Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck at the dinner for the members of the Science Council on January 23, 2014, in Berlin:

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

28 February 2014 · Dinner for the members of the Science Council · Berlin, Germany

Context
Gauck addressed members of the Science Council at a dinner in Berlin on January 23, 2014, reflecting on science policy and Germany's research landscape.
Main themes
Science policy, research and education balance, Science Council role, Germany as knowledge hub, humanities vs. STEM workforce mismatch, academic freedom, demographic change, skilled workforce shortage, openness to foreign researchers, federal-state relations in education, truth-seeking in research, democracy and compromise
Duration
~14 min
48th percentile
Words
1,663
48th percentile
Sentences
81
53rd percentile
Readability
52
68th percentile
Grade
11.1
33rd percentile
Syntax
3.09
59th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
23rd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 53%53%
  • Ceremonial 20%20%
  • Institutional 17%17%
  • Economic 10%10%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

81 sentences in 14 paragraphs

A warm welcome to a dinner dedicated to the sciences! Today, we could talk about a great ongoing task – the search for truth that is inherent in every research endeavor. In this search, there is often a struggle over which insight is the right one, which theory is the more convincing. There is no room for compromise here. Quite the opposite of democracy, for which the ability to compromise is indeed constitutive. And one could almost get the impression: You, dear guests, sometimes experience this different value of compromises in science on the one hand and in politics on the other hand in your work at the Science Council up close. Time and again, you face the task of defining the right measure: for example, in the balancing act of conducting comprehensive and demanding research while also managing with limited resources. I could also mention the balancing of top research and broad teaching or the search for a productive interaction between academic and vocational education. Not to mention the relationship between the federal government and the states!

All of this is reflected in your work programs and reports. You usually provide the appropriate recommendations for action right along with them. The equal coexistence and collaboration of the scientific and administrative commissions, this special personnel mix in your body has one advantage: extreme positions are ultimately excluded. From your statutes and your mandate arises the license to be visionary, and at the same time, you are compelled – and want to – to achieve a certain grounding. Both benefit the debate that we want something and that we recognize what is possible for us. Often noticed a bit late by the general public, but highly regarded in professional circles, you regularly take a stand on current scientific issues. The core question: How can the image of Germany as the homeland of poets and thinkers, inventors and developers maintain its vibrant colors and gain new nuances? For this tireless work – and that since 1957, when I was, for example, still a student! – I would like to sincerely thank the Science Council today, both the institution and each and every one of you! Thank you very much.

The annual meeting here at Schloss Bellevue or also at the Chancellery has now become a tradition, but for me personally, it is anything but routine. You are so much to our country: observers and explainers, assessors and advocates, sometimes also admonishers in the service of science. And Germany needs you as critical-constructive companions, as initiators, and often also as correctives in a field that, with its many particular interests and potential conflicts, seems hardly manageable, especially for laypeople.

Of course, I am aware that I rarely see the conflicts in detail, but much more often I see the best and the brightest in education and research. I meet people who receive an award for their outstanding achievements or who are already great hopes at a young age. And I am usually invited to places where success is at home. All of this is – fortunately – part of the reality in our country. But it is only one part of that reality.

That is why I will not stop asking about the problems and shortcomings – especially here in Bellevue, especially at nice occasions. Last summer, for example, I hosted 550 Humboldt fellows in the castle park. It is wonderful that we invite researchers to work in our country. Such a colorful afternoon then holds a real temptation. I think to myself, it is indeed a pure joy to live in this country and to be president. After all, Germany is today the most popular host country for foreign students after the USA and Great Britain. What a wonderful compliment for our country! But the fact is at the same time: What these young people experience in some government offices or at bus stops in our country often does not correspond to what we understand as openness to the world.

