Words of President Javier Milei at the Stock Exchange

Argentina Javier Milei · President of Argentina

10 July 2024 · Stock Exchange

Context
Milei addressed the Buenos Aires Stock Exchange in July 2024, delivering a technical lecture on money, prices, and exchange rate policy to explain his government's economic program.
Main themes
Monetary theory, inflation and price levels, exchange rate policy, general equilibrium theory, Argentine economic reform, fiscal and monetary policy, Keynesianism critique, economic stabilization, role of the economy minister, macroeconomic foundations
Duration
~68 min
97th percentile
Words
8,211
97th percentile
Sentences
356
96th percentile
Readability
60
87th percentile
Grade
10.6
27th percentile
Syntax
3.21
74th percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
18th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 84%80%
  • Institutional 6%5%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Ceremonial 4%3%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

356 sentences in 51 paragraphs

Good afternoon. First of all, I would like to thank the Stock Exchange, especially its president Adelmo Gabbi for inviting me and for his tremendous words. I must inform you that the speech will not be as entertaining as the one the other day; I will be giving a technical speech, as this is a different platform. I also want to thank my dear Claudio Zuchovicki, who was the one who made the arrangements for me to be here. So, it is a great pleasure for me to be giving this talk.

The talk is titled ‘Money, Prices, and Exchange Rate,’ but it could also be called ‘Issuance, Inflation, and Devaluation.’ The talk is divided into two parts: there is a theoretical introduction that I believe is worth making, in light of the poor quality of the domestic debate, where I am daily surprised by the shortcomings and failings of our economics professionals. This means that one has to deal, in some cases, with ignorance and in other cases with exaggerated egos that cannot accept that they are wrong.

In that sense, the theoretical introduction will be very useful for understanding what comes in part 2, which is what we are doing, that is, knowing why we are doing what we are doing. Ultimately, what this will end up demonstrating is that Minister Luis Caputo is the best Minister of Economy in all of Argentine history, and that what he is doing alongside Pablo Quirno and Santiago Bausili is an enormous, monumental task, and only history will be able to account for the fabulous work they are doing, and I have the privilege of being the President who has the privilege of having them doing this work. Therefore, today I will put on my economist's suit again and I will try to give my explanation of what is happening and how we will end up getting out of this. So, it will not be as attractive as the speech in Tucumán.

The first thing to understand is the way in which we economists construct economic theory, because it is what we later have to use as a toolbox to apply and to make the decisions we make. So, the first thing to understand is what the logic of what is called general equilibrium is. General equilibrium is the same field of application as macroeconomics, but with micro foundations. In fact, today all modern macroeconomics has almost completely cleaned itself of all that dirt, mud, and plagues that Keynesianism entailed. But well, that happens in other places, not here, so we continue discussing, I don’t know, the squaring of the circle, hot ice cream, things that we have… quite complicated.

When one poses the question of general equilibrium, one basically asks three questions: that is, whether equilibrium exists, whether it is unique, and whether it is stable. The construction of that equilibrium arises from the excess demand functions and seeks to find whether there exists a price vector that leaves all the excess demand functions at zero, that is, that all markets are in equilibrium simultaneously. And that is constructed from the demand functions of each of the goods in the economy, from each of the factors of the economy by individuals and by firms. Moreover, the firm is a property of individuals. And those demand and supply functions have a basic characteristic that they are homogeneous of degree zero, that is, being homogeneous of degree zero means that it depends on relative prices. Furthermore, if one looks at this, those excess demand functions, which are composed of the demand functions minus the supply functions for each of the markets, are functions that describe that for each price you give, it responds with a quantity.

But that is not enough to solve the problem, because I can throw a price vector and it will return a quantity vector, and it may be that this quantity vector is not in equilibrium. So, economists created a fiction called the Walrasian auctioneer, which states that when demand exceeds supply, prices rise, and in the opposite case, prices fall. That is, if you look at it, it is a function that gives that when you throw a price, it now responds with a quantity or from the quantity it responds with a price, to put it correctly. In that sense, in general equilibrium, we also construct a composite function between these excess demand functions and Walras's law and the Walrasian auctioneer, and that, if it applies in a set that is convex, closed, and bounded, and the excess demand functions are continuous, then one can apply Brouwer's fixed-point theorem and thus equilibrium exists. Moreover, since we are working with functions that are point-to-point applications, the disequilibrium is unique. And if we assume that direct effects outweigh cross effects, moreover, equilibrium is stable. That is, those are the conditions under which one constructs a model whose solution exists, is unique, and is stable.

