Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck at the celebration of the 100th birthday of Karl Carstens on December 8, 2014, in Bonn:

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

20 December 2014 · Celebration of the 100th birthday of Karl Carstens · Bonn, Germany

Context
Gauck addressed a celebration organized by the Konrad Adenauer Foundation marking the 100th birthday of former Federal President Karl Carstens, held in Bonn on December 8, 2014.
Main themes
Karl Carstens centenary commemoration, civic duty and democratic commitment, the 'Wandering President' hiking initiative, proximity between leaders and citizens, pragmatic realism in politics, German democracy and constitutional state, environmental awareness in the 1980s, transition from East and West Germany, legacy of Federal Presidents, Konrad Adenauer Foundation
Duration
~23 min
72nd percentile
Words
2,756
72nd percentile
Sentences
151
81st percentile
Readability
48
56th percentile
Grade
11.1
33rd percentile
Syntax
2.94
40th percentile
Vocabulary
2.29
72nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 31%26%
  • Social 29%25%
  • Geopolitical 18%15%
  • Ceremonial 16%14%
  • Environmental 6%5%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 14%

151 sentences in 39 paragraphs

In my life, I have sung so little about becoming President, as Karl Carstens has experienced. He did not come from distinguished circles, but carved his way from the bottom to the top of a free republic. And that I, who have often looked longingly from the East at what has taken place here in the German Parliament of freedom, can speak at this place on various occasions and now also honor a Federal President, is a special gift of history. And it fills me with deep gratitude.

Today we honor a man whose service to the community we consider outstanding, whose commitment to promoting the constitutionally free state was exemplary. That is why we gather here in good spirits and with confidence, because the memory of such an attitude and such actions should strengthen us ourselves. Karl Carstens' pragmatic realism, his sense of duty, and the convincing representation of democracy and our community can still provide us with guidance today. He was known as a realist and pragmatist. In retrospect, however, those elements of his thinking emerge that reach into our time.

Therefore, I am very grateful to the Konrad Adenauer Foundation for inviting us to this memorial event for the 100th birthday of Karl Carstens – I gladly accepted this invitation.

For this gives us the opportunity to view the world of Karl Carstens anew and to spiritually traverse his republic – our republic! – Yes, to wander.

With the "Wander-President," we thus embark once again into that time.

While wandering, one feels that the cheerfulness that moved his contemporaries occasionally arises. This began during his inaugural speech, where he informed the German public that he would walk through the republic during his term, on foot, in stages, from the Baltic Sea to the Alps. Of course, there are critics when one announces such a project.

And they immediately concluded: old-fashioned, somehow provincial! Wandering: Who does that? Somewhat traditionalist, this Federal President. And that after the wild times of the 1968 era.

Yet Karl Carstens had an interesting plan. On the one hand, he could embrace a current of the times and at the same time question it in a reserved manner. Concern for the environment had particularly captured young people at that time. Carstens shared this concern, but wanted to counter the general criticism of growth and civilization. It was, of course, also the milieu from which these topics were very forcefully raised, by the then very young green movement. That did not suit Carstens, we need not hide that.

He then set out in his own way to explore the natural beauties of Germany – on foot. This was a rather peculiar, as a North German I would say, a solid invitation to the bourgeoisie to take a closer look at what actually makes our country. At that time, the so-called "forest dying" was a challenge. During his hikes, Carstens also faced demonstrators who drew special attention to this issue. He was then able to conduct conversations in his own way, for example, about the idea of introducing lead-free gasoline.

"On the way," wrote a major newspaper, "the mockers ran out of air." The Federal President was indeed on the move with open eyes. And so, on his hikes, he encountered not only the spruce and the fir, the bear's garlic and the sundew, but he met people, and indeed very many people. At first, there were dozens accompanying him, later hundreds, finally thousands. They gladly brought provisions and gifts or sang something for him. That was a wonderful opportunity for encounters with the citizens. After 60 days and 1,600 kilometers, Karl Carstens and his wife Veronica, who often accompanied him, were no longer strangers to any concerns that existed in this country.

At the beginning of his term, the Bremer Karl Carstens was regarded as rather north German-cool, perhaps also as Hanseatic-strict. But now his warmth, even affection, became apparent. He was able to create closeness and break down barriers. He showed – like his predecessor Walter Scheel – that the dignity of the office can indeed coexist with proximity to the citizens. A chasm between representatives and the represented need not exist, we all know that. For in democracy, every citizen is equal. And authority is only temporarily granted in it, through election. And at the center, as we know, is always the sovereign, our people. By endorsing these views, Karl Carstens demonstrated a conception of office to which Federal Presidents still feel committed today. To empathize with others is not something everyone can do. Karl Carstens earned this quality, and perhaps he may also be regarded as a wanderer – not least because he was also a wanderer between worlds.

