Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck at the celebration event "40 Years of Co-Determination Act '76" on June 30, 2016, in Berlin:

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

1 July 2016 · Celebration event "40 Years of Co-Determination Act '76" · Berlin, Germany

Context
Gauck addressed a celebration event in Berlin on June 30, 2016, marking the 40th anniversary of Germany's Co-Determination Act of 1976.
Main themes
Co-determination, social partnership, trade union history, workers' participation, social market economy, labor-management relations, German industrial democracy, economic freedom and justice, collective bargaining, postwar reconstruction, identity and national culture
Duration
~20 min
66th percentile
Words
2,440
66th percentile
Sentences
134
76th percentile
Readability
40
37th percentile
Grade
12.1
47th percentile
Syntax
2.99
46th percentile
Vocabulary
2.31
75th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 31%31%
  • Social 31%31%
  • Institutional 16%16%
  • Ceremonial 14%14%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

134 sentences in 30 paragraphs

I am pleased that you have welcomed me so kindly. I value trade unions because I have spent 50 years of my life in areas where they were banned. That is how heartfelt relationships are formed!

However, there are other reasons why I gladly accepted your invitation. What moves you, dear trade unionists, and what you achieve is important for our country, and it is also important for the citizen and President Gauck. That we in Germany have learned to link economic freedom with participation, with the pursuit of justice and social solidarity, is something that trade unions have significantly contributed to.

Among the successes of this learning process is co-determination – co-determination in businesses and companies. Often, there have been – and we do not want to forget this – hard conflicts because of it, but ultimately, a balance of interests has always been achieved, sometimes after tough struggles. And so, you, Mr. Hoffmann, have also invited representatives of the employers to this festive evening. I was pleased to see how warmly you welcomed Mr. Kramer. Co-determination and the acceptance of co-determination is lived social partnership. And co-determination is the invitation to every single employee to shape and participate in "their" company – it is an offer to overcome lamenting passivity, a possibility for self-confident and responsible action.

It has now been 40 years since employees gained more say and control over company management. Tomorrow marks the anniversary of the enactment of the "Law on Co-Determination of Employees," as it was and is called. This law is one of the core elements of our culture of cooperation and consensus, which I would like to acknowledge in its entirety today, as it is formative for our social market economy. I align myself with the words of former constitutional judge Udo Di Fabio, who writes that co-determination is "a piece of grown national culture" with "identity-forming effect."

Looking at this growth, it becomes clear: Co-determination has always been closely linked with new beginnings and determination. Determination to change things for the common good. It is no coincidence that the beginnings of co-determination, one could say the original beginnings, are dated to the revolutionary year of 1848.

The departure from class struggle and the path to a culture of cooperation and consensus – for both sides, this was a difficult process of self-discovery that touched on their own self-understanding. What seems remarkable to me is that alongside the bitter conflicts that accompanied the introduction of co-determination rights under imperial rule and later in the Weimar Republic, there were also germ cells of voluntary co-determination at that time. The strength that German social partnership has today has been gained because both employees and employers increasingly internalized that they both benefit more in the long run from working together than from working against each other.

And there is another insight that both social partners share: that co-determination provides freedom, freedom from state paternalism. Where this freedom is suppressed, there is also no co-determination – as happened under the National Socialists and later in the GDR.

Co-determination experienced decisive boosts in the years following the world wars, when it was about coping with the political, economic, and social catastrophe. The trade unions also had to start anew. The largest, IG Metall, celebrated its 125th anniversary at the beginning of this month. I would like to extend my heartfelt belated congratulations at this point.

IG Metall, together with its counterpart on the employer side, formed the laboratory in which co-determination was tested in the young Federal Republic. I mean here the coal and steel co-determination. All those involved, company and union leaders, were clear at that time that rebuilding required joint efforts. Nevertheless, there were passionate discussions and debates before the agreement on the so-called Montan solution was reached in 1951. Hans Böckler, one of the great pioneers of co-determination, was even inspired by "William Tell." Co-determination was about, as the former DGB chairman called out, "reaching out into the sky and bringing down those rights that hang above, inalienable, unbreakable like the stars themselves." You can sense what an epochal step that was, which challenged the people who were actively shaping things at that time.

