Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier on the occasion of the presentation of the Marion Dönhoff Prize for International Understanding and Reconciliation to the "New York Times" on December 3, 2017 in ...

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

6 December 2017 · Presentation of the Marion Dönhoff Prize for International Understanding and Reconciliation to the New York Times

Context
Steinmeier delivered a laudation at the Marion Dönhoff Prize ceremony in Hamburg on December 3, 2017, honoring the New York Times for international understanding and reconciliation.
Main themes
Press freedom, journalism and truth-telling, Jewish history and the Holocaust, Kristallnacht, New York Times legacy, international understanding and reconciliation, German-American relations, exile and immigration, resistance to authoritarianism, civil society and courage
Duration
~23 min
71st percentile
Words
2,722
71st percentile
Sentences
160
83rd percentile
Readability
58
84th percentile
Grade
9.2
12th percentile
Syntax
2.82
24th percentile
Vocabulary
2.26
63rd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 48%48%
  • Institutional 37%36%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

160 sentences in 45 paragraphs

I would like to tell our guests from New York a story that was not in their newspaper. It is the story of the decline of a civilization, and it was experienced by an eight-year-old boy. This boy woke up one morning, and the house of worship, of which his father was the leader, lay in ruins. A mob had broken in during the night and destroyed the entire interior and all the sanctuaries. Only by luck had the fire not reached the family's apartment on the second floor.

When the eight-year-old looked out the window the morning after the attack, the men and women of the community were already busy clearing away the traces of the night, hauling out destroyed benches and tables. Outside on the street, a group of hecklers had gathered. They were insulting and spitting at those who were cleaning up. A little further away, the boy saw two police officers standing by, watching with interest but not lifting a finger.

Suddenly, a familiar face appeared from the crowd – the milkman. Completely unfazed, he made his way through the crowd, through the gate, up the steps to the family apartment. There, as he did every morning, he dropped off the milk, turned around, and disappeared back into the crowd just as unperturbed as he had come.

What was the boy supposed to make of all this? A bad nightmare in the midst of the normality that continued, just as the milkman returned the next day and the day after? The boy had been largely unaware of the growing assaults of recent years. His everyday life took place behind the walls of the house of worship, a sheltered world where scholars, theologians, and philosophers came and went – an "intellectual echo chamber," as one might say today.

Eight-year-old Walter Jacob did not know what was happening around him. But fortunately, his parents knew better. For they were readers of the New York Times. They knew on that morning of November 10, 1938, that this was not an isolated incident. Time and again since the rise to power, the New York Times had reported on boycotts, harassment, and violence against German Jews. And it continued to report, even though Joseph Goebbels – as he noted in his diary – repeatedly threatened their "slanderous foreign journalists" with expulsion. Immediately after the Night of Broken Glass, in the edition of November 10, Walter's parents read about the looting of Jewish shops on Leipzig Street and Friedrichstrasse in Berlin. And two days later, on November 12, the newspaper characterized the "Day of Nazi Terror" as a "threat to all civilization."

No, normality would not return. The Jacobs sensed this after all the reports from this almost last credible source, the New York Times. The rabbi's family decided to leave their homeland – that beautiful synagogue in Augsburg in Swabia, where I recently had the honor of speaking at its hundredth anniversary. By the end of that same year, 1938, the Jacobs traveled to their relatives in London. On New Year's Day of 1940, they finally arrived, together with 17 other Jews from Augsburg, in New York City. The adjustment – as Walter Jacob told me with a laugh – was not difficult for his parents at all. For they had been studying the local newspaper for years.

Walter Jacob is now 87 years old, lives in Pittsburgh, and is the rabbi of the local Rodef Shalom congregation. He continues to write books, just as his father did in Augsburg, and he still reads the New York Times every day.

And today – you won't believe it – he has come to the hometown of his wife, Hamburg, and he is right here among us: A warm welcome, dear Walter Jacob – how wonderful it is that you are with us!

Today, we honor an authority of enlightenment – the Gray Lady, the New York Times. We honor a beacon of reason in an age of rampant irrationality. We honor a flagship of press freedom at a time when Deniz Yücel and hundreds of journalists are imprisoned in Turkey, when independent newspapers in Russia are declared foreign agents, and when even in Western democracies the meaning and value of a free press are being questioned – even if only as a side note in a tweet early in the morning. I thank Matthias Naß and the jury for the invitation to this laudation, which I gladly and wholeheartedly accepted.

