Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck at the Education Day of the ZEIT Foundation "Equal Opportunities in Education: A Challenge for the State and Civil Society" on November 6, 2015 in ...

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

16 November 2015 · Education Day of the ZEIT Foundation "Equal Opportunities in Education: A Challenge for the State and Civil Society"

Context
Gauck addressed the ZEIT Foundation's Education Day on November 6, 2015, speaking on equal opportunities and educational justice in Germany.
Main themes
Equal opportunities in education, educational justice, social background and educational success, disadvantaged students, German education system, civil society responsibility, migration and integration, school policy, vocational education, educational poverty, state and community support
Duration
~34 min
87th percentile
Words
4,128
87th percentile
Sentences
242
93rd percentile
Readability
54
74th percentile
Grade
9.9
20th percentile
Syntax
2.77
19th percentile
Vocabulary
1.99
9th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 86%86%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Institutional 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

242 sentences in 40 paragraphs

The situation with education in our country is somewhat similar to that of football. Alongside the 80 million national team coaches, there are almost as many education experts. And that is quite understandable – because we all have our own experiences with education. Many of us have children and grandchildren. And we have all attended school. It is a formative experience of our lives. In school, friendships for life are often formed. Once we have entered the workforce, we attend further training and seminars, thus taking on the role of a student once again.

Education is a highly emotional topic. So much in our further lives depends on successful education. Weekly, we encounter education in the media, often in the form of percentages. We hear about studies, about statistics, and it is, by the way, good that we hear about them and that we do not pretend that this is not an important topic. In contrast to football, however, we cannot immediately elevate the "Education Republic" of Germany to the rank of a world champion. We still have some work to do on that. The fact that we cannot do so is also related to the strong international competition. And it would be presumptuous to pretend that we are the frontrunners here. But we should take note of what exists in the world under different conditions in terms of education systems and be open to what can help us. It is quite clear that we in Germany have an extraordinarily high-performing education system, the quality and diversity of which – I am of course also thinking of vocational education, not just preparation for academia – enjoys a high reputation worldwide. This can be stated without glossing over deficiencies and problems.

In purely quantitative terms, there has never been so much knowledge and so much education in Germany. We owe this, of course, to external circumstances, such as the long period of peace and the economic prosperity of our country. Much has also been achieved in education policy. The educational level of the German population continues to improve, as do the opportunities for education and further training. There are also more first-year students than ever before. And the number of young people without a school leaving certificate has significantly decreased in recent years – it is expected to continue to decrease in the future, but probably not to the extent that the education summit of 2008 envisioned.

However, one thing has not improved sufficiently so far: For decades, we have been discussing equal opportunities and educational justice in Germany. It is the great constant of German education policy: Educational success in Germany still strongly – yes, we could say: too strongly! – depends on social background.

That is what I would like to talk about with you today – and I will do so without launching into a fundamental lament about education policy. I will neither complain about an impending "education catastrophe," nor about "education panic" or the "education trap." It is also not my intention to participate in structural debates. Today, I would like to take a look with you at the educational reality in our country, at least at the part where background and opportunities are particularly visible together. Let me tell you about a school in my Berlin neighborhood.

Close to Schloss Bellevue, my official residence in Berlin, lies the Hedwig-Dohm-Schule, an integrated secondary school in the district of Moabit. What happens there helps to understand what is actually meant when we talk about disadvantage. The Moabit neighborhood is often a rough place. The Hedwig-Dohm-Schule is one of ten Berlin schools that the Berlin Senate calls "schools in difficult situations" and that receive corresponding support. It has 450 students. Almost all come from socially disadvantaged families, including migrant families. The student body is made up of thirty nationalities.

There are students who miss school for eighty days every year. The students simply do not come, and no one succeeds in getting these children to school. They grow up in households that cannot adequately be described by the term "educational distance." Because in many of these households, there is neither work nor any rules at all.

Some parents cannot even manage to get out of bed in the morning to make breakfast for their children. They seem not to understand what difficulties they are causing their offspring.

Thus, children arrive at school, if at all, always late and often hungry. The teachers, as the principal reports, sometimes have to explain to them that class is starting now and that they cannot leave the school building again to buy something to eat. It is not easy for the reading and learning mentors who volunteer at the school either – they do not receive only gratitude from the students.

Some parents or guardians do not speak German, and they are also illiterate in their mother tongue. Many of them have difficulties coping in Germany. Often, there is a gap between the school and the family. Language is not the only reason for this – there are also cultural barriers, disinterest, and insecurity.

