Speech by Federal President Horst Köhler at the Philip Breuel Foundation on March 2, 2010, in Hamburg-Nienstedten:

Germany Horst Köhler · President of Germany

8 March 2010 · Philip Breuel Foundation event, "Friendship Between Generations" · church in Hamburg-Nienstedten, Hamburg, Germany

Context
Köhler addressed supporters of the Philip Breuel Foundation in Hamburg-Nienstedten on March 2, 2010, speaking on friendship and solidarity between generations.
Main themes
Intergenerational friendship, demographic aging, solidarity between generations, family bonds, generational justice, national debt and future generations, gerontocracy, unpaid care work, social cohesion, intergenerational conflict prevention
Duration
~26 min
77th percentile
Words
3,110
77th percentile
Sentences
154
82nd percentile
Readability
49
59th percentile
Grade
11.5
38th percentile
Syntax
3.06
56th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
20th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 80%79%
  • Institutional 8%8%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Economic 5%5%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

154 sentences in 34 paragraphs

"Friendship Between Generations"

Dear Breuel family,

dear friends and supporters of the Philip Breuel Foundation: I thank you all for the invitation.

I am pleased that you have invited us all here to this church. For it is a place that fosters community. Countless couples have married here and later had their children baptized. Here, the bereaved have mourned their loved ones and found comfort. Here, people of all ages have always met. Here, one feels the depth of time. Our ancestors built churches like this and filled them with life over the centuries. It is a good place to reflect on what connects us across generations today, and what the relationship between young and old might look like tomorrow.

Much has changed since this church was built. Back then, around 250 years ago, people had an average life expectancy of 40 years. Today, it is twice that. Just 100 years ago, it was rare for grandparents to witness their grandchildren's weddings – today, they increasingly experience the birth of their great-grandchildren. Many people consider it a great blessing to be able to walk such a long path together with their parents and grandparents, children and grandchildren. The years gained in life can also be a great gift for society. They offer new opportunities for a meaningful life and a solidary and enriching coexistence of young and old.

However, while the number of elderly people is increasing, the number of children is declining. And this will put the relationships between generations to the test. Will the younger generation be overwhelmed by the care and costs of the elderly? What does the ever-increasing national debt mean for future generations? Is there a threat of a gerontocracy, a dominance of the old, because the rising number of older voters prevents what would be necessary in the long term for the younger generation?

We should discuss such questions honestly to find out what might ignite conflicts, where we have gone off balance, and how we can do better.

But despite the seriousness of the debate, we must not allow generations to be pitted against each other and distribution battles to be instigated. Those who prophesy a "war between generations" in the face of the challenges ahead instill fear – and fear only complicates mutual learning and good coexistence. They also overlook that there are other societal divides that are no less pressing for the future: those between rich and poor, those with good education and those without qualifications, those with and without jobs. Above all: They underestimate people – and their ability to change themselves and reshape their circumstances.

I am confident: We can also shape an aging and shrinking society in a solidary and livable way – if we support and preserve the bonds between young and old within families; readjust the foundations of our political and social institutions and regulations, and find a new, productive, and fair balance between paid and unpaid work; and finally, if we strengthen the willingness to take responsibility for others and care for one another, even outside of one's own family.

The foundation for this – and at the same time the consequence of it – is what the philosopher Robert Spaemann called "friendship between generations."

"Friendship" – that may sound too lofty to some in this context. But even the ancient Greeks understood it to mean more than just sympathy for a particular person. Friendship, in the sense of respect and consideration for others, was regarded by Aristotle as the most important foundation for living together in the polis. Or, to put it again in Spaemann's words: "The generations are each other's fate. We inherit the world as it has been left to us by the older generation. And we depend on the younger generation to somehow take up the legacy left to them and continue our intentions. Therefore, friendship between generations is a condition for this encompassing fate of ours not to prove hostile."

In most families, this attitude is lived out quite naturally. Parents and adult children may increasingly live apart. However – or perhaps precisely for this reason – there is a lively interest in each other's lives. For many grandparents, communicating via the internet is no longer unusual. The interaction between young and old is more collaborative than before, as many studies show. Generation conflicts over value issues – as was the case not too long ago – are now rather rare. Therefore, the vast majority of people today also perceive the relationships within their own families as good.

The cohesion between generations works, despite all the doomsayers about the breakdown of the family. People share what they have: affection, time, money. Around 30 billion euros – in cash and in kind – are transferred annually between parents and children. Grandparents, especially grandmothers, provide many hours of unpaid work through childcare. Conversely, two out of three people in need of care are cared for within the family – often by wives or daughters who are already beyond their working lives. Today's families, with their few children and their long-living generations, thus form the backbone of our society.

