Speech by Federal President Horst Köhler at the award of the "IZA Prize in Labor Economics" to Richard B. Freeman on November 5, 2007, in Berlin:

Germany Horst Köhler · President of Germany

5 November 2007 · Award of the IZA Prize in Labor Economics to Richard B. Freeman · Berlin, Germany

Context
Köhler addressed attendees at the IZA Prize in Labor Economics ceremony in Berlin on November 5, 2007, honoring Richard B. Freeman.
Main themes
Future of work, labor market research, IZA Prize in Labor Economics, unemployment, work and human identity, happiness economics, social integration through employment, labor policy reform, Germany's labor market development, welfare state financing, fulfilling employment
Duration
~17 min
56th percentile
Words
1,985
56th percentile
Sentences
111
68th percentile
Readability
42
40th percentile
Grade
11.8
43rd percentile
Syntax
2.88
31st percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 41%41%
  • Social 29%29%
  • Institutional 17%16%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

111 sentences in 19 paragraphs

"The Future of Work is Shapable"

"Personalities are not shaped by beautiful speeches, but by work and personal achievement," Albert Einstein knew. But once they have distinguished themselves through work and achievement, they are – rightly so – honored with beautiful speeches and awarded prizes. I do not want to preempt the laudation by Professor Zimmermann, dear Mr. Freeman. Therefore, at this point, I also extend my heartfelt congratulations to you!

You are receiving today the award from the Institute for the Future of Work, which is dedicated to national and international labor market research and has built a remarkable international network for this purpose. But wait, did we hear correctly? An Institute for the Future of Work? Does it really need a research institute?

Some may think of the title of Jeremy Rifkin's book: "The End of Work and Its Future." Was he perhaps a godfather in naming the IZA? I believe not. The IZA is not about the end of the working society, but about its wise organization and further development. Work – and how we can institutionally promote it – remains the future topic. That is why I am glad that the IZA – especially with its international orientation – has filled a gap in the German research landscape. I find it remarkable what you, Professor Zimmermann, and your team have accomplished in not even ten years. Congratulations!

The IZA enjoys an excellent reputation among scientists far beyond Germany with its comprehensive labor economics approach; and it has become indispensable in political consulting in this country. Especially in the last weeks and months, I wished for more intensive political consulting. Thus, the IZA is also a good example of how high-level research and well-founded advice to the political process can mutually enrich each other. Such fruitful dialogue is also essential for politics if it wants to be factually grounded.

Work has a future, and wise regulatory policy helps with that, as the last few years in Germany have made abundantly clear. The extremely encouraging development in the labor market shows: Unemployment does not have to exist, and I hold nothing of the thesis of the end of work; it probably only comes true in the land of milk and honey.

Work for all does not only have an economic significance. Work is at the center of our lives. Work has a significant impact on our well-being. It contributes to social integration and societal participation. Work helps build our identity and self-esteem. It is a crucial source of social recognition. New scientific findings from empirical happiness research – Economics of Happiness – confirm: Few things in our lives make us as unhappy as the fact of being unemployed. A high unemployment rate even affects our well-being when we are not personally affected. The feeling of increasing life risks associated with high unemployment weighs heavily on everyone and creates uncertainty.

These insights may seem trivial to us. But the appreciation of work expressed therein is historically anything but self-evident. The conviction that work is desirable was neither reached by ancient philosophers nor would the workers in the age of industrialization have readily agreed to this thesis. The former saw work as mundane and unworthy of a free spirit, while the latter only knew it as a heavy physical burden and often a threat to their health. These views and experiences still resonate in most economic models today. Sometimes, the so-called labor pain is mentioned. And this idea of labor pain often overshadows the significance of fulfilling employment for overall life satisfaction. Happiness research also provides important insights on this: People who can shape their work independently are more satisfied.

Because work has such great personal and societal significance, the question arises whether we in Germany are already doing enough and whether we are doing the right things to promote the creation and securing of competitive jobs beyond the current upswing and whether we are doing enough to integrate people into the labor market who have so far – for whatever reasons – been left out. It will not surprise you: I believe we are not doing enough. Above all, not when we look ahead and think again of more difficult economic times.

The Socio-Economic Panel, a representative longitudinal study of private households in Germany, which is maintained by an institute related to the IZA – at least in personnel terms – has investigated who actually finances our social state, our public infrastructure, and also German reunification. The result: It is primarily the employees who bear the main burden of the state. While other population groups – including, for example, transfer recipients – have been able to record income increases in recent years, net incomes from dependent work have stagnated on average. Other countries finance their welfare systems more through taxes; in Germany, particularly much rests on the factor of labor. This is not only a hindrance to the creation of new jobs, but it is also not a particular motivation for people in employment.

Should we not deal much more systematically with the connections between work and social security? If employment biographies no longer proceed steadily – and that is the reality, if permanent employment is no longer the norm, is it still timely to primarily link social security systems to that?

