Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck at the festive event for the 300th anniversary of external financial control on November 18, 2014, in Bonn:

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

30 November 2014 · Festive event for the 300th anniversary of external financial control · Bonn, Germany

Context
Gauck addressed a festive event in Bonn on November 18, 2014, marking the 300th anniversary of external financial control in Germany.
Main themes
External financial control, good governance and transparency, democratic accountability, history of German state institutions, Prussian origins of audit institutions, Federal Court of Auditors anniversary, rule of law, public trust in government, fiscal responsibility, Nazi era abuse of bureaucracy, GDR contrast with democratic institutions
Duration
~24 min
74th percentile
Words
2,904
74th percentile
Sentences
144
79th percentile
Readability
50
62nd percentile
Grade
11.3
36th percentile
Syntax
3.05
54th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
42nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 65%60%
  • Ceremonial 18%17%
  • Economic 14%13%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 8%

144 sentences in 33 paragraphs

What a beautiful place you have chosen for your anniversary:

This hall, where the German Bundestag convened, with its special transparency, is indeed fitting. It is also said of this building that it embodies a "dignity of modesty," which is also appropriate. Of course, we overlook at this moment that the construction became significantly more expensive than originally planned. Of course, you noticed that at the time and made the necessary comments about it. So we are inspired by this building in which we meet, and thus we are already right in the middle of the topic.

For we are currently reminded of the claim of our state, namely to act transparently and in the interest of the citizens and to use tax funds economically. And above all, we remember the birth of an institution that helps to verify whether this claim is actually fulfilled: external financial control.

It is a birthday that somehow does not belong to the classic commemorative days: 300 years. We look at the Federal Republic and what came before it and what existed alongside it, in the form of the GDR. And we see: It is a history of breaks that you elevate here to the dignity of an anniversary. But that tells us a lot about our country. And it also tells us that with a long-term perspective, it is possible not only to focus on the negative elements of German national history but also to recognize an early achievement in monarchical times. Just as the recognition of the rule of law principle by some monarchies, the introduction of an external control body is a good cultural and political legacy of old Europe. And I find it very inspiring that you have come up with the idea of drawing such a line of tradition in public. We are, after all, partly what has come upon us. We are not only in the negative but also in the positive; one can certainly clarify this at such a celebration.

There are worlds between the "Prussian General Audit Office," whose founding in 1714 is the reason for our anniversary, and its successors up to the present day, the audit offices at the federal and state levels. This should prompt us to ask: What exactly are we honoring?

We honor an important moment in the history of our country, a step from an absolutist society towards a citizen state. For with external financial control, a tool of modern state governance was introduced at that time, a tool of limitation, indeed even of self-limitation of state, then monarchical power. This instrument has served different purposes throughout its history – of course, the power of a single ruler as well as the strengthening of an elected representation of the people. As we know it today, it is an indispensable tool to ensure transparency and control of public affairs.

So today we are talking about an element of good governance – in modern terms: about "good governance." About an important prerequisite for citizens to be able to trust their state. And thus about an essential element of our democracy.

The birth of the then General Audit Office is fundamentally due to Prussian extravagance! Friedrich Wilhelm I had to witness how his father led an excessive lifestyle – and how Prussia declined outside the capital. He experienced nepotism, corruption, inefficiency at court – and outside in the country, devastation from wars, famines, and poverty. When he came to power, he literally sold the family silver: He radically cut the salaries of the remaining court and state officials, had all expenditures checked from then on – and invested parts of the money he saved in troops.

Anyone who visits the exhibition of the Federal Court of Auditors on three centuries of external financial control or takes the catalog in hand will learn many such stories about the long journey of external financial control from its birth in Prussia to its anchoring in the Basic Law of the Federal Republic of Germany. From an instrument of the king, who could determine the fate of his country according to his whims, to an instrument that helps elected parliamentarians to actually exercise their royal right, their sovereignty over the budget.

The history of external auditing is also a story of the constantly growing state tasks and thus state expenditures. It has curious aspects – for example, at the end of the 19th century, the Imperial Court of Auditors was tasked with auditing the budgets of Cameroon, Togo, and German South West Africa. It has frightening chapters that once again show how closely modern, efficient bureaucracy was linked to the mass crimes of the Nazi regime. It is important that the Federal Court of Auditors wants to research this chapter of history more closely. It shows: Every instrument of the state can be used for different purposes, but it can also be abused. In the GDR, there was no place for an independent audit office in the service of the citizens. Why would there be? A country that does not need a constitutional court and no administrative courts obviously did not need this instrument either. Financial auditing in the GDR was an instrument of political leadership to control the officials.