Now, the first thing we need to be clear about is this framework with which we work and it is the framework where we think, and how we design economic policy. I want to tell you that the vast majority of economists do not know these things because it involves knowledge of topology that they do not have. So, that is why we end up discussing things that are truly nonsensical because there is a serious deficit in training.

Now, the other problem is that if I have the characteristics of this system, which is homogeneous of degree zero, the one that resolves in relative prices, means that this system of equations does not give me prices for all goods; it will give me prices for all goods except one. In fact, Walras's law states that if n minus one market is in equilibrium, the remaining one is also in equilibrium; therefore, it is a redundant equation; thus, I will not be able to solve for n prices, but I will be able to solve for N minus one price. So, that is where the issue of what is called the numeraire appears, and the numeraire is a good that serves as money and that, basically, is in which you determine the rest of the prices. So that the system can find a solution, and fundamentally what is behind that are also the characteristics of what would be a barter economy. Now, the problem of the barter economy is twofold, basically: one is what is called the double coincidence problem, that is, I left, for example, I want to sell something to someone, but I have to ensure that another person wants to buy what I have and he also has what I need. Which in a large society is quite a complex problem.

And even when technology could solve that situation for me, I also have another problem, which is indivisibility. Because it may be that I do want to buy bread, the baker may want economics talks, but the problem is how many kilos of bread he is going to give me; I do not need and do not want that many kilos of bread. I assume that my conferences will be a little more expensive, especially after we have pulled Argentina forward. In that sense, you know that I am strongly committed to that because I renounced my privileged retirement. So I better do things right, because otherwise, it will go badly for me after the presidency.

So, individuals did not start crying; they take action and in the face of the problem, what do they do? They try to find a solution. And this is important because this is what begins to show what money is, and that is what will allow us to understand the logic of how to end inflation, the logic of the program we are doing, which is to understand what the nature of money is.

In this sense, money comes to solve these two problems. Ultimately, money is nothing more than a good of indirect exchange, that is, I do not demand money to take it to the wooden suit; I demand money to buy other goods, to facilitate exchanges. So, when man found out how he could solve this problem, one of the things he discovered was that there were some goods that were exchanged much more than others. So, what he did was buy those goods that were exchanged more, not because he wanted that good precisely, but because it served him indirectly to acquire the rest of the goods.

Thus, the first forms of money appeared. For example, when man was nomadic, what was the first type of money he used? Livestock. Why basically? Because he traveled with livestock and since livestock was something that everyone wanted, it served him for exchange. Whether he wanted livestock itself or whether he wanted other goods and could use livestock as an indirect means of exchange. If you look at it, that already represents a form of money, which is commodity money. Naturally, later man evolved, became sedentary. So, for example, something that he consumed a lot was bread, so naturally the currency transformed into what? Into wheat. Why? Because it was the way to make indirect exchanges; it was the way that allowed transactions to be achieved, or so it was with salt, with linen, with tobacco.

Now, if you look at it, now, by doing that you find that you already have a unit of account. That is, you will set those prices in that unit, whether it be livestock, wheat, salt, linen, or tobacco. It is a generalized means of payment because given the customs of the place, it can be used; that is, it is generalized and accepted. But it has a problem, which is that it does not operate as a store of value. Any of the goods we have just mentioned has the characteristic that it depreciates over time or, in other words, has a negative interest rate. For example, a good with a negative interest rate is ice cream: you go, buy the ice cream, and if you do not eat it, it melts. Well, these goods degraded over time.

That is why I always like to talk about the series Zorro when I discuss these topics; with all the years it has been aired, I imagine that 90% of us here have seen Zorro. Zorro is truly a hero; he is a true hero; Zorro is an anarcho-capitalist, he is a market anarchist and is obviously demonized. And surely if the media were in the hands of Captain Monasterio, he would be a terrible criminal. But Zorro was fabulous. Why is Zorro fabulous? Because in Zorro there is no paper money. So, when someone came from the port and came to trade, he evidently not only brought goods but also what? Gold. It was as if he had a label on his head that said ‘I have gold.’ So what happens, it was like a penalty without a goalkeeper, because for the criminals that was easy; they knew that there was gold there. So it is interesting because Zorro, what did he do? He fought against those criminals. And why is it also interesting that he fought against those criminals? Because if the criminals had been successful, the trade in the city would have fallen; and if trade had fallen, the quality of life would have deteriorated phenomenally. So, in which case Zorro defended not only private property but also defended the well-being of those who lived in the city because he basically protected them. Moreover, not only that, but he also fought with Captain Monasterio and the others, who also what did they do? They charged taxes. A total hero, that is, a fabulous character.

