Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck at the "Leadership Meeting Economy 2012" of the Süddeutsche Zeitung on November 15, 2012, in Berlin:

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

16 November 2012 · "Leadership Meeting Economy 2012" of the Süddeutsche Zeitung · Berlin, Germany

Context
Gauck addressed the Süddeutsche Zeitung Leadership Meeting Economy 2012 in Berlin on November 15, 2012, speaking on Europe's role in the global economy amid financial crisis.
Main themes
Financial and debt crisis, freedom and responsibility, European economic renewal, leadership and accountability, trust and legitimacy, regulatory reform, values in market economy, emerging markets, sovereign debt, crisis of responsibility
Duration
~38 min
89th percentile
Words
4,520
89th percentile
Sentences
269
94th percentile
Readability
49
61st percentile
Grade
10.5
26th percentile
Syntax
2.88
31st percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
34th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 53%50%
  • Social 21%20%
  • Institutional 11%10%
  • Ceremonial 9%8%
  • Geopolitical 6%5%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

269 sentences in 51 paragraphs

First, I would like to thank you, dear Mr. Kister, for the invitation. You are our host, and we are pleased! In the announcement for this congress, the word "crisis" was mentioned, more specifically: "financial and debt crisis," and right after that came the friendly sentence: "He" – referring to me – "can provide orientation."

Thank you for this vote of confidence! This might be called a credit for clear words. I will gladly try to redeem it within the framework of possibilities, but also the limits that the office of the Federal President has. This office does not make me an economist, nor a parliamentarian who would have to make decisions, and certainly does not make me a prophet. But it grants me independence, opportunities for open words, and moments like this, in which I am allowed to speak as a German, a European, and a global citizen, as per the program description.

"The new Europe in a new world economy": This is the title of your event. The title would be enough for at least two lectures. I would gladly dedicate a speech to our cooperation in Europe at another occasion. The world economy – keyword "emerging markets" – is currently changing at a pace that the contributions at congresses are often outdated by the time of the joint dinner. All the more worthwhile it is to search for the motives behind the crisis and our longing for renewal. This is to be my topic today. Under the overarching theme "Enabling freedom, assuming responsibility," which I have set for myself, I ask how we can convincingly connect freedom and responsibility? I am not only concerned with the question of how we want to morally assess or improve our actions, but also with how we can create facts for competitiveness and location strength. There is, alongside the political, also an economic rationale for freedom and responsibility!

Let us look back: The year 2008 stands for a shock that continues to resonate today. The financial sector has since become one of the most criticized professions. However, some bankers feel just as deceived and cheated as some savers or investors whose dream of a 25 percent profit ended in a 100 percent loss.

Some leaders also proved to be seduced, sometimes even seducers: with their profit-seeking and their greed – not only in the financial sector, with their promises of prosperity and excessive growth fantasies – not only in politics, with their gullibility and their exaggerated expectations – not only on the customer side. Excessiveness has led us into this crisis. Many actors realized too late: When the sense of proportion is lost, fundamental values – reliability, predictability, reason, and time and again trust – diminish. Not everything that was legal is perceived today as legitimate. We see: Everywhere where reasonable measure was no longer the standard, where freedoms were overstretched and abused – in lending, in shadow banking, in the real estate sector, or even in public budgets as well as in private debt – everywhere the crisis has taken hold of us and around us. Responsibility crises became economic crises and sovereign debt crises because claims and efforts no longer corresponded.

Anyone looking at the current employment figures and growth in Germany might think that the imbalance has been overcome. At the same time, we feel at every corner that our internal constitution is still in disorder. There is a discomfort that experts and laypeople share, without being able to spell it out in detail. We read every few days about the nervousness of the markets. We hear how the neighbor says to the car dealer: "Before the money is gone, I would rather make my grandson happy." She says this calmly and pragmatically, far from all panic. But sentences like these show that, as well as we are doing, something in our thinking has somehow changed. The belief in a "business as usual" has been shaken.

We now have two options.

First

: to correct the rules, that is, the external framework of action. This is good and right, because frameworks and rules are indispensable. I will return to this.

Equally urgent is the option two

: to review our internal convictions, our motives, and attitudes. This process seems to have come to a standstill in many cases.

