Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier on the change of judges at the Federal Constitutional Court on June 3, 2022, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

10 June 2022 · Change of judges at the Federal Constitutional Court · Schloss Bellevue, Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed a ceremony at Schloss Bellevue on June 3, 2022, marking the departure of Judge Paulus and appointment of Judge Wolff to the Federal Constitutional Court.
Main themes
Federal Constitutional Court, judicial appointment and farewell ceremony, Basic Law and constitutional order, rule of law, individual freedoms and democratic self-determination, judicial responsibility and trust, international law, constitutional jurisprudence, European Union law, judicial workload and productivity
Duration
~14 min
48th percentile
Words
1,661
48th percentile
Sentences
78
51st percentile
Readability
42
40th percentile
Grade
12.6
52nd percentile
Syntax
2.91
35th percentile
Vocabulary
2.20
48th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 69%69%
  • Ceremonial 19%19%
  • Geopolitical 9%9%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

78 sentences in 24 paragraphs

The paths of our constitution bring us together today. You are warmly welcome at Schloss Bellevue! I am very pleased that we have come together so quickly after yesterday's election in the plenary of the German Bundestag to bid farewell to you, dear Mr. Paulus, after "only" two months of extension into a new chapter of your life, and to appoint you, dear Mr. Wolff, immediately.

A change of judges at the Federal Constitutional Court is always a special occasion in the constitutional life of our state. It provides an opportunity to honor those individuals who embody the Federal Constitutional Court.

You, the judges of the Federal Constitutional Court, are the ones who ensure that our Basic Law is upheld, that individual freedoms and democratic self-determination are continually balanced in our liberal democracy. In doing so, you enable the free and democratic basic order to be effective and strengthen its reputation.

With your office comes great responsibility. Article 92 of the Basic Law states that the judicial power is "entrusted" to the judges. This wording from the fathers and mothers of the Basic Law expresses that a special trust is placed in the person of the judge.

As of today, you are leaving the office that has been entrusted to you for the past twelve years. When you were appointed in 2010, my predecessor, Federal President Köhler, noted that you were starting your term "relatively young" and with "youthful vigor" – you were only 42 years old at the time. Nevertheless, you were already regarded as an outstanding scholar and were even referred to as a "parade jurist," having been appointed as a professor of public law, particularly international law, at the University of Göttingen at the age of 38.

Your internationally oriented legal studies had previously taken you to Geneva, Munich, and Harvard. With your award-winning doctoral thesis on "The International Community in International Law" and your habilitation thesis on "Parliament and the Use of Armed Forces," you gained national and international attention. And that’s not all: you also practiced international law and represented the Federal Republic of Germany in two complicated international legal matters before the International Court of Justice in 2000 and 2004.

Wearing a robe in a courtroom was not entirely new to you when you took office in the Karlsruhe district – but your role as a judge was. And even with the areas of law for which you were responsible as a reporting judge in the First Senate, you were entering new territory as a "pure international lawyer." Your responsibilities now included areas such as intellectual property law, parts of tax law, inheritance law, artistic freedom, gambling law, and much more.

International law is missing. Whether you exchanged views on international legal questions in a quasi-living arrangement with your colleague Huber from the Second Senate, I do not know. However, I am aware of the following numbers: In the past twelve years, you have completed 4,150 cases as a reporting judge, of which 4,097 were constitutional complaints. That is 346 cases per year! Such a high number of completed cases is a testament to great productivity, high discipline, and tireless commitment. At the same time, the numbers hint at how high the workload of the judges of the Federal Constitutional Court still is. And they show, not least, how often citizens seek the help of the Federal Constitutional Court.

It is said that you fostered a wonderful team spirit in your department. That seems to me to be an important ingredient when it comes to managing such a large number of cases. Discussions characterized by openness and equality, a consistently friendly tone, family-compatible working conditions, and an open exchange of ideas even outside the court, such as during hiking or a good meal afterward – all of this was important to you and shaped the atmosphere in your department. I have also heard that your extraordinary erudition sometimes led your staff to divide the morning newspaper reading so that they could keep up with you somewhat during lunch.

