Speech by Federal President Horst Köhler on the occasion of the presentation of the Max Weber Prize for Economic Ethics on May 27, 2008, in Berlin:

Germany Horst Köhler · President of Germany

27 May 2008 · Presentation of the Max Weber Prize for Economic Ethics · Berlin, Germany

Context
Köhler addressed a Berlin ceremony on May 27, 2008, presenting the Max Weber Prize for Economic Ethics, reflecting on trust as a foundation of economic and democratic life.
Main themes
Trust as social capital, economic ethics, social market economy, civic virtue and self-discipline, role of business leaders and elites, tax morality, state institutions and rule of law, regulatory frameworks, distribution of economic benefits, democracy and free constitutional state, reputation of managers, Böckenförde dilemma
Duration
~18 min
60th percentile
Words
2,139
60th percentile
Sentences
115
69th percentile
Readability
48
56th percentile
Grade
11.2
35th percentile
Syntax
2.96
43rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
37th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 46%46%
  • Institutional 30%30%
  • Social 21%21%
  • Ceremonial 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

115 sentences in 16 paragraphs

"Foundation of Success: Trust"

"Trust is good, control is better" – says popular wisdom and someone else as well. But is that really true? Each of us can surely think of examples that support this saying. And yet: Fortunately, not everything can be controlled. And no one can want total control. One does not even have to think of the "big brother" from George Orwell's novel. It is already dark enough to consider that comprehensive control requires comprehensive rules to exist first. But those who want to regulate everything end up in bureaucratism, which stifles all spontaneous developments.

Democracy thrives on the existence of something like "civic sense," social norms, moral feeling, measure, and tact. These are virtues that make external control unnecessary because they aim at self-control and self-discipline. Where this civic sense, this self-discipline is lacking, where morality is lost, the free constitutional state is in danger. This dilemma was already pointed out in the 1970s by former judge of the Federal Constitutional Court Ernst-Wolfgang Böckenförde: The free state is existentially dependent on the morality of its citizens; however, it cannot enforce morality without giving up freedom. The rule of law must be able to trust that its citizens adhere to the laws – yes, that they do more than the laws require of them. And the citizens must have trust in the state institutions.

Trust is therefore a valuable asset for a society; social scientists – and also Professor Hüther has mentioned this – therefore speak of social capital. And it is empirically proven: Social capital is important for a stable democracy and also for lasting economic success. It must therefore concern us if social trust is lost. Surveys signal this to us, indicating that not even one in five currently believes that the social market economy functions well – an economic system that has brought great prosperity to us Germans.

What has led to this loss of trust? On the one hand, there is the feeling among many citizens that the upswing is not reaching them and that the economic benefits of the system are not distributed fairly. Personal experiences that wages hardly rise and that little remains from gross to net lead to dissatisfaction. Trust is disturbed that employees and society as a whole will be better off when companies are doing well. This old formula is no longer viewed in the same way. By the way, this is not only a question of the pay slip, but also of the positive role models that exist in a society – or do not exist. Abstract trust in an economic system is ultimately connected to trust in its leading actors. And their reputation has indeed suffered among us. According to a survey, 42 percent of Germans believe that most business leaders are corrupt. This is, of course, nonsense. It may have been due to the way the question was posed; and when asked about personally known entrepreneurs, strong trust values emerge. But the prejudice expressed in the survey is there, and we must deal with it. The behavior of some managers, who are particularly in the public eye due to their position, significantly contributes to the fact that the elite of the economy is no longer perceived as a role model by many today. This raises the question: Is this merely problematic behavior of individuals, or do we also need to consider whether our regulatory system is poorly constructed?

For despite the Böckenförde dilemma, the state is not powerless. Economic ethics teaches that the state can create institutions that, while not guaranteeing moral behavior, can nonetheless provide incentives to prove oneself trustworthy. People behave voluntarily in accordance with the rules when they have the impression that this is advantageous for them in the long term. This includes finding the rules plausible and also fair. And: Citizens only have the important trust in the rule of law when it is taken for granted that the same law applies to all and that one can trust that everyone adheres to the rules of the game or that violations – regardless of the person – will be sanctioned.

Let us consider, for example, tax morality. When public figures give the impression that they believe they are entitled to special rules, one should not be surprised if tax morality declines overall. The results from surveys speak a clear language here: Ten years ago, only 30 percent believed that tax evaders are fraudsters; by 2007, this had dropped to just 22 percent. If a majority in society thinks it is clever to cheat the tax office, then not only are tax revenues lost, but the free constitutional state and our collective trust in the democratic order are also at risk. We must therefore also ask ourselves why our tax system finds so little support among the population.

Do citizens still consider the tax calculation and tax rates, as well as the use of taxes, to be fair and purposeful? Financial scientists primarily cite three characteristics of an efficient tax system: efficiency, simplicity, and transparency. This means that the tax system should hinder the efficient use of economic resources as little as possible. The costs of tax collection should be as low as possible for the state and the citizens – simplicity is therefore also a servant of the yield of taxes, which is often overlooked. And the tax burdens and their distribution should be clearly recognizable to everyone.

