Full speech of President Javier Milei upon receiving the Prize of the Liberal Institute of the Czech Republic in Prague

Argentina Javier Milei · President of Argentina

24 June 2024 · Prize of the Liberal Institute of the Czech Republic · Prague, Czechia

Context
Milei delivered a speech at a liberty-oriented forum in June 2024, recounting his intellectual evolution toward liberalism and arguing for political engagement to defeat socialism.
Main themes
Libertarianism and political action, fight against socialism and statism, economic history and the hockey stick of growth, personal intellectual journey, liberalism vs Keynesianism, Austrian economics, Ludwig von Mises, cultural battle of ideas, neoclassical economics critique, capitalism and poverty reduction
Duration
~35 min
87th percentile
Words
4,169
87th percentile
Sentences
142
79th percentile
Readability
47
55th percentile
Grade
13.8
65th percentile
Syntax
3.44
92nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
36th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 82%76%
  • Institutional 7%6%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Social 5%4%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

142 sentences in 30 paragraphs

First of all, I would like to thank you for this recognition of the work we are doing in the fight for the ideas of freedom. And here I will share a small anecdote related to my relationship with liberalism. If you go to see a soccer match in Argentina, you will see the stands filled with people, very cheerful, with many colors, very colorful, very picturesque, and even with chants, a true spectacle in itself. But no matter how beautiful the stands are and how they look, and all the encouragement they provide, you place the ball in the center of the field, and if Messi does not come in to kick the ball, the ball does not move.

Why do I say this? Because the cultural battle, the discussion of ideas is very important, what one does in the academic field is very important. But without political action, you don't get anywhere. Because if we return to the soccer metaphor: they do kick, they do go for the goal, they keep scoring goals and they don't care. So the only real way to stop the advance of socialism, statism, collectivism, constructivism, the only way is to stand in front of them and give them the battle, not only in the cultural arena but also in the political arena.

In that sense, I can share what my experience is, because without a doubt all the background accumulated in academic terms is an extremely important guide for decision-making. I would almost say it is fundamental because it determines the north and basically what guides each measure taken. So, for that reason, I want to tell you two things: how I became a liberal, in a very concise version, and how I am carrying it out. In reality, my foundational training is as an economist, in my case, as in the vast majority of economists, and that arises throughout the country, there is no mention of liberal economists during the course. In fact, I often say that if a graduate economist in Argentina is asked who Ludwig von Mises is, he will say he thinks he is the number 9 of the Netherlands national team.

In that sense, I received a training typical of what is called a post-Keynesian, which would be a Keynesian with Marxist overtones; then I shifted to Fordist Keynesianism; then I shifted to the Keynesians of disequilibrium; then to the neoclassical Keynesians; then given all my mathematical background and in neoclassical economics, I became an accentuated neoclassical; then I ended up radicalizing in that situation and aligned myself with the real business cycle school, that is, with the school of real cycles. And when the subprime crisis appeared, 2007, 2008, and the global imbalance in the face of the possibility of a new catastrophe on the planet, I returned to refuge and to the reading of Keynes and Friedman. Therefore, in the face of that frustration I had with economic analysis, I decided to dedicate myself to issues of economic growth because I said: "Well, I will deal with long-term issues and, who knows, in 50 years if I was right or not."

So, I was happy, content with all the literature on growth, until I was invited by the World Economic Forum to give a presentation. Not the last one so flashy, but one on demography and growth. There I encountered the works of Angus Maddison and there I faced a very strong new shock. It was the issue of what in growth theory is called in empirical evidence the "hockey stick," that is, when you take Angus Maddison's series from the year zero of the Christian era to the year 2000, you will see that GDP per capita has the shape of a hockey stick: it is practically constant until the year 1800 and, from there, it takes a very impressive rise.

In fact, in the stretch from year zero to 1800, GDP per capita only grows by 40%, and that only occurs after the discovery of America in the 16th century. This implied that the world only grew at a rate of 0.02% per year, that is, it took 3,500 years to double GDP per capita. The other thing you see is that from the year 1800 to the year 2000, GDP per capita multiplies nine times, but in a context where the population almost multiplies by eight times. That is to say, in those 200 years, GDP multiplies by approximately 72 times. Why is this important? Because the amount of work in the economy is increasing strongly, and yet, the product grows more than proportionally.

That is to say, the postulate of diminishing marginal returns does not hold. And a problem arises that in neoclassical economics is called non-convexity, non-convexity, which is a problem of a mathematical nature that is actually associated with concentrated market structures. And the interesting thing is that when you study microeconomics and look at concentrated market structures, that is, I give you the most violent case, let's say the most extreme, which is monopoly, according to neoclassical theory monopolies are bad. And there arise two questions: because when you look at 1800 the number of people living in extreme poverty, that is, with less than one dollar a day was more than 95% of the population, and when you looked at it in the year 2000, that number had fallen to less than 15%. So, in addition, the levels of quality of life had multiplied phenomenally. So, the question is: how can something that has been so virtuous for humanity in terms of well-being and in terms of poverty reduction, something so wonderful, could be that economic theory, supposedly good economic theory, said that this was bad? That situation disturbed me a lot and it ultimately led me to something wonderful, which was to come across an article by Murray Newton Rothbard called "Monopoly and Competition."