I do not want to paint too bleak a picture here. But I would like to point out what efforts are necessary to give meaning to the concept of educational justice in this environment. If we think back, about 50 years ago, the Catholic girl from the countryside was the epitome of an education system that did not provide equal opportunities for equally talented individuals or from which certain groups excluded themselves by forgoing graduation or further education. Today, it is the boys from urban lower classes and from families with a migration background to whom society must pay attention.

When I mention the Hedwig-Dohm-Schule today, I also want to highlight what is already being achieved at such a focal school, especially by the teachers. Because it is they who instill in the children the reliability that they do not know from home and which is the foundation of all learning. At schools like the Hedwig-Dohm-Schule, the teachers and all staff start from the question: What can we do best for each individual student? Their attitude is: We begin with the specific situation of each individual student.

An example, which admittedly is not everyday, but precisely for that reason shows how much is possible: A new student arrives at the school, virtually transferred as a punishment. He had become criminal and, as it later turned out, was also addicted to drugs. He was in a desperate situation. And the school responded to this situation. It first arranged an internship for him so that he could bring structure back into his daily life. The student maintained contact with the school initially through a weekly day of classes. This way, he found his way back into the routine of classes. During that time, he underwent detoxification. In the end, he graduated from school and found an apprenticeship. A seemingly failed individual received a second chance – and he took it.

This is undoubtedly an encouraging story and speaks to the work of the school. And this story is not so singular. Today, on the flight here, I read in two Berlin daily newspapers the story of a young man. He is now already an adult, he has even written a book, his name is Yigit Muk, and one newspaper writes in its jargon: "from the secondary school thug to the top student, from the gang brawler to the student." So, what does he say among other things in this interview? I will read it out: "I had no goals before, except to play football well and to gain respect on the street. Not just scuffles, it was about knocking someone out. Most of the time, I wasn't caught, once I had to do community service. I had potential, but I didn't know anyone who had even thought about the Abitur. That changed, also because of teachers." The story I just recounted from Berlin also had a good ending; there was indeed a network of helpers. Everyone had the same goal: the single mother participated, the youth welfare office, the youth court assistants, the principal, the teachers, the school social worker. Truly a network. And we see here: Successes are possible, but they require perseverance and truly a great effort. And they need support measures tailored precisely to the student – perhaps, no, certainly many need a second and even a third attempt. And I am grateful for all the foundations, sometimes also associations or individual companies, that have recognized this problem and are creating new opportunities, even for a third fresh start.

I am reminded of the situation when I was a child and there were still many individual craft businesses everywhere in the flat countryside, craftsmen or farmers who had simple jobs to offer. Failed schoolchildren and young people would go there and learn the first skills at the hands of a master who believed in the boy or girl. That is how they found their way into life. It was often paternalistic, far from our views on modern pedagogical processes, but in this paternalism was an essential element, and that element is called: perception and attention. And through this perception of the specific situation of the individual and the attention of an engaged, guiding person, countless people who would never have graduated from high school and who did not even complete secondary school found a place in life and became respected citizens. Our society is organized differently today. And that is why we must strive to create these opportunities in a different sociological situation in order to realize second and third chances. And I thank everyone who is involved in this.

In difficult situations, we need many helping hands. We recognize that they are necessary, not only in the school but also around it. It cannot be solely the responsibility of teachers to motivate students to perform and to encourage them to persevere. Especially since they can often only fulfill the claim to do justice to each individual student if they invest more time and attention than their official duties actually require. Experience teaches us: It is the attitudes of the teachers that matter. We often overlook that they are overburdened, and we are among those who must ensure that they do not remain alone in their efforts for this group of individuals.

Teachers are also often the target of mockery and criticism. Yet they achieve almost incredible things in our country day after day. And I am glad that I can explicitly acknowledge this today, not only as a citizen but as President. Many of you constantly push yourselves to your physical and mental limits to continue practicing your beloved profession as teachers. Teachers, ladies and gentlemen, is one of the most important, one of the most beautiful, but also one of the most difficult professions. I am grateful for your great commitment, dear teachers, grateful for your idealism, for your patience, and for your energy, and I want to emphasize this gratitude today doubly and triply.

I just mentioned the example of the Hedwig-Dohm-Schule, which was drastic: But we see from it how important it is to start from the individual, from their talents, from their strengths and weaknesses. True educational justice must not be limited to something like formal equality.

The Enlightenment granted people equal rights. Therefore, we rightly expect our educational institutions to guarantee equal starting conditions for all students. But equal rights cannot compensate for unequal talents and abilities. They also cannot completely offset unequal social conditions and mental, cultural influences. It is therefore important to complement formal equality with specific support so that people can achieve what their abilities allow. This is the central claim that our society, especially our modern immigration society, must not fall behind: With equal talents, there must be equal opportunities for advancement.

