Speech by Federal President Horst Köhler on the change of presidency at the Federal Constitutional Court on May 14, 2010, in Karlsruhe:

Germany Horst Köhler · President of Germany

22 May 2010 · Change of presidency of the Federal Constitutional Court (farewell and handover ceremony) · Federal Constitutional Court, Karlsruhe, Germany

Context
Köhler addressed the ceremony marking the change of presidency at the Federal Constitutional Court in Karlsruhe on May 14, 2010, honoring outgoing President Papier and incoming President Voßkuhle.
Main themes
Freedom of assembly, Federal Constitutional Court, Brokdorf ruling, democratic participation, change of court presidency, rule of law, civil protest and democracy, political will formation, nuclear energy debate, judicial legacy of Hans-Jürgen Papier
Duration
~29 min
80th percentile
Words
3,420
80th percentile
Sentences
173
85th percentile
Readability
40
36th percentile
Grade
12.6
52nd percentile
Syntax
2.88
31st percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
35th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 59%53%
  • Economic 17%15%
  • Ceremonial 12%11%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Social 6%6%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 9%

173 sentences in 44 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Voßkuhle, eight weeks ago I handed you the certificate of appointment at Schloss Bellevue. I congratulate you once again on your important, responsible, and beautiful office. I wish you all the best and God's blessing for it.

Dear Mr. Kirchhof, dear Mr. Paulus: You too are facing new duties, challenges, and opportunities. You are also excellently qualified for this. I wish you heartfelt success as well!

Dear Mr. Papier, just a heartbeat before the appointment of the new President of the Federal Constitutional Court, I bid you farewell from this office. You have been a member of the court since 1998 and have been its president since 2002. You have represented the court in public life with dignity and have given it a clear profile. In addition to your judicial work, you have enriched legal and political opinion formation in Germany with many groundbreaking contributions. You have particularly devoted yourself to the question of what holds our society together and have advocated for nurturing and strengthening the foundations for the well-being of our society and our democracy. For this, you have called for changes, both legal and in the attitudes and engagement of citizens for their state. Not always have your proposals received unanimous approval. But you have always asked the right and important questions – this is acknowledged even by those who sometimes have a different opinion on the answers.

For your decades of commitment to the state and society, you deserve the highest respect and our collective gratitude! I wish you a bit more leisure and unbroken creative energy for the new chapter of life that has now begun; and I wish our country that we may continue to count on your advice. Thank you very much.

Are you aware of what decision the Federal Constitutional Court made exactly 25 years ago today? It was the so-called Brokdorf ruling, the court's first fundamental decision on the freedom of assembly.

The background of the decision was an intensification and escalation of the political battle of opinions, which many observers perceived as crisis-like. Hundreds of thousands of citizens opposed the democratically made decision for the peaceful use of nuclear energy at that time. Tens of thousands demonstrated at the construction site of the Brokdorf nuclear power plant. There were violent riots. When a new large demonstration was registered, the authorities imposed a ban on gatherings in an area of about 210 square kilometers. The Federal Constitutional Court partially upheld the constitutional complaints against this, but deemed a more narrowly defined ban on gatherings to be constitutional, and: It expected, with detailed justification, from the demonstrators and the police, instead of provocation and disproportionate reaction, a willingness to cooperate.

The court derived this outcome from the significance of the freedom of assembly and the right to free expression for our free democracy, and it did so with impressive words: "The right to assemble freely and without special permission with others has always been regarded as a sign of freedom, independence, and maturity of the self-aware citizen," states the Brokdorf ruling. Particularly protest assemblies contain "a piece of originally unbridled direct democracy, which is capable of preserving the political process from stagnation in busy routine." And elsewhere – because I liked it so much, I must read it to you: "Large associations, financially strong sponsors, or mass media can exert considerable influence, while the citizen often experiences himself as powerless. In a society where direct access to the media and the opportunity to express oneself through them is limited to a few, the individual has, apart from his organized participation in parties and associations, generally only a collective influence through the exercise of the freedom of assembly for demonstrations. The unhindered exercise of the right to freedom not only counters the awareness of political powerlessness and dangerous tendencies towards disillusionment with the state. It is ultimately also in the well-understood interest of the common good, because a relatively correct resultant in the parallelogram of political will formation can emerge only when all vectors are somewhat strongly developed." End of quote. By the way: The then chairman of the First Senate of the Federal Constitutional Court was Roman Herzog.

