wish you all the best from the bottom of my heart!

Dear Mr. Schluckebier, our country owes you a great deal! And I want to express this gratitude to you personally. I am particularly pleased to award you today the Grand Cross of Merit with Star and Shoulder Ribbon of the Federal Republic of Germany for your commitment and achievements.

Dear Mr. Christ, on September 5, 2017, the Bundestag elected you as a judge of the Federal Constitutional Court. This was a premiere – for you personally, of course, but also for the court and the Bundestag. Because after the abolition of the previously somewhat controversial delegation to the Judicial Selection Committee, the Bundestag elected a judge determined by it for the first time in the history of the Federal Republic in plenary session.

I warmly congratulate you on your election!

You are returning to your homeland. For you were born in the southwest of our country, in Langenargen on Lake Constance. After studying in Heidelberg, you entered the judiciary in Baden-Württemberg and then served as an administrative judge at the Administrative Court in Karlsruhe. Your career path was also varied, as you sought experiences in assignments to the Federal Chancellery, the Federal Constitutional Court, and the State Ministry of Baden-Württemberg. And after you had already been a judge at the Administrative Court of Baden-Württemberg, you became a judge at the Federal Administrative Court in 2008 and its Vice President from 2014. I am convinced: Your expertise and judicial experience are an enrichment for the Federal Constitutional Court. A newspaper wrote about your election that you are considered a diligent, meticulous judge and Senate chair. You will certainly need diligence, as you have not only just heard but also know from your time as a member of the "Third Senate" how much work will come your way in the coming years. And for that, I wish you strength and much success.