Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck at the celebration of the 60th anniversary of the German Press Council on December 1, 2016, in Berlin:

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

6 December 2016 · 60th anniversary celebration of the German Press Council · Berlin, Germany

Context
Gauck addressed the German Press Council's 60th anniversary celebration on December 1, 2016, in Berlin, reflecting on press freedom and democracy.
Main themes
Press freedom and self-regulation, German Press Council anniversary, journalism and democracy, crisis of trust in institutions, digitalization and media business models, fake news and media criticism, print media crisis, history of German press, democratic citizenship and informed public, state control vs. self-regulation
Duration
~18 min
59th percentile
Words
2,108
59th percentile
Sentences
115
69th percentile
Readability
45
48th percentile
Grade
11.5
39th percentile
Syntax
2.87
30th percentile
Vocabulary
2.25
61st percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 53%50%
  • Institutional 21%20%
  • Ceremonial 14%13%
  • Economic 5%4%
  • Geopolitical 4%3%
  • Technological 4%3%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

115 sentences in 33 paragraphs

Thank you for the kind invitation. I know I am not the first Federal President to have the pleasure of honoring the German Press Council. In fact, I stand in a long line of presidential congratulators that stretches back to its founding moment.

The small group of publishers and editors who met on November 20, 1956, for the inaugural meeting of the Council at the Bergischer Hof in Bonn had another appointment that same morning – at the Villa Hammerschmidt. Theodor Heuss is said to have regaled those present with anecdotes about the less than commendable treatment of heads of state by the press. However, I do not wish to entertain you with that today.

It seems noteworthy to me that the head of state of the Federal Republic of Germany was a patron of the institution whose 60th anniversary we celebrate today. Heuss saw the re-establishment as "a pleasing sign of the self-respect of the press."

There was undoubtedly a reason why the first Federal President took such a lively interest in the founding of the Press Council. It was not only the head of state speaking; it was also the former journalist Theodor Heuss. And he knew not only that the German press had taken too long during the Weimar Republic to consider a system of self-regulation. He also knew from his own painful experience how quickly the Gleichschaltung of the press had been enforced by the National Socialist state.

After that experience, they explicitly did not want state control, nor a state supervisory body. What could result from malicious intent was on display in the other part of Germany and bore the name "democratic centralism."

The reason the joy over the founding of the Press Council still endures 60 years later is easily explained. Those who, like the press, perform a public task – yes, who speak with the public and for the public – must also be able to publicly justify and have their statements verified. That this could and can happen without state interference is, not least, the achievement of your profession, ladies and gentlemen.

Democratic societies need the exchange of informed citizens among themselves. Equipping them with knowledge and judgment is also, and especially, the task of the media. The founding of the German Press Council as an organ of self-regulation was thus also an indication that the still young Federal Republic had made progress in spelling out the word democracy.

Can we now look back with satisfaction on 60 years of institutionalized self-regulation by the German Press Council? We can, even if its history, like the history of any institution, has not been free of crises, and even if there is sometimes criticism of a certain toothlessness in its actions. This criticism must not only be faced by the Press Council itself but also by those who do not take its admonitions seriously enough and thus harm it through disdain.

When we speak these days of daily and weekly newspapers, we unfortunately also speak of a crisis of print, a crisis of print media. The core of the challenge, we all know, is digitalization. It opens up seemingly endless possibilities for acquiring knowledge, participation, and communication.

But it also calls into question the business model of journalism as we know it: If everyone can be their own publisher, editor, and author, the threatening question arises, who still needs journalists, quality control, or newspapers? Daily newspapers will not be able to win the race for the dissemination of news. The crucial question remains how journalistic quality, economic success, and journalistic ideals can be harmonized into a cohesive whole. And we all still need to find an answer to that.

The current environment remains difficult. And as if that were not difficult enough, newspaper, radio, and television editorial offices must endure being labeled as "fake news."

The crisis of trust that we observe does not solely affect the media. It also encompasses politics, including political parties, as well as trade unions, churches, sports, and many other institutions of the state and society. For many, the feeling of life apparently includes the supposed certainty that there is no longer anything or anyone to rely on.

However, human coexistence is inconceivable without trust. The same applies to social interaction. Ultimately, the same holds true for the entire representative democracy. Its lasting success depends on the population's reliance on and trust in democratic institutions and their representatives. But precisely in this context, we have been experiencing a problematic decline in trust among voters for years. Politics cannot and must not overlook this. In the coming years, it will have to work very seriously to strengthen trust in the institutions of the state and also respect for the work of the parties.

And as for the media: Their task of being the bearers of even unwanted news puts them in a highly uncomfortable position. The daily newspaper on the breakfast table provides the first glimpse into the world of politics, which can evoke distrust, dissent, and even aversion in some readers. The media cannot free themselves from this role. They cannot heal the conditions they describe alone. And because the media are part of, but not the cause of, the crisis of trust, they cannot overcome this crisis alone. That is their dilemma.

Those who turn away and fundamentally question the impartiality of the media are not yet in the majority among us. Compared to other institutions of the state and society, the appreciation of journalism is still relatively high. But there is a strong and increasingly vocal minority that harbors distrust towards the media.

