Speech by Federal President Horst Köhler at the Annual Meeting of the Donors' Association for the German Science on May 11, 2007, in Stuttgart:

Germany Horst Köhler · President of Germany

12 May 2007 · Annual Meeting of the Donors' Association for the German Science · opera house, Stuttgart

Context
Köhler addressed the Annual Meeting of the Donors' Association for German Science on May 11, 2007, in Stuttgart, speaking on creativity as the foundation of Germany's future.
Main themes
Creativity, education and innovation, German science and research, knowledge economy, prerequisites for creativity, freedom of thought, competition of ideas, the German Future Prize, curiosity-driven learning, discovery-based learning, national competitiveness
Duration
~25 min
75th percentile
Words
2,962
75th percentile
Sentences
132
76th percentile
Readability
40
36th percentile
Grade
13.0
57th percentile
Syntax
3.11
62nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
29th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 60%57%
  • Economic 23%22%
  • Technological 6%6%
  • Institutional 6%6%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

132 sentences in 33 paragraphs

"The Stuff That the Future Is Made Of – Creativity in Germany"

For almost 100 years now, the creative power of great artists has been celebrated in this beautiful opera house. But how do sounds become music? How do words become a story that touches the heart? And what makes certain combinations of libretto and music so irresistible that they continue to captivate people for centuries?

For the past ten years, the Federal President – supported by the Stifterverband für die Deutsche Wissenschaft and its members – has been awarding pioneering researchers and developers with the German Future Prize. But what is the path from identifying a problem to finding a solution? How do a good idea lead to many good products? How do innovations arise that make our lives easier and enrich them?

Whether in art or in science and research, it always comes down to one ability: creativity.

However, creativity in the history of human progress is somewhat like light. As a layperson, one does not quite know what it is, but one quickly notices whether it shines brighter or weaker, or is even completely absent. After all, we can recognize creativity by its results, and occasionally it reveals itself openly, for example, when someone writes the "Marseillaise" in one night or discovers the law of gravity one fine day in the case of an apple. But most of the time, creativity operates more in the background and on very winding paths. That is why no one has yet been able to pin it down or define it, despite the many philosophers and educators, neuroscientists and innovation researchers, entrepreneurs and politicians who pursue it.

The English philosopher Margaret Boden succinctly describes the phenomenon of "creativity" as follows: "Creative ideas are new, surprising and valuable."

New – for example, is the optical formula with which Stefan Hell, the current recipient of the German Future Prize, overcame the Abbe diffraction limit and thus laid the foundation for light microscopy with unprecedented sharpness.

Surprising – was the way Melitta Bentz used her children's blotting paper to finally enjoy coffee without grounds.

Useful and valuable – as was Robert Bosch's idea of using a spark plug to bring the gas mixture in an engine to a controlled explosion. The spark plug enabled the breakthrough of the automobile and brought Bosch unprecedented economic success.

Leaving beaten paths of thought, recombining existing knowledge in unforeseen ways, breaking new ground for the never-before-seen – that is where creativity manifests itself. To explain or even control it conclusively is likely impossible. Creativity can "only be allowed or prevented," says Hubert Markl, the former president of the Max Planck Society. And that also means: creativity can be enabled, perhaps even facilitated.

And that is what we must care about. We all know how important ideas and how indispensable innovations are for the well-being of our country. We know, of course, that the most important resource we have in Germany lies in the minds of the people. And we know, of course, that we can only compete in the international arena if we are at least as much better as we are more expensive. Better – that means above all: more ingenious and faster in developing solutions that make life easier for people worldwide, perhaps even more beautiful. We know all this, of course. But do we act accordingly? Do we tirelessly ensure the conditions that allow or even encourage and facilitate creativity?

Creativity thrives on at least three prerequisites: education that fosters curiosity, freedom, and fair competition of ideas, which is always also an exchange of ideas.

Ideas are rarely mere strokes of luck: "Chance favors only the prepared mind," says Louis Pasteur. A solid knowledge base, the ability to connect information, the capacity to organize one's thoughts and think them through – these fundamental conditions for creativity must be established already in school. We know that we can do much better in this area in Germany. How is someone supposed to build bold structures of thought later if they lack the necessary building blocks of knowledge – not to mention the ability to assemble them solidly? Both must be provided to young people, especially when they leave our secondary schools, because otherwise, they do not continue. This is also exhausting for all involved, I know. But Thomas Edison rightly said: "Genius is one percent inspiration and ninety-nine percent perspiration." Learning, after all, requires effort: we need more willingness to do so, both on the part of learners and educators.