Now, to avoid this problem, which is not a new problem and that happened before paper money was created. So, they said, well, let’s fix this, and what did they do? There were institutions where you deposited gold or silver and in exchange, they gave you a paper, and then you exchanged those papers and thus made transactions. Up to that point, the story is quite nice, until there were a couple of revolts where some issued more little papers than they were entitled to; in a market process, they would have been inflated and the problem would have ended, but when lynching appeared, the State appeared, whatever form it took when all this appeared, and what did it do? It appropriated that and then, fundamentally, it appropriated the little machine to print bills, and as it lost value, what did it do? It imposed forced currency, and at the moment they imposed forced currency, so that you could not substitute coins, they forced you to demand the domestic currency and, therefore, expanded the base of the inflationary tax to rob you. Let’s say, a story quite well known in the Argentine case since that nefarious institution was created at Reconquista 266 called the Central Bank of the Argentine Republic. So, as you can see, not now, but I still have my sights set on it.

So, now, what is the point? The point is that if I now understand the nature of how money is created, first it solves a very interesting problem for me, because now, what am I going to use as a unit of account? I am going to use money as a unit of account. By using money as a unit of account, I will now be able to solve the system of equations of the general equilibrium model, all in terms of the prices of goods, in terms of monetary units, that is to say, the first thing it allows me is that you do not have to be looking at relative prices strictly, but you will be looking at prices determined in the domestic currency, that is, in pesos. That is to say, in terms of information management, it is a considerable saving. Imagine if for every item you were going to buy you had to do all the calculations all the time, it would be quite a lot. I think we would spend more time doing the calculations than. Likewise, we would surely find the calculator that would solve it, I mean, men do not stay still and we do not need the State to fix our problems.

That said, put this way and knowing that money is a good of indirect exchange, that means that the demand for money is a derived demand, that is, it is a mirror demand of what happens on the real side of the system, with the demand for goods. Therefore, if it is a mirror demand, if it is a derived demand that only exists for the purpose of implementing my present and future consumption plans, that is, my intertemporal consumption path, therefore, the demand for money will ultimately depend on the consumption path. And the consumption path in intertemporal terms depends on what Robert Lucas Jr.—may he rest in peace—called the deep parameters, that is, it depends on preferences, it depends on technology, and it depends on endowments. Which, unless they are omniscient, omnipresent, and omnipotent, they do not know, and for us, it is given. Therefore, under normal conditions, if the Central Bank were not printing little bills, throwing a party, and ruining people's lives, the demand for money would concretely have to be an absolutely granite function. Because it depends on deep parameters that are given for each of us. Therefore, there would be no reason for the Central Bank to exist, because ultimately that depends on our preferences. In fact, money is a private invention, it is not even an invention that the State invented, that is to say, the State appropriated it, which is another thing.

So, in that context, if the real demand for money is given, monetary equilibrium means that real balances must balance with the real demand for money. That is to say, that the nominal amount of money divided by the price level must be equal to the real demand for money. And now what do we find ourselves with: with the monetary nature of inflation, because if the real supply of money must be equal to the real demand for money and the real demand for money depends on the intertemporal consumption path, which in turn depends on deep parameters that are given, consequently, the monetary nature of inflation appears. Because to the extent that I modify the amount of money, what I will be doing is modifying the price level.

So there we will find this phrase that Milton Friedman used, that inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon. And the only thing the Central Bank can do is determine the nominal scale of the economy, and the price level will be determined by what? By the ratio between the money supply, which is what the Central Bank controls, against the demand for money that you determine.

Therefore, the only thing the Central Bank does when it modifies the amount of money is modify the price level. Hence the monetary nature of inflation. That is to say, what multicausal inflation? There is no multicausal inflation. That is to say, it will call multicausal the different nonsense for which a Central Bank issues, because the rest is pure nonsense. Moreover, do you want to identify bad economists? I will tell you, ask them to write the demand for money function. If the economist writes a demand for money function that does not depend on consumption and depends on income and the interest rate, I tell you, they are a fool.

