Speech by Federal President Horst Köhler on the occasion of the award of the International Prize and the Journalism Prize of the Friedrich-August-von-Hayek Foundation on May 13, 2007, in Freiburg:

Germany Horst Köhler · President of Germany

14 May 2007 · Award of the International Prize and the Journalism Prize of the Friedrich-August-von-Hayek Foundation · Freiburg, Germany

Context
Köhler addressed the Friedrich-August-von-Hayek Foundation award ceremony in Freiburg on May 13, 2007, honoring Mikuláš Dzurinda and Horst Siebert.
Main themes
Friedrich-August-von-Hayek Prize, Hayek's philosophy of freedom, individual liberty and self-realization, state intervention and market complexity, overregulation and legal complexity, subsidy reduction, personal responsibility, welfare state reform, Agenda 2010, competition of ideas, balance between state and market
Duration
~13 min
47th percentile
Words
1,597
47th percentile
Sentences
82
53rd percentile
Readability
45
48th percentile
Grade
11.7
41st percentile
Syntax
3.03
51st percentile
Vocabulary
2.26
64th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 35%35%
  • Institutional 34%33%
  • Ceremonial 20%20%
  • Social 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 3%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

82 sentences in 21 paragraphs

I.

We have come together today to honor Mikuláš Dzurinda and Horst Siebert with the "Friedrich-August-von-Hayek-Preis." I am very pleased to witness this and extend my warm greetings to both of them.

However, I must point out, dear Mr. Dzurinda, dear Horst Siebert, that Hayek himself was apparently quite skeptical of such honors. When he was awarded the Nobel Prize, he said in his table speech: "If I had been asked whether a Nobel Prize for Economics should be established: I would have said no." Hayek feared that such awards could make their recipients too influential. He fundamentally regarded award ceremonies as an unauthorized form of subsidy in the "economy of attention."

Well, at least Hayek did accept the Nobel Prize. And at least scientific awards are preceded by competition — the competition of ideas. For this reason, it can also be said of the Hayek Prize: It is a legitimate gain for the awardees and an enrichment for all of us.

II.

The core of Hayek's philosophy is his positive view of humanity, which is based on the power of freedom and places the individual at the center — with all their talents and ideas and with their drive for self-realization. Hayek saw the state in a servile role: It must secure the framework conditions under which freedom and the creative forces of individuals can unfold. Hayek harbored a deep mistrust of the illusion of state planning. Not only because it contradicted his view of humanity, but also because he was convinced that a system as complex as the market, driven by the preferences and decisions of an unmanageable number of actors, cannot be controlled. Hayek warns: Every state intervention in market activity, no matter how small, inevitably leads to the need for ever new and stronger interventions.

Today, we know how justified this concern is at its core and how difficult it is to break free from the spiral of state interventions. State regulations — no matter how well-intentioned they may be, and they are usually well-intentioned — always carry the risk of restricting the freedom and thus the creative power of citizens. Hayek's philosophy remains a constant reminder to be aware of our own ignorance, rather than falling into the delusion that economic life can be planned and directed in detail.

Has this message reached our society, is it alive and strong? Sometimes one must doubt it. Too many cling to the illusion that justice can be programmed through state interventions of all kinds, especially through a multitude of individual legal regulations. Not least for this reason, the average number of pages in the Federal Law Gazette has more than doubled since the 1960s. It seems that our need to create security and individual justice through legal provisions has grown in parallel with our prosperity. We have equipped more and more areas of life with increasingly complicated regulations. The result is a regulatory monstrosity that threatens to stifle the initiative and creativity of the people in our country.

Therefore, the simplification of tax and social systems is not only necessary for the sake of their comprehensibility and applicability, but it is also required because today it is often impossible to assess what the existing law still achieves in terms of justice.

Among the uncomfortable truths is, of course, that we all sit in a glass house: Often and gladly, the "lean state," the reduction of subsidies, tax breaks, and privileges are demanded: Yet, usually, no one wants to start with themselves.

According to the subsidy report of the federal government, the federal and state governments still spend nearly 60 billion euros per year on financial aid and tax breaks. The economy benefits the most from this. However, I still hear too few concrete proposals from the business sector for the reduction of commercial subsidies. Although something has changed, as the economy has recognized that it achieves more when it makes its own proposals. But overall, I find this still too hesitant. Those who call for more personal responsibility from students, employees, and retirees cannot simultaneously claim subsidies and state protection for themselves. In this regard, regulatory thinking is indeed egalitarian: it demands freedom from privileges for all.

