Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck at the 14th Berlin Symposium on Refugee Protection of the Protestant Academy on June 30, 2014, in Berlin:

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

6 July 2014 · 14th Berlin Symposium on Refugee Protection of the Protestant Academy · Berlin, Germany

Context
Gauck addressed the 14th Berlin Symposium on Refugee Protection of the Protestant Academy on June 30, 2014, reflecting on Germany's and Europe's response to the global refugee crisis.
Main themes
Refugee protection and asylum policy, Syrian civil war and displacement, German refugee intake quotas, European burden-sharing, humanitarian imperatives vs. political feasibility, internally displaced persons, global refugee statistics, Mediterranean migration routes, limits of refugee policy, UNHCR data and host countries
Duration
~25 min
75th percentile
Words
2,963
75th percentile
Sentences
151
81st percentile
Readability
53
72nd percentile
Grade
10.7
28th percentile
Syntax
2.95
41st percentile
Vocabulary
1.99
9th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 61%59%
  • Geopolitical 15%15%
  • Institutional 12%11%
  • Economic 8%8%
  • Ceremonial 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

151 sentences in 43 paragraphs

Exactly two months ago, I was sitting in a refugee camp, in a tent, in Kahramanmaraş, at the Turkish-Syrian border. I was sitting with a father, a mother, and a grandfather, and they were telling stories about the war that had displaced them and made them victims of terror. They were anxious, but they felt safe. They had four children. The youngest was born there in the camp. And now they were waiting.

I sometimes wonder if the people I met there would have survived if they had fled across the Mediterranean? Would the little ones have made it, would the youngest have been born, who would have survived, would everyone have died?

In situations like these, everyone realizes: Meeting people is something different than just encountering numbers or statistics. You look into faces – disturbed, frightened – hear the dramatic stories, feel the hope for help from afar, from the foreign. It must come from somewhere.

But of course, professionals dealing with the issue of refugees must also bow to statistics, must know numbers, must track them. They must recognize how great the pressure is from this part of the world population that is not at home. When we see numbers and statistics, we recognize what we can do, where we stand. So, some numbers must also be mentioned.

You all here in the room know: The federal government and the states have decided to take in an additional 10,000 Syrian refugees. I find that right, important, and valuable. 5,400 Syrians have found safe refuge in Germany thanks to the first two contingents.

But the civil war has been going on since 2011. The dead, no one can count anymore; more than 150,000 is mentioned. And even if no other European state has responded to the dramatic conflict with comparable humanitarian programs, even if those who are taken in Germany find better conditions than in most other countries in the world: The overwhelming majority of the approximately 32,000 Syrians who have come to Germany since the violence began have had to make their way through other means, including the illegal and life-threatening route across the Mediterranean.

Millions are stuck in the crisis region, as refugees in their own country or in camps in Turkey and Jordan. What is being done there, Daniela Schadt and I have seen with our own eyes. More than a million refugees currently live in Lebanon. That is, calculated per capita, as if there were 20 million refugees among us in Germany.

“Are we really doing everything we could do?” I have asked this repeatedly, even in my Christmas address. You, dear hosts, quote it in the announcement for this symposium. Numbers and statistics also give an impression here.

In the first five months of this year, a total of 54,956 initial applications for asylum were submitted in Germany – more than double the number in the same period last year. In absolute numbers, no other country in Europe receives more asylum seekers. However, relative to the population, Germany is not at the top in Europe, but in ninth place, clearly behind Sweden, also behind Austria, Hungary, and Belgium.

If we only look at ourselves, we often tend toward self-righteousness. But if we also consider how many others are solving the same or similar problems, we will inevitably become more humble.

Who is aware that so-called internally displaced persons make up the absolute majority of refugees in the world? Who knows that only a small part of the more than 51 million refugees and displaced persons worldwide seeks protection in Europe – and an even smaller part actually finds it? That usually the poorest countries take care of the poor from their neighborhood? When you relate the number of refugees to the economic power of the countries, according to the current statistics from UNHCR, the three largest host countries are Pakistan, Ethiopia, and Kenya.

“Are we doing everything we could do?” An answer lies – according to the mentioned numbers – close at hand: We, that is Germany and also Europe, are doing a lot. But not as much as it sometimes seems.

Unfortunately, politics has never been measured solely by humanitarian imperatives, but always also by what is politically feasible.

That is a sentence that is hard for me to say. I would actually like it to be different. But we live in a country where we are dealing with people who are themselves limited. And therefore, politics always focuses on what is feasible. This sentence contains something like a double demarcation: a demarcation from those who wish that we should open our gates wide for all the weary and burdened. But also from those who believe that the limits of what is feasible have long been reached and that we must isolate ourselves much better than we have done so far.

