Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck at the celebration marking the 20th anniversary of the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea on October 7, 2016, in Hamburg:

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

9 October 2016 · Celebration marking the 20th anniversary of the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea · Hamburg, Germany

Context
Gauck addressed the 20th anniversary celebration of the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea on October 7, 2016, in Hamburg, Germany.
Main themes
International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea, international law, peaceful dispute resolution, law of the sea, multilateralism, Hugo Grotius and mare liberum, maritime jurisdiction, global justice, national interests vs. international cooperation, challenges to international order, Hamburg as maritime hub, history of international law
Duration
~22 min
69th percentile
Words
2,588
69th percentile
Sentences
134
76th percentile
Readability
33
21st percentile
Grade
13.4
60th percentile
Syntax
2.87
30th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
39th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 42%41%
  • Geopolitical 34%34%
  • Social 11%10%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Economic 4%4%
  • Environmental 2%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

134 sentences in 37 paragraphs

I am very pleased to be here with you, at this historic place to commemorate a momentous event in history. Twenty years ago, on October 1, 1996, the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea was established. I extend my heartfelt congratulations on this anniversary.

And I thank the Free and Hanseatic City of Hamburg for its resolute support of the long journey of the German bid for the seat of the Tribunal. The history and present of this great shipping and maritime trade city are shaped by the relationship of humans to the sea. Hamburg is also a traditional residence of maritime law. The establishment of the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea here on the Elbe impressively marks the pinnacle of this tradition.

However, the Tribunal is above all a great enrichment for the international community and for its pursuit of peaceful dispute resolution. This pursuit is also a core concern of German politics.

The seas are the largest habitat on our planet, and the "Court of the Seas" has universal jurisdiction. Therefore, the international community attaches great importance to this court for the resolution of disputes concerning the sea. In its twenty years of existence, the Tribunal has earned trust and appreciation. So today, there is indeed a reason to celebrate.

But at the same time – we know this – this anniversary falls in a time when the centrifugal forces of the family of nations are at work. Wars and crises shape global events. National interests are emphasized in some places more strongly than the benefits of international cooperation. Defensive attitudes towards globalization are also gaining weight. We feel this in the European Union, but we also feel it worldwide. Therefore, I would like to share some thoughts today on the challenges for international law in these uncertain times.

But first, on such a festive day, attention must be given to the honoree, the Tribunal, and its work in one of the most traditional areas of international law. When the Dutchman Hugo Grotius, the great pioneer of international law, postulated the idea of the free sea in 1605, it was a provocation – politically, economically, and even ecclesiologically. Grotius sought to defend the claim of the still young Dutch state to free navigation and free trade against Spain and Portugal. The question of who owns the resources and wealth of the sea, this tension between "mare liberum" and "mare clausum," continues to shape international maritime law to this day.

The United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea is the most comprehensive multilateral treaty ever concluded. In a total of 320 articles, it addresses nearly all questions regarding the delimitation and use, exploration, and protection of the seas. Then as now, the Convention impresses, among other things, because it also addresses global justice and distribution issues. That despite differing national interests and varying views on the international economic order, an agreement was reached on a binding legal framework for the seas is a remarkable testament to the creative power of international law. Especially since the parties agreed that disputes should generally be settled in court. The grand idea of securing peace through law is thereby decisively strengthened. We wish for more of this internationally.

The Tribunal has taken on an important role in this regard. It decides cases of significant legal, economic, and political importance, such as disputes regarding maritime world trade and the delimitation of maritime zones in recent years. And even though the Tribunal shares the experience of most newly established international courts that the number of cases grows only slowly, it has nonetheless sent remarkable signals, for example, regarding the preservation of the marine environment.

Peace, security, and justice can only be achieved in a global, consensus-based system of rules, and I deliberately say "achieved," because we experience it daily: The mere existence of international legal provisions does not guarantee a peaceful, secure, and just world. What ultimately matters is the interplay between international law and politics.

International law aims to channel power and ensure mutual respect among states. "As communities of equal law and equal honor," this formulation comes from the international law scholar Alfred Verdross. The exercise of power is thus civilized and controlled. For this, international law is itself dependent on those who wield power: on their willingness and ability to agree on common interests and values and to make this agreement, if it exists, consistent and binding. How well this succeeds depends on the global political conditions. And throughout history, international law has experienced good and less good times.