Yes, we can say this calmly: Violations of the principle of diligence do occur, of course. Pointing out errors and criticizing reporting is not only acceptable but also quite welcome. However, those who claim that faulty reporting is not the exception but the rule, not inadequacy but intent, are likely less concerned with upholding the duty of care than with confirming their conviction that everywhere only lies and deceit prevail.

In itself, this is not a completely new phenomenon: that it is not the lie that is the most dangerous enemy of the truth, but the conviction – this insight of Nietzsche is at least as old as the firm belief of some that they are at the mercy of a conspiracy of foreign powers. And the conspirators have remained the same for conspiracy theorists – high finance, representatives of other religions or beliefs; today, intelligence agencies and military alliances are added, strangely enough, almost exclusively of Western provenance. The so-called mainstream media, according to the theory, are merely their lackeys, propagandists, warmongers, and profiteers.

Skepticism towards the media, and indeed a pronounced aversion towards their representatives, is truly not new. But the effect that this minority of media despisers achieves in public is indeed. And the excessive anger, even hatred towards the media, frightens us.

That it is now easier than ever to gain followers for even the most crude beliefs makes dealing with this phenomenon even more difficult. "In the digital age, it has become infinitely easy to create parallel realities and equally watertight micro-publics," explains media scholar Bernhard Pörksen to us. Social networks and the way they are used undoubtedly contribute to this development. Those who use them choose what they want to perceive, when and from whom they want to read or hear it, and finally, with which selected circle of so-called friends they want to share their insights. Algorithms amplify this effect. Ultimately, echo chambers arise, in which individuals or groups believe they possess the sole truth while being deaf to the outside world, listening only to their own convictions that echo off the walls.

If these convictions have also become interchangeable, one can today tell this and tomorrow that without consequence, can become entangled in contradictions or assert easily refutable claims, then what science calls a communication infarction has occurred. If it is enough to be convinced of oneself in order to successfully spread content-free chatter or meaning-laden falsehoods, then communication has become impossible.

However, democracy relies on successful communication and thus also on media that accurately reflect controversies. It needs a vibrant public sphere. It thrives on the exchange of opinions, not on opinion monads, closed, self-revolving systems. When facts play an increasingly lesser role, it endangers democracy.

The answer to how to lure communication refugees out of their parallel worlds must, unfortunately, remain a question I cannot answer today. I would have liked to offer it to you briefly and succinctly. But I cannot. We must work on that together. However, it is certainly worth asking how they ended up in their escape rooms and when this process of disintegration began. We need answers to these questions because we must not allow, we must not allow together, for this process to continue.

If we fail, the answers will be provided by others. We observe it in our own country and around us: The inhabitants of the echo chambers orient themselves towards those who tell them what they want to hear, not towards those who tell them what they should know. That is the populist temptation. It exists, ideologically justified, in multiple variants and simply in loquacious refusal to engage in discourse.

Finally, addressing the crisis of trust will also involve distinguishing contempt for criticism. For there is no doubt that there is also criticism, serious criticism, that the media must face.

Those who are accused of lying should, if they wish to defend themselves, have a concept of the truth. Reporting committed to the truth does not without reason lead with the commandments of the Press Code. This formulation is chosen with care. It states that the journalist should demonstrate respect for the truth. I understand this as a call to have respect for the facts and reality and to strive for a truthful informing of the public.

But how does one approach the truth when it is often difficult to identify unequivocally? Well, before the truth comes perception. Journalists should and must look closely.

I now come to the current time of these debates that you are having among yourselves. I am experiencing these days the self-critical discussion not only within the American media, which are asking why they did not see Donald Trump's election victory coming. Why they were overwhelmed by the strength of that societal undercurrent that carried the outsider to victory.

And I am pleased that a similar debate is also being taken up here in Germany. Are there perhaps also groups, issues, and convictions among us that have not been sufficiently explored, that are not adequately represented or respected in the media?

It seems to me that in Germany, journalists have not always been immune to looking in only one direction instead of all possible ones. The self-examination of the profession is currently revealing that journalists here too have sometimes been tempted to flee into the echo chambers of political harmony and to devalue or simply ignore opinions that they do not like or do not share. And that it is also not so easy in Germany to strictly maintain the boundary between reporting, enlightening, and instructing. This indeed requires from journalists a permanent self-examination, a self-assurance about the criteria of their own work.

I am convinced that the current debates among you serve to further improve journalism in this sense and to report as sensitively and fairly as possible.

As for what "fake news" means, ladies and gentlemen, I truly know. For I have experienced it for decades in the GDR. Here, where we meet, the GDR was just barely still present. Back there it ended, and up to here the fake news operated daily, monthly, yearly, for decades. I know what that is. It is not about discussion, but about constant denunciation, not about impartiality, but always about the supremacy of opinion. It has been an element of domination.

Let us not fall into fear and escapism in the face of all possible destructive energies, including those that swirl in populism. Everyone can do something to strengthen the open society. Journalists can contribute to overcoming the crisis of trust in our democratic institutions. Simply by continuing their work, with intelligence and insight, with openness, with impartiality. It is the same skills and talents that they must also uphold against their detractors: after all, it is the same talents that will ensure the survival of serious media against the competition of digital echo chambers.

Sixty years after the founding of the German Press Council, I am therefore not worried about the future of a free press in Germany.