We must protect and further strengthen this backbone. Many can contribute to this: Men, by taking on much more caregiving work than before. Legislators and employers, by enabling child-rearing and care to occur alongside work. There are no simple schemes; it requires agreements, careful observation, and flexible solutions for various individual cases. Some progress has been made, but much still needs to be done, especially regarding the care of the elderly. We need to take more precautions here. Colleagues, neighbors, and friends should also ask how they can strengthen the network that enables people to care for one another. And here, too, we need the spirit of friendship that makes a solidary, self-evident give-and-take possible.

Anyone who thinks about the give-and-take between generations inevitably ends up at the so-called "generational contract." In essence, it is not really a contract at all, but a state-organized maintenance obligation of the working population towards retirees and only encompasses two generations, as children are excluded. Its foundation, the pension reform of 1957, is long regarded as a sin of welfare state policy. Promises of benefits were made that could only be financed without problems under ideal conditions – low unemployment and consistently high birth rates. Even today, countless pension reforms later, this remains one of the biggest challenges in our welfare state, and at the same time, the most explosive issue for the relationship between generations.

It is no easy task to reshape the welfare state so that burdens and blessings are distributed fairly and that it is accepted by a majority. But this task is achievable.

From the political side, it requires the courage to correct existing imbalances and steadfastness to resist the temptation to seek votes by making promises to retirees. Each individual should be clear: Certainly, human communities have always cared – more or less well – for those who could no longer contribute to the common good because they were frail. However, this was usually only a few years after a hard, laborious life. The "retirement" as a distinct phase of life has only existed in human history for a relatively short time. What an achievement, what a gift! If we want to preserve this for future generations, we should put our expectations for a secure old age into perspective with the gained years of life.

Can we really take it for granted to enjoy an ever-longer phase of state-funded leisure after an ever-shorter working life? Most of us feel many years younger than we are. And we are not only getting older; we are also aging, on the whole, healthier. This means that the additional years of life are indeed mostly gained years. But why is there such an outcry when the Bundesbank dares to calculate, for example, that by 2060 – in 50 years – the retirement age must be 69 if the ratio of working to retirement phases is to remain the same? I believe we can and must share the gain in life expectancy better in the future – to the benefit of both the old and the young.

And I am sure: Most older people are fundamentally ready for this. I experienced this, for example, on a trip to Madagascar: There, I met German "senior experts" who helped, among other things, with the introduction of a dual training system. One of them told me that he had never experienced anything more beautiful in his entire professional life than supporting these young people in Madagascar in learning a profession that helps them build a livelihood.

Of course, older people also look forward to beautiful trips or more time with children and grandchildren. But very few want to leave their profession from one day to the next just because a rigid age limit dictates it. They do want to continue working (I can understand that well) – but perhaps differently and with fewer hours than before. We must make this possible, with adjustments for individual decisions, with opportunities for additional income, and with smooth transitions from professional work to other activities. Many, but not enough employers have already discovered how beneficial it is to utilize the experience of older people for as long as possible by integrating them according to their abilities – whether in mixed teams that are meant to promote knowledge transfer between generations or as "mentors," "coaches," or in "tandems."

There are thus many points of contact for friendship between young and old. And when older people remain professionally active longer or engage in voluntary work for the common good, they stay right in the midst of life. This is known to keep one "young." And older people are no longer feared for their neediness but appreciated for their abilities – abilities that enrich the coexistence of all. Here’s a little story about that: Some time ago, I invited older and younger people to a conversation at Schloss Bellevue. An older lady, a former ballerina, reported that she is sometimes asked how it is possible to dance at her age. She always replies: "In the past, I danced with my body; today, I dance with my soul." Beautifully said, isn’t it?

Certainly, careful consideration must be given to what people in different professions and life stages can achieve. But even where, for example, shift work or significant physical strain is involved, solutions can be found with a bit of imagination. No rigid scheme, but various building blocks for individual life situations and needs – that is how it should work. By the way, this also applies to the younger generation. For how sustainable our social security systems will be will not only depend on the numerical ratio between the working population and retirees but also on how many working-age individuals are actually employed.

Let us enable both old and young, men and women, to vary the phases, types, and intensity of work! Then much more could be accommodated in life: raising children, further education, social engagement, enjoying leisure time. Let us give those who have children or care for relatives more time. Let us allow them to reduce their work hours – and require those who currently bear no caregiving responsibility to engage more in their professional lives.

All of this is part of a new, future-oriented, and intelligent generational contract that brings together people of all ages, genders, and occupations instead of separating them. It recognizes that there are no clear boundaries for when someone is old, or when someone can no longer do this or that. It dissolves the rigid three-step process of learning, working, resting – for the benefit of all. The goal is a society of activity that not only recognizes paid work but also care and attention to others, and that enables reliable relationships between people of different ages – within and outside the family.