In a more sober tone, but no less passionately in substance, the next major stage of co-determination took place two decades later: in the dispute over the expansion of co-determination to large companies in all sectors. When the co-determination law was finally presented, neither employers nor trade unions were satisfied – of course for different reasons.

In light of the long struggles between employers and employees, it is remarkable how these very fighters have managed to arrange themselves in practice – that they have repeatedly succeeded in reconciling profit interests and social interests. This productive cooperation gives cause for pride and gratitude. It has provided a broad population with prosperity, work under good conditions, and proper social security – and not least the promise of participation and advancement. But not everyone has been able to benefit in this way, we know that too, and new developments in the labor market, such as new forms of employment, are causing concern for many people.

Co-determination is, of course, not an insurance policy against unwanted side effects of new beginnings and upheavals. For many employees in East Germany, the path to the social market economy, as beneficial as it was overall, also had painful consequences. However, it is fundamentally true: By involving employees in decisions about the future of businesses and companies, hardships can be mitigated and new perspectives can be found together.

Especially during the financial crisis, we Germans were able to benefit from the prudent and flexible cooperation of the social partners, supported by wise decisions from the legislator. For companies in distress, management and works councils negotiated tailored solutions at that time. Mass layoffs could thus be avoided. And one more thing has largely been spared us in economically difficult times, not least thanks to employee participation: permanent confrontations and permanent blockades. We know the possible consequences from other countries: macroeconomic damage on a large scale, burdens for citizens, and a social climate of distrust between employers and employees. How easily can all this lead to stagnation, even to the decline of entire sectors of the economy. And on a societal level, something is also missing, a crucial stabilizing element. Our German experience is that society as a whole benefits when cooperative solutions are found in working life. That is why I also take representatives of trade unions with me on many of my trips abroad. It is the pride in a cultural asset that we can showcase to the world.

It is clear that at anniversaries, one praises the honoree; I have done that and will continue to do so. But one must also ask in such moments: What does the future look like? Where structures solidify over decades, all parties should carefully observe whether weaknesses arise or whether adjustments become necessary as times change.

Even in the conception of co-determination, a dilemma emerges. For the employee representatives on the supervisory board, an ambivalent role is ascribed. They are, of course, representatives of the workforce, but they are also committed to the well-being of the company. This balancing act can succeed, as practice has often shown.

However, combining control and cooperation well is not easy, especially in times of crisis. Ideally, co-determination then bundles forces for modernization. It becomes difficult when, in critical market situations, inertia prevails in the company and in the supervisory board, and necessary innovations and market adjustments are postponed. As shapers of co-determination, employers and employees are therefore always faced with the task of organizing cooperation in such a way that innovations remain possible and even desired.

There is no shortage of changes that require new thinking and action. Some employees are feeling this acutely. Internationalization, digitalization, and flexibility raise questions about the future of economic and working life, as well as about the future of co-determination. In this situation, it is important for all parties to ask themselves: How can the traditional ideas of co-determination remain effective in the future?

I would like to highlight two aspects: co-determination in the European context and co-determination in the context of a changing world of work.

First, let us look at the European debate. In our partner countries, it is emphasized that employee participation is a "core component of a social Europe." The German co-determination has also gained recognition after its success in the financial crisis, even in countries that are otherwise reserved towards collective forms of employee participation.

Let me add the following: We do not want to impose our way of co-determination on anyone. But I think Germany has something to offer in terms of employee participation. And shouldn't we report on good experiences? This cooperation between two parties that were antagonistic to each other in earlier times often surprises people in the host country. Yes, for some, it is a culture shock. In fact, this cooperation is part of Central European culture, and we know who has contributed particularly intensively to this culture. We will always express our gratitude to these people, these groups, these parties, and these trade unions.

