Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck at the festive event "Human and Machine – in Good Company?" of the German Academy of Engineering Sciences acatech on the 12th of ...

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

26 October 2016 · Festive event "Human and Machine – in Good Company?" of the German Academy of Engineering Sciences acatech

Context
Gauck spoke at an acatech festive event on humans and machines in Berlin on October 26, 2016, addressing the societal implications of robotics and autonomous systems.
Main themes
Humans and machines coexistence, robotics and autonomous systems, societal impact of automation, caregiving technology, industrial transformation, economic potential of robotics, ethical frameworks for AI, labor and employment, quality of life, German engineering and innovation, fears and hopes about technology
Duration
~19 min
63rd percentile
Words
2,267
63rd percentile
Sentences
125
73rd percentile
Readability
50
64th percentile
Grade
10.7
29th percentile
Syntax
2.93
38th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
27th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Technological 35%35%
  • Economic 32%32%
  • Social 21%21%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Institutional 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

125 sentences in 27 paragraphs

The word "robot" evokes ambivalent feelings, at least for most people: there are hopes, but also fears. Not entirely blameless in this is a Czech writer whom many do not even know: Karel Čapek was the one who introduced the term into literature in 1920. In his play "R.U.R.," a business-savvy company appears that manufactures universal robots. These are cheap working machines that have no needs. They produce goods in abundance, perform all services, and enable people to live a life without effort and worries. The managing director is sure: now it begins with the long-awaited paradise on earth. He thinks this until he realizes that his business model has a catch. The robots develop a soul and begin to rebel against their masters. And it happens as it must in the drama: in the end, they wipe out all of humanity.

Čapek revives a primal fear of humanity that has always shaped our relationship with machines. To this day, the motif of the ominous rule of automatons is varied in numerous novels and films, and it sometimes resonates when modern robots are reported on in the media.

It was another writer, a grandmaster of science fiction, who took up arms against this Frankenstein complex: Isaac Asimov advocated for seeing robots not as metaphors and projection surfaces of our fears, but simply as machines, as devices. In his stories, he does not portray them as copies of humans, but as technical assistants that are wisely employed and perform their work as expected. And he creates the famous "Three Laws of Robotics," principles that are meant to enable a good coexistence of humans and machines. It is Asimov's merit that he, beyond fantasies of salvation and doom, thought about how a society could function in which humans and robots work together decades ago.

He anticipated a topic that we have turned to today and must continue to address in science and business, in society and politics. Because much of what he placed in the future is already a reality for us today or could soon become reality. If what you, the experts, predict is true, then we are at the beginning of a development that will fundamentally change our living environment in the coming years. And that means: machines will accompany us more frequently in everyday life, both in work and in private life.

Many people in our country, and I include myself here, still need more information about what our lives could look like when autonomous systems become our helpers. It is therefore good that the German Academy of Engineering Sciences is tackling this topic.

So far, we know stationary industrial robots in Germany; they have been around for quite some time. I have seen them screwing, welding, and painting behind safety barriers. Soon, however, mobile specimens will enter factories – they already exist in some places – and work alongside human colleagues, literally hand in hand. Not only in the workshop, but also in the office, learning systems will support employees in their work. On the street, in households, or in nursing homes, we will encounter intelligent machines or be accompanied by them at every turn, for example, when implants or wearable devices compensate for impaired sensory perceptions, restore lost bodily functions, or collect and process medical data.

We are thus living in an age of tremendous possibilities. Technological innovations can enhance our quality of life and increase productivity. And they can help us tackle the great societal challenges of our time.

I will name three examples:

In caregiving, technical assistants could help people stay longer in their familiar environment – granting them more autonomy and preserving their privacy. In road traffic, autonomous and connected vehicles could reduce the number of fatal accidents or at least alleviate traffic jams – thus conserving resources and reducing environmental impact. And in industrial production, assistance robots could not only increase efficiency and quality but also take on physically demanding tasks – thereby relieving older workers in particular.

Last but not least, the development of robots and autonomous systems holds great economic potential. Demand is already high, and economists tell us that the market will grow rapidly in the coming years. Germany now has a good starting position to be successful in global competition – also because many companies are already testing the new computers and robots in industrial production. Just recently, I visited the region of East Westphalia-Lippe. I looked at companies there modernizing their production and learned that almost every workpiece can be individually manufactured for each customer in the future. In some industries, it is no longer worthwhile to relocate a factory, for example, to Southeast Asia. Some activities have returned from there to Germany, to our high-wage country. This strengthens our industrial middle class, which many countries already envy us for.

However, as we know, we do not want to become complacent; we must become better and faster at turning research results into market-ready products. How this can work is demonstrated to me every year by researchers and developers at the awarding of the German Future Prize. An event that has become particularly dear to my heart is, of course, the President's Prize for Technology and Innovation. This forum is for me a constant proof that we have the right, the freedom, the strength, and the ability to become future-proof. What you may notice daily, I notice as a layperson at such events: We need even more experimental spaces where science, business, and society can exchange ideas early on. And of course, we also need more courage in investing in innovative projects, less fear of risk, and, related to that, less fear of failure.