Refugee policy will always remain a difficult policy. And I see no patent solution anywhere. We will never be able to offer refuge and a future to all those who are threatened and persecuted.

The asylum compromise of 1993 took into account the dramatically increased number of applications at that time after the end of the division of Europe, albeit in a way that is still controversial today. And I do not want to conceal that a statement by Burkhard Hirsch from 2002 resonates within me, which I perceive as a warning: “The history of asylum law is also a history of the defense against immigration.”

Perhaps it is this fear that led me some time ago to say: We could do more. We could do some things better. We must do it in respect of the rights to which we are committed. Above all, we should do it together, as Europeans.

Many older among us have experienced how Europe was a continent of refugees and displaced persons. This continent has found its values through a history of violence and wars, on which we today base our community in Europe: human rights and democracy, solidarity and openness – not fearfulness and defense.

In refugee policy, this presents us with a dilemma: On the one hand, the European Union has a legitimate interest in monitoring its external borders and protecting itself from uncontrolled immigration. On the other hand, it must ask itself to what extent it endangers the rights or even the lives of those who seek protection from justified fear of persecution.

The year is now halfway through – and already more than 50,000 refugees and migrants have arrived in the Mediterranean region, more than in the entire previous year. This also reflects the armed conflict in Syria, which has been added to the other ongoing crisis regions. A new conflict exists in Iraq; we all know that.

The growing number of boat refugees is also a reaction to the increasing closure of the southeastern land borders of the European Union. More and more people seeking refuge are therefore taking the life-threatening route across the Mediterranean. In the past one and a half decades, around 23,000 people have likely died attempting to flee across the sea. They have died of thirst, drowned, or are missing.

And hardly a day goes by without news of new refugees. Not even today. As most of you probably know, a message went around this morning that has shaken us: Again, a boat with 30 dead has been discovered off the coast of Sicily.

I cannot get used to such news. No one in Europe should get used to it. We are proud that two dozen states – including those that have been at war with each other for centuries – have abolished their border controls with each other and created a “space of freedom, security, and law.” The European summit in Tampere, where a common asylum system was negotiated in 1999, was, by the way, unanimous: “It would contradict the traditions of Europe if this freedom were denied to those who wish to enter our territory for justified reasons due to their living conditions.” So it says there.

And now the images of coffins in the hangar of the airport in Lampedusa, the images of climbing people at the barbed wire fence of the enclaves Ceuta or Melilla – they do not fit the image that we Europeans have of ourselves.

What can, what must we do?

The Federal Republic wrote a fundamental sentence into its constitution at its founding: “Politically persecuted persons enjoy the right of asylum” – a response that was still very close and completely unrestricted to the suffering stories of countless Germans who had to flee from the Nazi dictatorship. We should remember Hannah Arendt, who, after the Second World War, demanded the right to have rights in the face of statelessness and the defenselessness of people.

Both our constitution and the Geneva Refugee Convention urge us to grant refuge to people who are persecuted because of their race, religion, nationality, political beliefs, or because of their membership in a particular social group. While the reasons for flight may have changed over the past decades, the core points of the 1951 Geneva Refugee Convention remain valid to this day.

For me, therefore, a common European refugee policy must ensure that every refugee can also exercise their rights – not to be turned away without a hearing of the reasons for flight, and, if necessary, to receive protection from persecution. The high seas are not a lawless space; human rights also apply there. I refer not least to a ruling of the European Court of Human Rights.

A common European refugee policy must therefore not only protect the European borders but also save lives at the borders of Europe. As long as asylum seekers experience the same conditions of protection and assistance only in declarations, but not in reality in all member countries, all European governments will have to ask themselves what they are doing to actually align the reception, processing, and recognition standards in all countries.

And finally, we Europeans must share the emerging burdens of solidarity more fairly, transparently, and in a spirit of solidarity. I hear with interest that you will also debate here at the symposium how solutions could look that could relieve pressure from the border countries and also how we as Germans can be part of a fair distribution of burdens.

One thing we should not do: calculate what the other must do before we move ourselves. Because the refugees who land on the coasts of Italy or Malta are not just the refugees of Malta or Italy. They are not just the refugees of Lampedusa. They are refugees seeking protection in our Europe. They have rights that we as Europeans have jointly committed to respect. It is our shared responsibility as Europeans to treat them with dignity.

Our country has begun – for example, with the contingents for Syrian refugees – to respond to the new challenges as part of our responsibility in the world. The civil war refugees primarily need temporary protection, which we can offer them through humanitarian admission programs. Most of them want to return if at all possible.