Then it is also up to every child and especially every young person to seize their opportunity and accept help. Then the individual "will" comes into play. It also requires the willingness to make an effort. And anyone who no longer conveys this message is making a serious mistake. Children and young people can only experience it this way if they are willing to live this effort and this "will." They can only have experiences of happiness that are completely impossible without effort. Yes, it simply belongs to life. However, in our eagerness to be humane, we have often unlearned to make demands and express expectations that require effort. But that is not humane at all; it is out of touch with life. And we could trace this with very simple examples. The children we saw here had to get up, go to training, they had to make an effort, some learned it faster than others, as we saw. We also saw different talents, but we also saw a common joy among the differently gifted. And they achieved something through effort. Yes, why should we not convey this and always just pretend that society is in debt? No, we all are.

Today we will meet a man whose biography represents much of what we are thinking about and what I am talking about: about inner drive, an inner will, and the inspiring effect of school and learning. I am talking about a gentleman whom you will get to know later; it is Philip Opprong Spenner, who is participating here today. You, Mr. Spenner, grew up as an orphan in the streets of Nairobi, and today you work as a teacher, as a study advisor, here in Hamburg. And you once said: "School was the source of my self-confidence. I saw: There is something in me. School was my heaven." Well, how about that? Is that true?

Your educational experiences, Mr. Spenner, were made in East Africa and in Germany. You encountered people in Kenya who ensured that you could go to school. A German doctor adopted you, you came to Germany, and continued your studies in Hamburg after language courses and preparatory college. Thus, you are an example of what is possible in the German education system when an education-hungry young person receives opportunities and support – and that educational biographies can be continued here that began in other countries, in other parts of the world. At this point, I would like to add a thank you to the Hamburg Society. I know countless people who are active in Hamburg not only as teachers but also as doctors, dentists, entrepreneurs, tax consultants, in various professions, to bring the idea of solidarity to life by going abroad or being active in sponsorships and accompanying people on the path that is dear to us here. And this Hamburg civic society is indeed something beautiful. I just want to let that roll out of my heart today. I am happy, dear Hamburgers, that this is your culture. Thank you very much for that!

What happens outside of school significantly shapes learning and life at school. Therefore, it is obvious that we must not overload schools with expectations. School cannot be the repair shop of an entire society; it is often stated and still true that it cannot compensate for everything that was neglected by parents in the early years of a child's life.

From research, we know that it is not material poverty itself, but its accompanying circumstances that diminish the societal opportunities of children – for example, a low level of education, but also a lack of care or a lack of upward aspiration in the parental home. It is crucial that children grow up in a positive environment characterized by emotional security – mothers, hopefully with fathers, siblings, friends – they must be available as role models for a child; in short, it must grow up in a social and cultural environment that provides it with support.

And fathers and mothers contribute to children developing the willingness to make an effort. For who does not know that at the age of 13, one has different worries, different needs, and often also different interests than school and education? A positive attitude towards learning and achievement must be exemplified and attentively accompanied in the parental home. Parents, often also grandparents, empower and encourage children to set out and explore the world with an open mind and eagerness.

A few weeks ago, I heard a lecture by the education researcher Marcus Hasselhorn. He impressively demonstrated that education and upbringing in the early years form the most important foundation for later life. Early childhood education is also the key to successful integration. In many young families, this knowledge is lacking. And there are still deficits in language acquisition.

Germany now has experience with early childhood education and upbringing: Kindergarten, this German word has become a term worldwide. But this has been the case for a hundred years now, and we face the task of filling this term with new content. And we are gradually realizing that this also presents an opportunity for our country. In early childhood education, we simply need to get better and start early enough to compensate for disadvantages. Because what is neglected here is difficult, sometimes impossible, to catch up on later.

If educational success is so significantly determined in families, then we must also start with families. Families must be encouraged to take a greater interest in the advancement of their children and to ensure that they spend their free time meaningfully. There is often not enough awareness for this. All the more gratifying is it that we can learn from positive examples everywhere, including here, even today. I will later meet the Yarbas family. The Yarbas family, I have been told, has lived in Germany for decades. The parents come from Turkey and met here in Germany. The family received a scholarship. This now meant academy days for children and parents.

