Speech by Federal President Horst Köhler at the opening of the panel discussion "Future of Modernity" on October 20, 2009, in Berlin:

Germany Horst Köhler · President of Germany

21 October 2009 · Panel discussion "Future of Modernity" · Schloss Bellevue, Berlin, Germany

Context
Köhler opened a public panel discussion on the 'Future of Modernity' at Schloss Bellevue, Berlin, concluding his year-long 'Diversity of Modernity' dialogue series.
Main themes
Future of modernity, globalization and world conversation, Western self-understanding and values, individualism versus egoism, cultural diversity and dialogue, financial and economic crisis, climate change and sustainability, clash of civilizations, colonial legacy and power imbalance, ethics in science and economy, progress and its meaning, entangled histories
Duration
~14 min
48th percentile
Words
1,660
48th percentile
Sentences
78
51st percentile
Readability
47
54th percentile
Grade
11.9
43rd percentile
Syntax
3.04
52nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
36th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 58%47%
  • Ceremonial 23%19%
  • Geopolitical 6%5%
  • Environmental 6%5%
  • Economic 3%3%
  • Institutional 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 18%

78 sentences in 18 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

I warmly welcome you to the panel discussion at Schloss Bellevue.

This discussion is, in a way, the public part of the series of talks "Diversity of Modernity – Perspectives on Modernity," which I initiated a little over a year ago. There have been three rounds in the past months, three times wise women and men from different parts of the world, cultures, and religions have discussed here in this hall – on topics such as "Individual and Community," "Wisdom and Science," and – this morning – "Human and Modernity." This evening, we want to turn our attention to the "Future of Modernity."

"Don't we have other worries?" some may ask now. And indeed: The financial and economic crisis is not yet over; it still has existential consequences for many people in this world. In many countries, there is arbitrariness, violence, and poverty. We are confronted with terrorism and fundamentalism. And not least, it is becoming increasingly clear that we – all of humanity – face the enormous task of slowing down climate change and creating a global economy that is sustainable with nature and fair to people.

Upon closer inspection, however, behind these acute, pressing problems often lie the very questions that have been discussed here at Schloss Bellevue in recent months in varying groups. These are questions that simultaneously – and here we are at modernity – target the core of the Western self-understanding: How much individualism is beneficial to us – and when does it turn into destructive egoism? What ethical guidelines do science and economy need – and who can set them? What does progress mean – and what goal should it serve? I am convinced – and the discussions of today have further reinforced this belief: Especially in light of the current crises and great challenges, it is important for all involved – and we are all, willingly or unwillingly, involved – to know how others think about these questions. And it is important to seek answers together. That is what this series of talks is about, and that is what we are here for this evening.

For what we do or fail to do influences the lives and well-being of others. And no cultural sphere in this world has a monopoly on wisdom. Perhaps the current crisis also holds a great opportunity: the opportunity for a concentrated global discussion about coexistence in our One World and about shaping our way of life and economy. That no longer is primarily the "Clash of Civilizations" invoked, but also within individual societies and cultural spheres, the reflection deepens on which values and behaviors are compatible with a sustainable world society and which are less so or not at all. And finally, the opportunity for the realization to grow that there must be something like a "World Conversation" among people of different backgrounds who realize that it concerns existential questions for the future of our One World. The process of globalization must – as one of the participants in the discussion this morning put it – necessarily be accompanied by a process of communication.

But are we already sufficiently equipped for this? What do we know about the worldviews of others, about their historical experiences, about their cultural and religious values? Do we have any idea how others experience the promises and demands of the change that we summarize under the term "modernity"? Do we know what echoes terms trigger elsewhere – due to certain historical experiences or religious ideas? What do we know about other perspectives and other forms of modernity? I believe: still far too little.

The reasons for this are manifold. The power and wealth gap on our planet is still large, too large. In many countries of the South, the humiliations of the colonial era continue to resonate, and often mutual perceptions are distorted – through ignorance, or also because it suits the ruling elites. And because one should first look in the mirror, I want to add: We Europeans have gotten used over the centuries to measuring the world solely by our own standards. This is not helpful either. Because the global history of relationships is not a one-way street. "Entangled histories," as Shalini Randeria called it, one of the participants in the first round.

