Speech by Federal President Horst Köhler at the opening of the conference "Policy Changes in the Next Phase of Globalisation" of the Club of Rome on November 6, 2007, in Berlin:

Germany Horst Köhler · President of Germany

6 November 2007 · Conference "Policy Changes in the Next Phase of Globalisation" of the Club of Rome · Schloss Bellevue, Berlin, Germany

Context
Köhler addressed the Club of Rome conference on globalization policy at Schloss Bellevue, Berlin, on November 6, 2007.
Main themes
Globalization governance, social justice and distribution, education and knowledge society, free trade and comparative advantage, structural economic change, middle class anxieties, profit-sharing and worker participation, regulatory policy, mercantilist critique, Club of Rome conference
Duration
~22 min
70th percentile
Words
2,608
70th percentile
Sentences
132
76th percentile
Readability
46
50th percentile
Grade
11.7
41st percentile
Syntax
2.85
28th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
27th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 35%34%
  • Institutional 17%17%
  • Environmental 16%16%
  • Ceremonial 13%12%
  • Social 10%10%
  • Geopolitical 8%8%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Not in focus 3%

132 sentences in 35 paragraphs

"Learning to Share"

Welcome to Schloss Bellevue!

Many illustrious gatherings have taken place within these walls; however, a meeting of the world-renowned Club of Rome is a premiere even for Schloss Bellevue. By the way, we owe your meeting location today to the most recent Ice Age. Here’s how it happened: 20,000 years ago, this entire region was covered by massive glaciers. When the ice melted, so much sand was left behind that Brandenburg was once called "the sand box of the Holy Roman Empire of the German Nation." And when the Prussian King Frederick William I – 1688 to 1740 – had mulberry trees planted here in the Tiergarten to breed silkworms and produce silk, the trees would not grow in the sandy soil, the silkworms had nothing to eat, the project was abandoned, and the land was freed for development.

Silk "made in Prussia" – the idea was based on the mercantilist notion that it was best to produce as many products as possible oneself, import little, and wrest trade shares from other states, as foreign trade was seen as a zero-sum game, where one party gains what the other loses.

In fact, David Ricardo – 1772 to 1823 – has long since debunked this notion. He demonstrated that it is more advantageous for an economy not to produce everything itself, but to specialize in those activities where it is farthest ahead of its competitors. And it is more profitable for a country to open itself to international trade, as it is not a zero-sum game, but creates growth and enlarges the overall pie for all participating nations. The rapid growth of the world economy in the past 20 to 30 years empirically shows how right David Ricardo was with his theory.

And yet – no: precisely because of this, we must not leave globalization to itself or to the power of the stronger, as it should benefit all people. I could also say: It must benefit all people, because otherwise this world could tear itself apart.

We need a regulatory and development policy for the entire planet.

I will name the four reasons that seem most important to me.

First:

It is true that global trade and competition direct production factors in the participating states to where they are used most profitably. And it is also true that Germany has benefited from globalization like few other countries. But the associated change is taking place at a pace and with a force reminiscent of the decades of the first industrial revolution. In the industrialized nations, we know: The structural change from outdated to new technologies, products, and forms of work is the lifeblood of any economy. But as everywhere, the dose makes the poison. When the pressure for change from successful competitors, higher efficiency requirements, or changing consumer desires becomes too high, it leads to breaks and upheavals that can trigger existential fears and great uncertainty even among the middle classes. Many people in the West see the export successes of emerging nations; they see almost fairy-tale wealth increases among globalization winners; they often cannot understand the structural problems of domestic companies; they fear for their jobs and their standard of living. In the Western democracies, this leads to a new discussion about social justice, and the responsible governments face a dual task. I call it an educational task. This educational task is, on the one hand, to convince citizens that the mercantilist view is indeed incorrect, because the pie has truly grown larger for everyone thanks to globalization. For citizens in the West, who benefit from cheap imports and strong exports, and for hundreds of millions of people around the world who have been able to work their way out of deep poverty thanks to globalization. The second part of the educational task consists of recognizing and heeding that education in the knowledge society is the key to the Ricardo questions: What can we do to create added value compared to others? What should we focus on? The answers are: with good ideas, with intelligent products, with quality that meets the highest standards. All of this requires an education system and a level of education of the highest caliber. That is why we Germans are also beginning to recognize and heed again: Good education for all is the beginning of everything. And this applies everywhere, by the way.