I will explain to you why, why are they a fool if they include income? Because in a general equilibrium model, if they truly do general equilibrium as they say they do, if they do Keynesian nonsense, that is another problem. I mean, there you can call Copperfield and have him write all the functions you want. You do not know how creative I can be to put functions if you want or functions of whatever you want. But in a general equilibrium system, your incomes are determined by the value of your endowments that you sell in the market, for example, the leisure you provide in the market, and to that, you would have to add what? The share you have in the profits. Putting income in the demand for money function is one of the many brutalities that Keynes made. That Keynes was not an economist, that he only took an economics course with Marshall, who was the champion of partial equilibrium. So, when you construct a partial equilibrium demand function, you can include income. But you cannot do that in general equilibrium, because income is determined as part of the system. Therefore, you cannot do that, and why did he do it? He did it to derive the multiplier, and the multiplier is nothing more than the violation of the budget constraint. That is why it is funny, I mean, when you have a Keynesian who is going to want to create a fiscal deficit. It is magic. Of course, it violates the budget constraint.

So, there you already know, that if they included income, it does not work. And the other thing that is also another nonsense is to include the interest rate, because the interest rate is the relative price of present goods with respect to future goods. I mean, why does saving increase when the interest rate rises? Because present goods become more expensive relative to future goods. So what do they do? They consume less today to consume more tomorrow. But that is an indirect mechanism. And why does investment increase when the interest rate falls? Because future goods are more expensive than present goods. So you have the incentive to shift production from the present to the future, and there you determine between saving and investment, the Vickselian interest rate, the natural interest rate. But, in reality, those are the relative prices of present goods with respect to future goods. Moreover, the economy will be in intertemporal equilibrium when that relative price in each of the present goods with respect to the future is all equal, and there you will achieve equilibrium. If not, you will be able to make arbitrages, both present and intertemporal. Therefore, when you see economists putting those functions, ask them if they are truly doing general equilibrium, because if they say yes, they are lying. And that is wrong in many textbooks as well.

So, when you take the general equilibrium functions, they only depend on prices. Why? Because they consider present goods prices and future prices. That said, I am not aspiring to be Roberto Carlos among my peers, but well, I have more than 15 million Argentines who accompanied me. That said, then, what happens? This also has to do with the definition of inflation, yes, because you can use the definition that most economists adopted after the emergence of Keynes, which is the generalized rise in prices. Well, if you think about it in those terms, there will be no shortage of the caveman who wants to fix the problem, how?: by controlling prices. There is a small detail that violates property rights, and that makes the supply withdraw, and consequently generates scarcity. But the vast majority of economists, if you ask them what the market is, they start trying to describe a little drawing and do not know that behind that drawing there are property rights, there are a lot of things. But, aside from that, then, when you generate an excess supply, either because supply rises or because demand falls, or both things happen at the same time, what will happen is that the purchasing power of money falls. That is to say, that all prices expressed in monetary units rise. In fact, unless you are making disasters with the inflation rate and end up pulverizing the demand for money, what you will have is that when the money supply rises, that will lead to a loss of purchasing power of money, and all prices expressed in monetary units will rise. That is why the original charter of the Central Bank was wise, which said, "It is the fundamental mission of the Central Bank to preserve the value of the currency." It did not work out, did it? Because taking 13 zeros off the currency, we could take three more off, clearly it did not work out. The good thing is that we know it will never work out well.

But, beyond that, there also appears another nonsense from economists called pass-through, the pass-through of devaluation to price. It is a nonsense the size of a house. Why is it nonsense? Because if inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon generated by an excess supply of money that leads to a loss of purchasing power of money, all prices expressed in monetary units rise, that is, the exchange rate is one more price, it is the price of a foreign currency, I don’t know, the dollar, the price of the dollar, then, it rises because it is not that the dollar is rising, it is that the peso is losing purchasing power, and it is not that there is pass-through, in reality, if instead of studying, I mean, only post-Keynes, they studied a little earlier, they would discover that there is something called the Hume-Cantillon effect, which has to do with the way prices move. So, if I generate the excess supply of money, money will lose purchasing power, now what happens? Since the dollar is a financial asset, it rises first, after the dollar rises, then translatable goods will rise, after translatable goods, wholesale prices will rise, after wholesale prices, retail prices will rise, and last in line, who comes?: the wage earners. That is why, when you generate a devaluation process, how that will lead to wages lagging behind in dynamics, the fall in real wages will result in an increase in the number of poor and indigent people, what pass-through? It is called the Hume-Cantillon effect, but again: since they do not have real equilibrium models, they invent these methodological shortcuts that are false and that are nothing more than an abuse of mathematics.