The story that connects us Germans with the New York Times is long and multifaceted. And who has a sense for long and multifaceted stories, if not the New York Times, whose weekend edition is often over 100 pages thick? Even the assembled editorial staff of ZEIT would be astonished. And, dear ZEIT colleagues: They do this not just once a week; they do it every day.

This long story goes back to a certain Bertha Levy from Landau, who emigrated to America during the turmoil of the German Revolution of 1848 and met a Julius Ochs from Fürth in Nashville, Tennessee. So two Bavarians in the South – and today a late award in Hamburg. Their common son, Adolph Ochs, first revitalized the Chattanooga Times as a young man and then, in 1896, acquired the struggling New York Times with borrowed $75,000. Against the larger, aggressive, sensationalist competition of the "Yellow Press," he set forth a different, almost audacious vision: "All the News That's Fit to Print."

So a fact-oriented, comprehensive, demanding newspaper was to steal circulation from the tabloids? Yes, it was even to reach a global audience?! "How naive!" "How unrealistic!" some cried. Yet his vision became reality. And it remains so to this day – also under you, Arthur Ochs Sulzberger Jr., who now leads the newspaper in the fourth generation since your great-grandfather.

The New York Times has become a global authority. But it remains for us in Germany at the same time a window into a country, the United States, that will always be multifaceted, colorful, and contradictory – certainly much more complex than it is glorified by some and condemned by others here. The complexity of America, and the struggle with its complexity, is embodied better than anyone by the New York Times.

This newspaper has received many awards. But if today a German Dönhoff Prize is added to the 122 Pulitzer Prizes, it is important to me to remember the namesake of the prize. Marion Gräfin Dönhoff was a convinced transatlanticist. She never shied away from the political differences with the big brother in the West, but she – born in 1909 – knew what we owe to America. She knew: America is important for us Germans – not only geostrategically important but also repeatedly important for the formation of democracy.

Anyone in Germany today who speaks with a certain cultural arrogance about the break with the USA, because everything seems to be going in the wrong direction and the commonalities have disappeared, I advise: Just take a single look at the New York Times! This newspaper still sets the standards of a free press with the highest quality demands again and again. And we need such a press in these stormy times more urgently than ever.

Dear Arthur Sulzberger, dear Dean Baquet, after Walter Jacob, I would like to tell you about another New York Times reader of German descent, more precisely: a female reader. She is, to be fair, a fictional reader, but no less loyal: Gesine Cresspahl from Uwe Johnson's "Anniversaries" reads the newspaper from front to back every day. When I open the day of the novel's action, which is exactly half a century ago today, December 3, 1967, we find nothing but newspaper clippings from the New York Times – "the consciousness of the day," from the weather forecast to the obituaries. For Gesine Cresspahl – as for so many readers before and after her – the New York Times is the "diary of the world."

If you, Mr. Sulzberger, have ever wondered what your newspaper would look like if it were a living person, Uwe Johnson actually provides a very imaginative description. I quote: "The New York Times seems to Gesine like an aunt from a distinguished family. […] dark and elegant clothing, insistence on high hairstyles, a scratchy voice, smiles only in the corners of the eyes. The aunt smokes (cigars), she also drinks the hard stuff. […] The old lovers come for the memories, the younger generation for the education. […] She keeps up with the times. She is modern." Dear Mr. Baquet, I would love to know whether this description still corresponds to the self-image of the editorial team today.

As long as it exists, some express their suspicion that the Gray Lady is too close to the ruling elite. She is, like all independent media, the critical instance. But she stands within the democratic framework – not against the democratic framework. And so, by the way, not only since the last presidential election campaign, the "East Coast Establishment" has become a battle cry of those who despise democracy, with the New York Times being particularly counted among them. Even by such self-proclaimed anti-establishment fighters, who themselves come from well-to-do East Coast families.

I believe that quality media can withstand such criticism of elites. And they must, for the Gray Lady, also an authority of enlightenment, is not infallible. On the contrary: Enlightenment thrives on the search, on mistakes, on correction. This applies to the New York Times as well as to all of America. The authority of a free press is a borrowed one – borrowed from the authority of the informed reader. The New York Times has always had to face its critical questions:

Did the newspaper adequately highlight the horrific truths of the Holocaust in the flood of news during World War II – truths whose processing is also a painful chapter in the history of the New York Times?

Did it, especially in the decades of the strengthening Civil Rights Movement, adequately reflect the diversity of American society in its editorial staff?

Did it sufficiently critically examine sources regarding alleged weapons of mass destruction in the Iraq War?

Did it understand the concentrated mix of resentment, alienation, and anger in rural America that resulted in the outcome of the 2016 presidential election?