The son Yakup-Abdullah has been attending the upper secondary school since his secondary school graduation, and he would like to become a computer scientist. In addition, he is attending a German course. His mother has always closely accompanied his path and that of his siblings and is also actively involved in volunteering for other children. And Yakup's father has left unemployment behind, is now a taxi entrepreneur, and has further qualified himself through an English course. Dear Yarbas family, your example shows what forces can be unleashed in a family when they embark on a journey together. You can be proud of having dared to take this experiment. And to you, Yakup, I wish that you achieve all your dreams and goals!

The widespread notion is that a successful career can only be the result of a successful school biography. This is actually also somewhat derived from my speech.

But now let’s take a closer look at life. There is – and that is a good thing – a multitude of offers in our country, in terms of advice, projects, and initiatives for those young people who fail in school, also in vocational school, which I spoke about earlier. And we need to make this very clear to ourselves, visualize it clearly. And we recognize, when we look closely, that not everyone in life must fail who has once failed in school.

I want to give you a particularly beautiful example, the example of Thomas Fischer, who is now the presiding judge at the Federal Court of Justice. Only particularly qualified jurists reach that position. And now let’s hear what he says about himself in an interview: "I was a complete school failure." He describes his school time as "one big disaster." He actually always wanted to be a "rock star," and so he dropped out of school; he saw no point in it. However, the plan for a music career soon failed, and then it brought him back to school, where he eventually graduated from high school. He enrolled in the subject of German studies, had various jobs on the side, and dropped out of his studies after a few semesters. After that, he worked as a package deliverer. But somehow that was not enough for him, and he then began studying law – and there he found his path.

Sometimes, as we learn from this, one may have to fail in order to find a new fork in the road, to redefine and adjust a goal, to arrive at oneself. And perhaps we sometimes also need to develop or learn a new perspective on failure – and realize that real new beginnings are possible. It is good when there are supporters and support. In this case, it was the administration of Fischer's high school that gave him a second chance to graduate. Then there were university professors, later also supervisors and colleagues – people who recognized his potential and talent.

We still try far too much to build and maintain the facade of a seamless career in professional life. However, this contradicts many human experiences. If we uphold the value of lifelong learning on the one hand, and if more and more flexibility and openness are demanded from learners and employees, then there cannot be a rigid expectation on the other hand of what a biography should look like. We should then focus – also here! – on the individual and thus on the strengths, on the specific gifts of a person. Then a seamless resume should count less than what the person has learned "in the course of their life," especially through difficulties or temporary failures. We need nothing less than a rethinking in our society.

It is worth putting some old certainties to the test. Perhaps it will even be unavoidable to change our society and with it our education system massively.

This is especially true today, where so many people are seeking refuge in our country. Hardly anyone among the refugees speaks German. They come from countries with a different culture, different religions, and different political systems. Some are well educated and can soon be integrated into the workforce, but for the larger part, basic and specialized knowledge still needs to be imparted. All the more we must strive in the training of teachers. They not only need the necessary linguistic and intercultural competencies – they also need the necessary subject knowledge to convey what constitutes our free democratic order. School is also a world and a space that must convey values. Only then can education unfold the integrative effect that is intended for it.

Here in Hamburg, this development is already very noticeable. Many refugees have come to this city. The response of the citizens is impressive: I would like to mention, as a representative of many volunteers who are engaged in the "Weichenstellung" project of the ZEIT Foundation as mentors for children from refugee families. I have been informed about the Hassan family, whose ten-year-old daughter Basant is supported by mentor Yagmur Celik, who herself comes from a migrant family. After her first year of support, Basant is now attending a Hamburg gymnasium. Her mentor, Ms. Celik, says about her: "She has opened up a lot in the first year and dares to use an expanded vocabulary [...]." So far, Ms. Celik. She dares to do it. Something has happened that has opened up self-confidence in this person. These are the actions we need. We see: In addition to concrete language competence, there is another essential, an emotional component. The child feels: Someone believes in me. And it begins to open up and develop new self-confidence.

In new solutions, the growing optimism and pronounced tolerance of the younger generation can also help. While we cannot conjure up the required solutions overnight, we can make the right adjustments today.

In doing so, we can build on a strong education system, on many initiatives and projects that have been developed over the years and have proven themselves. The importance of school, by the way, also the importance of foundations, is not diminishing; it has become more important.

The task and obligation to ensure equal opportunities in our country will accompany us permanently, not least because we, as an immigration society, will be even more challenged than we already are. Many citizens will not have started their school careers in Germany or will come from families that have immigrated. Everyone deserves their chance, no matter where they come from, whether from within the country or abroad. All of this, I know well, brings effort, it also brings effort and significant costs. But it is the claim that a society of free and equal individuals must have of itself. We do well to face this claim. In it, who we are and who we want to be is revealed.