Speech by Federal President Horst Köhler at the celebration event "50 Years of the Science Council" on September 5, 2007, in Berlin:

Germany Horst Köhler · President of Germany

5 September 2007 · 50 Years of the Science Council celebration event · Berlin, Germany

Context
Köhler addressed the 50th anniversary celebration of the German Science Council in Berlin on September 5, 2007, reflecting on its role in shaping national science policy.
Main themes
Science policy, Science Council 50th anniversary, German research competitiveness, federal science funding, university autonomy and reform, Bologna Process, knowledge society, science-economy transfer, structured degree programs, federalism and science governance, young researcher mobility
Duration
~14 min
50th percentile
Words
1,718
50th percentile
Sentences
65
43rd percentile
Readability
34
23rd percentile
Grade
14.8
74th percentile
Syntax
3.13
64th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
23rd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 66%66%
  • Social 15%15%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Economic 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

65 sentences in 19 paragraphs

50 years of the Science Council: This is a significant anniversary – especially for an institution whose foundation, the administrative agreement between the federal government and the states, was initially concluded for only three years on September 5, 1957. At the latest with each extension, the question must have arisen, with proper exercise of discretion: Do we actually still need the Science Council? Given the rough winds that occasionally blew against the Council, the 13 extensions so far are certainly not a bad testament.

The Science Council is, as has often been described, a unique construct: It is more than a policy advisory body, more than a coordination committee, but less than a democratically legitimized governing and decision-making body.

The providers and recipients of advice and money sit together at the table to reconcile the desirable with the feasible in science funding. Representatives from the federal government and the states – each with their own interests, differentiated responsibilities, and different means of power – consult with experts from science and friends of science from public life about the goals of science policy. In the Science Council, the perspectives of the individual actors with their different preference structures should broaden, and their view should open up to the whole: to the truly national task of providing science and research in a federal state with the best, internationally competitive opportunities for development.

Let us remember: Even the founders of the Science Council were concerned that the great scientific nation of Germany could lose touch with the rapid scientific and technological developments in other parts of the world. And the founding fathers also faced the question of how the increase and dissemination of knowledge could be adequately financed and well organized in a federal state. It occupied him, wrote Federal President Heuss in 1956 to Chancellor Adenauer, the "concern of how the available resources, which certainly (...) require a very significant increase, can be brought to the highest level of effectiveness." We face this question today as well, only the treasure from the Julius Tower has unfortunately long been spent, which does not make the task any easier.

So how can the German science system be brought to the highest level of effectiveness under today's conditions? And how is that even measured? As many Nobel Prize winners as possible? As many patents as possible? As many publications as possible? As high places in relevant rankings as possible? As many students, better yet: graduates? Just determining the status of the science system is anything but trivial. The challenge of giving direction to its development is all the greater.

The Science Council has repeatedly tried this – sometimes with grand designs, sometimes with very concrete proposals, sometimes with greater, sometimes with lesser success. Some recommendations from the Science Council only had an effect after a certain latency period: For example, those who advocated for the introduction of structured degree programs in the 1960s and had to endure harsh criticism will now welcome their introduction under the Bologna label and may also wonder: Why did it take external, European pressure to initiate this perhaps most comprehensive study reform in the history of the Federal Republic?

And why did it take so long, to take another example, for the ideal of the autonomous, competition-oriented university to manifest in concrete changes, even though the Science Council had already established this ideal with its recommendations from 1985? Is this related to federal or other institutional obstacles, and if so, who advises politics on how to overcome these obstacles?

Science policy – especially in federalism – certainly seems to be nothing for the impatient. All the more, I am driven by the question of whether we are clear enough about how fundamental the global competitiveness of our science system is for the prosperity and well-being of our country. I wonder – and I naturally ask you: Are we succeeding in our universities here in adequately preparing enough young people to master a demanding and responsible professional life and to assert themselves successfully in the global knowledge society? Are we succeeding in providing young researchers in their most creative phase with the same freedom for their own research that many of our young scientists here miss and therefore seek abroad? And are we succeeding in quickly and purposefully transferring research results from science to the economy and thus to the market?