Let us remember. The discussion after 2008 culminated in keywords like "casino capitalism." There was talk of gamblers and risk-takers. The banking crisis and the debt crisis became part of everyday vocabulary, and new words like "bad bank" have found their place there to this day. Not only Greece, but a whole series of countries in Europe, America, and Asia, including Germany itself, suffer from a sometimes overwhelming debt burden. The connections are complex; problems have often accumulated over years or even decades. There are plenty of accusations. And it is rather rare for leaders from business and politics to admit: "I made a mistake."

A new approach to mistakes would therefore suit us well. Leadership, greatness, and credibility also involve recognizing and acknowledging mistakes. A friend from abroad once told me what he perceives as typically German: "Germans see a mistake as failure, think of it as defeat. In our case, however, a mistake is more of a valuable experience that helps with a new beginning." Perhaps we can learn from this attitude. If we want to identify causes and ways out of the crisis, it is certainly worthwhile to review our thinking, language, and behavior patterns.

In the past, a convenient solution lay in shifting responsibility into the abstract. This is then expressed like this: "The market has failed." "Regulation was lacking." "The sanction did not take effect." Blame was placed on "the system," "the politics," or best of all: "globalization," or even simpler "capitalism."

Do we actually still listen to each other? We speak so about an abstract enemy that sounds insurmountable like military power and walls of the Cold War. The problem with such abstraction is: In this world, there is no one with whom to negotiate, find compromises, develop cooperation, or even make peace. After sentences without "I" pronouns, the subject that could practice self-criticism and grow from it is often missing. The trail of responsibility then gets lost in lamenting the complexity of things, in the mode of non-responsibility, or simply in despondency. We eloquently complain about anonymous markets, masses, or mechanisms – we too rarely look at the people, their attitudes, with which they make decisions and can change something.

In addition, there is another preference: We prefer to look at the present. When it comes to consequences for the future, we like to ignore responsibility or take – more or less consciously – into account that our decision criteria today do not meet the requirements of tomorrow.

Anyone who takes a moment back from everyday business and asks whether the biggest global problems – I say problems, not challenges – have something in common will find: There is a common denominator in over-indebtedness, income disparity, environmental destruction, and many other issues. We have always made a decision at a certain point X – "back then" – to do something, the follow-up costs of which for the future we either did not want to foresee or could not secure.

We have decoupled the price of our actions from the moment of decision and thereby separated two things that belong together: the freedom to do something and the responsibility to stand for something. Instead, we have irresponsibly shifted some burdens into the lifespan of our grandchildren. I say "we" because I know very few who have not at some point fallen prey to this pattern. In some countries in Europe, the older generation, who have worked for decades with the best intentions for prosperity and quality of life, now stand helpless before a youth, a whole large population group, that critically questions and feels itself to be a victim of accumulated failures: without education, without work, without perspective for a self-fulfilled life in profession and society.

These are truly disturbing developments. Of course, I cannot conjure up help here when I describe these things, but I can certainly advocate for an attitude. I wish that we would question our ideas of responsibility and – where necessary – assume responsibility more convincingly, anchoring responsibility in the here and now. And in doing so, take the future into account! Responsibility must not be a business at the expense of others. Those who take it on must be willing to bear it immediately and sustainably. In sustainability lies the root of the word for attitude. Sustainability means expecting entrepreneurs, politicians, and interest groups to connect their decision-making processes with the question of whether they are overloading the entire system and harming the general public or with which alternative they can minimize future risks.

By emphasizing responsibility for the future in this way, I do not overlook the already successful aspects of the present; on the contrary: I want to strengthen these aspects. And I know that in the German economy – not only there! – responsibility is already being exemplary lived in many places. I am grateful for that. Here in the hall, at your conference, there are witnesses to this, responsible individuals, doers: professionally excellent, prudent, and integrity-driven personalities.

I am grateful when guests from abroad tell me in Bellevue about the good reputation that German companies and German entrepreneurs and their products have in the world, that "made in Germany" stands for quality, reliability, and high standards. Then they often tell me how much they admire the dual education system. I mention this as a concrete example of how responsibility is affirmed and promoted beyond corporate profits, and also practiced. There is a culture of entrepreneurship to which this system simply belongs. We see all of this. We do not question it; we are pleased about it. It is a source of our mental strength. It is equally beyond question that we cannot retreat to an island with this thought, because we want to build a new Europe and a new world economy. Especially as a successful economic nation, we are part of a great dynamic in which leading and being led could be closer together in the future than we would like.