I remember that when I received that article, a 140-page article, I went out to lunch at work and, well, I extended it. After three hours, when I finished reading the article, I said: "Everything I taught about market structure over the last 25 years is wrong." There I converted to the Austrian school. It is very interesting what Rothbard points out in that article because the first thing one has to consider is that the approach of the neoclassical economy structure in terms of monopolies, the first mistake it makes is what Hazlitt says about the difference between a good economist and a bad economist, they are one-period and one-good structures. That is, they ignore the effects of general equilibrium, what happens in the rest of the markets, and they also ignore timelessness.

Therefore, that already shows that the analysis was flawed, that the analysis was incorrect, that the analysis had serious problems. Not only that, but it also ignored the possibility of substitution. To put it another way, I can have the monopoly of producing Ferraris, let's say I am Fiat, so I can have the monopoly of producing Ferraris, but that does not mean that I do not have competition against a McLaren, or against a Maserati, or a Lamborghini. Therefore, that already showed that there were some problems. And, on the other hand, it was also not true that the monopoly had to be bad, because in fact the original definition of monopoly that corresponds to the orco Coke and is where Adam Smith took it from, defined monopoly as that place where the Monarch or the prince, or the feudal lord, or whoever was the representative of the State, determined that in the place where he ruled only one company could sell a certain product. That is to say, but if that was violated, he would come down with all the force of the law and that could imply anything from sending him to jail or sending him to the beyond. In that context, what became clear is that then the monopoly is bad when it is a monopoly imposed by the State, not when there is a single supplier. When there is a single supplier, in fact, Mises himself says: get angry with the other entrepreneurs who are not offering the product, not with the only one who is offering it.

I always exemplify this with a case where let’s suppose I have a situation where I have 10 companies offering cell phones and now a company appears that generates a new cell phone that is of better quality at a better price, naturally the other nine companies will go bankrupt. And that is not bad at all, it is part of the dynamics of capitalism.

That is to say, bankruptcies are part of capitalism, they are part of the process. Someone appears who is more efficient and goes bankrupt, and in that sense, there is a huge gain in well-being. Because now you have a better phone, which is of better quality, and you paid less money for it, and that money you saved can now be used for other things. Therefore, in addition, you have a gain in well-being because now you consume more of other goods. But, on the other hand, it is also questioned that the monopolist makes money. And what is the problem with him making money if, deep down, he is a social benefactor? He is making money because he is solving a problem for people.

And, in that sense, what can he do with all that money he is making? Well, one of the things he can do is spend it, consume it, therefore, he generates jobs and better living conditions based on where he is spending it elsewhere. Okay, now he does not consume it, now he saves it: well, if he saves it, that will finance investment, so it will generate new jobs in other places in the economy and allow the economy to continue growing, therefore, again he is doing good for everyone. The other is that he reinvests in his own company, but if he reinvests in his own company, he will increase the supply even more. Therefore, he will have to offer even better quality goods at better prices, surpassing himself.

And, finally, let’s suppose he is a tyrant and wants to ruin people's lives. Then he will not do any of that and will take all that money he earned and bury it in the ground. Well, he reduces the amount of money in the economy, the price level is lower and distributes well-being for all with lower prices. Ultimately, when the monopoly arises from these characteristics, it would be incorrect to label it as a monopoly or to look for the problem of non-convexities. But that problem in economics exists, because after the enormous damage caused by the emergence of Keynes's general theory and with all the disassembled economic analysis, and with the need to reassemble the system of thinking about the economy as a consequence of the destruction that Keynesianism had caused, you could choose between the line that came from the Austrian school, but which had been defeated by the Great Depression, not because it was the fault of the Austrian school but because of how those who interpreted what happened interpreted it. And, on the other hand, you had the line of Walras.

So, more work was done in that line of mathematical economics where from the work of Wald, which was already at the beginning of the 20th century, economists like McKenzie, Arrow, Debreu, Jan appeared, where they basically resumed that way of thinking from the arrival of Brouwer's and Kakutani's fixed point theorems. The reality is that the discussion of equilibrium was a discussion about the existence of uniqueness and stability. And the problem starts when the normative problem, the analysis of well-being, is inserted into the analysis, that is, when Pareto is brought into the mix. And when it comes to choosing for optimality, you find yourself in the dilemma of choosing between Adam Smith's pin factory, which are increasing returns and the idea of the invisible hand.