I am convinced: We could be significantly more successful in all these areas. The Science Council has repeatedly provided impulses on how to begin this – most recently with the "Recommendations on the Future Role of Universities in the Science System" and with its considerations on improving the interaction between science and business. The ongoing Excellence Initiative now seems to act as a catalyst: It encourages universities to sharpen their own profiles, it promotes new forms of cooperation between universities and non-university research, and it opens up new opportunities for promoting young talent.

Of course, the Excellence Initiative cannot and should not solve all the problems of German universities – especially since we cannot yet foresee how it will affect those who do not directly benefit from it. One thing we must not do: deny these universities the chance of rising to the excellence league. Therefore, the Science Council must continue to think about how we can maintain the incentive for all universities to build on their own strengths. In future competitions, entirely different rankings could emerge – especially if, for example, the excellence criteria are more tailored to the humanities and cultural sciences, and if outstanding teaching also plays a role instead of just research.

You all know how great the pressure for action in teaching is. That still a quarter of students drop out of university studies, that the significant exceeding of the standard study period seems to be more the rule than the exception, that in some subjects exam preparation by private tutors is an expensive norm, is certainly not solely the responsibility of the universities. However, it remains an outrageous waste of life and life opportunities, of intellectual and financial resources. We need more – and not fewer – committed educators, and we need better teaching at universities if the ongoing study reform is to succeed with increasing student numbers!

I, like many others, am eagerly awaiting the recommendations of the Science Council to strengthen the quality of teaching and study. It should be clear: The promotion of teaching and research must not stand in real competition: The "more" for one must not come at the expense of the other. Especially those who want to fulfill the Humboldtian unity of research and teaching with new vitality must free teaching from its neglected status at German universities. This also requires appropriate resources: The Higher Education Pact, which the federal and state governments agreed upon last year, can only be a first step to establish university funding on new, solid foundations.

However, it also requires more commitment from educators: Those who see teaching only as a burdensome obligation have missed their profession as university teachers and moreover miss the chance to inspire young people for a subject, to enable progress in it, and to learn from them.

A lot is currently in motion in our scientific landscape. Whether substance and direction are correct will not least be overseen by the Science Council. "Test everything, hold fast to what is good": This exercise according to the instruction of St. Paul has been undertaken by the Science Council several times over the past fifty years – most intensively perhaps in the early 1990s, during the evaluation phase of non-university research in the former GDR.

And as in this case, the Science Council should also remain open in the future to having its own procedures and results critically examined – this should be, alongside the independence of the voluntary council members from science and society, the best precaution against the accusation of being a power cartel of the "beati possidentes."

The recommendations of the Science Council carry special weight – but the Science Council has not been alone in the field of science policy advice for several years now, and that is a good thing, because competition is known to invigorate business: This is currently being experienced in another field by the economic research institutes. And because the pressure for consensus between advisor and advisee in the Science Council is practically "built-in," it should be all the more grateful for radical and visionary impulses from outside: from "think tanks" or from individual "science scientists."

Where politics decides on complex questions, it wants to be well advised – and thankfully, it sees this more and more often. Its demand for advice from science about science also repeatedly changes the field of providers. Next month, I will celebrate with acatech, the Academy of Engineering Sciences, that it is becoming a National Academy, and whether we will experience further changes in the architecture of the academy landscape remains to be seen; the Science Council has submitted recommendations on this. Ultimately, however, the decision lies with politics, that is, with the democratically legitimized parliaments and governments.

In my view, good political advice also includes following up on what the recipients make of it. Just a few years ago, the Science Council set out to systematically review its own effectiveness. I would like to encourage it in this intention. And in one area, it is particularly important to me that the Science Council implements the standards it applies to the science system within its own organization: With the Science Council, I am convinced that we must do more to provide qualified women with better opportunities in science. This also includes ensuring that they are adequately represented in the Science Council itself. Proposal lists without female candidates should therefore belong to the past.

Looking at the program of today's festive event with the contribution from Mr. von Hirschhausen, one might ask: Is the Science Council a case for cabaret? Certainly not. Nevertheless, it is good if an institution that is supposed to hold a mirror to science policy allows itself to be reflected again and again. The Science Council has entrusted this task today not only to a jester but also to a veritable scientist: Dear Mr. Frühwald, I look forward to your festive lecture!