He moved back and forth between the private sector and academia, between ministerial bureaucracy and politics. He was a lawyer and a diplomat, a university lecturer and a parliamentarian, a state secretary and then President of the Bundestag. He brought experiences from one sphere into the other. His career is an early example of a versatile career with a remarkable outcome.

Karl Carstens can also be seen as a role model for rising through education. Look around in our political landscape. You will repeatedly see this model in the various parties. It would be terrible if this were no longer possible in our country in the future. We are working to ensure that it remains so.

Karl Carstens never knew his father; he fell in World War I, even before the birth of his son. The struggles of fatherlessness and the looming social decline shaped Carstens' youth. And yet, talent, diligence, and a willingness to perform carried him into an educational path that led him to a professorship and ultimately to the highest office of our state.

Carstens' career began when the Federal Republic was founded. His rapid rise is in many ways a reflection of this republic. He belonged to that generation that had to grapple with the confusions, burdens, and various guilt during the Nazi dictatorship.

And he had to draw these lessons for himself. When he ran for the office of Federal President in 1979, parts of the public did not believe in this learning process. They saw Carstens' election as the pinnacle of repression. For he had been a member of the NSDAP. In fact, at that time, pressure had been exerted on Carstens to join the party in order to become a lawyer. Karl Carstens yielded. And, as he later formulated, against his own "better convictions." He himself said at the time that he had been "entangled." He used this word. Carstens did not seek an intensive, especially public, confrontation with his objectively low level of entanglement.

When he ran for the office of Federal President, the necessary confrontation with the history of National Socialism had by then reached large parts of the population. In those years, the realization had grown of how many public figures had indeed been entangled, in one way or another. There was also something like a systemic entanglement, which was often without personal guilt. But it existed, and at different times, people were willing to talk about it in different ways.

From today's perspective, the controversies of that time illustrate what painful processes were necessary to give the Federal Republic, despite its past, such a respectable profile. From today's perspective, we can and must say that some things would have been easier back then if more affected individuals had named and acknowledged guilt as guilt earlier. But it is one of the great achievements of post-war history to have built a new house of democracy on the ruins of totalitarianism, on deep guilt and moral failure. Certainly, only a few representatives of the early Federal Republic could look back on a biography without entanglement and without contradiction. But most of those who took on responsibility in the state and society and engaged in the democratic parties drew an important conclusion from the experience of their generation: that only an unconditional commitment to democracy and the rule of law could lead Germany into the future and that the dignity of man and the fundamental rights of the individual were at the core of this republic. Karl Carstens credibly and convincingly represented this realization. For this, we are grateful to him.

At the beginning of his professional career, he did not seek the path into public service. After liberation, he wanted to remain distant from the state. But he reflected early, in 1948, after a formative experience – a study stay at Yale University in America.

There he encountered the spirit of freedom and a willingness to engage for the common good, which inspired him and which he brought back to Bremen. Later, he habilitated with a work on the American Constitution. Finally, it only took the invitation of his mentor, the Mayor of Bremen, Wilhelm Kaisen, one of the founding figures of the Federal Republic. By the way, he had early on advocated for West integration as a Social Democrat. Let us remind ourselves these days how important it is for this country not to deviate from a path that was so important for Germany, for divided Germany as well as for reunified Germany. For this reason, it is a great pleasure for me at this point to express my gratitude by naming such a vigilant and wonderful Social Democrat. The Adenauer Foundation surely has no objection to that.

With the help of Wilhelm Kaisen, Karl Carstens found himself back in public service. From then on, and until his death, he was convinced that Germany's place must be alongside the free peoples. The maintenance of close relations with the United States of America was "at the top of all foreign policy considerations" for him. Germany needed friends and allies, and it found them in the West within the framework of the European Community and NATO. For those who wanted to engage in responsible politics could not overlook the power of the great neighbor to the East. In the Western alliance, Carstens saw, as he said, the foundation for a "powerful, secure, free-democratic Federal Republic."

For Carstens, the diplomat who quickly rose to state secretary, the great task of the post-war period was reconciliation with France. And he actively participated in that. He dealt intensively with European issues, both as a scholar and as a practitioner.