So, now we are starting to get closer, we have reached what is the monetary theory of inflation. Well, the extension to open economies is very easy, it is very extrapolable, because in reality if I have an open economy, I will have a relationship between international goods and local goods. That is to say, I know that by the law of one price or purchasing power parity, which is the version if you want of general equilibrium of the law of one price, I know that the domestic price is equal to the exchange rate multiplied by the international price level. And, moreover, if I am a small economy, the international prices are given. This means that then the exchange rate will be determined by the ratio of local prices divided by international prices. And if I know that domestic goods, the price is determined by the money supply divided by the real demand for money, the same applies to the rest of the world. Consequently, we find something called relative monetary conditions, and that is that the exchange rate is determined by the domestic money supply relative to the international money supply and the international demand for money relative to the local demand for money. In this sense, if the demand for money and the supply of money in the world were given, when I issue, given the amount of demand for money, it will not only raise the price level, but it will also raise the exchange rate.

So, I give you a piece of information: if I stop issuing, there is no reason for the exchange rate to rise. I mean, that is where zero issuance comes from, that is, we are solving the problem of inflation and obviously of the exchange rate; the only thing you had to do was go look in a textbook what relative monetary conditions are and how that interacts and how it maps with the model of purchasing power parity, but it seems we have economists who do not even know how to multiply and divide.

So, now we find ourselves with monetary policy, and you can follow different models or different forms of monetary policy: you can use an exogenous monetary policy, where you control the amount of money. So, when you determine the amount of money, what are you going to be determining? You will be determining the inflation rate, you will determine, in fact, the price level, and therefore the rate at which the amount of money varies will determine the inflation rate. Now you could use other mechanisms. For example, you could use the exchange rate. Now, when you set the exchange rate, the amount of money is determined endogenously. Notice that in the expression I mentioned earlier: the exchange rate arose from the ratio of prices, local prices in terms of international prices; now, if I set the exchange rate and the international prices are given, then what has to adjust? The price level. And the price level is determined by the ratio between the supply of money and the demand for money, and we said that the demand for money was given, because in fact you demand money based on your consumption pattern, which depends on the deep parameters of the economy. Therefore, what will happen to the supply of money? It will adjust to what? It will adjust to the demand for money, so that this price level is generated that is consistent with PPP. And that is how it works; that is why money is endogenous. What you will have is that, depending on how the demand for money moves, the Central Bank, for example, in the convertibility, when the demand for money increased, what it did was… what did they do? They took the dollars, sold them to the Central Bank, and there the Central Bank issued.

So, the amount of money expanded. And when you did not want money, you went and sold the pesos to the Central Bank, took the dollars, and the amount of money fell. Is that the only way to make monetary policy endogenous? No. You could think in terms of price controls and set prices. Now, if you are going to set prices and the international price is given, the exchange rate is already determined for you, do not insist on wanting to set the exchange rate and set prices, because… Unless, again, you are so fatally arrogant that you believe you can determine all the prices in the economy, for which you would have to be omniscient, omnipresent, and omnipotent, I mean, you should be the Creator. There are some economists who have an ego that believe they can, but I would tell you no, they cannot. Let’s say, Hayek would clearly demonstrate to you that this cannot be done.

Now, the other is to set monetary policy looking at wages, and if you look at wages, you could build a monstrous creature where prices are a markup over costs, with the cost being the wage. And there, even more, you can derive the model of distributive struggle; now, the other thing to say is that the model of distributive struggle is if everything I said before, the economists are fools, well, this is much more foolish. That is to say, talking about distributive struggle is almost like the supreme exaltation of being a fool, because saying that the price is a markup over costs implies that they did not realize that a man appeared in 1871 named Menger and created the subjective theory of value. That is to say, you would be determining prices by costs, that is, at least Guillermo Moreno when he says it, at least he says it to your face, he has no pretension of showing himself as an enlightened one. The complicated people who can be called reasonable as economists in terms of value theory and then use costs to determine prices, that is quite more complicated.

Having said all this, now we are in a position to see what happened in Argentina. Let’s say and why… my respect and admiration for Toto Caputo and all his team, obviously.