There could hardly be a better trigger word than "modernity" to spark a lively debate among wise minds from different parts of the world. The tenor of the debates in the past discussion rounds roughly corresponded to the beautiful anecdote of Mahatma Gandhi. When asked by a journalist, "What do you think of western civilization?", he is said to have replied: "I think it would be a good idea." This response expresses the legitimate expectation that "the West" not only preaches its values but also lives them and allows itself to be measured by them.

It was therefore inevitable that in our discussions, the self-image of the Western world was also called into question. A self-image that includes the emphasis on reason and scientific knowledge, the belief in the controllability of nature, the ability of the individual to take their fate into their own hands, the trust in economic rationality, and the positive power of progress. However, it is also a self-image that has some blind spots – for example, when it comes to the price of progress or the question of who has to pay for it.

For modernity does not only include a ethos of freedom from which universal human rights, democratically constituted communities, and the possibility of individual life design emerged, not only the great discoveries and inventions and the rapid increase in material wealth and health well-being.

Modernity also includes the feeling of alienation in a highly specialized, division of labor, and industrialized economic process and the detachment from traditional relationships – a feeling that awakens in many people a longing for manageable communities and simple answers to complicated questions. Modernity includes the often ruthless exploitation of our natural environment. Modernity includes the latent overload from an ever-accelerating pace of life and increasing complexity. But still, and to a frightening extent, for many people in the world, the existential challenge of securing their own survival. All of this has been addressed today and in the previous rounds of "Perspectives on Modernity."

And one more thing has been emphasized repeatedly: Just as there is no single view of modernity, there is also no single development model. For our so-called "Western" side, this means: recognizing that the times are over when we could view our own development path as a blueprint that all societies would follow sooner or later. Social change and progress do not necessarily have to follow Western patterns. Some developments that we today lament as threatening to the future of humanity can also be read as a consequence of our path into modernity – climate change is just one particularly striking example.

The "inclusion of the other" has been called for by the German philosopher Jürgen Habermas many years ago. Today, this is more relevant than ever, across all country and national borders. As a global community, we need a common ethos – I fully agree with Hans Küng, who has also participated in this discussion. We must think together about what we owe each other and how we can define and protect the global common good in a world that is as interconnected as it is fragile. There are plenty of open questions. Can we perhaps live better with less? What can we learn from other ways of seeing the world – the economist Alberto Acosta spoke this morning about the new Ecuadorian constitution, which is based on the indigenous concept of "sumak kawsay," or "good living"?

Niklas Luhmann once said: "Culture prevents the consideration of what one could do differently instead of the usual." And that is why intercultural, interreligious dialogues like this one are not an academic end in themselves, but a guide to rethinking habits and an opportunity to learn from one another. I hope that will be the case this evening. I wish for open, controversial discussions, for here diversity should be recognized and also acknowledged. We spoke this morning about the "dignity of difference," the dignity of the difference between cultures. And at the same time, it is about seeking commonalities – as the subtitle of this panel discussion suggests. Ashis Nandy, whom you will hear shortly, said this morning: "In dialogue with others, we simultaneously gain access to a part of ourselves."

Each one of you here in the hall is a potential mediator and amplifier in the search for a good path to a shared future. I am sure: We are all capable of learning. The future is open, and we have the power to shape it together and create a better world. I will not let go of this very "modern" view of the world. "Life has long legs" – this African proverb was quoted by Aminata Sow Fall this morning. Let us use them to move forward – and to meet one another.

Before I now hand over to Melinda Crane, who will charmingly and knowledgeably lead today's round, one more thing: The series of talks "Perspectives on Modernity" and this evening would not have been possible without the support of our cooperation partners. The event forum of the Georg von Holtzbrinck publishing group has brought its expertise in the conception, planning, and execution of international conferences and symposia, while the BMW Foundation Herbert Quandt has contributed its experience in organizing global opinion and knowledge exchange and in weaving international networks. Thank you very much for that!

I would also like to thank Professor Joas, a sociologist at the University of Erfurt and currently at the University of Chicago, who has provided his wise advice and good suggestions in preparing this discussion, and this morning Professor Kallscheuer guided us. I wish us all an exciting discussion and an inspiring evening!