So today we celebrate that our current audit offices are independent bodies. We celebrate that we, the citizens, can assume that our tax money is mostly used effectively and economically – and this trust in turn enables public institutions to actually fulfill their diverse tasks for the community.

The power over money is a fundamental prerequisite for a capable and shaping state. As a rule of law, it sets norms. As a tax and social state, it collects almost half of the economically produced wealth and invests it in public goods, in services, and channels it as transfer payments to private households and businesses – thereby creating public welfare in the best sense. 1.250 billion euros flowed through the coffers of public budgets and social insurances last year.

A brief look at the topic list of the Federal Court of Auditors gives an idea of how complex the tasks are. No public expenditure goes unchecked: from the computer equipment of schools to the locks of our country. From party financing to deficits in social funds to the costs of the energy transition. From counter-terrorism centers to foreign intelligence of German secret services. From the standard rifle of the Bundeswehr to the "Federal Reserve Grain."

At times, one might think that auditors are rather pedantic. Theodor Heuss, when he inaugurated the new service building of the Federal Court of Auditors in Frankfurt am Main in 1953, told a few fitting anecdotes. But he immediately intercepted the laughter: It is not "nitpicking," he made clear, but "state attentiveness" that is at work here. What a beautiful word!

Such state attentiveness – it is anything but self-evident. In how many countries in the world do we find corruption, elites enriching themselves at the expense of the state, unreliable authorities, mismanagement, and financial arbitrariness – ultimately to the detriment of all! How valuable it is, therefore, that external financial control has significantly shaped the self-understanding and understanding of the state in our country; how good it is that the claim to legality and accountability is so firmly anchored in the consciousness of the citizens; how important it is that we have this institution that sets standards for the actions of the public sector!

Some see our current audit offices as toothless institutions – this is sometimes referred to – or as "knights without swords." But those who deal seriously with them know very well: They are not, for even without their own directive and implementation power, they are taken seriously, indeed even a little and often a little more feared. You probably all know the famous words of the town captain to his officials in Nikolai Gogol's comedy: "I have called you here to make a most unpleasant announcement: An inspector is on his way to us!" In this case, the inspector turns out to be merely a supposed inspector. But the story teaches us: Just the announcement of a control leads the recipients to hold up a mirror to themselves. And even more, the permanent possibility that at some point, perhaps tomorrow, an audit could come has a disciplining effect.

Even Friedrich Wilhelm I demanded of his auditors not to spare anyone, "let him be who he will." And Johannes Rau provided amusement at the 50th anniversary celebration of the Federal Court of Auditors when he denied that he had traveled to Bonn solely to prevent the Court of Auditors from coming to Berlin and the Federal President's Office.

It goes without saying that the relationship between auditors and those audited is not always free of friction. That is a good thing. In the audited offices, people are usually glad when the auditors are gone. It would be concerning if it were otherwise – and it should not trouble you, dear auditors, in any case. I would like to take this opportunity to thank all of you for your attitude and for your service, for the seriousness with which you carry out your task, all of you who contribute to this important task, all of you who are in the hall and all of you who are working outside in your authorities, "thank you." I say this from the heart because I know that this cannot be an easy task. I can imagine that it is often a frustrating thing. You work meticulously and audit and audit – and if it is a good, indeed the best case, then you find: nothing! At least nothing that would be objectionable. You then make suggestions on how processes could be optimized, how money could be used better – but whether the affected offices draw the consequences that you consider right, you do not have in your hands.

What might now appear as a weakness is in truth rather a strength, for it protects the audit offices from being politically co-opted. The classic definition of auditing is clear: They should not assess whether a politically defined goal is sensible or nonsensical, but primarily check objectively whether an expenditure fulfills its purpose. There is a joke that illustrates this nicely. In the pub, they sit, we all know them, the pessimist and the optimist. An auditor now joins them. They all sit in front of a glass that is half full. "Half full," we know, says the optimist. "Half empty," says the pessimist. And what does the auditor say? He says: "The glass is, measured against its purpose, 100 percent too large."

The task of the audit offices is therefore primarily to uncover disorder – that is, all that does not correspond to the politically desired order. However, as the President has just hinted, the tasks of the Federal Court of Auditors have indeed expanded in recent years: away from mere hindsight, that is, "re-vision," to looking forward, with visions. Away from pure economy audits to auditing entire processes, from criticism to targeted advice to politics.