Understand me correctly: I am not advocating for the old rote-learning school. Rather, we must become more aware of the value of playful, independent, and discovery-based learning, which, by the way, should not only begin in school but should also be encouraged in the home and in daycare. And I am convinced that young people can best develop their creative potential when learning is not just about facts but also about experiencing and living. This is especially true for the natural and technical sciences, where we may also have a shortage of young talent because self-directed experimentation and immediate observation of nature are often neglected in school instruction. That is why it is good that initiatives like the "Wissensfabrik" and the science centers emerging everywhere are opening new opportunities for children, for example, to discover the secrets of a cell with a microscope, to build an arch independently, and to create a designer piece from a sheet of metal. Therefore, it is important that science reaches out to the researchers and developers of tomorrow: for example, at the annual science summers as part of the "Wissenschaft im Dialog" initiative or with the children's universities that have now become part of the higher education repertoire in many places.

Understanding connections, recognizing order, and creatively engaging with it: this is also a goal of good teaching in the arts subjects. Of course, music and art belong on the curriculum because they open up the world in a joyful and fulfilling way. But it is also permissible to emphasize their useful aspects – and one of them is that they have been proven to be particularly stimulating to creativity. It is doubly shortsighted, then, when it is precisely music and art education that are the first to be cut in schedule reductions!

What we need is the opposite of class cancellations – and we need different teaching: If children are to be truly challenged and supported in their learning according to their talents and needs, then the much-discussed individual support must finally be more than just lip service everywhere, and from now on, the excuse that there is unfortunately a lack of money or that teachers are inadequately prepared should be taboo.

I am convinced: All – fortunately already initiated – efforts for a better school will remain piecemeal if we do not succeed in training teachers in a way that is truly closer to practice, providing them with more support and recognition for their important work, and thus attracting the best to the profession. The Stifterverband has gathered and promoted good ideas with its action program "New Paths in Teacher Training." Now, continuing education must also be taken into account. That is good, because as the students in Kästner's "Flying Classroom" rightly say: "We need teachers who must develop if they want to develop us." – Teachers, therefore, who are role models in their willingness to set out for new shores time and again and take their students along.

Education – writes Hartmut von Hentig – gives meaning to curiosity. Education structures the natural drive for knowledge and helps creativity to take off. That is why we should strengthen the institutions that train this leap strength: schools, of course, and universities, too.

We want universities and universities of applied sciences to be breeding grounds for the mind, where curiosity and the urge to research are transformed into new knowledge. We want them to be places where people continuously expand their intellectual horizons – in the solitude of a library as well as in an interdisciplinary seminar or a multinational laboratory team. We want as many young people as possible to acquire the tools at universities to succeed in the knowledge society with their ideas and abilities.

However, in light of overcrowded lecture halls, dilapidated buildings, and a lack of equipment in laboratories and libraries, one occasionally gets the impression that education here follows the principle: "Necessity is the mother of invention." Now, it is undoubtedly true that scarcity can also be an important driver of creativity. This is evidenced, not least, by the history of the Stifterverband – conceived in 1920 by Haber and Schmidt-Ott as a "relief organization for German science." But we should guard against the delusion that every necessity can be turned into a virtue. Our universities are chronically underfunded, especially in light of increasing demands. In OECD comparisons, Germany's spending on students has long been only in the middle range, and in relation to our economic strength, our spending on higher education students is below average. We can afford this, even though we want young people to be able to study quickly and successfully and to encounter committed university teachers who are scientific mentors, role models, and partners at the same time. Such scientists do exist – as evidenced, for example, by the "Ars legendi Prize," which the Stifterverband and the Conference of University Rectors jointly award for excellent university teachers. We need more of them. A quality offensive for teaching is also being planned by the Conference of Ministers of Education and the Science Council. I am glad about that and look forward to it.

But it is not only the state – and that means, after the federalism reform, initially every federal state – that is called upon when it comes to the future of universities. The economy also bears responsibility, as it relies on excellently trained young talent and benefits from the scientific output of universities. It is good that companies take on endowed professorships and award research contracts to universities; it is relieving when they support renovation measures, and it is right when they assist students through scholarship programs and internships. And if you as a company do not know how to engage with universities: Ask the Stifterverband!

Creativity needs a solid foundation of education, and creativity needs freedom to unfold. Freedom – in this case, also means: adequate financial resources.

Year after year, the statistics from the Stifterverband show us that we spend too little on research and development. We invoke the Lisbon goal and yet have not come any closer to it – on the contrary: in 2005, expenditures for research and development were only 2.46 percent of gross domestic product. Is this what the consistent effort promised by the state and the economy for ideas and innovations looks like, which are supposed to secure a good future for our country?

The federal government has now at least launched a six billion program – a good start, now the states must follow suit. Here in Baden-Württemberg, I actually do not need to say this. As the only federal state, it already exceeds the three percent mark today.