At least: In my impression, the pendulum is gradually swinging back in the direction that Hayek indicated. This can be seen in demands for an activating welfare state that provides more preventive care than assistance. This was also the fundamental idea of the Agenda 2010, which Chancellor Schröder introduced; and I believe that the direction of this agenda is correct. We can now see that parts of these reforms are already having a positive impact; and we should acknowledge that. Furthermore, the reform policy of recent years emphasizes not only the duties of the state but also the duty of the individual to take personal responsibility and contribute. Hayek's ideas are thus regaining lost market shares.

This is encouraging, but Hayek would agree with me when I say: they must not be allowed to obtain a monopoly. Nothing would be further from him than the demand to canonize his teachings and to elevate them to the highest law everywhere, regardless of the economic traditions of a country. Hayek developed his maxims very fundamentally and in intellectual confrontation with the totalitarianisms of the 20th century. He did so with clarity and sharpness. But it is quintessentially Hayekian behavior to constantly scientifically scrutinize Hayek's teachings and to further develop them for the given political reality and the preferences of citizens. Both of these commitments have been taken on by the Hayek Foundation, and I am grateful for that.

Our country is currently in a phase of recovery. The economy is growing, demand is rising, and new jobs are being created. We should truly be pleased about this. But it must not be a reason to let up in our efforts. Rather, this new momentum offers a brilliant opportunity to sustainably strengthen the constitution of our economy with Hayekian arguments. Because we have not yet resolved a number of structural problems in this economy. For this, for the continuation of reform work aimed at sustainably improving the constitution of our economy, much explanatory work is needed. That is why it is good that the Friedrich-August-von-Hayek Foundation has also established a journalism prize.

And for strengthening the social market economy, one can argue excellently with Hayek: If "the morality of the market" — a term coined by Hayek himself — is in danger, then state action is indeed required. Once again, Hayek: "Liberalism teaches that we should make the best possible use of the forces of competition, ... but it does not teach that we should leave things to themselves. ... A smoothly functioning competitive system needs, like almost any other, a well-thought-out legal framework that is continuously adapted to its requirements." Therefore, anyone who thinks that regulatory policy is synonymous with lawlessness has thoroughly misunderstood Hayek.

III.

This also applies on a global scale. Five billion of the total six and a half billion people on this planet live today in developing and emerging countries. Despite great differences, the economy in many of these countries is developing at a remarkable speed. The people who live there are diligently and knowledgeably improving their own lives while also contributing to the prosperity of the entire world. It is a blessing that, thanks to globalization, countless people can work their way out of dire poverty. And it cannot be forbidden that they thereby invigorate international competition and challenge us to become more alert, creative, and faster.

However, the increased interconnectedness of our societies and economies also makes it necessary for us to develop an international regulatory vision that takes these new realities into account. We also need rules at the international level that ensure fair competition and give everyone the chance to contribute their knowledge and skills. Unfortunately, there is still no real order of freedom in globalization. While there are numerous norms and agreements, they are patchy and inconsistent — a coherent global regulatory policy cannot yet be said to exist. I am also thinking of an area that is not primarily economic, that of the recognition of international courts. This is still viewed very differently. But we also need a judiciary that interprets and applies the order of freedom.

Moreover, in international politics, we too often set the wrong priorities because we want to determine individual outcomes instead of establishing universally valid rules. Take trade policy, for example. There we regulate in detail tariff rates and quotas, country of origin criteria, and production methods, instead of focusing on general principles for fair treatment and a free economic order, such as free market access and legal certainty. Everyone defends their particular interests and then celebrates their small advantages as a national success. Unjustly, because the hidden costs of these cheap victories are usually borne by consumers everywhere — in the form of higher prices, lower quality, or expensive administration. And overall, one can even say that these hidden costs, in the worst case, also lead to poverty and hopelessness.

IV.

I think it is good that the Friedrich-August-von-Hayek-Preis exists, not least because it sets a high standard for good economic policy. And today we have two awardees who, in the best sense, stand for demanding theoretical and journalistic work as well as for effective political action in the economy and society. That they are receiving this award today is also a reason for optimism for me: Good ideas can indeed succeed in being heard and prevailing in the struggle for good policy.