The areas of law entrusted to you at the Federal Constitutional Court became your own, and you further delineated the constitutional boundaries. Not long after taking office, in July 2011, you as a reporting judge brought about your first important Senate decision. In the case of the imitation of Le Corbusier designer furniture by an Italian company, the First Senate established in the so-called Cassina decision that foreign legal entities based in the European Union can be bearers of material fundamental rights. Furthermore, in this decision, as in many others, you dealt with the question of when and to what extent national courts are obliged to refer questions to the Court of Justice of the European Union in Luxembourg for a preliminary ruling. Much depends on this, as only the application of Union law by the national courts of the member states ensures that the European legal community is realized.

Beyond "Cassina," you prepared ten additional Senate proceedings alongside numerous chamber decisions. You have often dealt with the principle of equality, for example, regarding the constitutionality of municipal levies or local consumption and expenditure taxes or broadcasting fees. What may sound technical has a significant impact on the everyday lives of many citizens!

You have also become famous: In legal circles as well as in the music industry, you have made a name for yourself as the "DJ of the Federal Constitutional Court," particularly in the case "Metall auf Metall," which dealt with the so-called sampling. I do not know of any previous oral hearing in the plenary chamber of the Federal Constitutional Court where music was played. Clearly, you wanted to make audible what the Senate had to decide. This precision is exemplary and should underlie every judicial decision!

You have also contributed to numerous Senate proceedings for which your colleagues in the First Senate served as reporting judges – I think, for example, of the climate protection decision from just over a year ago or the decisions on fundamental rights infringements during the COVID-19 pandemic. I have heard that you always developed and presented your position in the best scientific manner and quickly and decisively adopted the sometimes equally necessary pragmatism of the judge. "Senate work socializes," is said to be the not entirely new conviction at the Federal Constitutional Court.

I cannot assess that; I only know: When it was appropriate, you found clear but always carefully weighed words – and several times also wrote a dissenting opinion, such as in the decisions on the Collective Bargaining Agreement Law, the Thuringian Shop Opening Law, and the ZDF ruling from 2014.

In the Senate, your great argumentative strength will be remembered. You always sought the big picture without shying away from the details. I believe you were greatly appreciated for that.

After twelve years, a long time, you are now leaving the "judicial ring" next to the Karlsruhe Palace. You are exchanging your office with a view of the palace park for the lecture halls of the University of Göttingen. You are returning to your chair, back to academia, especially back to international law, which has been brutally violated since February 24 – right in the middle of Europe. The daily news and images from Ukraine document not only the endless suffering of the Ukrainian civilian population but also the traces of brutal crimes. The task is clear: The international community must investigate and clarify what has happened since Russia's invasion of Ukraine in Bucha, Kharkiv, Mariupol, and many other places. International courts must hold accountable all those who have committed and continue to commit crimes in this war. War crimes must not go unpunished! We must make it clear now: International law is not a blunt sword that can simply be ignored!

Dear Mr. Paulus, I am sure we will continue to hear from you. I would now like to invite you, together with President Harbarth, the State Secretary, and the Secretary of State, to come forward for the presentation of the certificate of discharge.

Our country, our rule of law, and our democracy owe you much. I thank you sincerely for your great commitment. And I am pleased to now award you, as a visible recognition of your merits, the Grand Cross of Merit with Star and Shoulder Ribbon of the Order of Merit of the Federal Republic of Germany.

Dear Mr. Wolff, the German Bundestag elected you yesterday as a judge of the Federal Constitutional Court. I congratulate you wholeheartedly on this!

Like your predecessor, you come from academia, being a professor of public law, environmental law, and technology law at the University of Bayreuth. Before your appointment to a professorship, you worked in practice: two years as a consultant in the constitutional department of the Federal Ministry of the Interior, in the department for constitutional special areas. The Federal Constitutional Court can now benefit from the diversity of your experiences.

Your future workplace "Schlossbezirk 3" is also not unfamiliar to you. After your legal clerkship, you were there in 1994 as a research assistant to the then Federal Constitutional Court judge Kirchhof. Later, you appeared several times as a procedural representative before the Federal Constitutional Court. As an expert, you have made a name for yourself in the field of security legislation.

In Karlsruhe, you will now encounter entirely different areas of law as a reporting judge, namely social law, questions in the area of statutory health insurance, and artistic freedom. With your experience, I am sure you will easily find your way into the new subjects.

Now I would like to invite you, dear Mr. Wolff, together with President Harbarth, the State Secretary, and the Secretary of State, to come forward for your appointment and oath.

Dear Mr. Wolff, once again, congratulations! You will be welcomed by friendly colleagues at Schlossplatz. This will make your start easier. I wish you good luck and all the best for your new office!