As Adelmo well said, when we won, we won with two very clear mandates. The third appeared later, but the first mandate was to end inflation, to end inflation. The other mandate was to end insecurity, and the minister, Dr. Patricia Bullrich, is doing an enormous, monumental, sublime job, because she is putting criminals in jail.

And obviously, also, a derivative of the adjustment we made is that the poor Minister of Human Capital is being attacked from all sides, why? Because she is discovering theft everywhere, and so, as she is denouncing all the thieves, she is being attacked from all sides, but we are also going after corruption.

Now, returning to the issue of inflation, when we were back in December, inflation was running at 1% daily, which if you annualize gives about 3700 or 3600 and something. Now, when you took the first two weeks of December, it was already running faster, and if you analyzed it, it gave you 7500 annually. You can say: ‘no, well, but this is an exaggeration.’ In fact, I remember that when we came to power, one of the things I did in the speech was to tell the truth to the people. Well, in fact, it is the first time in history that not only does a libertarian liberal win, what did you expect, that a libertarian liberal would win under normal conditions of pressure and temperature? It was obvious that it had to be chaos, because if not, the populists would have continued to win, that has to be internalized.

The second is that we showed that this inflation rate, if there was monetary validation, could reach levels of 15000 percent. That had to do with monetary imbalances, plus the needs for issuance and the mess that was inside the Central Bank. In that sense, it was very interesting because, and this shows the intellectual dishonesty of economists, because as they repeatedly missed, they try to show the history that hurts them the least in terms of mistakes. Because when you take the wholesale inflation of December, it was 54%; if we had validated it monetarily, that is, if we had not made the fiscal adjustment—and now I will explain each of the things we did—what would have happened? There would have been monetary validation and inflation would have actually been 17000%. And with the last wholesale inflation data at 3.5, that is an inflation of 50%. That is to say, the giant that is here in front brought the inflation rate down from 17000 to 50%. Look if he is not a giant.

Now… but then how did this work? Well, if we say that inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon generated by an excess supply of money that causes the purchasing power of money to fall, the prices expressed in monetary units to rise, what had to be cut was the monetary issuance. And there we found ourselves with a consolidated deficit of 15 points of GDP, where five points were in the treasury and 10 points were in the Central Bank. So, the first thing we did was go to zero deficit. This is very interesting because our hypothesis was to achieve it throughout the year 2024, and there Toto’s team threw everything they had to make it happen. And there is something very interesting and worth knowing, we decided to cut public works completely, we decided to cut discretionary transfers to provinces completely, we decided to eliminate intermediaries of poverty, with which with the same money people were much better off, because the transaction cost, that is, the theft, was reduced. I remember that when… that was a coordinated action between Dr. Bullrich, Minister Pettovello, and Minister Ferraro, who was in charge of Infrastructure, one of the things we did was to remove the social plan benefit. When we did that, they truly said everything to us, the number of things they said to Minister Pettovello was enormous. But that had a reason. Why?

Because the beneficiaries of social plans receive their payments on a card, but where is the trap? When they need to verify that they had to work. And that was where they lost half of the social plan.

So, in that sense, by removing, we said that temporarily those counter-performances were removed, what happened? They did not have to go sign, by not needing the signature, what happened? Their income doubled. Naturally, three days later, Mr. Belliboni was threatening with a march, which he said would bring 50,000 people to the square, when in reality he said that number because he expected to bring 100,000, and there, we created, we put into motion the new security doctrine, and whoever blocked the street would not get paid. Moreover, whoever blocked would face consequences, and not only that, but we also used the transport network to communicate to people that they did not need to go to the march, that they should not be extorted; if they were extorted, there was a number to report; and I warn you that we have already received more than 20,000 reports executing, and making those who have extorted the most vulnerable pay consequences.

So, in that sense, what happened? They ran out of firepower, and I remember we put more than 12,000 troops on the street and only 3,000 showed up, and from there, we also put the street in order, we put security issues in order, and we started to fight that battle where we have resounding successes, like when federal forces entered Santa Fe and reduced the number of homicides, for example, by 70%. That is to say, achievements, not words, not narratives, achievements.