And lastly, and not quite so seriously: Did it always exercise the necessary care in its image editing, especially regarding the portrayal of the German head of state?

The New York Times has never shied away from the critical questions about its work; on the contrary: It continuously draws consequences. This includes the clear, institutional separation of reporting and commentary, more resources for investigative research, stricter requirements for source verification, more transparency in the newsroom, and strict rules for the use of social media. And as you, Mr. Baquet, have repeatedly emphasized: "We, the reporters, must get out of our New York bubble."

Reporters are not robots, and they should never become so! But precisely for this reason, the critical look inward – at one's own attitudes, inclinations, and prejudices – is just as much a part of the journalist's profession as the critical look outward, at the subject of reporting. For their critical self-reflection, the New York Times deserves my special respect – especially now, as we in Germany are also having critical debates in and about the media, whether regarding reporting during the refugee crisis or about the proper handling of the taboos of populist parties.

I believe that the self-criticism that is expected of politicians should also be expected of media makers. Of course, especially in this confusing world, we need trust in the authority of the media. But I am sure that self-criticism does not undermine the authority of the media – on the contrary: It is the foundation for trust in the media. The New York Times has understood this.

"All the News That's Fit to Print!" In the motto of the New York Times, an impressive, extremely self-confident, timeless professional ethos of journalism is reflected. But at the same time, all the great, open future questions of journalism are mirrored in the same motto. Today, we can put a question mark after every word:

"All"? Which medium can still claim completeness in this world?

"The News"? What are news, what are fake news? And who is trusted to make the distinction?

"Fit"? Who decides what is appropriate for public attention? Certainly not just newspapers, but also trolls and bots and tweeting presidents.

And "To Print"? When I recently asked a group of students when they last held a printed newspaper in their hands, I received only astonished looks. Printed newspapers?

In all these big questions, in all the upheavals of our time – digitalization, the watershed of the last U.S. presidential election, the cacophony of the post-factual – the New York Times appears to me above all as: composed. It has reflected on the fundamental virtues of its profession:

How to respond to irrationality? With reason and with absolute objectivity.

How to respond to constant excitement and hysteria? With the good craft of thorough reporting.

How to respond to growing polarization and partisanship? By putting oneself in the shoes of the other, taking argument and counterargument seriously.

How to respond to lies? By clarifying the facts.

There, in the classic virtues of reporting, between excitement and indifference, lies the core of journalism: enlightenment. That is what this profession is about: to inform! And I believe that this is and remains a noble task.

The Washington correspondent Maggie Haberman recently said with wonderful clarity: "Some people would like us to be the opposition party. But that‘s just not our job!"

Good journalists are authorities in democracy – but journalists are not better politicians. There are examples of this from recent times. Perhaps the New York Times is already a step ahead of some German media figures who, especially in these times, tend to lean towards public education. The New York Times' reaction to populism was not self-aggrandizement, but self-restraint in focusing on the actual, noble task of enlightenment.

And so I return to the beginning of my speech, to that milkman in Augsburg. This figure from Walter Jacob's childhood has made me reflect. Who might this German have been, who placed his milk bottles in front of the rabbi's door in Augsburg on the morning after the later so-called "Night of Broken Glass"? What might have gone through his mind? Was he brave or a follower? Did he simply do his job courageously? Was his unwavering walk through the crowd even a silent act of solidarity?

One can only speculate who this milkman was and what moved him. But I am quite sure of one thing: He was in the dark. Of course, he saw with his own eyes what was happening around him – but could he know how the regime had systematically orchestrated the pogrom night across the country? No, because the free German press had long been dead at that moment, strangled by Goebbels' Ministry of Propaganda and its daily directives and prohibitions. If the milkman had read his Augsburg National-Zeitung on November 11, two days after the pogrom, he could have read: "According to police findings, there are all indications that Jewish elements themselves caused this fire."

It is not only a great fortune to be informed freely and independently – no, it is vital for democracy! And that is why informing is the professional honor of the journalist. But even more: To be informed is a citizen's right – and I believe, a citizen's duty! To be a democrat and remain uninformed – that does not go together. No president, no milkman, no voter can afford that. And that is why we must not retreat an inch when press freedom is threatened. If this freedom falls, all freedom falls!

The Jacobs were informed. Gesine Cresspahl was informed. Millions of readers of the New York Times are informed. And 500,000 new subscribers since the last US election are as well.

Dear New York Times: Please continue to bring us "All the News That's Fit to Print," so we can be informed! Congratulations, Gray Lady. Or in Uwe Johnson's words: Congratulations, "Aunt Times."