Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck at the festive event "60 Years of the German Press Club" on November 12, 2012, in Berlin:

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

13 November 2012 · 60 Years of the German Press Club · Berlin, Germany

Context
Gauck addressed the German Press Club at its 60th anniversary celebration on November 12, 2012, in Berlin, reflecting on press freedom and responsibility.
Main themes
Freedom of the press, press responsibility, role of journalism in democracy, political accountability, censorship and its legacy, press-politics relationship, background discussions and confidentiality, media landscape in Germany, Article Five of the Basic Law, public discourse and informed citizenry
Duration
~17 min
59th percentile
Words
2,098
59th percentile
Sentences
126
74th percentile
Readability
49
61st percentile
Grade
10.5
26th percentile
Syntax
2.70
13th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 48%47%
  • Social 40%39%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

126 sentences in 33 paragraphs

Perhaps I should start with a little story to illustrate why I am pleased to speak today and why a speech about the role and freedom of the press is so important. When my grandmother died in the 1960s, I wanted to include the Psalm verse "My times are in Your hands" in the obituary. I was unable to do so. The publisher of the Ostsee-Zeitung, which was published in Rostock, explained to me that they were making a communist newspaper. A Christian text like that was not possible. Even the obituary was censored.

That was a long time ago, and those conditions have been overcome in our country. But it crosses my mind when I talk about the freedom of the press today.

The German Press Club has invited me to its 60th anniversary. What a wonderful occasion to talk about the freedom of the press, the responsibility of the press, freedom of expression, and the relationship between politics and journalism.

However, let us not lose sight of the occasion of this evening: I extend my warmest congratulations to the German Press Club on its 60th anniversary. My congratulations include wishes for you and your club. My congratulations also include wishes that we all – informed citizens as well as politicians – have for you, for the press as a whole. Because as proud as we are of our diverse media landscape, there are also things to discuss that may be less pleasing to all of us. I will come back to that later.

At a celebration of your 60th anniversary, anecdotes swirl through the room. They are part of what makes the club, but not only that. The most important thing is that the German Press Club has added a fundamental building block to the media landscape in the still young Federal Republic – the confidential conversation between politics and the press. The German Press Club established a place for background discussions, a place for the legendary "Under Three."

Your "club rules" state: "No reporting is allowed on club events. Exceptions to this rule will be announced by the current chairperson."

It may be difficult for outsiders to understand that journalists come together in a club about which they are not allowed to report on its events. After all, their main task is to report. But behind every news item are considerations, strategies. Behind the news are actors who want to promote their concerns or disrupt the strategies of others. When you invite politicians to your club, that is exactly what you are after: you want to better understand contexts and attitudes. You want to know how a particular decision comes about, what motivates the protagonists.

You need to know this, because without this background knowledge, you cannot fully grasp political processes, cannot analyze and comment on them deeply enough. And that, in turn, is what is expected of you: that you provide a contribution to the discussion with your analysis, with your commentary, with which readers, listeners, and viewers can better assess events and political actors. You do not have to share your standpoint to appreciate that. But people want your contribution to the debate. You support the orientation and judgment of the many. There are not many tasks that are more beautiful and appealing. So I congratulate you on that as well.

When we look at our media landscape today, we can always talk about whether we feel well-informed, whether what we see on television or what blares from the car radio corresponds to the information mandate. There are fabulous newspapers, good online media, and unfortunately, there are also others.

But whether good or less good, in one respect it does not matter: Article Five of our Basic Law protects the press and its freedom. Take it as a guarantee for your work. The state and civil society want open discussion, want arguments for and against. And to form a judgment, explanations and backgrounds are also needed. In a free and independent press, citizens find them. That is one reason why we protect the freedom of the press. Another reason for the special protection of your work is the expectation of the control function. Citizens wish for political actors to be honest and fully committed to the common good. But they can hardly control whether it is as they hope.

It is part of your tasks to monitor and criticize political processes and actors. You also give a voice to counterarguments. And that has consequences: lobby groups must reckon with their influence being critically examined. A minister must reckon with their statement being compared to one from a year ago. An opposition politician can never be sure that their 180-degree turns will go uncommented. You investigate and you criticize the state, society, parties, or organizations. Not out of a joy in painting things black, but because it is your job.

Reporting, fair information, should also include conveying what has been successful! But public criticism creates control over the criticized conditions. Just the publication – sometimes even the fear of it – can have consequences, can lead to changes in behavior. The republic knows enough examples.

Your profession is therefore also referred to as the fourth estate. You are participants in the political process, you occupy an important position in the formation of opinion and will – and at the same time, you also bear a very large responsibility. We expect you to live up to this responsibility. You are not only free from state interference, from censorship, you are also free in your acceptance of this responsibility. It is part of our daily lived freedom of the press. It is self-evident to us, it simply belongs to our democracy.

However, if we look at the everyday reality in the media industry, not everything is in order. There are indeed situations in which your work is hindered. There are misconducts and there are supposed constraints. We must talk about this openly.

