Speech by Federal President Horst Köhler at the IX. Munich Economic Summit on April 29 in Munich:

Germany Horst Köhler · President of Germany

29 April 2010 · IX. Munich Economic Summit · Munich, Germany

Context
Köhler addressed the IX Munich Economic Summit on April 29, 2010, urging financial market reform and democratic oversight in the wake of the global financial crisis.
Main themes
Financial crisis reform, regulation of financial markets, democratic oversight of capitalism, savings capitalism vs financial capitalism, G20 reforms, public debt and taxpayer liability, financial sector bonuses and speculation, economy in service of society, social responsibility of business, sustainable prosperity
Duration
~29 min
82nd percentile
Words
3,522
82nd percentile
Sentences
212
90th percentile
Readability
47
53rd percentile
Grade
10.9
31st percentile
Syntax
2.81
23rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
16th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 63%60%
  • Social 17%16%
  • Institutional 9%8%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Environmental 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

212 sentences in 61 paragraphs

"Do not waste the crisis!"

Imagine that power producers had installed a new supply system that brings them magnificent profits and then causes power outages for everyone else for four weeks. Imagine that farmers would become rich with new cultivation methods and then trigger a crop failure every seven years. Imagine that waterworks made their tap water more palatable than ever with innovations, and then, due to those innovations, suddenly no drinking water would come from the taps.

Imagine that in all three cases this would have been quite foreseeable and also predicted.

Then you would inevitably ask: Is it not the duty of the democratic state to protect its citizens? And should the state not do everything in its power to ensure that no business sector increases its growth and profits at the risk of many others suffering existentially? The answer can only be Yes!

The ninth Munich Economic Summit is dedicated to the topic "The financial crisis: The way forward." We will only find this way forward if we think far beyond the financial crisis. We must not waste the crisis, but must learn from it. It has raised very fundamental questions.

I believe at least three answers to the crisis are necessary:

We need

first

financial markets under the primacy of democratic politics and in the service of the overall economy.

We need

second

an economy in the service of society as a whole.

And we need third a social coexistence to which everyone contributes.

These are three tasks of design that no one can take from us. They require the courage of politics, the insight of citizens, and the willingness for democratic self-determination.

The international "financial industry" has driven its own profits to dizzying heights with so-called financial innovations and has not asked about the risks. In doing so, it has triggered a crisis that would have led to a collapse of the global financial system without state rescue measures. The governments, parliaments, and central banks of Western democracies had no choice but to respond with an unprecedented financial stimulus and far-reaching guarantees for financial institutions. They had to accept an explosion of public debt and the associated liability of today's and future taxpayers.

Such a rescue operation cannot be repeated – neither financially nor politically. Must not the democratic states of the world therefore do everything to avoid a repetition of such a crisis? The answer can once again only be Yes! Citizens want to be safe from irresponsible behavior in the financial markets. The next severe crisis of the financial system would, I am sure, not only call into question the functionality of our economic and social model but also its credibility. Countering this must be an imperative task for democracies as communities of values and protection and for their officials.

The summit conference of the heads of state and government of the G20 in Pittsburgh has laid the right and important foundations for this. But what will come of it? The international "financial industry" and its lobbyists are obviously leaving no stone unturned to dilute the agreed measures. At the same time, betting continues, new financial bubbles are already forming again, and while states and citizens are still struggling with the consequences of the crisis, parts of the financial sector are already awarding themselves gigantic bonuses again. Have those involved even understood what is at stake?

The practice of today's prevailing financial capitalism can certainly not be a model for us. It is self-sufficient. It operates primarily with bets and debts. It increases its own returns without regard to whether this benefits the well-being of nations. The current crisis shows a pattern that is unacceptable – the profits have been made by a few, while the losses must be borne by the general public.

There is a better model. Ralf Dahrendorf pointed this out 25 years ago. He distinguished between "pump capitalism" and "savings capitalism." Savings capitalism means creating lasting values instead of making bets, financing real goods and services instead of building virtual financial pyramids. In savings capitalism, short-term thinking and speculation do not dominate, but rather real economic investment and ownership that binds itself in responsibility. There, one is interested in a stable monetary value and shows respect to all who save money and thus prepare for the future. An economy based on this model improves the living conditions of all. It aims for sustainable prosperity for all.

