Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier on the change of judges at the Federal Constitutional Court on January 11, 2023, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

11 January 2023 · Change of judges at the Federal Constitutional Court · Berlin

Context
Steinmeier addressed the ceremony marking the change of judges at the Federal Constitutional Court in Berlin on January 11, 2023, bidding farewell to two departing judges and swearing in two new ones.
Main themes
Federal Constitutional Court judge transition, judicial oath and duty, diversity of judicial backgrounds, rule of law, democracy and constitutional order, farewell to outgoing judges, swearing in of new judges, judicial ethos and independence
Duration
~30 min
82nd percentile
Words
3,540
82nd percentile
Sentences
160
83rd percentile
Readability
50
63rd percentile
Grade
11.5
38th percentile
Syntax
3.10
60th percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
47th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 53%51%
  • Ceremonial 33%32%
  • Social 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 5%4%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

160 sentences in 38 paragraphs

I am pleased that we can once again accompany the change of judges at the Federal Constitutional Court in a larger setting. I am also glad that I can see many of you again on this occasion. But I also know that these are always days of mixed feelings. What is the beginning of something new for some, something they have aspired to or even longed for, is for others a farewell from a position they have held with dedication and passion for many years. Today, I have the honor of honoring and bidding farewell to two outstanding personalities, dear Ms. Hermanns and dear Mr. Huber, while at the same time appointing and swearing in you, dear Ms. Fetzer, and you, dear Mr. Offenloch.

The demands that the oath of office places on the judges of the Federal Constitutional Court could not be higher: The oath includes – as we will hear later – the promise to always adhere reliably to the Basic Law and to apply and safeguard it to the best of one’s knowledge and conscience. When one thinks about it, one inevitably asks the question of who is to meet these requirements. The Basic Law has the answer ready. It provides in Article 94 that the Federal Constitutional Court consists of "federal judges" and "other members." Thus, the Basic Law itself wants the Federal Constitutional Court to be composed of people with different professional backgrounds and influences. And it is indeed correct: Your judicial decisions do not arise in a vacuum. The judges of the Federal Constitutional Court share the highest professional competence. The Basic Law also sees it as a strengthening when very different biographies and influences, judicial experience, legal scholarship, political and legal practice are represented in this court.

I am convinced that the diversity of the judicial personalities strengthens the Federal Constitutional Court as an institution. For when decisions are discussed and weighed from as many different perspectives as possible, this increases their social and political acceptance. This is vital for our democracy. It only functions when the rules of the rule of law are respected and adhered to. You, the judges of the Federal Constitutional Court, watch over this. In doing so, you also help secure the existence of our democracy – even if that means that your decisions are sometimes met with controversy.

You, dear Ms. Hermanns, and you, dear Mr. Huber, have not only fulfilled the promise associated with your oath of office. You have demanded a great deal from yourselves during your twelve years as judges at the Federal Constitutional Court, and for that, I want to thank you today.

Dear Ms. Hermanns, you come from Lower Saxony and grew up in the Emsland. But for a long time now, you have been based in Saarland. You moved there in 1986 after your legal training. In Saarbrücken, you initially worked as a research assistant at the renowned Institute for European Law at the University of Saarland; from there, your extraordinary legal career took off. In 1990, you entered the judicial service of Saarland – initially as a personal advisor to the then Minister of Justice, Arno Walter, whom I still remember fondly. Your first position as a "real" judge followed in 1993 at the District Court of Saarbrücken. After further stations at the Federal Court of Justice, in the Saarland State Chancellery, and at the Saarland Higher Regional Court, you became a judge at the Federal Court of Justice in 2004. At the same time, you were a member of the Constitutional Court of Saarland. You had to give up this position when you exchanged the Hereditary Grand Ducal Palace in Karlsruhe for the palace district twelve years ago and have since worked at the Federal Constitutional Court – not only in the Second Senate. But I will come back to that later.

At that time, you brought the experience of a federal judge into your office, being a so-called "judge-judge." "Unknown, but brilliant" – this is how the Süddeutsche Zeitung described you in November 2010 on the occasion of your election as a Federal Constitutional Judge. A few years later, the Saarländische Zeitung wrote about you: "She belongs to that kind of judge who avoids any fuss about her person out of respect for the dignity of her sovereign task." That you would be unknown today, I would like to doubt. But you have never made a fuss about yourself. Being in the public eye was not your intention. With you, one can clearly sense: you have the ambition to speak through your judgments. That is your judicial ethos. This ethos also includes that you have always sought the most convincing legal arguments for your decision-making – sober, unimpressed, and independent of the political explosiveness of the case to be decided. For this, you were highly regarded in the Karlsruhe environment.