A fundamental question of distribution justice that industrialized nations face is: How can additional sources of income be opened up for workers whose employment biographies are becoming more unstable, whose wages are no longer growing as they once did, and who are nonetheless contributing to the rapidly growing profits and investments of companies? In my conviction, the answer is: profit and corporate participation in the hands of employees.

The peoples of the world have it in their hands to shape globalization that benefits everyone. The state of productive forces allows for decent labor protection to be observed everywhere, and people can receive more than starvation wages. And the global potential for income and work is so great that everyone can find their livelihood if incentives and responsibilities are structured correctly and if we learn to share better.

Since the fall of the Berlin Wall, we have said: "Division can only be overcome by sharing." That is a good principle for the internal development of every nation and an important orientation for the relationship between peoples in the emerging world society.

This brings me to the second reason why we need a development policy for the entire planet: Not all nations are benefiting from international trade and change. This has various causes. Some isolate themselves and remain poor. Others have nothing with which to trade, neither natural resources nor sought-after products. Still others suffer under corrupt rulers and miserable governments.

All these countries deserve the respect and help of those who are better off. This help is not altruistic, not least because it helps prevent poverty and hunger migrations and armed conflicts, which almost always have repercussions on third parties and act destabilizingly worldwide. History has repeatedly shown us what can happen when people have nothing left to lose.

However, any assistance should be tied to clear conditions: What decent governance means can be measured and assessed, it can be demanded and made a prerequisite, and many poorer countries are already willing to measure themselves against it. The NEPAD initiative, New Partnership for Africa's Development, is a good example of this. It also sets the right goals in content, for example, with the commitment to the rule of law and the development of rural areas. Assistance against poverty, injustice, and violence requires finally agreeing on fair economic and trade relations. And: The resource wealth of developing countries must primarily benefit the peoples there.

This brings me to the third reason for my call for a development policy for the entire planet: The international rules and patterns of behavior have not kept pace with the speed of our world's integration. Too often, ignorance and one-sided interest representation still determine the behavior of states.

This also creates room for conflicts between ethnicities and cultures, where we urgently need mutual respect and trusting dialogue.

By now, everyone should know better. The world is globalized. Globalization means interdependence. And this interdependence is becoming increasingly intense. The era of unilateralism is therefore over. Effects are fed back to their source.

With cooperative world politics, everyone fares better. This can be justified religiously, philosophically, and even game-theoretically, as shown by the works of the Global Ethic Foundation by Hans Küng and thinkers like Kant, Rawls, and Amartya Sen. But unfortunately, we are still far from this in many respects, for example, regarding how the voices of emerging and developing countries are heard in the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund, or also regarding when the many subtle double standards in world trade policy will finally come to an end. Foreign policy must be understood as world domestic policy.

However, it is not only a matter of improving existing international legal agreements and practices; much new must also be built so that the power of change can be directed into orderly, beneficial channels. The natural and legitimate place for this construction work is primarily the United Nations. With the UN Charter, the Human Rights Pact, and the Millennium Development Goals, we have good conceptual foundations to shape globalization for the benefit of all. However, I believe we should also include the Universal Declaration of Human Responsibilities formulated by the InterAction Council.

We all know: The United Nations will have to grow in its task of a regulatory and development policy for the entire planet. Its actions must become more concise, more efficient, and should be much more closely intertwined with the work of international financial and trade organizations. But the United Nations cannot be stronger than the goodwill of its member states to cooperate. How strong this will is will be revealed in the debate on UN reforms initiated by UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan and continued by his successor Ban Ki-moon. We need rapid, far-reaching progress. This will particularly depend on the insight and strength of the great states of this earth towards a new, cooperative world policy.

I would have to say the following even if I had not been the Managing Director of the International Monetary Fund: The international financial markets have become so self-sufficient that it must raise concerns. Ricardo would surely be pleased with how quickly the necessary capital can be mobilized worldwide for good business ideas today. But on what convoluted and almost virtual paths money is currently being generated, that might have unsettled him. In the meantime, even the banks have become somewhat uneasy, or how else can one explain that they recently did not want to lend to each other? Even central bankers and finance ministers have – hopefully not just temporarily – become thoughtful. They must provide answers to the questions of where the risks of financial markets lie, who can control them, and who bears the costs if that fails.