This is sometimes certainly a balancing act, for purely mathematically, much may seem plausible or implausible. And yet a reform, a budget cut, an alternative procedural proposal may not be politically feasible or not so easily implemented. Democracy has its own rationality, its own procedures, and also its own limits. Even if it may be glaringly obvious to an auditor – the actual political responsibility for where our state could save or act more sensibly lies with the elected representatives of the people. And that, we all know, is a good thing.

Nevertheless, the audit offices are a very essential element of our democratic order. They are part of the learning system of democracy. Their uniqueness is not that they are perfect and complete, but that they are capable of correcting mistakes, transforming, and finding new ways in societal discourse. For the public debate about how our community should be organized to remain future-proof, the expertise of our auditors is indispensable.

There are a number of important questions that we need to discuss, keyword: federal-state financial relations, tax justice, or debt. Where, for example, do state debts limit the necessary scope of action for future generations? Where do we restrict their scope of action by spending money in the wrong places and thereby failing to make sensible investments?

Other questions touch on the foundation of our state structure: How can the financial relationships in the federal state be redesigned so that the federal government, states, and municipalities can fulfill their tasks in the long term? How can it remain clear to the individual citizen who is responsible for what? The internal financial network is complex, to put it mildly, and it will remain complex, perhaps even become more complex. It has emerged from arduous compromises. However, we must keep in mind the price of opacity in the end. A dangerous gap opens up when those who pay, namely the citizens as taxpayers, can no longer recognize who is responsible for what. At the very least, this must remain verifiable – in the interplay between the Federal Court of Auditors and the State Courts of Auditors.

Finally, when we talk about good governance and an efficient public sector, we will not only talk about expenditures but also about revenues. Only a financial policy with moderation allows our state, at all levels, to fulfill the many tasks of public welfare. Moderation means: avoiding extremes. An excessively high tax burden meets with resistance when it can hardly be justified with counter-performance. It is then perceived as a restriction of action, impairs the willingness to perform, and leads to justified discontent. Conversely, a state that demands too low taxes or fails to collect demanded taxes will, sooner or later, find itself in a predicament and will not be able to secure the trust of its citizens either. Here, too, the Courts of Auditors have their task: It is part of their mandate to control revenue collection.

There is a need for action where the tax administration does not check or is unable to check whether tax returns are correct, where interest income remains untaxed because money has been taken abroad. There is a need for action where a company's taxes do not depend on its profitability but rather on whether clever lawyers have distributed the corporate parts to the right countries to exploit inconsistencies in international tax law. Because when citizens get the impression that tax law is only poorly applied or that loopholes exist for those who possess wealth, it can lead to the fatal view that the honest person is the fool.

Certainly, it is not easy to ensure uniform taxation. Capital and taxpayers move from country to country, economic relations are increasingly intertwined, we all know that. What is needed is actually clear: common, international principles for corporate taxation, a consistent international exchange of information between the tax authorities of different states. And it seems to me that a different wind is now blowing. The fact that a large number of states have recently agreed to cooperate is a welcome development. But it remains a task to also bring on board those countries that are, so to speak, providers of tax-saving models worldwide and benefit from them.

It is good that in recent decades, the Courts of Auditors have also been increasingly cooperating internationally. Some colleagues from comparable foreign institutions are our guests here today – and I am pleased that they are here!

We will continue to have to discuss openly in our country what the responsibilities of the public sector should be – and what they should not be. We will talk about what constitutes an efficient community and also about the gap between the desirable and the feasible.

We hope that the "remarks," as the Federal Court of Auditors elegantly calls them, will not only serve as a bothersome distraction for the respective government and a welcome argument for the respective opposition, but as what they are: an expression of a state's self-commitment, a good state, to act in the interest of its citizens.

Thus, we can say: Today we honor a pillar of our statehood. It is a pillar that is sometimes overlooked, certainly. It is not as powerful as the parliaments, not as present as the governments, and not as prominent as the constitutional courts. But for the stability of our republic, our state, it is indispensable.

If you look closely at the Federal Eagle here in the former plenary chamber of the German Bundestag, you will notice something peculiar: it has a slightly asymmetrical plumage. It is said that the artist wanted to convey something to us. Perhaps he wanted to say: We will never achieve perfection. Not even in such a high house, I might add. We are, after all, among humans, among fallible beings.

So let us not expect that the "remarks" will one day no longer be necessary because everything everywhere is treated and handled properly and economically down to the last detail. We will not expect that. But the pursuit of it, we should at least not give up! And for you, the responsible ones, the employees at the Federal Court of Auditors and the State Courts of Auditors, this means: We will continue to need you. We are glad that you exist!