In some countries, trade unions are also resisting a corporate co-determination as practiced in Germany. And in some European member states, the forces advocating for employee participation have also come under pressure. Accordingly, the debate over European regulations on co-determination is quite controversial. The dispute over the participation of employees in the newly created European Company lasted particularly long and fiercely – for more than 30 years. And the discussion continues. Because this European legal form allows for a flexibility and heterogeneity in co-determination issues that is quite new for us in Germany. This presents opportunities, but of course also risks. And it raises sensitive questions: Do the regulations for the European Company promote the erosion of our traditional German co-determination system? At its core, it is about the very question that has always ignited the co-determination debate: How far does entrepreneurial freedom extend, and how can it be reconciled with the interests of employees?

In recent decades, employees and employers, together with politics, have succeeded in providing answers here in Germany that have advanced the country economically and socially. There is thus a wealth of experience available when it comes to shaping co-determination in the European context. I know this task is difficult. But difficult tasks are challenges, and solving them brings a special satisfaction. But was the struggle for participation in businesses and companies ever easy? Did it happen by itself? I do not think so. Those who were there at the time know better than I do. Co-determination was and is a constant struggle for balance, control, and participation. And the results of this struggle, I am convinced, are worth seeing.

The basis of our ability to find balance is a conviction that still seems to me to be guiding: Long-term economic success should be the result of a lasting balance of interests. Our social market economy is not a model for maximum and short-term profit. It is profit-oriented, but also a model of pacification and participation – thus a model with a future, of that I am deeply convinced.

I come to my second point: co-determination in the context of the changing world of work. A phenomenon of this change is the merging of the real and virtual worlds. We still do not know exactly what this change will mean in practice. But with all due caution, it can be said that work structures and work models are becoming more heterogeneous. Our co-determination model is essentially oriented towards the classic employment relationship in the company. So how should we respond when work is organized more decentralized and individually? The Hans Böckler Foundation has already engaged in intensive considerations on this. And I would like to encourage all of you, esteemed guests, to participate in the explorations for a future-oriented employee participation!

In this exploration, it is worthwhile to also consider the historical roots of co-determination. Among these roots is something particularly valuable: it is the idea of human dignity. A person should not be made an object of the work process; they should be able to contribute as a self-determined individual. However, for self-determination to unfold, it must also be enforced and secured. Protecting and promoting the interests of the individual, through the bundling of many forces, is what enables co-determination in the workplace as well as in the supervisory board. However, it cannot be denied: collective representation of interests, especially in times of declining collective agreements and highly individualized corporate structures, is difficult, not only for trade unions. Prophecies such as "self-determination replaces co-determination" have been accompanying the debate about the changes in the world of work for quite some time.

I say this: that would not be a desirable option for me. Of course, co-determination rules should not hinder the self-realization of employees. And perhaps in the past, there has sometimes been the impression that those involved in co-determination did not take employees as responsible economic citizens seriously enough.

But the problem has now been recognized. Here is a quote: "If co-determination wants to assert its function, it must think and act more than ever from the perspective of the individual and not limit itself to securing status." Perhaps these words sound familiar to you? They are an appeal from the Hans Böckler Foundation. Co-determination can only function in alliance with self-determination. And even though I am speaking here at the invitation of the DGB and the Hans Böckler Foundation, I want to mention that, of course, the legitimate interests of entrepreneurs must also be taken into account. These are also interests of self-determination.

Co-determination is therefore a demanding achievement that requires joint care and further development by employers, employees, and trade unions, as well as wise framework setting by politics. Co-determination has always thrived on visions for a better working world, on a sense of what is feasible, and on the confidence that economic and social benefits can best be increased in a community of responsibility. This must also be the case in the future when it comes to adapting co-determination to new challenges.

In conclusion: There is this beautiful old workers' and wanderer's song by Hermann Claudius, the great-grandson of Mathias Claudius – "When we march side by side." In the refrain, it has always been sung: "With us comes the new time." This claim to design, carried by optimism, I wish for all of you on this anniversary of co-determination.

In this sense: Good luck!