Speech by Federal President Horst Köhler at the event "60 Years of the Federal Press Conference" on October 8, 2009, in Berlin:

Germany Horst Köhler · President of Germany

9 October 2009 · 60 Years of the Federal Press Conference · Berlin, Germany

Context
Köhler addressed the Federal Press Conference's 60th anniversary celebration on October 8, 2009, in Berlin, reflecting on journalism's role in democracy.
Main themes
Press freedom and democracy, quality journalism, political discourse in Germany, media industry challenges, enlightenment and public responsibility, relationship between press and government, commercial pressures on journalism, journalist professional standards
Duration
~14 min
49th percentile
Words
1,690
49th percentile
Sentences
102
64th percentile
Readability
57
81st percentile
Grade
9.4
14th percentile
Syntax
2.72
15th percentile
Vocabulary
1.97
7th percentile

Translated from German

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

102 sentences in 23 paragraphs

"Enlightenment Requires Attitude"

When Werner Gößling invited me to this evening six months ago, I wondered: Why does the Federal Press Conference want to be congratulated on its 60th birthday by the one federal politician who, by virtue of his office, has the least to do with it?

But then I looked at the calendar. Quite right: Your regular clientele is otherwise occupied these days. The board has invited in wise foresight; I am happy to be here, congratulations.

To the point: "If the relationship between the federal government and the press has come to the point where it stands today, it is (...) due to the unsuitability of the majority of correspondents."

No worries, that was just a quote. However, it is at least the quote of a member of the Federal Press Conference, and it is almost as old as the BPK itself. It comes from November 1950, and the author was Hans Georg von Studnitz. So was the worm in there from the very beginning?

I do not want to go that far. On the contrary. In a country where the relationship between politics and the press is always good, I would not want to live, let alone as head of state. Because such a country is highly unlikely to be a democracy, at least not a vibrant one. And the suitability of a journalist for his profession cannot be measured in a democratic state by how well he ensures a good relationship between government and press.

Rather, it should be measured by how well he or she can ensure a good relationship between the press and the public. And even there, Studnitz has a lot to offer – let me quote:

"The end of the severe crisis in which the German press has been for about a year is still not in sight. A whole series of daily newspapers and magazines are still in a desperate struggle for their existence. Very many German newspapers and magazines will never get on the right track as long as they continue to be made by the wrong people. Today, there is no justification for a state in which, at many newspapers, ignoramuses are responsible for publishing and editing. Instead, we are experiencing that incompetents, who are unceremoniously shown the door from newspaper companies, receive huge severance payments just to leave and let the professionals take the helm."

End of quote, 59 years old, I certainly do not claim it as my own, and by the way: As Federal President, one is sometimes not allowed to speak as one can quote.

But I did not come here to complain with you about the central office. There is a responsibility of the federal political correspondents gathered here for the quality of political discourse in Germany, even if you are by no means the only ones who bear this responsibility. And let’s be honest: The quality of political discourse in Germany sometimes leaves room for improvement.

I know many are wondering whether the industry can still provide the framework for quality journalism. They stare in fascination at declining circulation and plummeting advertising bookings, and all they can think of to defend themselves are more drama, more personalization, more ostentatious distancing from the world of politics. I believe there is another way, and I am glad that it is being pointed out by people from the industry itself. Listen to what the editor-in-chief of the Braunschweiger Zeitung recently had to say: "In reflecting on the actual mission, we are helped by what many see as a disadvantage of a publisher; newspapers are businesses, albeit special ones. This is an advantage: We must care for our readers, must sense and satisfy their needs – which has little to do with populism."

I believe that is true. Those who say commercial pressures inevitably lead to a decline in quality are, conversely, saying: Money determines the quality of the press. It should not be that simple. The demand of your readers, your viewers for enlightenment is enormous, and whoever offers this commodity in high and durable quality delivers more than education and maturity and judgment for the individual, as important as they are; they provide the practical manual for being democratic, they make it clear to people what they can achieve together, and how much strength and creativity arise when free people discover and use their possibilities together.