How well the relationship between old and young develops in our society will increasingly depend on the extent to which people, beyond their own families, form bonds with individuals from other generations, stand up for one another, and care for each other. If more people remain childless or have no grandchildren, this will not only change private family constellations, but it will also alter the social fabric and the nature of our interactions. One of the important tasks of the future will therefore be to spark curiosity among people of different ages beyond the family and to promote their encounters. We must rediscover the value of a community based on reciprocity.

Awareness of this is growing. Many new places for encounters for people of all ages have emerged in recent years, not least thanks to the commitment of foundations: multi-generational houses, facilities that connect daycare centers and nursing homes, intergenerational housing projects in city centers. Many forms of community engagement between the elderly and the young are now well established: initiatives such as reading mentors, "borrowed grandmothers," or "senior experts," as well as computer courses taught by young people for older adults or history workshops where older witnesses and young people go on a quest into the past together.

Municipalities can initiate a lot in this regard by, for example, providing land for such purposes, aligning their urban planning with the needs of all age groups, and, above all, establishing points of contact for civic engagement. The willingness to participate is great; many people are once again orienting themselves towards the small circles of life where they can directly experience their value and effectiveness: family, friends, neighborhood, and clubs. However, engagement often fails because individuals cannot find a starting point, as they do not know where to turn.

Some cities are already further along; they offer many opportunities to get started. Others could do even more, and there are many possibilities: volunteer exchanges, cooperative models, partnerships between the state and civil society. We can also wisely utilize the diverse possibilities of the internet for better connections between generations. However, it is urgently necessary for local politics to receive a reliable financial framework – and I know that this is easier said than done. But many ideas and the willingness to participate wither away when only scarcity can be managed. Therefore, I hope that, in the end, the reform efforts will succeed in strengthening the municipalities.

The ability to engage for others, however, is not something that can be turned on at the push of a button. It should be promoted as much as possible: through "Fit for Volunteering" programs offered by companies for future retirees, through "Corporate Social Responsibility" projects by businesses, and also through more social learning projects in our daycare centers and schools. Social competence, mindfulness, empathy: this must be part of the educational process from the very beginning. It is essential for children to experience that others care about them – about their ideas, their abilities, and also their insecurities. Equally fundamental is it for children to learn how to pay attention to others and to advocate for them. This is precisely what the Children's Art Clubs of the Philip Breuel Foundation are about: through art, music, and theater, they aim to empower young people who otherwise have a difficult time in life. And how happy and self-confident this makes the children, we witnessed impressively earlier. Thank you to the Philip Breuel Foundation for this commitment, and thank you to the leaders of the Children's Art Clubs!

We must learn to care for one another more: to take responsibility not only for ourselves but also for others. Especially the generations that are now entering retirement age bring a lot to this: these are men and women who often have experience with various forms of self-help and engagement for others and who are also open to alternative ways of living. Think of the former mayor of Bremen, Henning Scherf: he uniquely manages to turn gray into color and to live and promote the diverse possibilities of harmonious coexistence in old age.

But he also reports that this is not always easy and pleasant: he has cared for housemates who were dying together with his shared living community. The humanity of our society will also be determined by the willingness to help those who can no longer help themselves and who have no children or whose children live far away. It would be nice if help in the future would increasingly come from other familiar people in the personal environment. What politics can do, it should contribute to – for example, by recognizing not only close relatives as "caring family members" during caregiving periods but also friends and neighbors who provide non-professional assistance.

And one more thing: friendship between generations will also require much more openness to cultural and social diversity in the future – because this will increase. Not only are many migrants who came to the country as very young people in the 1970s now reaching retirement age. Many of today's young people have the experience of being "bi-national," as they or their parents were not born in Germany. Making connections between the elderly lady from Nienstedten and the young person from Wilhelmsburg is certainly not easy – but it is desirable and rewarding.

The potentials for all of this lie in our own minds and feelings. It is our special ability to empathize that makes us human. And neuroscience has found encouraging evidence: the human brain remains an elastic organ well into old age. While gray cells die off, if we stay active, both mentally and physically, new cells and even new connections can form. The prerequisite is that we remain in practice – through an education that is designed so that people learn to take care of themselves (also: to plan ahead) and to want and be able to continue learning throughout their lives. Pablo Casals answered the question of why, at 92 years old, he still practices the cello daily: "Because I believe I am making progress." Why do we laugh at that?

This is the optimism with which we should design the society of tomorrow – together, in all friendship between generations. Then, as paradoxical as it may sound, the aging of our society will also be an opportunity and a driving force for social dynamics and change. Let us seize the many opportunities that lie in the "society of long life." Let us make it a "society of good coexistence between young and old." Our ancestors laid the foundation. They worked and hoped for us, just as we now work and hope together for all those who come after us.