Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck during his inaugural visit to the Federal Constitutional Court on October 18, 2012, in Karlsruhe:

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

10 November 2012 · Inaugural visit to the Federal Constitutional Court · Federal Constitutional Court, Karlsruhe, Germany

Context
Gauck addressed the Federal Constitutional Court during his inaugural visit to Karlsruhe on October 18, 2012, marking the customary meeting between new heads of state and constitutional bodies.
Main themes
Federal Constitutional Court, rule of law, fundamental rights, constitutional order, judicial independence, legal fidelity, democracy, German legal history, GDR experience, European constitutional jurisprudence, individual rights vs. state power, civic legal consciousness
Duration
~8 min
29th percentile
Words
1,005
29th percentile
Sentences
49
32nd percentile
Readability
44
45th percentile
Grade
12.2
47th percentile
Syntax
3.09
60th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
37th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 69%69%
  • Ceremonial 18%18%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Social 6%6%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

49 sentences in 14 paragraphs

Thank you very much for the exceedingly warm welcome. It is a beautiful tradition that after changes in office, the constitutional bodies also get to know each other personally. Not only for this reason have I gladly come to Karlsruhe today. Of course, I was already fundamentally aware of the significance of the Federal Constitutional Court. However, in the lead-up to this visit, the political situation and the very current rulings of the Federal Constitutional Court have made me acutely aware: Without the Federal Constitutional Court, our constitutional order would be incomplete.

So I come to you with great joy and deep appreciation.

I myself grew up in a societal system where the constitution contained some fundamental rights and state guarantees. But in the GDR, citizens could not enforce their rights against the state power. There was no instance before which citizens could sue the socialist state.

Therefore, the democracy movement of 1989 already knew: Independent courts – committed solely to the law, to no government, and to no ideology or idea – are an indispensable part of a rule of law.

However, for this independence and for the rule of law as a whole, a second element is also essential, perhaps more important than a finely honed system of legal protection: I would like to characterize it as "attitude." This includes the legal fidelity of citizens and the legal fidelity of those who apply the law – judges, prosecutors, lawyers, and administrative officials. It is their ethos to apply the law correctly. This is important to mention because we have to acknowledge a dual history of legal loss in Germany. We have experienced in Germany how jurists became accomplices of the ruling power – how the law was perverted. And I want to name one more thing here: People from countries where legal consciousness is less pronounced do not ask in vain: Why are prohibitions and obligations followed in Germany?

Perhaps one answer to this question lies in the fact that the rule of law in Germany is older than democracy. In the old Federal Republic – certainly in a longer process – judicial review has become a matter of course over more than 60 years. Thus, the Federal Constitutional Court crowns our rule of law. With its rulings, it has impressively fulfilled the promise of the Basic Law and its guarantees of fundamental rights. Those who, like the East Germans – and the Eastern Europeans – have once lost everything that guarantees the subjectivity of a citizen, the freedom, the democracy, the legal certainty, those who have lost all this know how to appreciate the guarantees of the rule of law that our constitution contains. And that is why I will remind everyone, wherever necessary, of the high value of being able to assert one's rights against the state in court.

Gustav Radbruch once said: "Nothing is as decisive for the style of a legal era as the conception of man to which it is oriented."

In this sense, the Federal Constitutional Court has been and continues to be a model and an example for other constitutional courts: The rights to freedom and equality bind not only the executive and the judiciary but are also, according to the rulings of the Federal Constitutional Court, a standard for legislation. With this jurisprudence, the court places the individual at the center and no longer the state or the class, as has often happened disastrously in Germany. In this way, the court has significantly shaped the understanding of the state in the Federal Republic. It has had a decisive influence on ensuring that the consciousness of the rule of law and legal fidelity are firmly anchored in the minds of the citizens of Germany.

Whoever is tasked with controlling the other constitutional bodies, administration, and courts inevitably attracts criticism. As constant as the approval and trust of the Germans in their Federal Constitutional Court is, criticism of it also arises constantly – sometimes expressed in harsh terms. But you can withstand criticism – I am sure of that.

Not only in the current crisis does politics sometimes perceive Karlsruhe's "interventions" as an unnecessary burden. Even in neighboring countries, some are astonished by the role of German constitutional jurisdiction. This does not change the fact: Your decisions are read attentively, in Berlin, throughout the country, by our neighbors, in Brussels, in Luxembourg, and Strasbourg; by the way, also in other continents.

I have said elsewhere that we must not act as the preceptors of all of Europe. This certainly applies to the Federal Constitutional Court as well. But we must not deny our experiences. We can certainly showcase our experience with democracy, with debate, with a rule of law across Europe and say: This is how it can be done. And among the positive achievements, the Federal Constitutional Court and its jurisprudence are particularly noteworthy.

For even the negative decisions of the Federal Constitutional Court fulfill an important function: pacification! Karlsruhe grants a kind of "quality seal." "If the Federal Constitutional Court has no objections, then it must be all right." So it was – in my impression – also after your decision on the ESM.

In my preparation, I also realized that the Federal Constitutional Court and the Federal President have an institutional closeness. Our independence has – I believe – a special responsibility: You guarantee in a special way the freedom of citizens on the one hand and the balance of powers on the other – for example, when your rulings require greater parliamentary involvement for important state decisions. I see my task as strengthening trust in our democratic institutions, in their processes and decisions. This visit here today serves that purpose.

To all of you – the judges – I would like to thank you once again for the warm reception. A special thanks goes to the scientific staff of the house and all those who support our constitutional judges in their important work. I look forward to the discussions and many new insights.