I see leaders in a triple responsibility: inward, outward, and for a cooperative coexistence in our society. I can also express it this way: It is about the responsibility for the success of the company in the market. It is about the responsibility for the acceptance of the company in society. And it is about the responsibility for the rules that should apply in coexistence. These categories overlap, just as life cannot be sharply defined. What is crucial for me in this triad is: Leadership obliges not only in one respect. One of the most important lessons from the crisis was that we must constantly broaden our perspective: from the original entrepreneurial tasks to factors such as credibility and trust, to the great ethical and social issues.

Responsibility also means: providing answers. Not only to the questions of shareholders and investors but also to those of employees and customers, suppliers, partners, citizens, children, and grandchildren. This willingness to engage in conversation has been partially lost by some and completely by others. However, this behavior I praise is actually based on very old virtues and an old wisdom that we must continually rediscover.

Martin Buber, the Jewish philosopher, once formulated it this way: "Real responsibility only exists where there are real answers. Answers to what? To what happens to one, what one sees, hears, and feels." So far Buber.

The first step in assuming such responsibility is the acknowledgment of the responsible subject, of the human being with his possibilities. We do not need to reinvent this. I think of an old concept, the honorable merchant – some say: an endangered species. This is not quite true, because even in ancient Venice, it was claimed that it was easier to train a clever lawyer than an honest merchant. So we know that it is difficult, but he exists. You all know him; some of you are him, and you do not necessarily suffer from it, but you earn good money despite your integrity. This is something we should remind ourselves of from time to time. Perhaps we can recall in this context a business personality that is typical for our country, and that is Robert Bosch. By the way, the first Federal President of our country wrote a biography about him. His motto was: "A decent way of managing a business is ultimately the most profitable." This is how Robert Bosch dared to put it simply. One cannot say that he became poor in the process. A company that is still committed to this corporate philosophy is still competitive and partly leading in the market.

I would also like to calmly remind you of the scene in the banking sector. To remind you that, of course, in the real existing world of banking, there are also people who did not engage in speculation in 2008. I have personally encountered some of them. In doing so, I had interesting experiences. Some told me that they did not understand the complicated banking products before 2008 and therefore did not enter the business. Others told me exactly the opposite: they understood these products too well to want to get involved. In any case, there are honest merchants in this sector.

The task of an entrepreneur, as we know, remains primarily to make a profit, to write good black numbers, to ensure market viability, to be courageous, to take risks, and to make investments. The point is: risks must remain manageable and must not ultimately control us. Companies and abstaining from action always belong together in some way. Black numbers are no reason to cross red lines!

Free entrepreneurship therefore needs boundaries. I would not have thought that I, a lover of freedom, whose life theme is the overcoming of boundaries, would sing a hymn to boundaries here. By the way, I also belonged for a time to those who believed that when it comes to regulation, less is more.

My fundamental attitude has, of course, changed. I love freedom. I am not willing to sacrifice it to fear. Even in times of crisis, we must not believe that we can become future-proof by taking away the freedom that makes the economy strong. But the cut of 2008 did reveal a fallacy. Too many had written the "lean state" on their banners back in the 1990s. Because we hoped to promote growth with less bureaucracy. Real growth, no false prosperity, no excess. In the banking sector and on the global financial markets, this was unfortunately a mistake in many respects! The most important message of the flagging should have been directed at a capable and willing state! Instead, we allowed freedom and responsibility to drift apart and now must bring them back together, yes: lead them!

Responsible action now means being a friend of some boundaries out of freedom! When a few take the freedom to bear no responsibility, they destroy the conditions under which we can live in freedom. Those conditions of freedom, which, by the way, the economy needs. Boundlessness may grant these few unheard-of heights at times. But for the many, for the others, boundlessness does not create a habitable living space, but a desert.

If life is to succeed, then freedom and responsibility must go together. This coupling does not happen by itself, certainly not automatically. Even the honorable merchant alone cannot create it. It must be organized at a societal level, ideally also designed globally.