Not least, his experiences as Permanent Representative of the Federal Republic to the Council of Europe and his participation in the negotiations for the Treaty of Rome made him an advocate of the idea of the United States of Europe. He played a significant role in the success of European integration: when the negotiations for the Treaty establishing the European Economic Community faced a severe crisis in October 1956, it was Karl Carstens and his French partner Robert Marjolin who prevented the negotiations from failing. The continent, Karl Carstens was convinced throughout his life, must be more than just a free trade zone; it must also unite politically.

From today's perspective, we particularly appreciate how Carstens recognized and emphasized West integration as a condition for German unity. In his view, the Federal Republic could not have exerted sufficient attractiveness on the residents of the GDR without Western ties. And without West integration, without European integration, one could not have committed France, Great Britain, and also the United States to the goal of reunification. From this, the priorities of West German politics naturally emerged for Carstens: freedom – peace – unity, in that order.

Thus, it was an indispensable element of every state visit for President Carstens to remind his interlocutors that the Federal Republic is working towards a state of peace in Europe "in which the German people regains its unity in free self-determination." To visitors from the most distant corners of the world – such as the royal couple from Tonga – he presented this quote from the "Letter on German Unity."

He did not want to follow the logic of early Ostpolitik. However, once the East treaties were concluded, he recognized that Germany would not come closer to reunification without a relaxation of relations with the Warsaw Pact states. From today's perspective, Karl Carstens was a German and foreign politician who significantly contributed to the emergence of a country in which we can still live today in freedom, peace, and prosperity.

He saw his office as Federal President as a non-partisan instance, exercised his constitutional duties with care, and simultaneously made it clear that he was aware of his office-specific authority. Thus, he once confidentially informed the Federal Chancellor that he would not carry out the dismissal of a minister because he considered it unjustified.

The most important domestic political decision of his presidency had to be made at the beginning of 1983, when it came to dissolving the Bundestag prematurely and ordering new elections. Chancellor Kohl wanted – after taking over the chancellorship – to fundamentally re-legitimize his government through Bundestag elections and had therefore posed the question of confidence in the Bundestag – with the aim of dissolving the Bundestag.

As planned, the vote was then lost.

It was not only Carstens' most important decision, it was – as he himself said – his "most difficult decision." He deliberated for exactly 21 days, the maximum allowed by the Basic Law. He knew that his decision would be politically and legally controversial, regardless of the outcome. He wanted to be able to represent it as an ordinary professor of constitutional law before his peers. And at the same time, he sensed that his decision would be challenged by way of an organ complaint at the Federal Constitutional Court, the first such procedure for a Federal President.

At that time, in the transition from the SPD-FDP coalition to the coalition of Union and FDP, it was a fundamental question: whether the instrument of the vote of confidence, deliberately used by the governing majority and yet ending in a foreseeable defeat for the Chancellor, could and should lead to new elections. Critics saw it as a "fake" vote of confidence, a trick in which a withdrawal of confidence was merely feigned.

Thus, in practice, a constitutionally foreign right of self-dissolution of Parliament would arise.

Karl Carstens decided to dissolve the Bundestag. In his justification, he stated that he could not determine "for what reasons the individual member of parliament had denied the Chancellor his approval." He had come to the conviction that the stable government desired by the Basic Law and politically sought could no longer be achieved without new elections. The Federal Constitutional Court later confirmed Carstens' legal opinion. This confirmation was essential for him, as he later admitted that he would have resigned had the Federal Constitutional Court not confirmed his decision. This event remains significant to this day, as it helped clarify the conditions of votes of no confidence and new elections. Karl Carstens' prudent actions in the spirit of the Constitution contributed to securing the stability and governability of the country, two principles that ranked very high in the hierarchy of his political values.

Karl Carstens also became a respected Federal President because he left behind the sharp-tongued party politician he had once been. He used his office to integrate. Throughout his term, he convinced many who had once viewed his election with skepticism. Respect and affection from all walks of life came his way. His wife, Veronica Carstens, also played a significant role in this. I would like to remember her today. During his presidency, she continued to work as a doctor and took on many of the worries and needs of the people. Together, they founded the Karl and Veronica Carstens Foundation.

As the patroness of the German Multiple Sclerosis Society, Veronica Carstens also earned great merits. We should also bow before her today.

And let us not forget one more thing: Karl Carstens drew from his Christian faith and gave his strength for the idea of the common good. And both are interconnected – at least that is how I see it.

The essence of his thinking was left a few years before his death in a speech in Dresden:

"Whoever is free bears responsibility; whoever has rights also has duties; whoever makes claims, especially claims on the state, must also be willing to provide performance." We can still gather behind these words today.

So let us bow before the achievements of a German democrat, and honor his memory through our attitude and our actions as citizens.