Regarding the ethos of journalists, we could first ask: Can you assure your readers, listeners, users, viewers, can you assure the citizens that you are always aware of your responsibility in your daily work? Do you work every day of the year to promote and enrich the political discourse on which our democracy lives with your articles, contributions, and comments? Can you in good conscience assure that your research is always so thorough that your publications and comments breathe the expertise that does justice to the topics? What does fairness mean to you? Can one trust that there are no buddy relationships, no collusions with the powerful? Do you see your work as self-critically as you expect from those you criticize?

Let us take a look at the conditions under which journalists sometimes have to work; a perfect media world does not seem to exist! Where individual media hold a monopoly position, the diversity of opinion quickly falls by the wayside. But economic pressures also severely affect press freedom in everyday life. When cost pressure determines the editorial daily routine, when the hard-won advertisement halves the editorial text on the page or kicks the commentary out of the paper, deep research, knowledgeable reporting, and balanced commentary quickly become wishful thinking.

And each of us also knows journalists who act like buddies, who sometimes confuse themselves with political advisors and are thus anything but independent. We also know press reports that recklessly contribute to political apathy and fatigue with democracy.

Even critical reporting should recognize positives; for example, it must be able to appreciate the so-called backbenchers who try to master even the driest matters in committees, who prepare intensively for the sessions and thus make parliamentary decisions possible.

This hard work of democracy does not seem to be worth a headline. But should it therefore simply fall out of reporting or at best be commented on ironically?

I am nonetheless confident and want to trust that the vast majority of journalists take their role as chroniclers and observers of politics very seriously and fulfill it to the best of their knowledge and belief. Your research is not always pleasant, your comments are not always comfortable, but they breathe expertise and diligence. That is not the exception but the rule. And one should also be able to rejoice and be grateful for that!

Journalists receive feedback on their work. Letters to the editor. New subscriptions. Cancellations. They receive phone calls – not just from press offices. People approach you on the street, in the parliamentary canteen. On the internet, the like button is pressed – or not. One could also say that your work is noticed and in a way also controlled. That is a good thing.

In Germany, there is an extraordinarily dense system of recognition on the one hand, and control and sanction on the other. This shows that we care about the quality of our press.

And that is why we want to acknowledge this as well. In our country, many journalism awards are given. Some can compete in terms of prestige with a high award in sports. But the control of your work does not only include the prominent praise for what has been done well. You also face sanctions for what has gone wrong and especially for violations of rules.

Moreover, where rules are violated, where the press is hindered or even lied to, but also where the demand for fair and truthful reporting is not met, where privacy is violated, where journalistic instincts are replaced by hunting instincts, the laws, including press laws, come into play. It is good to know that. But it is almost even better to know that the press has created instruments for self-control with the German Press Council, with statutes and codes, that you independently monitor the rules and that the systems of self-control are effective.

Federal President Gustav Heinemann received the press code adopted by the press associations on December 12, 1973. In it, you, the German journalists, commit to respect for the truth, to uphold human dignity, and to provide truthful information to the public. You commit to journalistic diligence, to the separation of advertising and editorial content. You assure the citizens – and not just as a side note – that you are indeed aware of your responsibility as the fourth estate and work accordingly.

By setting such standards, by defining yourselves as true observers, by proving in your daily work that you accompany the political process with independent and persistent research, you are, despite all independence, also part of a political overall system that guarantees you the freedom you need for your work through the safeguarding of press freedom.

Let us finally ask again about the role of the institution whose anniversary we are celebrating today. Even you, the members of the German Press Club, sometimes find it difficult to classify political decisions. Politics is usually a very complex structure, a complicated web of interests, constraints, and individuals.

The founders of the German Press Club recognized this and therefore deliberately created a place where it is not about sensationalism, not about the news as such, but about the contexts behind the news.

Only seemingly is there a contradiction between the confidentiality of background discussions and the transparency that citizens are entitled to expect. On the contrary, I believe that background confidentiality is also necessary to bring more transparency to political processes and decision-making paths.

Precisely because your conversation partners know that not every sentence will make the morning news the next day, they speak openly and seriously with you about politics and its backgrounds. You, in turn, need this openness to be able to accompany the political process knowledgeably. You need this openness to be able to comment on it critically if necessary. You can more easily recognize whom you can trust, whom the public can attribute credibility to.

Politics also needs such encounters to better explain its actions. And that, in turn, is what informed citizens want: an explanation for politics and its effects. Because without politics being explained, acceptance for politics, for politicians, and ultimately acceptance for our democracy will dwindle sooner or later. By contributing to the analysis, explanation, commentary, and debate of politics, by giving a voice to arguments for and against, by contributing to the clash of opinions, our press contributes in a significant and natural way to the functioning of our democracy.

This is good and it should remain so. Once again, I congratulate the German Press Club, which for 60 years has ensured that we have a free, informed, and good press.

Congratulations!