An economy with this model must also serve the financial markets. They should act as trustworthy intermediaries between savers and investors, rather than putting everything at risk. This serving role is the true justification for the existence of financial markets, and defining them as such must be the central goal of the reorganization of financial markets.

Politics must regain its primacy over financial markets. It has left too much room for the interests of financial market players without rules. This was one reason why the financial crisis could arise at all. And it has led to the state being extortable during the financial crisis – and it still is today. Such a thing must not happen again.

This demands simple and hard rules for the "financial industry." It must be given limits so that freedom does not destroy itself.

Four

consequences from the crisis I consider to be paramount:

First:

The central market economic principle of liability must be reinstated throughout, especially through sufficiently high equity for all types of financial transactions, regardless of the definition of a bank, meaning including, for example, hedge funds and private equity firms.

Second

– and this is also very much about liability: No bank and no financial player should be too big to fail. This urgently requires a special insolvency regime for internationally operating financial institutions, including the possibility of temporarily placing an institution under state administration.

Third:

We need maximum transparency in the area of so-called derivatives and an end to shadow banking. An international approval procedure, a kind of international TÜV, should be established for financial innovations, and derivatives should only be traded on public exchanges.

Fourth:

The heads of state and government of the G20 should insist that the "financial industry," as stated in Pittsburgh, makes a "fair and substantial contribution" to addressing the costs of the crisis. Personally, I still believe that a levy on international financial transactions is the best way to achieve this.

The federal government is taking the right steps, as shown by the key points it has adopted for a new financial market regulation. It is also encouraging to see the close coordination with our French partners. I would even wish that the German-French tandem would show even more leadership. Because as necessary as a global new financial order would be, we are still far from it politically. Should we just continue to wait for it?

President Obama has given a strong new impetus to the American debate last week with his speech on financial reform, and I wish him success – also in the interest of all of us. He rightly says: "(…) a free market was never meant to be a license to take everything you can get – no matter how."

But even if reform progresses in the USA, Europe should not just wait. I believe that the Eurogroup would do well to present its own powerful proposals for a new regulatory framework. It should not shy away from simply banning certain types of business and also asset classes, such as uncovered "naked shorts" or over-the-counter transactions with huge leverage. We also need disarmament for such "weapons of mass destruction." And Europe needs efficient central supervision over cross-border institutions and a European rating agency. Strict rules for the financial markets would also correspond to the logic of our commitment to a stable euro.

Regarding the situation of the euro and Greece, I want to say only the following today: The euro has served Europe well so far. If we do not make serious mistakes, it will continue to do so in the future and remain an anchor of stability in the world currency system. It is distracting to re-fight the battles of the past now. Greece must now take responsibility. However, it understandably expects help for self-help. The involvement of the International Monetary Fund in the assistance is to be welcomed, as it can also utilize the entire experience of this institution in dealing with debt crises. Germany should also contribute to stabilization out of its own interest. And all members of the Eurogroup and the European Commission must learn from the crisis. The European Economic and Monetary Union needs better coordination of national economic and financial policies and an effective mechanism to counteract imbalances in member states in a timely and sustainable manner. The federal government is rightly advocating this.

Even if the international community and the European Union were to provide the financial markets with the missing good order, that alone would still not be sufficient. In a variation of a well-known saying by Ernst-Wolfgang Böckenförde: The market economy also lives from conditions that the state cannot guarantee. It relies on economic citizens who do not only pay attention to the letter of the law but also to its spirit, and who orient their actions according to values and attitudes that the state cannot enforce. In the area of the economy, for example, these are the values and attitudes of the honorable merchant. The more business leaders embrace this model, the freer the market can remain.

When freedom, good rules, creative diligence, and decency come together, sustainable economic success and social cohesion will also emerge. This is our experience from sixty years of social market economy.