The peaceful use of nuclear energy still divides opinions today. This was recently demonstrated by the human chain between the Krümmel and Brunsbüttel power plants with at least 100,000 participants. But even the largest demonstrations have long been part of our democratic everyday life and almost always proceed peacefully, not least thanks to the constructive cooperation of organizers and police. This positive development is certainly also due to the jurisprudence of the Federal Constitutional Court. At the same time, the Brokdorf ruling and its effects provide a good starting point for some reflections on the political culture in Germany.

The Brokdorf decision also faced criticism at the time. It was said to weaken representative democracy and threaten to make violent acts more likely in the end. However, the decision quickly found predominantly support. It was understood by citizens as a well-understood, well-reasoned, well-balanced, and politically sensible connection of common good interests and political citizen rights. The Federal Constitutional Court can look back on a long series of decisions that have been received positively by citizens. This is primarily what underpins the high public esteem of the court and the acceptance of the institution of the Federal Constitutional Court.

And perhaps this high regard is also based on the fact that Germans may have a certain preference for a procedural and decision-making style that they perceive as follows: non-partisan, oriented towards given commandments and prohibitions, relying on arguments rather than on compromise-based give and take, and ultimately resulting in final-instance, unchallengeable decisions.

And one more thing speaks in favor of this assumption: political practice. In political debates and in the competition of societal interests, opposing positions are often formulated as if one were already in Karlsruhe, and often enough they are ultimately carried there. Those who want to achieve something declare the desired outcome as a constitutional mandate, and those who do not get it appeal to the Federal Constitutional Court. With this, a little bit of terrain for independent design is given up each time, a little bit of space for open-ended political dispute and compromise is lost, a little bit of civic and democratic self-determination. At the same time, this development gradually leads to a legalistic approach to politics and a politicization of the legal, which we cannot desire.

To avoid being misunderstood: Justice elevates a people. It is gratifying how legally-minded the Germans are. The Basic Law is an expression of our liberal and democratic self-understanding and the values that should be decisive for our coexistence. At the forefront of this is the principle of the rule of law. Our constitution needs a strong guardian, and the Federal Constitutional Court has proven itself most happily in this role.

But the Federal Constitutional Court is not intended as a substitute for politics. It cannot take away from citizens and their representatives the task of thinking politically, arguing, deciding, and then acting. It does not want to do that at all. Therefore, it is actually an anomaly of democratic politics when the court engages in legal "agenda-setting," perhaps has to do so, as it has already done in not a few decisions. Therefore, it is actually another such anomaly when a minority that has been outvoted in parliament tries to bring its political conception to attention or even to enforcement via Karlsruhe, even though it knows that the relevant majority decision was most likely within the limits of what is constitutionally permissible. And therefore, it is actually an anomaly in the life of our democracy how some citizens no longer discuss, coalition, or demonstrate for their interests and political goals, but rather take out a legal protection insurance or join a "litigation association" and litigate through the instances. That can all be, but I simply want to address it as a problem.

From all of this speaks a certain reluctance towards the democratic and party-political everyday life with its many efforts and towards the debate of opinions that is decided by democratic majority, and not always by one's own. From all of this also speaks that trust in institutions other than the Federal Constitutional Court has declined. Political parties, parliaments, and governments have lost much of their esteem. Many no longer trust them to tackle the really important problems, from local public debt to global measures against global warming, from combating terrorism and organized crime to wisely shaping demographic change. This impression is reinforced by media that almost daily declare a new crisis and prefer to portray politics as a chain of failures and as a den of intrigue. But a pure media phenomenon, the loss of trust is certainly not. Problems are also growing at the so-called grassroots level. In many cities and municipalities, the conditions for local political and civic engagement are suffering because the financial situation is so precarious. And long-familiar institutions like the church and school suddenly have terrible cause for self-examination. Thus, we find doubts and self-doubts in many places.