No one can exclude the possibility that the next financial market crisis will impact the entire world economy and thus severely affect the work and income of people around the globe. Here arises a previously unanswered question of political responsibility and accountability. I hope that the International Monetary Fund will seek and find its relevance in the 21st century primarily in this area.

The most compelling argument for humanity to finally understand itself as a community of responsibility and to act accordingly, I have saved for last. In sharp terms, it is: One world – or none.

As it stands now, this cannot continue indefinitely. Humanity is consuming the planet as if it had a second one in reserve. We are far from the principle of sustainability. The climate change should actually bring everyone to their senses. If we do not massively reduce CO2 emissions, we will all have to pay the price for the economic damages, especially the people in the southern half of the earth, who contribute the least to CO2 emissions. Therefore, industrialized nations, emerging and developing countries must pool their strengths here, to better conserve the earth through new technologies and a strategy of efficient use of available raw material and energy reserves. The opportunities for this are there.

I, for example, have learned that with appropriate research efforts, a fivefold increase in energy efficiency is possible in the long term. In the spring, Chinese scientists proudly reported to me: The president of the Chinese Academy of Sciences has confirmed, together with his colleagues from the G8 states and the other largest emerging countries, the analyses and conclusions of the World Climate Council. So there is a global community that can act powerfully to curb climate change.

Unfortunately, it took a long time for the fundamental idea of the Club of Rome, that humanity lives and operates within a finite global ecosystem, to become generally recognized in political consciousness. No one can take away the credit from the Club of Rome for articulating this challenge early on. "The Limits to Growth" was the study presented 35 years ago by Dennis Meadows and his team on behalf of the Club of Rome. It has become a classic—not only in Germany—and had a significant impact on the political landscape in many countries.

Such widespread effects are unfortunately rare. From the years following "The Limits to Growth," I can only recall the reports of the North-South Commission led by Willy Brandt (1980) and the Global 2000 Report, which was published in 1981 on behalf of US President Carter.

Only in more recent times have there been two further examples of such effectiveness, both awarded the Nobel Peace Prize: the film and writings "An Inconvenient Truth" by Al Gore and, above all, the report recently prepared by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) under the leadership of its long-time chair Rajendra Pachauri.

Works like those of the Club of Rome and the IPCC create awareness of problems and bring the arguments for a prudent approach to creation to the front pages of daily newspapers and into conversations at the dinner table. And that is exactly where the topic belongs. For as much as we need international cooperation in research, technology, and politics for environmental and climate protection, we need more than that: We need a change in our lifestyle. It is not about restriction or even limitation of our freedom. It is about a change in consciousness.

The change begins in industrialized countries with the question: Does a lifestyle primarily focused on quantity make us happy at all? Wouldn't a little less, but qualitatively more valuable consumption actually do us good? Our quality of life need not suffer as a result—in fact, quite the opposite. And wouldn't it be very satisfying to know that this less enables others, those in need, to have a little more and gives future generations a future? Does that contradict economic thinking? I don't think so. Wasn't economics once a "moral science," and aren't many of its classics also social philosophers who asked not only about quantities and prices but also about value?

Many questions that I would like to leave with you, dear members of the Club of Rome. I wish you fruitful discussions, and I am eager to see the results. I am pleased that you are here. Perhaps Schloss Bellevue will serve as the starting point for a groundbreaking process of work.

Let me conclude with another meeting here in this hall and with a quote. Just over half a year ago, the heads of state and government of the member states of the European Union gathered here. We celebrated the 50th anniversary of the signing of the Treaty of Rome. They were the beginning of a success story that can also inspire courage for addressing the challenges that nations face worldwide today.

Now, such celebrations can easily become somewhat bloodless rituals. That is why I invited Thomas Reiter, a German astronaut. He showed us photos of the Earth that he took from the International Space Station (ISS)—photos that displayed our world in all its beauty and vulnerability. And that reminded me of a quote from another astronaut: Sultan bin Salman Al Saud from Saudi Arabia. After his space flight in 1984, he reported: "On the first day, everyone pointed to their country. By the third or fourth day, everyone pointed to their continent. By the fifth day, we no longer even paid attention to the continents. We only saw the Earth as one whole planet."