Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier on the change of judges at the Federal Constitutional Court on July 16, 2018, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

19 July 2018 · Change of judges at the Federal Constitutional Court · Schloss Bellevue, Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier spoke at Schloss Bellevue on July 16, 2018, at the ceremonial change of judges at the Federal Constitutional Court, marking Judge Eichberger's retirement.
Main themes
Federal Constitutional Court, rule of law, judicial independence, party-political influence on judiciary, democratic principles, European Union rule of law concerns, Poland judiciary reform, farewell to Judge Eichberger, judicial appointments, Basic Law
Duration
~14 min
48th percentile
Words
1,645
48th percentile
Sentences
67
44th percentile
Readability
46
50th percentile
Grade
12.9
55th percentile
Syntax
3.21
73rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.22
54th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 54%54%
  • Ceremonial 28%28%
  • Social 13%13%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

67 sentences in 16 paragraphs

Warm welcome here at Schloss Bellevue! In these turbulent times we live in, it is reassuring that the paths and procedures of our constitutional life follow clear rules and that politics has been able to agree on a successor for you, dear Mr. Eichberger. I am very pleased that you have all come and I warmly welcome you all.

Dear Mr. Eichberger, the postponed world tour or other adventures can begin. Today, you are not only ending your term, but also your – one may say in these football-driven times – "stoppage time" is coming to an end. The reasons are well known, which is why you had to stay "on the field" longer than planned. That reaching an agreement on a successor is not always easy is nothing new for you. When you were elected twelve years ago, the media accompanied your election with the remark that a "structural left-liberal majority in the First Senate" was coming to an end, as your predecessor Hömig was the last judge proposed by the FDP at that time. It was therefore noted that your election was a politically gentle appointment.

You all, my ladies and gentlemen judges, can certainly assess this much better than I can, but it seems to me that viewing the Constitutional Court through a politically tinted lens is rather superficial. It does not do justice to you and, above all, to the highest German court in any way. As an active politician and participant before the court, I have always experienced that constitutional law, and not the party program, is the standard by which you decide. As the head of the Federal Chancellery and as Foreign Minister, I too had to experience that the Federal Government can lose before the Federal Constitutional Court. And even if such defeats were sometimes painful, they always had a positive side, as they occasionally remind us of the significant sentence in our Basic Law: "The judges are independent and subject only to the law."

And especially in these days, it is particularly important for me to point out this rule of law axiom for two reasons: On the one hand, there is currently a debate about party-political distribution keys for the appointment of constitutional judges and judges for high judicial offices. I find that a bad sign. It could create the impression that the influence of the parties on the judiciary is to be expanded. On the other hand, such debates are used in other countries, including in our immediate neighborhood, as an argument for judicial reforms. Reforms that aim to restrict the rule of law structures there and undermine the independence of the judiciary. Yes, we live in a time when many of our achievements of a democratic and liberal rule of law are increasingly under pressure – unfortunately also here in Europe.

Such developments within the European Union have long ceased to be purely domestic matters. Not only because membership in the European Union requires adherence to and compliance with legal minimum standards, but also because the ever closer cooperation of the judicial authorities, especially the recognition and enforcement of decisions from other member states, is based on the fact that we can actually trust in the adherence to these legal standards. The concrete consequences that can arise when this trust begins to crack are illustrated, for example, by current proceedings before the European Court of Justice regarding whether the doubts about the rule of law in Poland are justified.

The neutrality of the state – and thus the obligation to impartiality and objectivity of the administration – as well as the binding nature of the judiciary are core elements of the rule of law, whose disregard undermines that very trust without which our democratic rule of law cannot exist.

And, dear Mr. Eichberger, our rule of law cannot do without personalities like you. When you were elected to office in 2006, the Mannheimer Morgen quoted your former legal training instructor and former Vice President of the Administrative Court of Baden-Württemberg, for example, with the following words: "It was already evident back then that he has what it takes to achieve the highest judicial honors." You had an excellent reputation even back in your trainee days.

After studying law, you entered the judiciary of Baden-Württemberg. Prior to that, you obtained your doctorate in Mainz on the topic "The Restriction of Legal Protection Against Administrative Procedural Actions." This interest in public law led you to administrative jurisdiction, from where you repeatedly sought experience in other state areas, in the Baden-Württemberg Ministry of Justice or – who would be surprised – as a research assistant at the Federal Constitutional Court, at that time with Hans Hugo Klein.