This includes the state, whose primary task is to set rules and enforce them. This includes a society that learns to appreciate regulation and effective supervision anew. And this includes a broad societal debate about what we want and what we do not want.

Take the financial sector as an example. The credo of banks should literally be the credibility of their actions. Some banks are rightly bringing the concept of credibility back to the forefront, thinking aloud about lower returns, about fewer salary allowances and bonuses. Some even express their regret and respond to the accusations that are now being dealt with in courts. For me, it is incredible: this manipulation of the Libor interest rate by some highly reputable institutions. It would have been unimaginable for me a number of years ago what we are now partly discussing in courts. Thus, some banks are consciously announcing a cultural change.

Much has only just begun. The rampant growth in the financial sector has not yet been eliminated, but we are on a path of correction. Fundamental changes are still necessary. After all, politics and business share a basic understanding: the financial sector urgently needs to be cleaned up! The goal must be that individual banks can no longer lead entire states to the brink of disaster. There will certainly be intense discussions about the "how" of this cleanup, while the "when" is perceived by many observers as being approached too slowly.

Politics is trying to regulate, but unfortunately, there is little international consensus on the measures and principles of regulation. Moreover, it seems that politics is often outmatched by the banks. Insiders illustrate this repeatedly with the "hare and hedgehog phenomenon" in the vast field of regulation.

I look forward to the day when the banks themselves formulate a concept that is not only debated in expert circles but also leads to a broad societal discourse. The banking system of the new world economy – if you will – in any case, a banking system that has a future, must not collect these bonuses in good times and then demand taxpayers' money in times of trouble due to its systemic relevance. Bank bailouts may indeed be necessary in individual cases to avert damage not only from the bank but also from the general public. I do not close my eyes to that. But above all, banks must again fulfill genuine business responsibilities and be liable for the consequences of their actions. The current certainty of being rescued in an emergency shifts the risk attitude of banks in a way that neither corresponds to the market nor to the wishes of taxpayers.

With the effort to find new and convincing rules, the issue of acceptance is, of course, connected: for me, the key term of the second form of corporate responsibility, responsibility outward. Promoting acceptance means, in my eyes, more than good PR or working on the company image. Promoting acceptance is the sustainable engagement with one's own values. By attitude, I do not simply mean nobility. Attitude is shown when leaders in companies have understood that credibility is an indispensable part of their corporate capital, just as credibility is inseparably linked to banking or the mandate of politicians. Credibility sounds not only morally valuable but is also economically wise, a real, monetary gain for companies! We know the examples where a lack of credibility, a lack of anchoring of fundamental values has driven entire retail chains into ruin. Customers sometimes respond more harshly to moral violations than to tangible product defects. Conversely, solidity and reputation are often even incentives to buy. The brand "made in Germany" largely lives off this. Acceptance arises like a mosaic from many parts, such as the working conditions for employees, the fulfillment of environmental protection regulations, the selection of suppliers and contractual partners – simply from all standards that a leader can justify with the statement: "Because these values are worth it to us."

Healthy companies need a healthy environment in their own interest. This applies socially, it applies ecologically, and it applies globally. When we observe the debates about CO2 quotas or environmental destruction, we get a sense of how multifaceted acceptance issues will need to be addressed in the coming decades.

Not everyone has understood that not only money and resources but also our social values are at stake on the global marketplace. But it is about human dignity, about human rights, about respect and coexistence among the different. It is about democracy, about its citizens, and all conceivable forms of responsibility. It is about the foundations of our freedom! We must not relinquish these values anywhere – at no factory gate in the world.

With this "we," I do not mean only leaders of all kinds but a real "we all." Bangladesh, Budapest, and Berlin belong to a world economy. The scope for responsibly acting entrepreneurs is also shaped by the sense of responsibility of customers. With the receipt, one can also cement terrible conditions. Or, to put it another way: consumers have enormous market power. Where cell phones become a lifestyle, production conditions are increasingly not irrelevant. One can line up at 5:00 AM for the latest device on the market. But one can also protest for an entire day in front of the store against inhumane workplace contracts, where these products are manufactured. How long will Europeans continue to buy jeans for ten euros, even though they know that the very poorest in Asia or Latin America pay a high price for the production of such products, thus paying with their health and dignity so that we can shop so cheaply? We should not forget the images of burning factories and tortured bodies behind closed bars; they concern us, the customers. We know the cases of today and the forecasts for tomorrow if someone does not often step forward and say: I made a mistake, and I will do it differently now. I am so free! If we do not recognize this, the mistakes we see today will also be the mistakes of tomorrow.

