Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck at the Federal Final of the Student Competition "Youth Debates" on June 28, 2014, in Berlin:

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

9 July 2014 · Federal Final of the Student Competition "Youth Debates" · broadcasting house, Berlin, Germany

Context
Gauck addressed the federal final of the 'Youth Debates' student competition on June 28, 2014, at a historic Berlin broadcasting house.
Main themes
Freedom of expression, democratic debate, youth civic engagement, power of words, authoritarian suppression, peaceful revolution in Eastern Europe, GDR experience, rhetoric and argumentation, democratic participation, civil courage
Duration
~11 min
38th percentile
Words
1,286
38th percentile
Sentences
78
51st percentile
Readability
58
83rd percentile
Grade
9.3
13th percentile
Syntax
2.77
19th percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
31st percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 69%69%
  • Ceremonial 22%22%
  • Institutional 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

78 sentences in 13 paragraphs

This is a special place for a final of "Youth Debates." A place that stands for the power of free speech, but also for the attempts of the powerful to misuse words and to suppress, rather than promote, freedom of expression. What this broadcasting house has not experienced here in Berlin: the democratic beginnings of radio in the Weimar Republic, then the propaganda and lies of the National Socialists, the struggle for interpretative authority between the victorious powers from East and West, and of course "Sender Freies Berlin," the voice of freedom in the long-divided city.

The power of words is particularly evident in the efforts that oppressive regimes make to prevent, rather than promote, free access to information and open exchange of arguments. Countless people in many parts of the world still suffer under such repression today. We often do not realize this enough. As a resident of an unfree country, the GDR, I experienced firsthand how the Communist Party sought to suppress free speech with all its might. Many words I wanted to say back then, and often did say, were politically unwelcome. Often, in those times, all that sufficed were allusions and symbols. People learn to understand that, but it is not free speech.

Many people in the GDR, but also in other dictatorships in Central and Eastern Europe, were fed up with this game of hide and seek by the end of the 1980s. They no longer wanted to endure the life they had fallen into in silence and tolerance. They wanted to finally make the attempt to live in truth. This is what the great Václav Havel told his fellow countrymen back then. They wanted to be able to say what they believed, loud and clear. Twenty-five years ago, they fought for their freedom, and, miraculously, they did so peacefully. The Peaceful Revolution remains a beacon. Its message to the despots of this world is: The longing for freedom cannot be suppressed in the long run.

Twenty-five years ago, people in East Germany risked a lot to be able to express their opinions openly. In our Basic Law, which drew the consequences from the unfreedom and injustice of the Nazi regime, freedom of expression is guaranteed as a fundamental right; it must not be infringed upon in its "essence." But abstract constitutional articles alone are not enough. Democracy also needs life, needs citizens who make use of their rights, who get involved, who want to help shape things, and who intervene courageously and confidently in debates, whether politicians like it or not. We want people in this free country who dare to step onto the public stage, express their opinions, and form alliances for their interests.

We learn this in competitions that exist in many schools. And "Youth Debates" contributes to young people growing into convinced and convincing democrats, and this has been happening for more than ten years now. That the competition is a great success story is evidenced by the more than 175,000 students who participated this year alone. They learn to speak freely and take a stand. They also learn to listen well, respect other opinions, and remain fair and factual in verbal battles. But the most important thing is: Those who participate in "Youth Debates" quickly realize – debating is really fun! This is indeed the very best prerequisite for engaging in societal discussions.

What the democratic public needs are also spontaneity and passion, wit and esprit. They should not replace reflection and thoughtfulness, but they will promote engagement with topics and attention to problems. What we do not need is a soulless jargon in which every message is polished to the point of unrecognizability. At this point, I would like to quote Walter Jens, the great rhetorician of the Federal Republic, who passed away in June of last year. He once said: "A speech is (...) convincing when I show: This is me, and I mean it as I say it." Sounds quite simple, doesn't it?

And he said something else that I find important: In democratic debate, it is perfectly permissible to be convinced by one's opponent. How wonderful it is when one can say to another: "I am no longer so sure that I am right on this point." Such a person does not necessarily lose; rather, they gain – namely, respect and credibility. Yes, Walter Jens is right: It is an expression of humanity and also of wisdom to publicly acknowledge a mistake. Debating is not a sport in which the fastest tongue or the strongest vocal cords prevail. I know that many understand it that way. But actually, that is not what it is about. Debating is a contest of arguments. And the beauty of democracy is that we can learn from each other.

This does not mean that it always has to be harmonious; we see that when we listen to the debates that move the times. And we may experience this in the final as well. In open societies characterized by cultural diversity, there are conflicts of interest, and of course, there is also disagreement. Sometimes it takes unfair forms. The legislator cannot prohibit that either. One must simply strive to change it through better examples. We must endure and carry this, and we must continually seek compromises. This is sometimes laborious, but it is worth it! And it is exciting because often ideas emerge in conversation that we had not anticipated at all. Almost everything can be said in a democracy, even uncomfortable things, even far-fetched things, as long as it does not violate the rights of others, as long as it does not destroy the common ground of understanding, as long as it is done fairly and peacefully.

Today, this broadcasting hall transforms into an agora, a marketplace like in an ideal republic, where the power of words can unfold freely. "Youth Debates" brings young people together, enables encounters and friendships, even across national borders. Here among us today are the winners of the competitions in Spain and China, and in the fall, an international final will again take place in Warsaw. What a beautiful symbol for cross-border understanding! And I would like to extend a special warm welcome to our guests from abroad.

This competition is only possible because numerous people and organizations work together and engage collectively, with civic spirit and enthusiasm, and of course with funding. I thank the Hertie Foundation, the Heinz Nixdorf Foundation, the Robert Bosch Foundation, and the Mercator Foundation. And I thank the participating state parliaments and ministries of education. It is precisely the constructive and complementary collaboration of foundations and public authorities that has made this project so strong, indeed, without which it would hardly be possible in this form.

Last but not least, my thanks go to the mentors and jurors, the teachers, the parents, and alumni who continually bring this wonderful competition to life. All of you, your collaboration and participation, make democracy appealing, and for that, I thank you from the bottom of my heart.

Dear finalists,

now finally to you! I can imagine that you are feeling nervous. I certainly would be quite anxious in such a situation. This is probably the case for everyone; if not, then something is not quite right. So, you can confidently step onto the stage. You will be debating in front of people who know what nervousness and tension are. And however you perform in your debates: You have already won. You have personally grown on the way to the final, and you have experienced the power of free speech. I look forward to what you have to say. And I wish you much success. May the better argument win!