A golden age was the 1990s. The fall of the Berlin Wall and the reunification of Germany, the dissolution of the Soviet Union, and the democratic revolutions in Eastern Europe created a political climate from which the international legal order significantly benefited. The decades-long blockade of the United Nations Security Council due to the East-West conflict seemed to be overcome. The international community demonstrated its willingness for closer cooperation by creating numerous new institutions and frameworks. International jurisdiction also experienced – not only in maritime law – a surge in growth. In the numerous new establishments – there are now around 150 international judicial bodies – this insight manifested itself that international law also brings obligations.

A milestone in this development was undoubtedly the expansion of international criminal justice. With the establishment of the International Criminal Tribunals for the former Yugoslavia and for Rwanda, and then especially with the founding of the International Criminal Court in 1998, it was impressively underscored that international law does not only focus on states, their sovereignty, and their interests. A core concern of international law is the well-being of people, the "value of humanity." With the legal dynamics of the 1990s, hopes grew at that time. The intensification of international law, the strengthening of human rights and judicial protection, all of this fueled the idea that the international community could move towards a "law of the global population," towards a "world constitutional state."

Unfortunately, the aspirations of that time have given way to a different reality. The old world order shaped by the East-West conflict no longer exists, but a comprehensive, lasting, peaceful reordering has not yet been achieved. A discomfort with international entanglement and globalization and everything associated with it is becoming palpable. The belief in the exclusive problem-solving competence of the nation-state is experiencing a renaissance in many places.

The framework conditions for the further development of international law have thus deteriorated. Nevertheless, we should not forget that international law has always developed in spurts and not uniformly in all areas. It is also not always about high politics. Often, our everyday lives are regulated in such an unproblematic way by international law that we are hardly aware of it. Who thinks, for example, when buying bananas in the supermarket, of the international framework "Codex Alimentarius," which is supposed to ensure that only safe food is offered for sale? Even something seemingly so self-evident as the time is regulated by international law. The vast majority of agreements and regulations that the international community has reached for practical reasons have proven to be crisis-resistant.

However, the changed political climate becomes palpable in international law where political interests are contested, such as in the United Nations Security Council. Contrary to hopes a quarter of a century ago, a lasting agreement on the enforcement of the international prohibition of the use of force has not yet been achieved. The homogeneous interest situation that allowed for unanimous decisions of the body in the 1990s no longer exists. The Security Council today is as polarized as it was before the fall of the wall. We must once again observe that the value of the rules-based system of the use of force, as provided for in the United Nations Charter, is being undermined by individual states because power-political interests weigh more heavily. Millions of people must pay the price for the paralysis of the Security Council. To all those who bear responsibility, I can only appeal not to condemn the principle of collective peacekeeping to failure.

In the area of human rights protection, great hopes have often given way to disillusionment and concern. Not only far from German borders are fundamental rights such as freedom of the press and assembly under pressure. Worldwide, millions of people are fleeing from war and severe human rights violations.

In the conflict-ridden world situation of our time, stronger legal controversies are also emerging than we were accustomed to in the harmony of the 1990s. Old powers have revived old claims to shape. Rising powers are making themselves known as ambitious co-creators of the international legal order. The willingness to understand international law as an order that binds the interests of states to overarching community interests, especially to human rights, has decreased.

Instead, priorities are becoming visible that signal a certain distance from the legal developments of the past decades. The emphasis on state sovereignty, combined with a relativization of individual rights, is not new. But when some states advocate for a significantly more restrictive interpretation of human rights, it requires our collective attention.

Intense discussions are emerging for new international legal initiatives. Some are already being conducted, for example, in negotiations in such important areas as the regulation of cyberspace.

The development of international law remains a contentious matter because the coexistence of nations is inherently shaped by conflicting interests. The international legal order is also not perfect. But in the grand historical arc, there are indeed remarkable advances. The numerous multilateral treaties, the international organizations, and the courts – this common order represents a level of understanding and joint governance that would have been unimaginable even for a pioneer of international law like Hugo Grotius.

A core component of this order is and remains the Charter of the United Nations. The great goals laid down there have lost none of their relevance.