And not to mention all these scammers who are now parading through the Justice system and who will pay the consequences of having stolen bread from the most vulnerable. Returning to the issue of fiscal adjustment, we also started to eliminate economic subsidies, and it is very funny because when you… we had campaigned with a chainsaw… Ah, we also fired a lot of public employees and we also did not follow the inflation of public salaries step by step, and in that context, yes, there was a chainsaw, but the adjusters appeared. That is to say, some frauds who said that, for example, no adjustment could be made more than 1% of GDP in a year and that it was a great achievement. Of course, in the face of the failure that we achieved zero deficit in the first month of management, they started saying it was not sustainable. We also had a surplus in February, March, April, May, June, and July as well. Despite the seasonality of the payment of the bonus.

So, the adjusters started, that is, those who said that no adjustment could be made now started with the quality of the adjustment. So, it was a lot of blender and little scissors. When you review what we are attaching, more than 90% is chainsaw. But well, they need to wash their guilt, the serial offenders need to wash their guilt. If not, go grab the reports they made in December, look at how they missed everything. I won’t even tell you when they said we had to set the exchange rate at 600, and if we did well with the inflation path they estimated, it was higher than what we had. And then they come to chase us with the real exchange rate. They have a problem with the model, I mean, they have a problem with the model. They have a lot of nonsense and little math, to put it one way.

Having said this, now, was that enough? No, that was not enough. We had to go, because that only fixed a third of the problem. The other two-thirds were in the balance of the Central Bank, and it was essential to end the quasi-fiscal deficit. Not only because it was 10 points of GDP, but because we had a problem that was endogenous issuance. And there other problems also appeared, because of course, many are used to looking at how economic policy is made abroad, and we could also go and lift all the reports of all those who said that the real interest rate had to be put in positive territory. Now, if you put the real interest rate in positive territory, today we would be talking about having ten times the monetary liabilities compared to the base and we would be talking about carry trade, when hyperinflation explodes, with the visions of those geniuses. Instead of doing that, we thought more in terms of the market and not in terms of nonsense about what the interest rate is as a monetary problem. Look, the interest rate is not a monetary issue; the interest rate exists because time exists, it has to do with intertemporal substitution. So, what had to be done was to arbitrate against the currency that the Argentine leaves the peso, which was in dollars. When you do that arbitration, yes, of course, in real terms the rate was negative, and being negative allowed us to lower what? It allowed us to lower the weight of the remunerated liabilities; it allowed us to lower the quasi-fiscal deficit, and at the same time, because there are still frauds who say ‘no, Argentina is insolvent.’ Look: to determine whether a country is solvent or not, you have to look at whether the debt-to-GDP ratio is non-increasing. That is mathematically resolved with a formula called convergent geometric progression. Now, if you have zero deficit, the debt does not grow, therefore, you are on a non-increasing path.

Consequently, the zero deficit is the most brutal way to ensure intertemporal solvency. That is why the country risk went from 2900 and at one point touched a little over 1100, until Congress started to do its thing with the fiscal degenerates, wanting to spend like crazy and well, the market sent us the bill. And since we still have capital controls, you buy dollars indirectly, not directly, by hitting the solvency through the price of the bonds, ‘oh, the dollar is rising’. And yes, of course, as long as the fiscal degenerates want to do their thing, yes, you will see it in the price of the bonds and, obviously, you will see it in the dollar. Now, I am going to tell you something: if the fiscal degenerates want to pass laws that go against budgetary balance, you know what? I will veto them all, I will not deliver the fiscal result.

And while we consolidated fiscal solvency, we were generating cash surpluses and, in addition, we were liquefying and correcting the problem of the Central Bank's balance sheet and with the inflation rate falling, a curve of pesos began to be recreated. That is why I always mention the enormous task of Dr. Pablo Quirno, because from the financial policy, a curve of pesos began to be recreated, which is what today allows us to finally solve the problem of remunerated liabilities and with the endogenous issuance of remunerated liabilities, in order to, yes, now, advance to the second stage of the program, which is zero issuance.

Therefore, with the fiscal deficit finished, and the problem of the endogenous generation of money resolved, we have two issues left to solve, one is the issue of the puts. This issue that seemed like an abstraction, a few days ago you saw what it could cause. But given the strong position we have in the Central Bank's accounts and our cash position in Banco Nación, we were able to defeat them, we were able to defeat that bank with coup intentions.