However, those refugees who cannot return because they would be persecuted or even killed, or because the violence in their home country has simply not ended, need a permanent perspective for life in exile. It is good that Germany has been taking in particularly vulnerable individuals through a resettlement program for two years. Those who speak with people who can finally arrive – often after years of painful uncertainty – know how much one must wish that even more of them would receive this chance. It is good that the Grand Coalition is willing to expand the resettlement program. The numbers speak for themselves: currently, places are being sought for 170,000 refugees. Germany is currently taking in 300 per year, the entire EU about 5,000, while the USA alone takes in more than 50,000.

Overall, in my opinion, it is about making the procedures for refugees fairer and more effective. Faster examinations, as agreed in the coalition agreement, bring, if they remain fair, clarity to all sides more quickly. However, a more effective refugee policy also includes that we humanely reject those who do not have grounds for flight according to the valid criteria that would justify admission, at least in our Federal Republic. I wish for a solidarity that we can also live.

It is good that in areas that have long been controversial, something has now moved: for example, in the relaxation of the residence requirement or the work ban for asylum seekers. Some time ago, I visited the transitional accommodation in Bad Belzig. And there I saw that many who have to remain inactive suffer from not being able to work for a better life. They simply have to sit and wait. This weighs heavily on their spirits. The vast majority of them do not want to be recipients of charity. It is good, therefore, that the time of the work ban is being shortened. It is difficult when the remaining restrictions continue to hinder the chance of finding a job.

In principle, we should consider how to create more permeability between the pathways of "asylum" and "labor migration." For once someone has unsuccessfully sought asylum, they are unlikely to find entry through another gate, even if they have qualifications that are indeed needed in this country. Many of the refugees who have made it to Germany are highly mobile, flexible, multilingual, and willing to perform and take risks.

We know: The boundaries are often fluid between politically forced, economically forced, or genuinely voluntary migration. While we cannot and do not want to abandon the distinction between those in need of protection and those who are not, the right to asylum is non-negotiable. However, we should – both nationally and at the European level – strive to ensure different avenues for entry, from studying to family reunification.

Allow me a small digression: We are here in the Französische Friedrichstadtkirche, a place that – like many family names in our country – reminds us of one of the most famous refugee groups of the past: the Huguenots. Our Federal Minister of the Interior thus has a – I admit: very long-standing – migration background. When his ancestors came to this area, they had a long history of persecution, civil war, and toleration behind them. At that time, newcomers were given the opportunity to earn a place in their new homeland through their own work – certainly to the advantage of the host country. We should also keep this in mind in a society where much is discussed about demographic change, population decline, and the impending shortage of skilled workers.

Migration, as studies have long shown, can be a strong engine of development, by the way, also for the countries of origin. Or, as the famous economist John Kenneth Galbraith put it: "Migration is the oldest remedy against poverty." We should build on this, ideally for the mutual benefit: with programs designed to help both the migrants themselves and the societies that receive them – and in the long term also the communities and societies they have left behind. We now know, for example, that migrants send three times as much savings back to their countries of origin as public development aid flows. Harder to quantify, but no less important, are the knowledge and, not least, the values they bring back to their homeland when they return.

"Are we really doing everything we should be doing?" The answer to this question does not depend solely on financial resources or political programs, but at least as much on how honestly, pragmatically, and soberly politics and society discuss the challenges of refugee policy. It would become clear that the numbers and proportions I mentioned at the beginning are by no means so alarming that our willingness to help would already be overwhelmed. Solidarity is, first and foremost, a foundation of our human coexistence, and moreover, it is a hallmark of our democracy.

Those who come are people who have often experienced terrible things and need support. I am grateful to the civil society organizations, also to the churches, the welfare associations, the lawyers, and all the volunteers who have been advocating for humane improvements in asylum policy for many years and who continually stand up against those who incite hatred against immigrants or even throw incendiary devices at asylum seeker homes. The commitment of many municipalities, of citizens for the very concrete needs of refugees, is also admirable. Many communities no longer see them as bothersome guests for a time, but as people to whom – no matter how long they want to stay – bridges must be built into our society, because that is also in the interest of our society. There are countless initiatives that promote encounters in various ways and thereby also foster understanding of the situation of asylum seekers.

That is encouraging. We want to be open and remain open to the desire of people to be free as we want to be: free from persecution, from violence, from death. We want to follow this longing of theirs, and we can still remain grounded in our politics. With understanding for the reasons people have to leave their homeland. With consideration for the limits of our society's capacity to receive. But above all, with foresight regarding the opportunities of immigration. We must want to see it. And we see all this in the awareness of our shared responsibility as Europeans.

We know: It will never be possible to do enough. But if we do not do what we can, we not only fail our neighbor, but we also lose our inclination towards ourselves, our self-respect.