Progress in the further development of international law requires great efforts and a long breath. That fundamental norms are repeatedly violated is painful and bitter. But the consequence cannot be to put the goal of a dignified order up for negotiation. An order that deserves that name must be equally a value, legal, and peace order.

Germany has a special interest in securing what has been achieved in international law and making further progress – out of historical obligation and in the awareness of growing international responsibility. Legitimacy, stability, and predictability – conveyed through common rules – benefit all states, including the powerful.

The states share responsibility here. Ensuring peace and international security and guaranteeing respect for human rights is a collective task. A common challenge that requires both moderation and determination: moderation to do justice to the particular orientation of international law to the respective global political situation. Determination to defend fundamental principles of international law, especially in politically tense times.

Both require support from international jurisdiction. At the founding of the Tribunal twenty years ago, the international community was guided by the far-sighted conviction that a strengthening of international jurisdiction is a gain – a gain for peace that outweighs the loss of state sovereignty.

It is concerning for the validity of international law when states refuse to cooperate with international courts or to comply with their decisions. The Tribunal is not unfamiliar with such experiences, as you all know who have gathered here today. Although, we must also admit, these are rather isolated cases. But even in proceedings of the European Court of Human Rights, there are tendencies of refusal, where states decline to ensure better protection of fundamental and freedom rights in the event of convictions. Even in states that pride themselves on their rule of law tradition, there is often a reluctance to remember the obligations that come with the recognition of supranational judicial oversight.

This also concerns international criminal justice. Significant efforts are still required to hold accountable those responsible for the worst crimes. And now more than ever, it requires intensive advocacy to secure the necessary support for the International Criminal Court.

It is not enough to establish international courts. Their value to us, whether there is a willingness to fully exploit their potential to promote peace and justice, only becomes evident through long-term political and institutional support. And powerful support from the international community, that is also my wish for your International Tribunal on its 20th anniversary.

The Tribunal has made a successful journey over the past twenty years. I am confident that it will gain even more weight: For as a dispute resolver, the Tribunal has done remarkable work. And in these crisis- and conflict-ridden times, prompt and convincing dispute resolution is needed more than ever.

The debate on the future design of the international legal order will also affect the law of the sea. How the Tribunal will articulate the protection of the seabed as the "heritage of mankind" has significance far beyond maritime law.

With challenges comes responsibility. I am sure, esteemed members of the Tribunal: It is in good hands with you. May the jurisprudence of the Tribunal help preserve the achievements in the development of international law. And may the Tribunal, in productive cooperation with the rest of the international judiciary, strengthen the awareness that state sovereignty, properly understood, cannot mean a retreat from international responsibility.

So let us pool our efforts to engage persistently and judiciously for the diverse needs and interests of states, for the great goal of peace through law.

I have presented my fundamental considerations to you today. I have not only referred to the anniversary of this day, and there is an important reason for that: It is the state in which the international community finds itself. The unresolved conflicts, the blockages, among others in the United Nations Security Council – in your presence, Mr. Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon, I wanted to make us aware of this problematic situation. With the anniversary of this Tribunal, we celebrate a milestone in the long struggle for the rule of law worldwide. I emphasize, it is a milestone, but we celebrate it because it is progress.

In doing so, I speak to you as a person who was born in war and who, as a young man, could never have imagined that here, in this Germany with its terrible history of guilt, injustice, and violations of law, an important international instance of jurisprudence would one day be based.

When I connect this wonderful event with the legal tradition of this city, we become aware that even the most terrible conditions, even the very worst conditions, can be changed through processes of transformation. Only: There must be enough people willing to participate in this change for the better. And so I connect my congratulations, which are directed to all of you who bear responsibility here, with the hope that worldwide the willingness grows to not end the victorious march of the "Rule of Law" at some intermediate station, but to continue it further.

To you, Mr. Secretary-General of the United Nations, I thank you for your diverse efforts in this direction. We bid farewell to you, as Secretary-General, with great gratitude and respect. It has been a great work that you have accomplished, and I want to take this opportunity to thank you not only for being here but also for what you have done for the international community.

To you, Mr. Secretary-General, and to you, Mr. President of the Court Golizyn, and to the Court, my very best wishes.