Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier on the change of judges at the Federal Constitutional Court on December 23, 2023, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

23 December 2023 · Presentation of certificates and appointment of Federal Constitutional Court judges · Schloss Bellevue, Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed a ceremony at Schloss Bellevue on December 23, 2023, to mark the swearing-in of new Federal Constitutional Court judges and farewell to departing ones.
Main themes
Federal Constitutional Court judge transitions, rule of law and judicial independence, constitutional security, farewell to outgoing judges, appointment of new judges, protection of citizens' freedoms, risks of autocracy to judiciary
Duration
~22 min
71st percentile
Words
2,672
71st percentile
Sentences
139
78th percentile
Readability
49
59th percentile
Grade
11.0
32nd percentile
Syntax
2.95
41st percentile
Vocabulary
2.28
68th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Ceremonial 49%47%
  • Institutional 38%37%
  • Social 13%12%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

139 sentences in 35 paragraphs

A warm welcome to Schloss Bellevue – just before Christmas. We are bringing the gift-giving a little early: there are certificates and a medal.

And I understand that the colleagues I am appointing and swearing in are eagerly looking forward to their new desks in Karlsruhe after the exciting phase of public debate and the election of judges. I will not stand in the way of that. However, allow me a few words about the court, the outgoing and incoming judges.

Rarely before has the Federal Constitutional Court been so much in the public eye in recent weeks – in politics and in the media. I am glad that this has happened – with few exceptions – with the necessary respect. Our rule of law is completed by a judiciary whose task it is to oversee compliance with the constitution and to interpret its provisions authoritatively, even if individual decisions pose difficult challenges for politics. A constitution is not meant to make things easy for politics. Rather, we have given ourselves a constitution to control the exercise of state authority so that the freedom of citizens is protected. How important this is can be seen from the fact – your former president Voßkuhle recently reminded us in "Die Zeit" – that an immediate disempowerment of the independent judiciary usually occurs in states where autocrats have seized power. Voßkuhle draws the conclusion for us that we should make the Federal Constitutional Court more constitutionally secure. I too would feel more comfortable if some of what we have regulated in the Federal Constitutional Court Act, such as election procedures and terms of office, were transferred to the constitution and thus secured by the requirement of a constitutional amendment majority.

Dear Ms. Kessal-Wulf, dear Mr. Müller, with you, we bid farewell to two judicial personalities who represent the broad spectrum of constitutional judges: You, dear Ms. Kessal-Wulf, are shaped by the image of the judge who has been accustomed throughout her entire professional life to speak solely through her judgment. And you, dear Mr. Müller, after your time as Minister-President of Saarland – as you once described it – exchanged your task of shaping for an unconditional duty to precision in legal decisions. A completely new life! Let us take a look together at these very different biographies:

Dear Ms. Kessal-Wulf, you were born in Stadthagen, in Schaumburg-Lippe. A little bit of law was laid in your cradle, as your father was a senior public prosecutor. And if I am correctly informed, your two brothers are also lawyers. After studying at the University of Kiel, you passed the first state examination in Schleswig in 1982 and the second in Hamburg in 1985. You then entered the higher judicial service of the state of Schleswig-Holstein, where you were appointed a lifetime judge at the Flensburg District Court in 1988.

After a secondment to the Schleswig-Holstein Higher Regional Court, you were appointed a judge there in 1992. Already at the age of 33! Particularly impressive, alongside your work as a judge, you earned your doctorate in 1995 at the University of Kiel on the topic "The Internal Associations using the example of public companies, franchising, employee participation, and trade associations." Your work was not only rated summa cum laude but also awarded the faculty prize and the prize of the Kiel Doctores Iuris e.V.

At the Higher Regional Court in Schleswig-Holstein, you were a member of the Senate for corporate, banking, and stock exchange law. At the Federal Court of Justice, to which you were elected by the Judicial Selection Committee in 2001, you were in the 4th Civil Senate, which was responsible for inheritance and insurance contract law. The press wrote about your professional career upon your election as a Federal Constitutional Court judge that you had made a "rapid career." You had a reputation for being outstandingly knowledgeable. Apparently, you were also particularly impartial! Because you were elected to the Federal Court of Justice on the proposal of the Green Justice Minister from Schleswig-Holstein, but in November 2011, you were then elected by the Bundesrat on the proposal of the CDU/CSU as a judge of the Federal Constitutional Court – by the way, as only the second woman proposed by the Christian Democrats for the Constitutional Court. On December 19, 2011, you were appointed and sworn in.