The world we live in wants to be explained so that it can be shaped. It has never been as complicated as it is today. But it has also never offered so many opportunities for learning, so many possibilities for peaceful reconciliation, so many chances for cooperation, and so many new perspectives on old certainties. It should be a great time for people who earn their money with curiosity.

This is not about promises; it is simply about self-determination. And it begins with the realization that one should demand from one’s own thinking the penetration of facts even when they are uncomfortable. This is sometimes a challenge for supporters of established worldviews, but journalists should not shy away from it. What should one think when many of you are eager to pass judgment on the use of the official car by the Minister of Health, but few can give a competent judgment on the minister's health policy?

I believe you are mistaken if you think people do not want to know that. I believe many people out there feel uneasy at the thought of the future of our healthcare system because they realize that we can only sustainably maintain this system if it also meets the criterion of economic viability. Health is the most valuable asset, but we suspect that we cannot afford to pay any price for it. So we are approaching the question: What is the maximum price for health? What are we willing to spend together per month at most? I believe people are ready to face the tension that lies in such considerations. But they lack enlightenment.

Why is it not being offered? Because it is arduous to acquire the judgment necessary to credibly provide enlightenment? Because there is also the temptation for members of the Federal Press Conference to merely suggest competence? Perhaps it is easier to cheat at the federal level than, for example, in local journalism. Local journalists have it harder: Their judgment is always against the readers' own judgment. Mistakes and lack of diligence are noticeable. Local journalists must be competent; otherwise, their work is challenged on the ground. Federal political correspondents, on the other hand, can feign expertise and hide a lack of judgment in herd behavior.

For example, I noticed how many of you agreed in your assessment of the recent election campaign. I have a terrible suspicion: I believe many in the media who ostensibly demanded more sharpness, more ideology, more attack in the name of democracy and in the fight against political apathy were not really concerned about democracy: At best, they were bored, and at worst, they missed something with which to boost their ratings and circulation. And you know what? I believe many people out there have seen through that.

At least, you have not allowed yourselves to be deprived of the ability for self-reflection. Günter Bannas, for example, held up a mirror to the profession a few weeks ago. What would it be like, he asked, if the desired ruckus had been provided in the election campaign? His answer: "Those television moderators and political critics who currently speak of the boring, indeed undemocratic election campaign would have etched even deeper furrows into their faces. It would be beneath the level, they would say, it would increase party apathy, voters should turn away, they would say and write. The Federal President would intervene warningly and warn of a decline in political culture."

I am not sure about the conclusion, but what came before is certainly correct. It is just a pity that one had to struggle through to page 42 of the Saturday FAZ to share this insight.

I do not know if you had time in the past weeks for Jürgen Leinemann. I was touched by what I read there. Also by what he gives you and your colleagues as advice: "I miss an attitude in many journalists. By that I mean: seriousness. To stand up for something special, to find it important. I miss passion."

Having attitude. It is a rather old word. But I think it could come back into fashion. Just like another, much simpler word: having an idea. Together they are strong, I believe.

Entertainment is important, even in your profession. But as a means of information. Not as a substitute for it. Already far too many people have the wrong impression that the purpose of politics is entertainment. This development is unhealthy. For democracy. And also for those who report on it. Funny: Studnitz had that in mind back then too: "The sales crisis of the German daily press is in reality a revolt of the newspaper reader against newspapers that no longer know his intellectual needs because they consider him to be dumber than he actually is. The audience today wants to be entertained or educated, but in any case informed. Publishers and editorial offices should engage in introspection. And they will understand that at the beginning of the German press crisis stands the quality crisis; the declining performance of so many newspapers that have managed to bore the audience instead of stimulating it. The time for an internal reform of the German press, a process of self-purification, is long overdue."

I know a press spokesman who told me that the Federal Press Conference is the only association he has ever been proud of. When you ask him why, he cannot answer precisely in a journalistic manner. But he also does not back down from his judgment. There is something special about you, he says. Please do not rest on that. Do something with it. There is much to discover for all who can ask questions. And they can also be questions about themselves. Once again: Congratulations!