Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck on the change of judges at the Federal Constitutional Court - Dismissal and honoring of Herbert Landau as well as appointment of Christine Langenfeld on the 20th ...

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

22 August 2016 · Change of judges at the Federal Constitutional Court · Schloss Bellevue

Context
Gauck addressed a judicial change ceremony at Schloss Bellevue on 22 August 2016, honoring retiring Federal Constitutional Court judge Herbert Landau and appointing Christine Langenfeld.
Main themes
Independent judiciary, rule of law, judicial appointment ceremony, Herbert Landau's career and retirement, Christine Langenfeld's appointment, constitutional court independence, freedom and responsibility, German reunification contributions, democratic order, criticism of courts
Duration
~13 min
46th percentile
Words
1,586
46th percentile
Sentences
80
52nd percentile
Readability
44
47th percentile
Grade
11.8
43rd percentile
Syntax
3.02
50th percentile
Vocabulary
2.28
69th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 41%38%
  • Institutional 32%30%
  • Ceremonial 24%23%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 8%

80 sentences in 21 paragraphs

Welcome to all of you here at Schloss Bellevue.

We are gathered for a change of judges, and obviously, changes of judges always come as a surprise – much like Christmas! The political sphere was evidently a bit surprised by your retirement, dear Mr. Landau, which is why you had to stay in office longer. But today is the day, and I can now release you into your well-deserved retirement.

I would like to take this change of judges as an opportunity to point out something that needs special emphasis in this time and these days: an independent judiciary as a Conditio sine qua non of a rule of law. That independent judges control the actions of state power and, if necessary, place them within legal limits is an indispensable civilizational achievement. At least that is how this Germany sees it. Therefore, we cannot silently accept when, in the world, whether near or far, the guardian role of the judiciary is called into question and the executive and legislative branches seek to evade the controls of the courts.

This does not mean that criticism of the judiciary is unheard of. As a theologian, I must add that the judiciary also belongs to the realm of the fallen world, much like the church. Therefore, criticism must also be allowed here, and the Federal Constitutional Court must, as experience shows, also face such criticism of its rulings. You all, dear members of the Constitutional Court, have experienced this. Criticism of court rulings is part of the rule of law and our free democratic order, part of the discourse in society. However, it has a different quality when the responsibilities and control competencies of the courts, especially the constitutional courts, are to be curtailed or bypassed. Democratic rule-of-law states thrive on an independent judiciary, on the respect and compliance with rulings by all citizens, the politically responsible, and the other constitutional institutions. Legal fidelity and legal obedience are fragile goods – especially constitutional jurisdiction, which has hardly any means to enforce rulings, relies on this legal fidelity. And an independent judiciary needs independent judicial personalities. With that, I would like to return to you, dear Mr. Landau, after these general remarks.

As an "unusual," indeed "exotic" newcomer, you were introduced in the media when the Bundesrat elected you as a judge of the Federal Constitutional Court in 2005. Your biography continues to attract attention, even from me: "From Baker to Top Judge," was one of the headlines. It may be that this shortening of your life path does not suit you. But it is remarkable that a baker boy from Siegerland first embarked on the path of the artisanal family tradition, then worked as a social worker, and at the age of 26, married and with two small children, began a law degree. This foundation, on which your impressive career in the judiciary and judicial policy is built, can encourage young people and inspire them to develop their talents and abilities. That is what I particularly like, as I see myself as an encourager, as one of those who turn to those in society who cannot yet fully believe in the potential within them and the opportunities our society offers them. That is why I enjoy telling such stories.

Your own driving force was, as you have described it, dear Mr. Landau, the chance to shape your own life while also contributing to societal developments.

You had the opportunity to do so – in historically significant times, during which you, as a representative of the Hessian judiciary, prepared the unification treaty in a Bonn judicial working group during the negotiations for German reunification. This was followed by the organization and coordination of Hessian reconstruction aid for the judiciary in Thuringia. For your contributions to realizing the Basic Law and the democratic rule of law and social state for all Germans, I would like to sincerely thank you today – also on behalf of all those who were engaged at that time.

