State visit to the Swiss Confederation from April 25 to 26, 2018 - Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the panel discussion on the topic "Can Democracy Survive in the 21st Century?" at the University of Fribourg on April 26, 2018 in ...

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

27 April 2018 · State visit to the Swiss Confederation: panel discussion "Can Democracy Survive in the 21st Century?" · University of Fribourg, Fribourg, Switzerland

Context
Steinmeier spoke at a panel discussion at the University of Fribourg during his state visit to Switzerland on April 26, 2018, addressing the question of democracy's survival in the 21st century.
Main themes
Survival of democracy, authoritarianism and illiberal democracy, social polarization, digitization and social media, populism, globalization and inequality, disinformation and algorithmic manipulation, German-Swiss relations, trust in democratic institutions, privacy and data regulation
Duration
~11 min
40th percentile
Words
1,363
40th percentile
Sentences
58
38th percentile
Readability
46
52nd percentile
Grade
12.4
49th percentile
Syntax
3.27
79th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
26th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 27%26%
  • Technological 21%21%
  • Ceremonial 21%21%
  • Social 18%17%
  • Geopolitical 9%9%
  • Economic 4%3%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

58 sentences in 14 paragraphs

I thank you for the warm welcome, Madam Rector, and for the invitation to be here at the University of Freiburg. Mr. President, you know it: I often and gladly come to your beautiful country! As Foreign Minister, I was here particularly often, because Switzerland is simply indispensable on the world stage of diplomacy. And now I come for the first time as the German Federal President. This state visit is a sign of the close connection and friendship between our two countries. Thank you very much for the invitation, dear Alain Berset!

I have been particularly looking forward to today’s discussion round. No, I do not say this out of politeness, because in that regard, we Germans cannot hold a candle to the Swiss anyway. I say this because our topic today is also my heart's topic as Federal President – not because I wished for it, but because I have seen the need for it. Just imagine for a moment that someone had proposed such a discussion round ten or twenty years ago: "Can democracy survive in the 21st century?" Imagine someone had asked that – for example, in the 1990s, when some even proclaimed the end of history after the fall of the Iron Curtain. Or in 2011, when the buds of the Arab Spring were universally celebrated on Facebook and Twitter. I suspect that most of you would have furrowed your brows in surprise, thinking, "Now he is exaggerating" – and then turned to more pressing questions.

And today? Today we come in large numbers and with great interest to such a round. I believe: This is justified. The challenges to democracy are visible to everyone. The question of the system is openly posed by some. And this is not only far away, in Russia or China, where it is said: "Growth and security – yes, freedom and democracy: no." Quite the opposite: In truth, a new fascination with authoritarianism has already deeply penetrated the transatlantic West and Europe, where some have proudly proclaimed the era of so-called "illiberal democracy." In short: We are in the midst of a testing time for democracy.

As food for our discussion, I would like to mention – as briefly as possible – three keywords.

The first is social polarization, which concerns us in Germany and Switzerland in a similar way. After the shockwaves of the Brexit vote and the American presidential election in 2016, we Germans felt the cracks that also run through our society in the following year: first in a federal election campaign with some bitter outbursts of anger and aggression, such as we had not known before, and finally in the election results of September 24 itself.

I believe it is important that we as democrats do not simply lament polarization, but that we take a close look at its causes, especially where life has become more difficult for many, at the everyday conflicts in the country, far from the grand world politics:

For example, when the big cities are booming and rents are becoming ever more expensive, but in many rural areas, life prospects are disappearing and especially young people are moving away. When bonuses and incomes on the international financial markets soar to dizzying heights, but many, especially less well-educated people, see primarily the fear of job loss and the risk of social decline in globalization and technological progress. And when populists then turn all these fears against a so-called establishment – whether in politics, business, or even science; whether in Bern, Berlin, or especially in Brussels – then the societal centrifugal forces increasingly gnaw at trust in the democratic system itself, in its representatives and institutions.

The polarization brings me to the second keyword, digitization. I think little of declaring digitization itself to be the source of political evil. On the contrary: The digital revolution has brought unprecedented freedoms, allowed new business models to grow, and connected people all over the world. But the digital revolution undoubtedly has the potential to further amplify the centrifugal forces in our societies – when under the cloak of anonymity, the tone in social networks becomes increasingly harsh and irreconcilable; when the boundaries between what can be said and what is unspeakable increasingly blur. Or when algorithms on YouTube & Co. are not programmed for editorial responsibility or factual clarification, but for maximum click yield and user retention; when – for the sake of maximum time spent on the platform – after a radical video, the next more radical one is suggested. In election campaign times, social media can even become a tool for voter manipulation. Since Cambridge Analytica, we all know what is meant. For all this, we undoubtedly need rules. But what should they look like, and who should make them? I would also like to discuss this with you.

The Israeli scholar Yuval Noah Harari recently said: "The greatest danger facing liberal democracy today is that the revolution in information technology makes dictatorships more efficient than democracies." Well, this line of attack on democracy is not new. It was precisely this that gave the radical forces their fatal attraction in the 1920s and 1930s. And it is true: Democracy is a demanding form of government because it is based on compromise, because not all power flows to a "strong hand," but because it guarantees every citizen not only freedoms but also imposes a part of the responsibility. Therefore, I call it the form of government for the brave.

What is new, however, and what Harari means, is how autocratic regimes can systematically make "better" decisions through digital technologies. "Better" in terms of the output that follows from these decisions – whether in terms of prosperity or security, environment and infrastructure. If autocracies, which do not care about privacy and civil liberties, access all available data and feed this data to increasingly powerful algorithms, can they not soon control human behavior down to the smallest social units and deep into private life? Can they not counter dissatisfaction and rebellion, which often stand at the beginning of democratic movements, even earlier? By the way, all of this is no longer dystopian science fiction: In China, a so-called social credit system is currently being prepared, which, based on big data, is supposed to reward good behavior and punish misconduct – with both, of course, being defined by the state. And when we then imagine how, according to reports, 600 million cameras will monitor public spaces in China and, thanks to artificial intelligence, even recognize individual faces in the crowd, we can begin to grasp the significance of Harari's warning words.

My third and final keyword follows, so to speak, in reverse from all of this. As a reaction to the restlessness of our time, to digitization, artificial intelligence, and the other, ever faster waves of technological disruption, I feel one thing increasingly strongly in our societies: a new need for identity and orientation, for deceleration, for clear answers, for firm support in the current flow.

Perhaps we should not be surprised that at this time, it is precisely those political forces that know how to use the digital future for themselves, who conjure up a golden past. Populists use the new channels to provide old answers to the question of identity and orientation: isolation, exclusion, nationalism.

I believe: It must not and cannot be that way! Our societies need a positive vision of the digital future that takes the need for social and economic security seriously or – as I mentioned above – for functioning output while simultaneously preserving freedom, diversity, and openness – in short: that creates a desire for the future.

I know: There are many exciting ideas in Switzerland for this – and I want to learn from them, for example, how you have recently succeeded time and again in using the tools of digital communication for democracy, against populism, and for a clear distinction between facts and opinions. I am eager to hear about your experiences in this regard. So: I look forward to four clever, engaged Swiss people here on the podium and to your questions and contributions from the audience! Thank you very much!