So, in the construction as it is posed in neoclassical theory, that is a dilemma. And to retain the properties of well-being, economists cleaned out increasing returns, went to production functions with diminishing marginal returns or constant returns to scale, and in that way managed to maintain the idea of the invisible hand as a situation of optimality, where everyone maximizing their utility, and firms maximizing profits, that leads to a situation of maximization of well-being. But, among other things, by killing increasing returns, they killed economic growth, and neoclassical theory could not explain economic growth.

Consequently, it had to systematically resort to patches to be able to explain economic growth.

I would almost say that the situation of economic analysis on these issues is quite funny and frustrating, because when Robert Solow tests a model with a neoclassical production function, the model developed in 1956 in parallel with Trevor Swan, and in 1957 he tests it, the situation is very frustrating because he only manages to explain 15%, and everything else was residual. In Solow, the way everything was fixed was with exogenous factors determined by hand. Therefore, everything he had to explain the theory, he explained by hand. That debate was settled by the mid to late 80s, with Mankiw and David Romer and Weil, who basically empirically tested a hypothesis raised by Robert Lucas Jr., which in turn was inspired by something that Uzawa had done in the early 70s, driven by George Stigler, who was the head of the economics department at Chicago, when he told Solow that the problem was that he had not included human capital. There, two lines of analysis develop: one, the microeconomic, which is that of Gary Becker, and I feel deeply proud because Gary Becker is on the list.

In fact, when I lived in my old house, in the center of the living room, I had a painting one and a half meters by one meter of Gary Becker making the deduction of the intertemporal Slutsky equation. So just imagine what it represents for me, an active follower of Gary Becker, to have seen his name on that plaque. And poor Gary Becker endured in the living room of my house until my beloved four-legged son, Conan, was joined by Murray, Milton, Robert, and Lucas. I had to tear down the walls and make some renovations, and there was no longer room for the painting. But beyond that, basically, literature was corrected in that way, and literature continues to have a correction that, from my point of view, is not the best. Probably the one who has best interpreted these kinds of issues is Paul Romer, who has won the Nobel Prize in Economics and who has been able to better capture the ideas of Adam Smith and Schumpeter to explain economic growth. This idea that each company, with the idea of creative destruction, creates its own monopoly and is constantly trying to capture increasing returns. They make innovations and this process is generated that Schumpeter described as creative destruction, and it is what allows us to see strong growth.

These kinds of issues are obviously important, I would almost say they are core. To the point that with my chief advisor, Dr. Demian Reidel, we are rewriting a large part of economic theory, in order to derive Pareto optimality, both static and intertemporal, having non-convex production functions. That is to say, if it turns out well for us, I will probably be awarded the Nobel Prize in Economics along with Demian. But that is part of another story, because it would correct this problem, it would eliminate the conflict between the pin factory and the invisible hand.

And this is interesting and, moreover, libertarian liberal, in a country where until recently the ideas of the left dominated, until in December 56% said they wanted a change in favor of Freedom. And, in that sense, it is impressive, because Argentina, which at the end of the 19th century was among the richest countries on the planet; by the time we came to power, Argentina was ranked 140th, with over 50% of the population living in poverty, in a situation where Argentina produces food for 400 million human beings, with a fiscal pressure in the sector that produces food of 70%, meaning that the State takes the food from 280 million human beings in Argentina and 5 million people who cannot afford to eat. Furthermore, with inflation accelerating, by the time we arrived in the first week of December, prices were rising at 1% daily, which is equivalent to 3700% annually. In the second week, it had accelerated and began to rise at 7500% annually. By the time we were in power, the wholesale inflation for the month was 54%, which annualized gives 17,000% annually. In that context, we came to power. There is no need to cry or complain, or anything, because under normal conditions of pressure and temperature, people are not going to choose a libertarian liberal president.

What is interesting is that it then becomes very clear that Argentina has two very clear economic problems: that is, the problem of not growing, in fact, in the last 10 years, GDP per capita fell by 15% and inflation was absolutely out of control. So, it was clear that it needed a specialist in growth and money. Well, the people were not mistaken, 56% chose the specialist in growth and money, which is my case. And in that sense, that conversion I made to liberalism when I read Rothbard and read Mises, and read Hayek, Walter Block, Alberto Benegas Lynch (Hijo), Hans-Hermann Hoppe, Jesús Huerta de Soto, Miguel Anxo Bastos, and so many other giants of the ideas of Freedom.