Further professional stations included the Administrative Court of Mannheim and the Federal Administrative Court in Leipzig, where you worked from 1998 to 2006. Your interest in research and teaching made you an honorary professor at the University of Tübingen in 2004. Thus, it seemed almost natural in 2006 that you, if I may say so, ascended the legal Olympus in Karlsruhe – without, however, as everyone assures, losing your grounding.

People who know you very well and work with you praise you as undogmatic, unpretentious, open, and approachable. Highest professional qualification, an open ear, and argumentative strength are what characterize you, and – as I have been told – a virtually proverbial, inexhaustible work ethic. You needed that for the thick legal boards you had to drill through. I will only mention two of the 4,774 cases you brought to decision as a reporting judge: among them decisions in politically highly controversial fields such as inheritance tax and its modalities. This case occupied you for almost two years. Particularly high demands on your work ethic were also placed by the compensation proceedings following the nuclear phase-out due to the Fukushima disaster. The case files, I have been told, contained well over 10,000 pages of written submissions. Your opinion in preparation for the oral hearing is said to have comprised 500 pages alone. What a Herculean task it was to distill the constitutional essence from this mass of submissions, the arguments that ultimately matter. It is obvious that you were treading legal new ground with the proceedings.

And those who had to supervise such proceedings as reporting judges are often attributed great influence in the media, sometimes even power. You personally have always rejected such attributions and denied that the constitutional judge has political shaping power. This modesty and the personal ambition to solve the cases at hand professionally are, alongside independent thinking and the highest professional qualification, the qualities that distinguish judges in a democratic rule of law and that you embody exemplary.

That you have found time for your wife, your four children, for tennis, swimming, skiing, reading, and visiting museums alongside the enormous demands of the court and your commitment as President of the German Section of the International Commission of Jurists, I can only explain by the fact that you – as your friends and colleagues say – have an unusually balanced and calm demeanor despite all your diligence. In Westphalian terms, one would say in the shared homeland of Mr. Voßkuhle and myself. Nevertheless – this has also been reported to me very confidentially – you should also be glad that soon – in just a few moments – you will have more time for things other than legal matters.

Dear Mr. Eichberger, our country owes you a great deal! For that, I thank you very much – I do so very personally. For your commitment and your achievements, I award you – I say this now as Federal President – the Grand Cross of Merit with Star and Shoulder Ribbon of the Federal Republic of Germany.

Dear Mr. Radtke, the Bundesrat elected you as a judge of the Federal Constitutional Court on July 6, 2018. I hope you are not alarmed by the described constitutional judicial workload and the task ahead of you. I am convinced you are well equipped for it: After attending school in Lübeck and Kassel, you completed your military service, followed by a law degree in Göttingen, which you completed in 1987 with the First State Examination in Law. Before your legal traineeship, you worked as a research assistant at the Faculty of Law in Göttingen at the chair of Prof. Dr. Fritz Loos. After the Second State Examination in Law – in 1992 – you obtained your doctorate and habilitated in 1997 with a work on the dogmatics of arson offenses. You received the teaching authorization for the subjects of criminal law and criminal procedure law. After professorships in Saarbrücken and Marburg, you held the chair for criminal law, criminal procedure law, and international criminal law at the University of Hanover from 2005 until September 2012. Alongside your academic work, you always sought contact with practice – for example, you were a judge in the criminal senate of the Saarland Higher Regional Court in the early 2000s. It is remarkable that you – coming from a successful academic career – switched to the Federal Court of Justice in 2012 when you were elected as a federal judge in the 1st Criminal Senate of the Federal Court of Justice. From Hanover, where I still know a bit, I have heard that your departure was felt as a very, very painful loss.

Now the Constitutional Court can benefit from your diverse experiences in academia and practice. And I am sure that you will be a great asset to the court.

I would like to congratulate you, Mr. Radtke, warmly. I am sure you will quickly find your way into the new tasks, and when you look around here, you will be welcomed by friendly colleagues in Karlsruhe who will make your work as easy as possible. Thank you, and thank you all.