Unfortunately, we must note that the German tax system only partially meets these criteria. The numerous deduction and structuring options influence the economic behavior of citizens and distort resource allocation. In our complicated tax system, many can no longer fill out their tax returns without tax experts. Moreover, the complex regulations, the constant changes in tax law, and sometimes highly interpretable legal texts lead to high opacity and legal uncertainty. Some feel encouraged by the numerous structuring options to find and test as many tax-saving opportunities as possible. The tax office becomes the "opponent," and tax saving becomes a "national sport." The incentives for tax avoidance are, of course, greater the higher the tax burden is. In a general decline of tax morality, it eventually becomes just a small step for some from tax avoidance to tax evasion. To be very clear: This step is completely unacceptable. As important as I see the simplification of the tax system, this necessity cannot serve as an excuse for tax evasion. For we should not forget: Tax laws are also democratically legitimized law. They may not please us in detail, but those who see this as a justification for violating them undermine the crucial trust in our rule of law.

Let us return once more to the question of how much control in the economy is necessary, but above all, how much trust is possible. As a means against too much bureaucracy – and thus as a means to strengthen the element of trust in the legal system – voluntary self-commitments have become fashionable – from the self-commitment of the automotive industry to reduce CO2 to numerous codes of conduct in the chemical industry. An important example is the Corporate Governance Code. Some also refer to it as "soft law" because it aligns itself with binding law: Companies can decide which parts of the Corporate Governance Code they want to apply. But once they have made that decision, the law also compels them to adhere to this self-commitment.

The idea of personal responsibility behind self-commitments is commendable, and some have proven to be quite successful – like the recent training pact. However, the results of such self-commitments often turn out to be rather disappointing. This ambivalence is also found in the Corporate Governance Code. The accompanying commission has just submitted its report and concludes that the code has "undoubtedly established itself as the epitome of standards for good corporate governance." Only five recommendations are rejected by more than ten percent of DAX companies.

But what has this high acceptance actually achieved? It has clearly not prevented "all-round care packages" from being granted to executives; and when one looks at the current evaluation of the commission, it is striking that the approval rates for the recommendations are particularly low where genuine behavioral changes are required, for example, regarding managerial liability and the limitation of severance payments. If the code does not stimulate real behavioral changes, then its impact remains modest. It may have initiated a useful debate about good corporate governance, but it has changed little in reality. Perhaps we do need to adjust the legal rules of corporate governance – and this is already being discussed vigorously. But let us not delude ourselves into thinking that there is a corporate law that regulates everything perfectly. Let us remember: Morality cannot be mandated by law.

In essence, many self-commitments and legal regulations would be unnecessary if everyone behaved as trustworthily as the ideal of the honorable merchant suggests. Already in the Middle Ages, merchant handbooks praised the "true and honest merchant." He is characterized by fundamental virtues such as honesty, caution, the safeguarding of business secrets, courage at the right moment, love of peace, seriousness, politeness, wisdom, order, and a good upbringing – that is, an upbringing that imparts not only knowledge but also values. The honorable merchants of the Middle Ages distributed a portion of their profits to the poor and further promoted the development of infrastructure and culture. In the course of the industrial revolution, this ideal may have suffered later. But there have always been honorable merchants who have further developed it. What should today or what could today belong to the principles of the honorable merchant? I believe that definitely includes a pronounced sense of responsibility, long-term thinking, and a focus on the goal of sustainability. Above all, it is about the leaders in companies defining for themselves what makes an honorable merchant, that they participate in the societal value discussion. This is actually almost the most important thing to me: They should show their colors. They should not shy away from dialogue, but rather fight for the acceptance of the social market economy. This can only succeed if they show that they take seriously what burdens society and if they exemplify that decency and honesty are prerequisites for creating sustainable values.

The primary task of companies is and remains, of course, to satisfy the needs of their customers with their products and services. To do this sustainably, they must invest and generate profits. And for that, they need trust, the trust of their employees in the company and its leadership, the trust of business partners, and the trust of customers in their services. And trust is built through virtues such as truthfulness, moderation, and courage. These virtues must be learned and lived, for example, through a credible appearance both internally and externally, through a culture of moderation and role modeling in managerial salaries, as well as in pricing in markets with low competitive pressure, through courage for innovation and investment in new things. Those who take great risks and bear much responsibility and succeed should also be able to gain much. I consider legal caps on salaries to be the wrong approach. For they are unlikely to do justice to the varying interplay between risk and profit. Rather, it is about sharpening the problem awareness among those who are to be role models – and I add: also must be – and strengthening the supervisory bodies. These should then intervene when there is a lack of a culture of moderation and role modeling. I know that excess is not the rule, but when exceptions occur precisely where the public is particularly attentive, it has consequences far beyond the individual cases. Then the impression arises: "The managers" or "the entrepreneurs" are stuffing their pockets. And one should not be surprised if the image of the social market economy becomes a distorted one for many.

Our economy is supported by the many companies that, away from the spotlight and stock market news, are extraordinarily successful – indeed, leading – in the global market. Fortunately, that is the foundation. Is it a coincidence that many of these successful entrepreneurs, long before the term "Corporate Social Responsibility" became fashionable, viewed social responsibility as an inherent part of their work? Probably not. There were also entrepreneurs who publicly stated: "Leadership means serving." A saying from Mr. Merkle. Thus, these entrepreneurs likely understood early on that moral behavior is beneficial to a company's reputation and that it is part of lasting, sustainable corporate value.

Once again: Trust is important. Those who squander trust will find it difficult. Let me say, please: Earn trust. And above all: Do not gamble with it. It is worth it – not only for companies but for all of us! Thank you!