Overall, a development is emerging that could gradually take on truly crisis-like features. Precisely because Germany – like other nations – faces great challenges, our democratic and societal institutions need the trust, confidence, and active participation of citizens.

Doubt and self-doubt can be productive. However, they must not paralyze, but must be an incentive, an incentive for self-determination and trust-building. What can be said to be encouraging?

I name

four

reasons:

First:

Our everyday life here in Germany is economically, ecologically, politically, and institutionally much more non-crisis than crisis.

For example, our labor market has weathered the global economic downturn of the past two years much better than many experts had feared. The success was the result of trust in businesses and good cooperation between trade unions and employers' associations, of wise political decisions – keyword short-time work regulation – and of financial sacrifices that employees and employers have made together. Everyone can truly be proud of what has been achieved.

Second:

Our political institutions are strong and capable of action. I allow myself, based on my own professional experience, to say: I have encountered many, many countries and democratic institutions. Our political institutions are strong and capable of action!

They have proven this in the face of the global financial crisis, and this should give them confidence and strength at the state, European, and international levels. Democratic politics has the task of protecting our open society and our freedom by setting clear boundaries to the free play of interests and enforcing those boundaries.

This is currently especially necessary for the international financial markets. Here are a few brief remarks: At the end of last week, a tightening of the financial crisis with unforeseeable consequences for the stability of the euro and the European integration project as a whole was emerging. It was right for the heads of state and government of the European Union, together with the International Monetary Fund, to act decisively. The proposed credit authorizations make it clear to the actors in the financial markets: The members of the European Economic and Monetary Union stand together. They have the political will and the economic strength to break speculative waves.

We Germans are neither the "paymasters" nor the "fools" of Europe, as some newspapers claim, but we bear our share of responsibility for Europe in accordance with the size and performance of our economy. We do not forget how important Europe is for our prosperity and how important Europe is for us, for our good future. We do not forget that! In the European internal market, we sell two-thirds of our exports. This is a strong home market in globalization that secures jobs in Germany. We will not give that up. It is therefore in the interest of the people in Germany that our country actively and decisively participates in the precautionary measures against the crisis.

I also have great respect for the decision of the European Central Bank to purchase debt securities from Eurozone countries in this extreme exceptional situation. This also contributes to stabilizing the situation. Yes, this decision was unorthodox and carries risks. But to speak of the inevitability of a weak currency is out of the question. I am convinced that the European Central Bank and its president will continue to follow their stability mandate in full independence. Jean-Claude Trichet is not the man who will abandon his life's work out of opportunism. He personally, and the European Central Bank as an institution, remain guarantors of the stability of our currency. That is my own judgment based on the experience of working with him.

I personally understand and share some of the outrage over the behavior of global financial actors and rating agencies. But I also say just as clearly: That financial actors focused on unilateral profit maximization can now determine the fate of entire nations is clearly also, and even primarily, due to political failures, namely insufficient state regulation of financial markets, excessive public debt, and the previous inability of the member states of the Euro Group to advance the necessary structural reforms for the internal cohesion of the currency union. We can identify the causes of this crisis. That is already worth a lot. The causes of the crisis – I repeat – anarchic financial markets, over-indebted public budgets, and the laxity and confusion of national economic and financial policies – must be put in order. Only then can we break the vicious cycle of ever-increasing financial crises.

For this, we need more Europe on certain issues, not less. I say this here quite deliberately. I advise that we finally actively and constructively participate in the discussions about the goals and procedures for effective coordination of economic and financial policy in the Euro Group. Actively and constructively! And so, Madam Chancellor, I understand what you said yesterday in Aachen on the occasion of the awarding of the Charlemagne Prize to Prime Minister Tusk.

That is all I have to say on the regulatory tasks that now lie ahead in Europe.

Beyond such regulatory tasks, democratic institutions have the right and the ability to set new goals for our coexistence in a timely manner, such as an ecological transformation of our social market economy and the entire way we will live together in the future. They can take on this task, and I am grateful to have more and more the impression: they are doing it!