At the Federal Constitutional Court, you succeeded Rudolf Mellinghoff. The law of insurance, criminal law and criminal procedure, the law of reopening and reinstatement, pre-trial detention, and administrative offenses fell within your department. Areas of responsibility in which the case load is high. However, one area of responsibility played no role for a long time, namely that for financial constitutional and budgetary law. Here you only became active as a reporting judge at the end of your term. The FAZ titled you as "The Composed One."

Dear Ms. Kessal-Wulf, I am always impressed by the following numbers, as they show how much work needs to be done in Karlsruhe. I mention them also because they illustrate that citizens are taking advantage of the opportunities to approach the Federal Constitutional Court. By December 18, 2023, you, dear Ms. Kessal-Wulf, had prepared a total of 4,119 decisions as a reporting judge, of which 3,970 were constitutional complaints and 14 Senate decisions. This can only be managed if you are, like you, "clearly an exceptional talent for legal work combined with discipline." And you deliver outstanding professional performance, diligent, disciplined, and not a daredevil – as the FAZ acknowledged.

Among the decisions you prepared were many of fundamental importance. I think, for example, of the decision of September 23, 2015, regarding the scope of the parliamentary reservation for military deployments in cases of imminent danger. This concerned a Bundeswehr deployment in Libya. A particularly significant societal decision was the ruling of February 26, 2020, which dealt with assisted suicide. Here, the Federal Constitutional Court confirmed the right to self-determined dying. Among the numerous chamber decisions, there were also some that had far-reaching effects, such as the decision of September 30, 2022, regarding the NSU trial or the so-called Kudamm racers.

Even at your election, you were considered assertive, oriented towards legal argumentation, and persistent. Your colleagues highlight your openness and curiosity.

You have reportedly once said about yourself: "I do not seek conflict, but I can endure it." That you did not shy away from preparing uncomfortable decisions as a reporting judge is also evident in the decision on the invalidity of the Second Supplementary Budget Act of November 15, 2023. Hardly any other decision has occupied politics as much as this one.

Even though this decision was certainly a thunderclap, you are praised as "a woman of quiet tones." Judicial restraint may be further enhanced by your North German nature. You do not like to push yourself into the foreground, so it is said. Despite all your restraint, you are described as a great boss who is very interested in her employees and also follows their life paths. Your employees, I hear, enjoyed working for you and appreciated the team spirit in your department, as evidenced by the departmental meetings that took place repeatedly.

Dear Ms. Kessal-Wulf, a new chapter in your life begins today. I have been informed that you are curious about the world and have already traveled widely. Perhaps you will now have a little more time for travel to places you have not yet visited. I wish you all the best from the bottom of my heart!

Dear Mr. Müller, when the Bundesrat elected you to the Constitutional Court twelve years ago, some received this with skepticism. A politician on the Constitutional Court – a former Minister-President even – was too much politics in the court for some. Others, however, emphasized even then that the court needed the expertise and experience of a seasoned politician who, of course, also brings the necessary qualifications as a lawyer for the highest German court.

My impression is that you have satisfied both groups. Those who were critical of your election because of your political role were convinced by your self-imposed greatest restraint in public. You focused on your new office and, in the best sense of the word, spoke through the judgments you helped shape. And the court, as I have heard from various sources, has been enriched by your experience from your political life, especially since you were always able to locate this expertise legally.

You once answered the question of which role was more exciting – that of the Saarland Minister-President or that of a constitutional judge – by saying they were completely different worlds. The work at the Federal Constitutional Court is characterized by the absolute duty to coherent legal argumentation. And the intellectual challenge is exciting!

With your election as a judge of the Federal Constitutional Court as a member of the Second Senate on November 25, 2011, by the Bundesrat and your appointment on December 19, 2011, you succeeded Udo Di Fabio. Initially, your department did not necessarily cover the areas of law that are generally considered exciting: criminal enforcement law, condominium law, or the law of voluntary jurisdiction. But over time, more exciting areas of law such as parliamentary law, party law, or electoral law were added.

You have prepared important decisions, dear Mr. Müller. I can only mention a few here: The decision of February 6, 2013, regarding subsequent preventive detention following psychiatric confinement had implications for our entire penal system. The NPD prohibition proceedings you prepared received significant public attention, which on January 17, 2017, did not lead to a prohibition because, in the court's view, there was a lack of evidence for a successful enforcement of their anti-constitutional goals. The decisions on party financing and the financing of the work of political foundations are also landmark. And until the end, you were occupied with federal electoral law, even though you no longer have to prepare the recently pending proceedings. But by December 15, 2023, you had prepared 260 Senate decisions, of which 226 were electoral procedures! In total, your record as a reporting judge shows 3,755 decisions.

No wonder that your colleagues described you as the simultaneous embodiment of diligence and sociability. In the evenings, you were said to be the last one in the court, and even when it got late, you were often one of the first at Schlossplatz in the morning.