Attitude must not be exhausted in appeals. Attitude requires action. And indeed, from everyone: not only from leaders in business and politics but also from customers and citizens. If you will: the economy and society are not always just the others. Where this is internalized, we learn: responsible capitalism is possible.

Let us not remain stuck in outdated antagonisms. Decency in economic life is important; at the same time, the pursuit of profit is not indecent. It is only the sheer greed, the desire to increase at any cost, that becomes dangerous. The civilization of greed, however, creates this enlightened capitalism that gives our societies a future. Too often, those who call for responsibility when it is needed are simply pushed into the corner of dreamers – as if there were only a choice between selfish entrepreneurship and unrealistic altruism. Here the social, there the economy. Here the warm-hearted good, there the cold competition. We must overcome this thinking in false alternatives. We cannot do without competition and growth. These incentives make our society particularly capable of learning and particularly innovative. What is crucial is that we find the rules that prevent false practices and enable fair competition. This also requires a willingness to cooperate; for me, this is the third dimension of responsibility. It opens the space for balance, for compromises.

Long before the debate about the new Europe and the new world economy appeared on the horizon, the mothers and fathers of the Basic Law described our canon of values and explicitly anchored the social state alongside democracy and the rule of law. In this sense, I would like to remind you of Article 14 of the Basic Law: "Property obliges. Its use shall also serve the welfare of the general public."

There are many responsible leaders in our country who feel committed to this welfare of the general public, live values, and take responsibility. My first award ceremony at Schloss Bellevue was dedicated to two well-known ambassadors of social partnership: the trade unionist Michael Sommer and the top manager Hubertus Erlen. Each – in his own way in his field – had been concerned for decades with responsible decisions in companies. And each could report from the true, real, lived life of cooperation and the search for future viability. Michael Sommer recalled in his acceptance speech the concerns in 2008, the willingness to compromise, and the entrepreneurial co-responsibility that was evident at that time on both sides – among employers and employees. Social partnership, as we learn from such an example, has proven itself in our country. You, Prime Minister Jean-Marc Ayrault, have just recently pointed this out. I am very grateful for that. And in 2008, we indeed had to face a truly difficult situation, perhaps the most difficult since 1949. We have good experiences with democratic co-determination. Works councils and social plans did not ruin our companies but secured the location of Germany. We have learned that short-time work benefits in critical phases can save the long-term prospects of a company and its employees. Where social balance was highly valued, the crisis hit less hard.

I therefore find in this crisis a wealth of hopeful possibilities, in any case, an incentive to act. Many European interlocutors confirm to me that they experience social political balance in their countries as a space for dialogue and compromises, as a prerequisite for a welfare policy that empowers rather than disempowers or paralyzes.

Europe legitimizes itself before its citizens through the realization of economic and social goals. I have the impression: more and more Europeans recognize that social stability and cooperation are also an economic gain. Where we experience this expanded economic rationale and the willingness to reform, Europe is on an encouraging path.

Dear Prime Minister Ayrault, I follow with great sympathy the fact that very intense discussions in this direction have begun in France. Precisely because this is an extremely uncomfortable political path, I join all those who appreciate and support these efforts. I am very pleased to welcome you and the French delegation here! You are especially warmly welcome!

As we know, France and Germany are among the nations that are repeatedly asked to commit themselves with particular strength to Europe. Let us do this together with our European partners in a way that does not prioritize some over others, but rather ensures that everyone is convinced to take their share of responsibility.

Germany is – especially after our crisis experiences – ready to entrust its economic and political experiences to the European community. This was true in the difficult post-war years, in all the challenging times of reconstruction. This was true during the time of national reunification in 1990. This was true about ten years ago, when Germany was economically struggling. And this is true now, in times of economic prosperity. We believe that our experiences will not weaken but strengthen the future prospects of Europe.

My wish is also a request: We must not leave the last word in the crisis to the fearmongers – neither at home nor in the world. Freedom must never be the freedom to abandon our values.

You here in the hall can make it clear in these days: We are all free, but none of us is free from responsibility.