Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck to introduce the panel discussion "Law and Justice – Dealing with the SED Injustice in Unified Germany" on December 10 ...

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

21 December 2014 · Panel discussion "Law and Justice – Dealing with the SED Injustice in Unified Germany"

Context
Gauck introduced a panel discussion on law and justice regarding SED injustice in unified Germany, held on Human Rights Day, December 10, 2014.
Main themes
SED injustice and transitional justice, rule of law versus moral justice, dealing with GDR past in unified Germany, victim rehabilitation and compensation, criminal accountability of GDR functionaries, societal memory and democratic renewal, Bärbel Bohley's critique of Rechtsstaat, generational understanding of historical injustice, inner peace and social reconciliation
Duration
~13 min
44th percentile
Words
1,500
44th percentile
Sentences
86
56th percentile
Readability
56
80th percentile
Grade
9.7
17th percentile
Syntax
3.03
51st percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
24th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 77%77%
  • Social 14%14%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

86 sentences in 17 paragraphs

I would like to thank you for the invitation to speak here, and I also appreciate that this is only an introduction and a greeting, because, in itself – given the focus you have set and which is your task – I would like to give a two-hour keynote address. But I will save that for another time and will only introduce our following discussion.

A difficult topic that will concern us today. Difficult not because one cannot find clear words – we will find them. But because it is associated with so many emotions. The handling of "law and justice" has a strong influence on whether wounds hurt longer. It also has something like an ideological counterweight, because the representatives of the former form of rule try to wrap everything that hurts in cotton wool. One is welcome to talk about what hurts. But not when it falls within the time when one has borne responsibility oneself. This is one of the reasons why there are different debates in every reckoning, in every transformation of a society. There is the time, the early time, when the victims and the emigrants, the resistors, know everything and they do not have to remain silent about it. But that is not yet the time when all the people living in this country deeply understand what is being talked about. It takes another generation until this realization reaches not only the heads but also the hearts, so that there is a real turning point within a societal body.

We are in such a transitional phase.

The topic of law and justice is particularly suitable for becoming dissatisfied, because no one, no institution, no state, and no person can ever provide justice. The justice we dream of always lies just outside of what we can shape.

And when we gather here for an event, as we have done in previous years, and want to remember the past, it is not about finding the formula with which we can create justice. Rather, it is about how we can better shape democracy by remembering the injustices and wrongs of past times. That is our goal, and I am therefore pleased that there are always people and institutions that promote this willingness not to simply stand by in shaping today's democracy: We are actors. This topic has accompanied me personally, as you know, for years.

I also remember a well-known sentence that Bärbel Bohley said relatively early on, which everyone here in the room knows: "We wanted justice and got the rule of law." A very, very problematic sentence. Understandable from the depths of feelings, but totally unsuitable as a description of the state of an open society. Nevertheless, she spoke to many people from the former GDR. Because the injustices of the GDR often did not come to trial. That was also fine, because individual criminal guilt was not provable. Therefore, many functionaries went unpunished, some of them went unpunished because they were not capable of being negotiated with, and then questions naturally arose.

I remember very well the questions: What is it actually with the rule of law, does it have no morality? Does it leave the questions of morality aside? Is the rule of law simply toothless? Does it capitulate in the face of the legacy that the unjust state has left behind? And then there are reactions ranging from anger to resignation. And there are those who look closely and try to shape what is possible in our country, in this legal system, legislatively. And the reunified republic has actually achieved quite a bit in this regard. One must always keep in mind what the writer Herbert Rosendorfer once said, that justice has about as much to do with the judiciary as a regional church administration has with the dear God.

And yet we do not want to blame the judiciary for not being able to bring about justice. Its actions have a nexus to the establishment of justice; it promotes reflection, while the goal of justice is not overlooked. It is there to protect and shape the legal system. Nevertheless, we are talking about a fundamental human need. This need exists in friendships, in schools, in families, and in society. The goal, when one speaks in general terms about justice, is always a balancing of differences and interests. And such a balance is important because it constitutes the prerequisite for inner peace.

The ideas about what characterizes a just balance are very different. And after the end of the GDR, some perceived the leniency of the West German prosecuting authorities as downright scandalous, because of the 100,000 accused, only one in 133 was convicted. Others spoke of "victor's justice."

Many GDR citizens had hoped that the rule of law would reorganize everything as much as possible: it would punish the guilty, disempower the powerful, and rehabilitate and compensate the disempowered. But when the rule of law did what it was able to do according to its norms, many were disappointed. It seemed insulting that, for example, the legal norm that everyone is equal before the law also benefited the former oppressors. As a concrete example: Erich Honecker, he was ill, and the court reacted as a lawful court must react. Many people could understand that. But others wondered, how would the state at that time have treated me? One cannot forbid people to ask such questions; one must listen to them – and representatives hear it as an appeal to let justice grow. I have the feeling that our parliament has done that. It has tried to protect the norms of the rule of law, to remain within the norms of a liberal legal order, and at the same time to show: There is also injustice that belongs in court. We should appreciate the effort that the judiciary has made to find ways of delegitimization and condemnation in a difficult legal landscape.

It was a great gain that for those cases in which the contradiction between positive law and justice seemed almost unbearable, a solution could be found. I mean the trials against the border guards. That is, those who fired deadly shots at people who wanted nothing more than to leave the GDR and those who ordered it. It would have been hardly reconcilable if the perpetrators had gotten away with it because their actions were covered by GDR law. However, the trials almost universally did not end with acquittals, but with sentences, albeit with suspended sentences, because the so-called Radbruch formula was applied. Law, as the jurist and legal philosopher Gustav Radbruch once developed in light of the crimes of the Nazi regime, must not become a means to defend obvious injustice.

Based on this maxim, there were then convictions.

In the meantime, the criminal prosecution of SED injustices has been completed. And during the course of the trials, it has once again been shown that the rule of law is only strong when it remains true to its own rules, when it treats everyone equally and does not bow to the morality of the good, the morality of the victims. Only that creates legal certainty. And without legal certainty, there can be no trust in the law and in the institutions of the law.

Criminal prosecution is indeed indispensable for dealing with a dictatorial past, but it is not everything. At the same time, we have learned that steps towards justice can also be achieved in other ways than through criminal law, through courts. I mention the keyword in connection with the legislation on the Stasi files: opening the archives. This gives individuals, the victims, researchers, and the media access to archival material that allows for a delegitimization of the perpetrators. A delegitimization without a court ruling. The review of public service employees for possible collaboration with the Stasi is also a form of restitution, of balancing between former perpetrators and former victims. For this, we did not need the courts either. We were still capable of action towards achieving more justice.

But the idea of what justice is, of course, varies greatly among us. That is why it is so important that we talk about it, that we do not suspect each other. That we do not make moral accusations against the judges when they do their duty, as if they were other people than we are, as if they had no morality, as if they did not know the morality and dignity of the victims. That is not the case. But they are judges, not journalists, not politicians, and not representatives of interests. Therefore, I am now looking forward to the panel discussion.

The engagement with the past, as we all experience, is not a closed chapter. By the way, it will not be in ten years either. And therefore, I would like to expressly thank the work of the Federal Foundation, to Ms. Kaminsky and the board.

Thank you very much. Keep going. It is important.