Everyone who knows you, especially your employees, highlights your down-to-earth nature, your humor, and your openness to everyone. Given your down-to-earth nature, it is hardly surprising that you not only still live in your hometown of Eppelborn but are also the second chairman of the Eppelborn football club. It also fits that you rarely decline a game of skat – whether with the employees in your department or with your driver. And just as you do not shy away from grilling with friends, you do not let anyone else do the grilling for you. Employees have also been able to convince themselves of this during invitations to your home in Saarland.

Dear Mr. Müller, twelve years plus an extension at the Federal Constitutional Court come to an end today. My impression is that you have enjoyed this time despite the work. But you are also looking a little into the future: Recently, you have occasionally appeared publicly in your Saarland homeland. There have already been speculations that you wanted to return to politics. I have no idea if there is any truth to that. I also hear the opposite. Others say your next life goal is to return to a judgeship – one that continues your great passion for the card game. Therefore, it is rumored in the scene that you are aiming for a lifetime judgeship at the skat court in Altenburg in Thuringia. I am sure you would enrich this court with your expertise as well.

Judicial changes at the Constitutional Court follow certain traditions, which regularly include the awarding of the Grand Cross of Merit with Star and Shoulder Ribbon. Exceptionally, this will not be the case for you today, as you were already awarded this order level as Minister-President of Saarland. Let me express my gratitude and appreciation for your work as a judge at the Federal Constitutional Court – even without a new order certificate.

Dear Mr. Müller, therefore, I can only ask you to come forward for the presentation of the discharge certificate. Already now: All the best to you!

Dear Ms. Kessal-Wulf and dear Mr. Müller, your so different personalities have been a great asset to the Federal Constitutional Court and a stroke of luck for our democracy. For this, I thank you from the bottom of my heart:

Now your terms of office are coming to an end. First, I would like to invite you, dear Ms. Kessal-Wulf, to come forward to receive your certificate of discharge, together with you, Mr. President, and you, Mr. Minister and Mr. State Secretary.

Dear Ms. Kessal-Wulf, our country owes you a great debt of gratitude. I sincerely thank you for your outstanding commitment. And I am pleased to award you the Grand Cross of Merit with Star and Shoulder Ribbon of the Order of Merit of the Federal Republic of Germany for this.

Dear Mr. Müller, you already have the recognition on your lapel that outgoing colleagues usually receive. Therefore, you will leave empty-handed today. Nevertheless, I would like to thank you once again sincerely for your commitment. You have rendered valuable service to our country.

Dear Mr. Frank, dear Mr. Wöckel, the Federal Council elected both of you as judges of the Federal Constitutional Court on November 24 and December 15, respectively. I congratulate you warmly on this!

For you, a new professional chapter begins, full of challenges. And with a high responsibility that comes with the office of judge of the Federal Constitutional Court. The case numbers I just mentioned will also be something you will have to manage. But I am convinced that this will not deter you.

Dear Mr. Frank, since October 5, 2015, you have been the Federal Prosecutor at the Federal Court of Justice. At the age of 47 upon taking office, you were the youngest Federal Prosecutor in the history of the Federal Republic of Germany. After studying in Würzburg and Munich, you passed both state examinations in law with distinction and earned your doctorate in criminal procedure law summa cum laude.

You worked as a public prosecutor in Munich and in various roles within the Bavarian judiciary. The Bavarian Minister of Justice already praised your legal expertise, leadership skills, and talent in dealing with people at that time. Upon your appointment as Federal Prosecutor, the Federal Minister of Justice characterized you as an "excellent jurist" and "committed civil servant with sensitivity and leadership strength," experienced and resilient.

That you are also approachable and easygoing, I have experienced myself during our meetings and conversations. Your new workplace is not far from the old one. This may facilitate a quick arrival and adjustment.

Dear Mr. Wöckel, you are also coming to the Federal Constitutional Court as a federal judge. Since February 1, 2021, you have been a judge in the 2nd Senate of the Federal Administrative Court. Before that, you were a judge in the North Rhine-Westphalian judiciary, in my East Westphalian homeland, at the Administrative Court in Minden. During this time, you were already seconded to the Federal Administrative Court, and later also to the Federal Constitutional Court. Growing up in Chemnitz, you studied law in Dresden and Freiburg. After your legal clerkship at the District Court of Freiburg, you were an assistant at the Institute for Public Law at the University of Freiburg with Dietrich Murswiek from 2004 to 2010, where you also wrote your dissertation. "A brilliant, non-partisan judge at the Federal Administrative Court," commented Reinhard Müller on your election in the FAZ.

Dear Mr. Frank, dear Mr. Wöckel, you are both well equipped for the tasks that lie ahead of you.