That said, we are making progress on an agreement to end the problem of the puts. So, the question is when do we lift the controls. We are going to lift the controls, and we have always said it, it’s not that we didn’t say it, we said that we had to achieve fiscal balance, checked, inside. We said that we have to end the remunerated, inside. We have to end the puts, we have them, checkmate. And the other thing we need is the convergence of the inflation rate. The first step we have to aim for is precisely to map the inflation rate with the devaluation rate. Once we achieve an inflation rate around 2% monthly, we will go for a 1% monthly inflation rate, and when inflation has disappeared, when it is at levels close to zero, then we will have to choose whether we go to a zero devaluation scheme. That is, it would be a fixed exchange rate or we let it float. And we also said what the conditions were, because what happens is that the external sector accounts in Argentina have seasonality. I mean, what would happen if with all the cold that has been happening these last few days we did not buy gas? We would have defended the dollars but, what would have happened? You would have had a pretty rough time in terms of cold, I can explain to you what it was like for me the other day in Tucumán, that to be able to use the presidential band I was in a suit without thermal clothing, my fingers were stiff.

But aside from that, the external sector accounts, as one has a crawling peg system, in the end, it is like fixed in jumps, implies that all the variation comes from the quantities side, and as in winter we have to import energy then we have room to lose more than 3000 million dollars, so that they say ‘oh, well let’s see what happens’. So, if they start to be altered because we lose dollars, it is normal. And I will tell you something: if it gets colder, we lose more dollars and if it gets warmer we lose less, because it has to do with that. Now what happens is: in that dynamic we are going to be contracting the amount of money and the risk we have is that the amount of money, for example, the monetary base, is very low. And let’s not end up squeezing the amount of money so much that we end up choking the economy by accelerating the rate of disinflation because, by the way, the economy is also starting to show signs of recovery. And also how is the recovery going to come? Well, look, first you are seeing it in the real wages of the private sector, clearly for more than two months real wages have been rising and they haven’t lost as much as they say. Not only that, with the adjustment scheme of pensions, as the inflation rate falls, pensions also gain. Therefore, in the short term we will have a recovery in demand and we will begin to emerge.

In addition, we will have already cleaned up the problem of stocks, because when everything was seen as a disaster, what happens? They overstocked. And then, what is the consequence? That for a time production also fell, until they cleaned the stocks. Now they have to be rebuilt, which will push forward. Another thing that will also push forward is the fact that Argentina is an economy that has destroyed its capital. Consequently, the value of the marginal product of capital is high, that is, the real returns of the projects are high, therefore, there are incentives to invest, even with the old legal structure. As if all this were not enough, having saved 15 points of GDP, that money now returns to the private sector. While in December of last year we were discussing whether we were going to hyperinflation or not, today we discuss about 30-year mortgage loans.

So, as if all this were not enough, there is also a lot of dishonesty here. We managed to pass the Bases Law, with only 15% of the deputies, with 10% of the senators, we passed the largest structural reform in Argentine history, because it is five times larger than the reform that Menem made and we did it with the least number of legislators in history. Thank you, Guillermo Francos.

But it didn’t stop there, it didn’t stop there, because the DNU is still in force. Therefore, the reform is eight times larger than the one Menem made, which was the largest reform in Argentine history. So, when they say no, they don’t have a plan, they don’t have a plan… I say, 800 structural reforms, there is no plan. But I will tell you something, there are 3200 more in the pipeline. We are going to be the freest country on the planet.

In fact, with the reform we have sent, we will jump 90 places in terms of economic freedom; therefore, we will begin to resemble countries like Germany. Some neighbors who are now invaded by the left of the Germans, so not so much in that sense, and in that sense, that puts us on a path of tremendous economic growth. But, again, our goal is to be the freest country on planet Earth and as we finish the stabilization process and lift the controls, that will also further boost economic growth, because it will allow foreign direct investment to come and all that situation in which economic growth will be generated, there we have to make decisions. Why? Because when the economy starts to grow seriously, whether it is because it has a low capital stock per capita, whether it is because it has low wages, for whatever you want, because we are also contributing 15 additional points of savings to fuel growth… but, in addition, we have the structural reforms and all this will begin to generate greater long-term economic growth. That is to say, we will enter a path of higher growth. And what is the central point? That will also generate what?: resources, fiscal resources. I commit here, before you, that those resources will not be for increasing public spending, those additional resources that generate growth will be used to lower taxes, to return freedom to Argentines and to grow seriously again.

Therefore, we are reopening the path of freedom, returning to embrace the ideas of freedom. And, if we stay on this path and understand that this time the effort will be worth it, in 30 or 40 years we will be again one of the greatest world powers. All embraced to the ideas of freedom. So thank you very much and long live freedom, damn it!