Individual freedom is, for you, inextricably linked to responsibility and social duty. I wholeheartedly agree with your statement, "Freedom lived without responsibility destroys community" – a quote in which I also see my own understanding of freedom expressed. This realization and your Christian faith have motivated you from a young age to engage socially in the church. Later, as a social worker, you worked with convicted offenders. You know the realities of criminal enforcement and also the efforts of rehabilitation, a life reality that even the most thorough theoretical studies can never fully illuminate.

Social motivations were also what led to your career as a lawyer largely taking place in the field of criminal law. You were a criminal judge, a senior public prosecutor, and finally, for three years, a reviewing judge in the 1st Criminal Senate of the Federal Court of Justice. As State Secretary in the Hessian Ministry of Justice, you initiated a cross-party model project for the aftercare of released violent and sexual offenders together with Saxony-Anhalt.

How should the state deal with people who have fallen to the margins of society and crossed the boundaries of the law? How can offenders be reintegrated into the center of society? How can victims be helped? These were never just legal or legal-political questions for you, but also humanitarian ones. Engaging with people, doing justice to their personalities, indeed taking a "deep insight into the soul," into "the good and the evil," was part of your judicial self-understanding.

In criminal law, you also prepared important decisions as a rapporteur: the ruling on plea bargaining in criminal proceedings, for example, which permits the so-called "deal" within narrow limits. Or the decision on preventive detention, after which the legislature had to reshape the handling of dangerous sexual and violent offenders. You also significantly influenced the case law to strengthen the right to self-determination of churches and the principles of civil service. Overall, as a rapporteur, you prepared more than 4,200 cases. And this number is noteworthy because it illustrates the workload that a Federal Constitutional Court judge has to manage. I wish the public knew more about this.

In your offices, the person Herbert Landau was always visible. Independence, down-to-earthness, steadfastness, clear positions – these are qualities that those who know you and work with you appreciate. For some, this may have been quite uncomfortable – for process representatives, perhaps, from whom you expected answers in oral proceedings that followed the Siegerland maxim: "A word is a word for us. We do not beat around the bush." You were concerned with getting to the bottom of a matter, illuminating an argument, distinguishing the unimportant from the important.

Beneath the rough exterior of Herbert Landau lies a soft core – there we meet the lover of Mozart, the family man for whom his wife, children, and grandchildren are particularly important. The Herbert Landau who is shaped by a deep humanity and love for people! Your older brother acknowledged this trait when he honored you in the liber amicorum by reflecting on 1 Corinthians 13.

Dear Mr. Landau,

Your term in Karlsruhe is coming to an end. But you will not cease your commitment to the state and society; rather, you will engage voluntarily to continue to bring the principles and freedoms of the Basic Law to life.

Dear Mr. Landau, you have rendered exceptional service to our country. For that, I thank you – both as President and personally – from the bottom of my heart. It is my pleasure to now award you the Grand Cross of Merit with Star and Shoulder Ribbon of the Federal Republic of Germany as a sign of recognition.

Dear Ms. Langenfeld,

I am pleased to see you again, and my joy is particularly great because I will appoint you today as a judge of the Federal Constitutional Court. On July 8, the Bundesrat elected you to this office. My heartfelt congratulations on this equally honorable and demanding task.

As a professor of constitutional law, you have been dealing with the constitutional state and constitutional life for decades. From the very beginning of your academic career, you have not only focused on German law but have also looked beyond borders. Your studies in law took you, among other places, to France. Your academic career has been shaped by European law as well as by current social and legal-political issues. "The Equal Treatment of Men and Women in European Community Law" is the title of your doctoral thesis. And in 2000, you habilitated with a work on the integration and cultural identity of immigrant minorities – a topic that still occupies us intensely today and has brought us together on various occasions. Other focal points of your research include education, religious issues, and social cohesion. Since 2000, you have been teaching and researching as a professor of public law at the Georg-August University of Göttingen. In 2012, you took over the chair of the Expert Council of German Foundations for Integration and Migration – an office that has brought us together at events and in discussions on issues of immigration and refugee policy.

In the future, you will enrich the Federal Constitutional Court with your expertise and scientific knowledge.

Ms. Langenfeld, my heartfelt congratulations! Many new challenges await you in Karlsruhe. I know: Your new colleagues will welcome you warmly and make your start easy. For the new chapter of life that begins for you today, I wish you all the best and God's blessings.