More than two-thirds of research and development expenditures in Germany are provided by the economy. However, I am increasingly hearing from companies: We are relocating research and development capacities abroad – to where we produce and where our markets are. I then like to inquire further: Of course, such relocations are a normal part of the internationalization of our economy. Many foreign companies also invest in Germany, and they create research and development capacities as well. At the same time, however, caution is warranted: The parts of companies responsible for innovations have a special leadership and steering function. Sending them abroad may facilitate collaboration within the company there; but does it also make work easier at home? And from an economic perspective, there is a strong interest in ensuring that the export and import of research and development capacities at least balance each other – and even better, that it tilts in favor of the domestic location. I know that a single company can only take this into account to a limited extent. But at least the old craftsman's rule should always be observed before relocating abroad: measure three times before cutting once. Are, for example, personnel costs abroad really so much lower even in the medium term? Is it possible to forge the cohesion that characterizes local company communities there, or do good employees leave at the first better offer?

And when I sometimes hear the objection: Here in our country, we no longer find enough highly qualified, good employees. Then I return the question: Can you as entrepreneurs not contribute a great deal to changing this by supporting schools and universities and by also showing young people how exciting and promising the professional challenges are, for example, for those who study natural or engineering sciences?

Support for research and development requires determination, perseverance, and courage: for example, the determination to concentrate resources instead of spreading them thinly across all possible fields of innovation; for example, the perseverance to persistently seek new insights and better solutions, even if this does not yield quick profits; and for example, the courage to financially help creative research and development projects over the hurdle of the initial phase. In Germany, only 0.014 percent of gross domestic product is invested in promising but still risky start-up projects – in the USA, this share is twice as high.

The federal government's high-tech strategy shows what we can do better in promoting innovation: not only in venture capital but also, for example, in the participation of small and medium-sized enterprises, whose research and development potential is far from being fully utilized.

And from another source, it could also flow more vigorously for science and research in Germany: I mean private foundations. I do not need to convince you of this, as many of you have founded foundations for exactly this reason. I thank you for that. And I hope that your example will inspire others as well – ideally in such a way that the promotion of science and research in Germany becomes a matter of honor for citizens. The upcoming amendment to foundation law, to which the Stifterverband has also provided important impulses, will make it even easier and more attractive in the future to transfer private capital into foundations and thus support science and other charitable purposes. In any case, I wish for growth, especially in philanthropy, that is, in engagement for the cohesion and future viability of our society.

Good ideas need freedom, but they also need the right measure of reliability. For example, anyone who is advancing a long-term basic research project should not have to ponder every day whether their endeavor might soon be postponed in favor of short-term, marketable goals. Or also: Anyone pursuing a somewhat crazy but not implausible idea should not have to fear that a failure will overshadow or even ruin their entire future career. And those who have good ideas and bring them to maturity must be able to rely on the protection of their intellectual property by the legal system of the state.

Freedom and security for new ideas; the factor "time" is also important: We know that innovation cycles are becoming shorter and the pressure for change is increasing. Time is therefore a precious resource, indispensable for creativity: Without leisure, there is no muse's kiss. It is no coincidence that innovative companies give their employees time to use freely; it is no coincidence that university professors use "sabbaticals" to advance their research. However, many flee from German universities and research institutions and seek freedom from bureaucracy, committee work, and reporting obligations elsewhere. In the global competition for the most creative minds, it is not enough to appeal to the patriotism of scientists – we must do more to support them before they turn their backs on us.

More freedom: this is not an invitation to idleness: saturation and certainty – entitlement and claim – can be powerful inhibitors of creativity. There are also many examples of this in the German scientific landscape. The remedy for this is primarily one thing: competition. One can seek a solution to a problem or try to find the best one. Wanting to be at the top creates creative dynamics. Would we have experienced so much upheaval in the higher education landscape in recent years without the Excellence Initiative? And would we have seen so much willingness to collaborate among people and institutions without it and the Pact for Research and Innovation? Because this also fuels creativity: exchange – between colleagues; between disciplines (creativity is notoriously undisciplined); between basic research and application orientation; between science and industry. We do not need narrow-minded thinking; we need communication and cooperation! "The boundary is the most fertile space of knowledge." – This statement by the Protestant theologian Paul Tillich may be one of the best answers to the question of how the new comes into the world. And that is why it is right to focus on interdisciplinary networks and strong clusters of science and industry. There are good examples of this in Germany, but the exchange can be even better. The Stifterverband continually provides us with good insights on how to achieve this.

The quote from Walther Rathenau states: "The complaint about the sharpness of competition is usually just a complaint about the lack of ideas." The Stifterverband does not complain but points the way to the land of ideas with its programs for schools and universities and its initiatives for networking science and industry. For this, I thank you and wish you continued success.