You started in the Second Senate with pre-trial detention, the reopening of criminal proceedings, enforcement law, weapons law, and insolvency law; alongside this, you, like others, dedicated yourself to general civil law. After about a year, you were able to hand over pre-trial detention and "inherited" from the outgoing judge Mellinghoff the area of law for which you have been responsible as a reporting judge to this day: tax and duties law.

This area then became the focus of your department. As a judge of the ordinary jurisdiction, you had not previously dealt with this very technical matter. All the more impressed were some legal companions by the depth and precision with which you made this new area of law your own. And it started off with a bang when the Senate, based on your reporting, declared in May 2013 the unequal treatment of registered partnerships compared to marriages in the context of spousal splitting to be unconstitutional. Later, you made a name for yourself with the decision on "mantle purchases" – where, as the public learned, it was not about fur coats, but about complicated regulations regarding the tax loss carryforward for corporations, which the Senate declared unconstitutional. This was a sensation in tax law, for which the court received great approval in the professional community. Other prominent cases for which you were responsible as a reporting judge revolved around the tax treatment of initial training costs, the principle of trust regarding the tax deductibility of advance payments on ground lease interest, and the tax privileging of income from business profits over income from surplus. Sometimes, a significant constitutional law problem was hidden under the mantle of tax law, such as behind the beer tax, which culminated in a landmark Senate resolution on the competence of the mediation committee.

You did not shy away from bringing about uncomfortable decisions. No Supreme Court likes it when the Federal Constitutional Court declares its judicial submissions inadmissible or finds a violation of the right to a legal judge due to a breach of the obligation to submit to the European Court of Justice. During your time in the First Chamber of the Second Senate, this sometimes led to clear words regarding the obligation of factual clarification by lower courts, for example, in the context of rehabilitating victims of unlawful criminal prosecution or protecting life and health during evictions. In short: If there was something legally to criticize, you clearly named it, or in your words: "If the premises are such, then one must subsume under them."

There is a lot behind this, sometimes hard work: You have handled over 3,500 cases as a reporting judge. "She always wanted to discuss everything, to think to the end," is said about you with great respect. In your department, it is said that it was always cooperative and very tolerant. One could learn a lot from you without being lectured, it is said. Above all, I have heard that your "quiet but strong leadership" has earned great respect. I believe that for many judges, you have become a role model.

Finally, as I hinted at the beginning, you were briefly also active in the First Senate. In the proceedings regarding the wearing of headscarves in public schools, the Vice President of the Court, Constitutional Judge Kirchhof, did not participate due to concerns about bias, so you moved up and took on special responsibility. The colleagues from the First Senate will remember your commitment, for you not only participated in the decision but also, together with Judge Schluckebier, wrote a special vote. By the way, this was not your only special vote – the Second Senate also had to take note of your dissenting opinion regarding the corporate status of the Jehovah's Witnesses, and finally also in the decision regarding judges for a limited time.

But regardless of whether you were active in the Second or the First Senate, whether you were a reporting judge or not: you treated every case as if it were your own, delved deeply into it, and set the highest standards for the stringency of the arguments. "Because," you are said to have said, "eight decide." And that cannot be denied!

Long Senate sessions will no longer shape your everyday life. When asked what you will do after your time at the Federal Constitutional Court, you are said to have answered last autumn: "I will see then; right now, I still have the table full of files." You have remained true to your work ethic until the end. Perhaps you will now take some time for cinematic experiences: I heard you wished for films as a farewell. And for your engagement as an ambassador for Saarland and as an expert in the Venice Commission of the Council of Europe for democracy through law, you now also have more time. I wish you all the best from the bottom of my heart!

Dear Mr. Huber, you did not come to the Federal Constitutional Court as a classic judge, that is, not as a judge-judge. At the time of your election as a Federal Constitutional Judge, you were an active top politician, holding the office of Minister of the Interior of Thuringia. But actually, you are a university professor by training. After your studies in Munich and Geneva, your doctoral thesis and habilitation in Munich, you were already a professor of public law in your early thirties. Your first call took you to Augsburg in 1991. After that, you held professorships in Jena and Bayreuth. In 2002, you returned to your alma mater, Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich, where you have since held the chair for public law and state philosophy. In between, you were repeatedly drawn abroad for guest professorships in Finland, Portugal, and Italy. If I were to list your activities as an expert and your memberships in professional associations individually, I would probably not finish this afternoon. However, you also brought – perhaps not so well known – judicial experience into your new office. For you had already served as a judge in an auxiliary capacity at the Thuringian Higher Administrative Court and later at the Bremen State Court.