We need strategic answers to these questions; not just tinkering with individual levers. That is why it is right and important that the significance of institutional foundations for the labor market has recently received more attention.

The perspective beyond the national horizon that the IZA maintains can often be helpful. What can we learn from our neighbors and friends? In Europe, for example, there is currently a discussion about whether it would not make sense to bring the Danish model of "flexicurity" more to the fore. In principle, this is not a new question, but it is still important. It is about connecting a flexible labor market with social security and with labor market policy options for the unemployed. Of course, this discussion must be conducted with care. Because, not least from you, Professor Freeman, we have learned: It is not so easy to transfer the success model of one country to another – and one cannot simply pick the cherries. Because institutions are always embedded in a political and social context that influences their effectiveness. That is why it always comes down to a holistic approach. The values and value orientations, the culture and history of a country influence as intrinsic factors the actions of people and thus also the effectiveness and acceptance of their institutions. Strongly market-oriented models evidently work better when people live in the tradition of a risk-taking pioneering spirit and bring the corresponding willingness to provide for themselves, as is often said about Americans. The affordability of well-developed welfare systems, on the other hand, necessarily requires that "free-rider mentality" is socially sanctioned and kept within narrow limits; otherwise, the financing becomes lost. The functionality of social systems is therefore closely related to the ethos of a society. And let’s be honest: How is the social state morality of the Germans, and what incentive systems fit best with that? Is it not reasonable and in the well-understood interest of all to write promoting and demanding equally large, as it corresponds to the principle of performance and consideration?

With some – perhaps typically German – institutions, we have indeed had good experiences, such as with our Works Constitution Act. For example, works councils contribute in many ways to economic efficiency and social balance in the labor market. They give employees a voice and thereby reduce unproductive job turnover. They have a positive coordination and communication function within the company and generally strengthen employees' identification with "their" company. Collective agreements, in turn, commit the parties involved to common goals, for example in further training, and ensure that agreements are also adhered to. This is also a principle of order, an important one. They limit the harmful market power of the economically stronger. The strong international position of the German economy is certainly also related to stable framework conditions and continuity. The German tradition of proactively seeking a balance of interests between operational requirements and the needs of employees with appropriate mechanisms has likely contributed significantly to this. But precisely those who want to preserve these advantages must always consider whether and how successful institutions need to be adjusted to changing framework conditions.

I personally believe – and this must be said repeatedly – that the German trade unions made a very constructive contribution to the development of our country and the prosperity in our country after the Second World War in the history of the Federal Republic of Germany. Social partnership has proven itself overall. But I also say: It must continually prove itself anew and must not rest on its laurels.

Among the future tasks for the institutional conditions of our labor market is also the question of how to counteract the drifting apart of our society. Income distribution in Germany has become more unequal in recent years. This is related to higher educational returns, but also to a declining wage share. A too strong divergence of incomes could become a growing burden for social cohesion and undermine citizens' trust in the fairness of our market economy. Therefore, I believe that we – in addition to better access to good education for all, which is a crucial key for me – must think much more decisively than before about possibilities for a stronger participation of employees in profits and capital and ultimately also come to a decision. We should not miss this opportunity to open up a second source of income for employees and thus involve them more than before in the prosperity gains thanks to globalization. And at this point, keyword "social cohesion," I would like to remind you of something I have already said repeatedly: Especially those who earn a lot and have high incomes should contribute through a culture of moderation and role modeling so that those who receive less can cope with it.

The future is shapeable within our God-given possibilities. This also applies to the future of work. Germany has experienced a lot of change in the labor market – and overall for the better, quite clearly. I saw Mr. Weise from the Federal Employment Agency earlier. I believe one can say: The reforms there have paid off. The agency is doing a good job, and what is most important: We see it in the labor market. Now, however, we must ensure that the wrong conclusions are not drawn from the development and that this success in the labor market continues.

The reform policy of the last ten years, including Agenda 2010, has contributed to these successes. It has strengthened our growth base, it has created more jobs, alongside the good global economic situation and, of course, alongside reasonable collective agreements. Politics and social partners are still called upon to support, strengthen, and promote this positive development in the labor market. Leaning back makes no sense. We still have many open questions: How do we achieve the integration of hard-to-place long-term unemployed? There are far too many of them. Today we are concerned about child poverty. Families are also affected by unemployment – including children. So how do we ensure that long-term unemployed people return to work? What labor market policy changes does demographic change require? How do we motivate employees and employers to invest more in further training? I believe that lifelong learning is still the most neglected area of our education system. These are just some of the questions that need to be solved.

Science can make important theoretical and empirical contributions to this. Therefore, I ask you: Continue to engage in labor market policy debates with clear analyses and inspiring ideas! We need that. There is still much to be done.