It became a determining element at the time of doing politics as well, because not only does the Austrian school of economics have the part linked to economic analysis, but it also includes making a whole proposal about freedom, and a proposal about the ethics and morality of freedom. That is why, for us, it is always very useful when we face a problem, that we always start from the definition of liberalism. So, I usually use the definition of Alberto Benegas Lynch (Hijo), which says: "Liberalism is the strict respect for the life project of others based on the principle of non-aggression, in defense of the right to life, liberty, and property, whose institutions are private property, free markets free from state intervention, free competition understood in the sense of Adam Smith or in the sense of William Baumol, with the idea of contestable markets, the division of labor, and social cooperation, and where one can only be successful by serving others with better quality goods or better prices."

In that context, it is a very strong guide for the design of policy. If you look for my speeches in the Chamber of Deputies, one of the things you will see is that I have always expressed myself against the fiscal deficit, and the main criticism of the fiscal deficit is that, above all, it is immoral. The fiscal deficit is immoral. Because if you have a fiscal deficit, you have to finance it and one brutal way, and one of the worst and most immoral, is to use debt, borrowing. Why? Because debt is future taxes, meaning that today’s party of the present generations is passing the cost onto future generations, to our children, those who do not vote, to our grandchildren, and even to people who have not yet been born.

Something truly immoral, an aberration, in fact, Argentina has frequently used that mechanism. Argentina is the largest serial debtor in modern history, which is also an aberration because it implies violating the property rights of those who decided to finance the party. In other words, we are so irresponsible that we go to a party, we borrow money, and then we don’t even end up paying it back. It is the worst of worlds. The other case is that, when financing runs out, politics uses monetary issuance.

In that sense, Argentina since the creation of the Central Bank has removed 13 zeros from the currency, destroyed five monetary signs, had two hyperinflations without war, today we could remove three more zeros from the currency, we were on the brink of hyperinflation, which I also tell you we have defeated, we are defeating. Because although the wholesale inflation of the last month was 3.5% and that annualized gives 50, remember that we come from 17,000 and in the last week the inflation of food and beverages was 0%. That is to say, something that had not been achieved for 30 years; therefore, we are also now defeating inflation because inflation is a tax, it is an unlegislated tax. Therefore, it is absolutely immoral, because it also punishes the least well-off more severely, which makes it absolutely regressive and, as if that were not enough, it also distorts the functioning of the price system and, therefore, penalizes growth, that is to say, it is a machine for impoverishing. And we are also strongly attacking the fiscal deficit and monetary issuance.

And finally, another way that the treasury has to finance itself is by raising taxes, and when you raise taxes it is an attack on property. In fact, if you take it to the limit, if taxes are 100%, we are directly in slavery. So, there is also another issue in terms of freedom and that the larger the State, the less free one is. In that sense, note that when we came to power we had a fiscal deficit of 15 points of GDP, 5 in the Treasury and 10 in the Central Bank. Our campaign proposal was a chainsaw and they said we were crazy, that it could not be done, that with luck we could adjust one point of GDP and that the Central Bank issue would fix itself.

The reality is that we made a fiscal adjustment in the first month of management and reached zero deficit in financial terms. We ended up making an adjustment of seven points of GDP in the Treasury and now we are starting to restore allocations and we have made an adjustment of six points of GDP. On the other hand, the quasi-fiscal deficit of the Central Bank, which was 10 points of GDP, we have reduced by nine points. That is to say, that in 6 months of government we made the largest fiscal adjustment not only in Argentine history but we have also made the largest fiscal adjustment in the history of humanity. We are returning 15 points of GDP to the private sector.

Therefore, Argentina has the potential to grow due to the very dynamics of the rebound after making a strong adjustment and stabilizing, it has the potential to grow because it is an economy that, after 20 years, was very de-capitalized and the returns are very high, which allows for growth even with the institutions we have. The fact of contributing 15 points of savings will allow for an investment boom and, therefore, there will be economic growth. On top of that, as if all this were not enough, we embarked on a program of structural reforms that already has the approval of the Chamber of Deputies and the Senate, and now it has returned to the Deputies for the final version, plus a DNU. In total, there are 800 structural reforms.

Think that the largest structural reform that had been made in Argentina was in the 90s, during Menem's government, which made about 100. So, in less than six months we sent eight times more structural reforms than the maximum case of reforms in Argentina. This will allow us to move up 90 places in the economic freedom ranking and that we can resemble countries like Germany, France, Italy. However, our program does not end there: we still have 3200 more structural reforms pending, we are thinking of becoming the freest country in the world and, therefore, we are aiming for the long term to be the richest country in the world and, above all, for convergence to accelerate through the use of artificial intelligence.

Therefore, hand in hand with the ideas of freedom and technological progress but, above all, with the ideas of freedom, of free markets, of respect for private property, of respect for life, with these moral values, Argentina will emerge from its dark present to become the brightest case in the history of humanity to be rich again, and all thanks to the ideas of freedom, alongside Rothbard, Mises, alongside Hayek and all those thinkers who not only fought in academia for the ideas of freedom, but many of them even did so on the battlefield. Thank you very much and long live freedom!