On the occasion of your appointment in Karlsruhe, the media described you as combative, conservative, and eloquent. The newspapers labeled you "the active one" – as if the press had sensed the diverse areas for which you would be responsible in Karlsruhe. After the departure of Judge Di Fabio, you took over responsibilities for European and international law. In addition, you were responsible as a reporting judge for municipal law, central register matters, federal-state disputes, and actions for enforcement. Your department was thus involved in particularly many Senate proceedings, reaching the incredible number of over thirty, including a multitude of oral hearings!

Throughout your term, you were intensely engaged with fundamental questions of European integration and had to deal with the limits of transferring sovereign rights to intergovernmental institutions. In these areas, the Second Senate, with you as the reporting judge, made several decisions that fundamentally shape the relationship of the German legal system to intergovernmental legal orders.

As early as 2012, the Senate issued three important rulings that particularly highlighted the overall budgetary responsibility and the budget rights of Parliament as well as the information rights of the German Bundestag. It started with the ruling on the Nine-Member Committee, followed by the decision on the ESM/Euro Plus Pact in the summer, and finally, in the autumn of the same year, the Senate also decided on the expedited procedure for the ratification of the ESM Treaty.

With the OMT decision, the Second Senate made history. In January 2014, the Federal Constitutional Court submitted a case to the European Court of Justice for a preliminary ruling for the first time in its history. Following the "response" from Luxembourg, the Senate once again defined the limits of the opening of German statehood. The decisions regarding the European Banking Union and later the provisional application of the CETA trade agreement further elaborated on the ultra vires and identity control. Against the backdrop of a violation of the right to democratic self-determination, the Senate declared the unconstitutionality of the law on the agreement on a Unified Patent Court in February 2020. Furthermore, the Senate fundamentally addressed the protection of fundamental rights in the multi-level system, as seen in the decisions on the European Arrest Warrant and the European Schools and – or should I say: respectively – in the Ecotoxicity decision.

Once, as your former colleague Paulus put it in his farewell speech, it "crashed loudly." This was the case with the ruling on the PSPP program of the European Central Bank on May 5, 2020, when the Senate found actions outside the Union's competencies. In the meantime, the waves have probably calmed down somewhat. Parts of the expert community read conciliatory tones towards the European Court of Justice from one of your recent Senate proceedings, namely from the ruling on the EU's Corona Recovery Fund. And the President of the European Court of Justice, Koen Lenaerts, recently stated on the occasion of the seventieth anniversary of the Court in a television interview that while the PSPP decision is a "heavy block," he perceives signals of cooperation from Karlsruhe, and – to quote him directly – that the Federal Constitutional Court remains the "best ally" of the European Court of Justice.

Whether this is a statement or more of a proposal for a target agreement, I will leave open. In any case, it remains important from my perspective to conduct the dialogue of the courts in the European Union according to the jointly established rules. Otherwise, we can hardly counteract the centrifugal forces to which the European legal community is clearly exposed.

But there were also other important topics in your department. For example, whether civilian victims of armed conflicts can be compensated individually. Less visible, but certainly very numerous, were the proceedings to compel action. Three Senate proceedings concerned municipal self-administration rights, protection against the withdrawal of municipal tasks, or conversely against the transfer of new tasks. Additionally, you had to decide on the constitutionality of the option municipalities, the register-based census, and the Berlin rent cap, which the Second Senate declared unconstitutional. The capital was not pleased about this but had to acknowledge that it simply lacks the competence. Probably, a few people from your Bavarian homeland did not rejoice when they read in a chamber decision that a referendum on Bavaria's exit from the Federal Republic of Germany is inadmissible. In short, it stated: "There is no room under the Basic Law for secessionist efforts by individual states." I am sure: Even for you as a Bavarian and as a well-known supporter of more direct democracy through popular initiatives, this sentence must have flowed easily from your pen.