That is why, as a second question on the way out of the crisis, it is important: How do we maintain the strength of the market economy? I believe that every nation must first balance its assets and liabilities. So let us talk about public debt. In order not to plunge the entire world economy into the abyss, industrialized countries have massively increased their public debt – by 20 to 30 percent of their economic output within three years. The OECD expects that the debt of industrialized countries will exceed their economic strength – that is, the mark of 100 percent of gross domestic product – for the first time next year.

This has consequences. New research shows: Public debt even significantly below this magnitude is a mortgage for the prosperous development of the economy and society. Historically, financial crises have primarily been debt crises. This also applies to the current crisis. The bitter truth is: Most Western societies have lived chronically beyond their means long before the current crisis management.

And Germany is not exempt from this. Our explicit public debt currently stands at almost 1.8 trillion euros or about 74 percent of our overall economic output. If we also consider implicit debts, that is, all financial promises the state has made for the future, such as financing pensions, the total debt burden is even significantly higher.

To this day, we rely on the fact that primarily economic growth will help us deal with the debt problem. Some even recommend incurring even more debt for this purpose. I believe that this is bad advice that we should by no means follow. It would lead us into a hopeless debt trap, as the limits of growth can no longer be overlooked for developed economies.

Potential growth in Germany – as in most other industrialized countries – has continuously declined over the past decades. It currently stands at about one percent. A slightly higher growth path is still possible and also desirable in Germany for some time. Achieving it depends on our ability to implement structural reforms. But I equally emphatically add: With growth and growth policy alone, we will no longer be able to solve the debt problem. We must also take into account the rapid decline in the population. Germany will likely have over ten million fewer inhabitants by 2050. Fewer and fewer people will have to service a growing mountain of debt if we leave things as they are.

This is not a good future perspective for Germany. And I can only warn against thought experiments about a "solution" to the debt problem through "controlled inflation." On the contrary: there must be no doubt that the central banks are determined to reduce the excess monetary liquidity in the markets – even one of the central causes of the crisis.

My advice for Germany is this: to ensure lasting stability and to give new strength to our social market economy, we must make the consolidation of public finances the decisive, the guiding state task of the next ten years. This is not only a constitutional obligation but also a moral duty! Consolidation can only succeed convincingly if state expenditures and subsidies are scaled back.

I advocate for linking the recovery of public finances with sustainable reforms in our tax and transfer systems. These additively grown systems are rife with inconsistencies and, due to their over-complexities, hardly allow for reliable judgments about whether they even achieve their political goals. I believe that even simplifications and the elimination of contradictions could achieve a lot of good. Furthermore, I advocate for a savings policy that also knows and states where savings cannot be made.

Savings cannot be made in the area of education, research, and development in our country. We must invest more, not less, in our education system, in our universities and research institutions, and in a societal climate where education and the pursuit of education are respected and valued. A great collective effort for these goals is the most important contribution to the future viability of our country.

Good education for all is the prerequisite for social integration and for high-quality jobs. It is also the most important answer to the question of social justice. Children from families with a migration background, children from low-income and educationally disadvantaged families still have significantly worse educational opportunities than their peers. This is an outrageous injustice, and it harms our economy and our coexistence to the core. Our vocational education, our higher education system, and our research institutions are also in urgent need of more investment.

With the agreement between the federal government and the states to gradually increase spending on education and research to ten percent of gross domestic product by 2015, the right course has been set. I want to emphasize this explicitly in recognition. However, this intention must also be implemented in reality. Achieving this goal is worth a tax increase if necessary.

A world-class education system and research institutions are also necessary for the transformation to an ecological social market economy. This transformation is without alternative. In the year 1800, one billion people lived on Earth; by the year 2000, there were more than six billion, and in forty years, there will be over nine billion people. But resources and the biosphere do not grow accordingly. Therefore, the world needs a third revolution after the steam engine and the microchip, a revolution of environmental compatibility, a revolution of resource-efficient use, and the progressive development of renewable energies. This revolution has already begun, and Germany is currently at the forefront of nations. But we must not rest on our laurels.