I must take a moment to pause here: I like, want, and will not understand in the future that a nation, which is capable of naming future goals in so many questions and also opening and walking paths into the future, lives so often in a constant feeling of cultural discomfort. That simply does not make sense to me. What we feel does not align correctly with what we could perceive. Why is it that we are so hesitant to spend what we have in innovative potential, what we also have in enthusiasm for solutions, as if it were a currency that one cannot really trust? I wish that this, let’s say in five years, when another president speaks to you, may have completely changed.

Now I owe it to you to also inform you that I am not completely naive.

So, with all the enthusiasm for the technical and economic possibilities of our time, we must of course also always consider that there are risks that we must take seriously. And that we must not dismiss hastily. We are aware of the multitude of social, ethical, legal, and cultural questions that exist and that we must face. But I believe we should do this with a pioneering spirit. With confidence that we will succeed in mastering these challenges together.

What moves people in our country the most is the change in the world of work. Some fear, and one can understand this, some simply fear losing their jobs: the robot is faster, better, cheaper. What will become of me? We know from the history of technological development: the introduction of the steam engine, assembly line, and computer has always cost jobs. What later became clear is that countless new jobs were also created. And so far, it has been the case that at every new level of automation, more people could work than before, often in better professions. Today, no one knows exactly how digitalization, the fourth stage of the industrial revolution, will affect the labor market.

Scientists only agree on one point: in many industries and professions, the division of labor between humans and machines will change. Robots will not only take on simple tasks but increasingly also complex thinking tasks. This opens up new perspectives for humans, creating new fields of work with new tasks and requirements. It will often depend on combining human qualities, such as creativity and empathy, with the precision, endurance, and computational capabilities of machines. In the process, job profiles will change. A product developer, for example, could work in a team whose members are distributed all over the globe and connected via a data line. We already know how this works; it will expand. I recently looked at such virtual processes in East Westphalia, in a so-called laboratory of the future.

The change in the world of work poses far-reaching questions for us. Which tasks can and do we want to leave to machines in the future, and which do we want to leave to humans? How can we prepare trainees and employees for changing requirements? Whatever the answers will be in detail, one thing is clear: humans must retain control over workflows in the future. They must be the "conductors of technology," not subservient assistants to it.

When robots work with us or cars move independently through cities, there will not only be encounters but sometimes also accidents. We must therefore fundamentally clarify who should bear responsibility when people are harmed by the actions of machines. We must not carelessly dilute or even abandon the classic concept of responsibility, which is based on the autonomous individual. That is why it is good that we are now discussing how much control we want to relinquish to assistance systems while driving, to name a concrete example.

Another aspect that concerns people in our country is data protection. Many innovative devices and programs can only deliver their benefits if they collect, process, and network personal data. New business models have already emerged that touch on users' privacy. What we need here is a reliable legal framework.

We often still lack knowledge about how new technologies will affect us in the long term. There is a great need for research across disciplinary boundaries. In principle, it holds true: robots and machines must serve us humans, not the other way around. They should be guided by our wishes and needs. We must not relinquish human dignity to robots, to put it bluntly. This human dignity is emphasized in our constitution; it is too valuable to us. Every person must also be able to freely determine their life in the future.

Especially because we want progress, we should also ask ourselves what we might lose if we let machines act for us. Automation makes life easier; it helps us reach our goals faster. But it also distances us a bit from the world, from the closeness of humans to humans. When we let specific tasks be taken from us, we also have fewer experiences and perhaps acquire less knowledge.

In the face of machines, we also become aware of what makes us human. The robot, as "smart" as it may be, lacks social and emotional intelligence. It has neither empathy nor does it feel morally responsible. It does not know what it means to be in a body and grow up in a specific social environment. There are infinitely many situations in which it cannot replace humans. And there are many situations in which people prefer to deal with other people rather than with a machine; that is quite clear.

In our democratically and market-oriented society, technology cannot be imposed on people. We, the citizens, are the ones who must make decisions. We should all clarify what is technically feasible and economically sensible. We should discuss what is desirable, but also what is ethically justifiable, for the individual and for society as a whole, including for future generations. I often wonder if we do this with sufficient rigor. However, I am sure: an open debate is the key to creating acceptance for innovations. And it prepares the ground on which political decisions can then mature.

Scientists and engineers bear a special responsibility in this regard. They must explain their projects and inform about possible consequences, as long as they can assess them themselves – and they should be able to. Entrepreneurs introducing new technologies in their companies should involve employees in a partnership and also address their needs. Last but not least, it is the task of politicians and journalists, as well as social scientists and philosophers, to convey and discuss technical topics in a clear and understandable language.

In a society that still depends on highly developed technology, we need a deeper understanding of science. And that is why I would like to explicitly commend the work of your academy, all those responsible, and all the people and institutions that support it. You promote collaboration among disciplines, strengthen the exchange with the economy, and provide important impulses for political debates. I would like to encourage you: Build even more bridges into the world of machines. Open the laboratories and workshops, bring your current knowledge to the people, and not just to the initiated. We all need your ideas and visions, yes: We need science fiction, but in the best, in the serious sense.

Isaac Asimov was right: Those who want to shape the relationship between humans and machines must not be blinded by horror scenarios and salvation expectations. So let us always clearly name the concrete opportunities and risks. Let us discuss what kind of society we want to live in with robots and autonomous systems. It is nothing less than the question of what role we humans want to assign ourselves in this world.

And with that, I have come to the end and thank you for your great patience in listening to me as a layperson.