What a number, what proceedings! As I heard, you were once asked in a Bavarian lecture hall how it is "over there" in Karlsruhe. To this, you reportedly replied: "Sometimes it is not quite easy." This sentence from your mouth may surprise some contemporaries who have experienced you publicly in the media or at lectures – I am convinced that this statement shows humility and respect for the difficult questions and for the even more challenging task of answering them correctly. If you also meant that there was indeed real debate in the Senate and that not everything is simply accepted by colleagues, then it holds true: Dispute is often the first step towards resolution.

Where the dispute cannot be resolved despite intense consultation, the procedure knows a way out: Four times you have taken the path of dissenting opinions. In the decision on the constitutionality of the Therapy Placement Act, you could not identify with the Senate majority, just as little as with the decisions on the Council of Europe Convention on Cybercrime, on the unconstitutionality of the Nuclear Fuel Tax Act, and on removal from public service by administrative act.

You will now be more frequently present in the lecture halls of the Bavarian capital, but I am sure that not only your students will continue to hear your voice; we will also continue to hear from you. And in memory of our previous encounters and conversations, I look forward to it. All the best to you!

Dear Ms. Hermanns and dear Mr. Huber, your very different personalities have been a great asset to the Federal Constitutional Court and a stroke of luck for our democracy.

I would now like to invite you, dear Ms. Hermanns, to come forward first to receive the certificate of discharge, together with you, Mr. President Harbarth, and you, Mr. Minister Buschmann and Mr. State Secretary Krösser.

Dear Ms. Hermanns, our country owes you a great debt of gratitude. I sincerely thank you for your outstanding commitment. And I am pleased to award you the Grand Cross of Merit with Star and Shoulder Ribbon of the Order of Merit of the Federal Republic of Germany.

Now I would like to invite you, dear Mr. Huber, to come forward.

Dear Mr. Huber, on behalf of the German people, I thank you for your outstanding commitment to our country. It is a great pleasure for me to now award you as a visible recognition of your merits the Grand Cross of Merit with Star and Shoulder Ribbon of the Order of Merit of the Federal Republic of Germany. Thank you once again and congratulations!

Dear Ms. Fetzer, dear Mr. Offenloch, the German Bundestag elected both of you as judges of the Federal Constitutional Court on December 15, 2022. I congratulate you warmly on this!

A new chapter in your lives begins, which will bring many challenges. I hope you were not filled with dread when you heard how much work lies ahead of you. It is now up to you to take on the responsibility that comes with the office of judge of the Federal Constitutional Court.

With you both, two top jurists from Baden-Württemberg are joining the Second Senate. That your places of birth, Reutlingen – where you were born, Ms. Fetzer – and Constance – your birthplace, Mr. Offenloch – are only about a hundred kilometers apart in a straight line is probably coincidence. Less coincidental seems to me that your professional paths are quite similar, as I have noted.

Dear Ms. Fetzer, "when I grow up, I will study law" – you decided this at the age of fourteen, as you revealed last year in a justice podcast. Since 2009, you have been a federal judge, as a member of the 8th Civil Senate of the Federal Court of Justice. You took over its chair in May of last year. Previously, you worked as a judge in Baden-Württemberg and were responsible for the training of legal trainees for a time. You have said about your Senate at the Federal Court of Justice that "real life" takes place there. I am certain: The cases in the Second Senate will certainly not be any less exciting.

Dear Mr. Offenloch, you are also coming to the Federal Constitutional Court as a federal judge. Since October 2013, you have served at the Federal Court of Justice, most recently as a judge in the 6th Civil Senate. Before that, you were a judge in the Baden-Württemberg judiciary, during which time you were seconded to the Ministry of Justice in Stuttgart twice, once at the beginning of your career as a personal advisor to the management and later as a departmental and deputy department head. You also have six children. This means: In addition to your extensive professional experience, you bring a considerable degree of stress resistance to the Karlsruhe judiciary.

Dear Ms. Fetzer, dear Mr. Offenloch, we have heard that you are well equipped for the tasks ahead of you. I wish you that you quickly find your way into your new responsibilities and enjoy working with your colleagues in the palace district.

I would now like to invite you, dear Ms. Fetzer, to come forward for your appointment and oath, together with you, Mr. President, and with you, Mr. Minister and Mr. State Secretary.

Now I would like to invite you, dear Mr. Offenloch, to come to me for your appointment and oath.

Dear Ms. Fetzer, dear Mr. Offenloch, I wish you every success in your new office!