I advocate for systematically and comprehensively setting goals for a forward-looking transformation policy. Yes, we must prepare for far-reaching adjustments in the economy and in lifestyle. But it will be a self-directed change, not one that is suffered. And it will be worth it: Experts tell me, for example, that we could already reduce resource consumption in Germany by 30 to 40 percent today if we truly operated efficiently. I am convinced: The "green revolution" will not only secure the jobs and incomes of the future – the green revolution will also improve our quality of life.

I would like to urge economists to think even more about how the market-based price mechanism can be used for a forward-looking ecological transformation policy. For example, I believe that the eco-tax certainly deserves more self-confident political advocates – many studies show this.

Achieving more with scarce resources also applies to our social state as a whole. We should think about it even more from the goal perspective: from the individual person. We must invest in their abilities, promote and demand their capacity for self-determination and self-provision. I call this the "investive" social state; you, Professor Sinn, speak of the "activating" social state. We are probably talking about the same thing, and I believe we have a very similar view of humanity – we believe in the maturity of the citizen. The Agenda 2010 was a step forward. We are not at the goal yet.

To make our social state weatherproof for the 21st century, we must continue to consistently check whether it invests in the maturity and independence of citizens. Only then can it achieve what is necessary without constantly expanding – and this social state must become more efficient, especially in light of the dramatic demographic changes in our country. We spend a lot of money on social benefits in Germany – around 750 billion euros annually, nearly a third of our economic output. But we often achieve significantly less than other countries. In part, we do not even know what we are achieving. One example: We spend almost 190 billion euros on the promotion of marriages and families. However, what actually contributes to encouraging people to start a family, what gives children a good future, no one can really say so far. At least the question is now being thoroughly investigated.

The best social security is help for self-help, the best social movement is advancement through performance, and the best-tasting bread is the bread earned by oneself. Therefore, we should demand from our social state: Everyone who wants to work must be able to work and then have enough to live on. This maxim can be realized, especially since we are also facing a paradigm shift in employment policy in Germany. In just a few years, demographic developments will lead to a shortage of well-qualified workers. Companies are already responding to this by trying to retain skilled workers even in difficult order situations. This is to be welcomed, but we can do even more.

We should also further develop the labor market for personal services, especially since the demand for them continues to grow. People are getting older, and that also means: More and more people will need support and care. And: More and more households will depend on or wish for both partners to work. This means that the demand for childcare and household-related services will increase.

This also shows: We are not running out of work in Germany, and this offers the opportunity for everyone seeking work to feel needed and valued. Both the Institute for the Study of Labor and the Institute for Employment Research of the Federal Employment Agency have made noteworthy proposals for a future-oriented labor market policy. I share their view that full employment is possible in Germany. Why don’t we finally take this goal seriously? An investive social state and an economy in the service of the entire society – they are achievable!

What is now the third step forward, out of the financial crisis? Which society should the economy benefit? I can only briefly address this question here. It is important that we always keep it in mind. I advocate for the guiding principle of a free, fair, and solidarity-based civil society. It excludes no one, it helps everyone to develop their own talents and to lead as self-determined a life as possible, it brings people together.

It is important to recognize that even such a society of subsidiarity depends on good political design of the state framework. The small circles of life should not perform tasks for the state for which it runs out of resources. Rather: The self-responsibility of the small circles must be valued as a value in itself, but also used for the common good.

This requires a new relationship between engaged citizens and the state. Wherever people solve social tasks through their own initiative and civic engagement, the state should not take their place but support them, give them freedom, and recognize and promote their strength and ideas. I have encountered so many people in our country who take action themselves, in self-help groups, in sports clubs, in parent councils, in church communities, in citizens' initiatives. These people are already searching for solutions to new questions; they create cohesion, solidarity, belonging, and trust. In the economy, there is often talk of capital. What is created here is social capital. This is at least as valuable as financial capital.

The financial crisis – the way forward: If politics tames the financial markets, if we in Germany ecologically transform our social market economy, if we design our social state investively and strengthen social cohesion – then we have not wasted the financial crisis but used it for a new beginning. That is worth the sweat of the noble.