In dealing with such tensions, I see one of my important tasks – not an easy one, certainly not always easy, as you can imagine. How does one answer the question, for example, of what the Federal President wants to do about the fact that many humanities scholars can only find a job that does not match their qualifications, while doctors, engineers, and computer scientists are sometimes desperately sought after? Then a lover of freedom cannot demand strict quotas. I experienced that in the past when even access to the Abitur was quota-based. And I cannot rightly call for a dictate through state control. I am very glad that you, Professor Marquardt, have clearly opposed such "planning fantasies." However, we also share the realization that Germany cannot afford a random "continue as before" for economic and other reasons, at least not if we want to remain a competitive location in times of demographic change.

The threat scenarios of a shrinking skilled workforce have now been comprehensively described. What is still missing are convincing counter-concepts that do not just have a project character but work broadly, impact over time, and reach young people, educational institutions, employers, and thus as many people as possible! I will read with interest your "Recommendations for the Qualification of Skilled Workers in Light of Demographic Change," of which a first part is to be published this year, as I have heard.

Do you have any further thematic recommendations for me? Then please let me know. I sincerely hope that you will share some ideas with me this evening, even though I have no budget, nor do I manage a ministry, and yet I am happy to listen to what I might then discuss with ministers and members of parliament. My terrain is discourse. Not every communication, I know well, can initiate great changes, but in the best case, a consciousness arises from our joint efforts, and one day a new reality.

When I speak of science, I usually have a triad in mind: on the one hand, the structures that must be reliably established. Especially in East Germany, so much positive has emerged that we hope to celebrate extensively on the 25th anniversary of the fall of the Berlin Wall this year. I, for one, want to do so, not dutifully and abstractly, but from the heart and as concretely as possible. Recently, for example, I was a guest at Viadrina and met with President Komorowski there. We walked together over the bridge from Słubice to Frankfurt/Oder – my goodness, I thought about how it used to be. There was a time when we East Germans were not even allowed to go to Poland, let alone to the West. But when Solidarity was active, we were not even allowed to go to Poland. And now I walked hand in hand with the Polish president to where young people from these different regions now study and learn together for our common Europe, wonderful experiences!

The second point that concerns me is the finances with which the structures for education and research are maintained, modernized, or expanded if necessary. And thirdly, I have something that is closely linked to the first two points – I am talking about something that cannot be expressed in formulas or calculations, that is the mentality. The mentality that a society needs to unleash the necessary dynamics. In my view, innovations such as the Excellence Initiative or the "Package of Packages" have noticeably accelerated the pace of development in Germany. Rightly so, I am pleased! We must not give up this agility now, well aware that the scarcity of public budgets and the debt brake set limits. The good news: Dynamics does not arise solely from large sums, but from an energy that is contained in many small quality offensives, in the strategic cooperation of individual institutions, and in the committed work of individual researchers and research groups who are dedicated to specific research projects. You can illustrate this in detail far better than I can. However, we will agree on this: An education and science republic will never be "finished"; it remains a work in progress, a product of constant change of the actors involved.

To the public, the efforts at the grassroots level are sometimes difficult to explain. I am aware of that. All the more gratifying when the broader public also notices that there are indeed successes to report and that perseverance has paid off: The three percent target, long a distant dream, has been achieved. Never before has so much money been invested in research and development in Germany – both absolutely and measured against gross domestic product – as today. The Pisa shock has also proven to be somewhat healing: International comparative studies show that our students have indeed caught up in competition and now rank above the OECD average in all areas. There is also more discussion today about equitable opportunities for education and thus participation for all children than there was before Pisa. At the same time, when I bring up the topic, you know how much work we still have to do in this area.

The most valuable thing in my eyes: Unlike several other areas of politics, science can rely on a large societal consensus. Who still disputes today that education, research, teaching, and innovation should be primary goals of our political action, and that better basic funding for universities is one of the urgent tasks?

This consensus is precious, but its implementation is anything but trivial. It is not only a task for politics but also for the economy, society, and each and every individual: What are we willing to contribute for education and for science? With this question in mind, I ask you to raise your glass to a year of ambitious goals! Without compromises, we will not get through 2014 either. But our motivation for the highest demands on ourselves: that can be unlimited!

Thank you.