To prepare the necessary decisions, there must be intensive communication, as much as possible with and in all areas of society, to utilize all the knowledge and creativity that exists in our country. And when decisions are made democratically, there must be communication again, because the ecological transformation, to stick with this example, will only succeed if it is understood and embraced as widely as possible and if it is designed and implemented in a decentralized manner; and this is true for most changes that are truly important and desirable. That is why I wish for intense debates on many topics, like the one on the peaceful use of nuclear energy, and I hope that many of these debates will have their starting point, their peak, and their decision-making center in the German Bundestag and in the state parliaments.

In all of this, it will also be an important goal to promote the normality of change. Political design, economic and social paradigm shifts, and technological progress will continue to bring about constant and perhaps even faster structural change. And we must accept this to some extent in order to preserve what has been achieved. This is no reason to always speak of crisis and catastrophe, as that only leads to desperate worry or unproductive paralysis of fear. Much better is alert calmness: We have already mastered many challenges in Germany with ingenuity, diligence, and flexibility. Let us continue to trust in these virtues! Above all, let us trust in the abilities and willingness to go along with this.

And let us promote the source from which these virtues spring: Our democratic institutions do well to strengthen the life circles from which strength truly flows into our free democracy: the family and religious communities, the education system, cultural life, and the citizens' awareness of their capabilities. Much has already begun in this regard! But: Let us do even more!

All of this requires the same three-step process: analytical consultation, fact-oriented decision-making, and prudent implementation. This is the essence of good politics. There is already much of it. It is even the norm in our parliaments and administrations. But we will need particularly good politics in the coming years to meet the challenges.

And we need it quickly. Bill Clinton liked to play the song "Don’t Stop" as a campaign jingle. Some politicians often take that too literally. They should, on the contrary, finally stop only thinking about the next day. They should also think about the next and the following decade! All free democracies have a sensitive weakness in this regard. In Germany, the next nationwide relevant election is due on average every three and a half months. That is not a horizon for forward-looking political decisions; it must not hinder or delay them. In a rather intelligent American television series about the White House, an advisor says to the president: "I believe Lincoln did what he thought was right, even though it meant the loss of half the country. I believe you" – the advisor says to the president – "are not doing what you think is right if it means losing the electoral votes of Michigan." The problem sounds strangely familiar, don’t you think?

Thirdly:

Good political decisions could significantly strengthen the involvement and participation of citizens in our democratic order and thus its vitality. Unfortunately, there is some truth to the image of spectator democracy. But I am convinced that we can bring the political spectators in our society "back onto the field" if we make the framework conditions for political engagement more attractive. This should start with giving city and municipal councils, for example, more of their own design options as schools of democracy. A perennial topic in our political discussion; but progress is too slow. The dialogue between parties and citizens could be intensified by allowing non-members to influence the formation of electoral lists, and the options for cumulating and panachaging could also shake things up a bit at the federal level. New forms of political opinion formation could be tested outside of parliaments, such as citizen forums and communication platforms on the internet. The position of individual members of parliament could be strengthened – for example, someone who knows that accepting a mandate definitively means leaving their profession and entering financial dependence on re-election may be less likely to take that step. In this context, the often-expressed criticism of the remuneration of members of parliament may point in the wrong direction.

Fourthly:

The Brokdorf decision was not an end, but a beginning. Today, students are demonstrating for more lessons and students for better universities; today, citizens are defending the public space of their cities against political extremists and gathering as a sign of international solidarity, as they did after the attacks of September 11, 2001.

Today, the number of citizens' initiatives is overwhelming; there are countless groups preserving monuments and restoring churches, founding citizen foundations, and providing "Every Child a Musical Instrument," helping in development cooperation, in environmental protection, and advocating that cohesion in Germany does not weaken but strengthen. A new relationship is also emerging between engaged citizens and the state. Where people solve social tasks through their own initiative and civic engagement, politics and authorities should not take their place but support them, give them freedom, and recognize and promote their strength and ideas.

All of this is lived freedom, as our Basic Law desires and as the parents of the Basic Law hoped for from us and from those who come after us. Our free democracy is indeed also, and first and foremost, built on self-aware citizens and on the institutions of their self-organization, as the Federal Constitutional Court emphasized and reaffirmed 25 years ago.

If all these forces of our democracy, both state and societal, are wisely advised, courageously decide, and prudently act, then we will advance Germany well – I am quite confident of that – and relieve the Federal Constitutional Court a little.