Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck at the opening of the Bellevue Forum "Refugees – a Challenge for Europe" on February 26, 2016, in Berlin:

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

27 February 2016 · Bellevue Forum "Refugees – a Challenge for Europe" · Bellevue Palace, Berlin, Germany

Context
Gauck opened the Bellevue Forum in Berlin on February 26, 2016, convening European leaders to discuss the refugee crisis threatening EU cohesion.
Main themes
Refugee crisis in Europe, European solidarity, Schengen area and border controls, rise of xenophobic movements, German refugee policy, European dialogue and consensus, Central and Eastern European attitudes, European integration challenges, intra-EU disagreements, migration and asylum
Duration
~13 min
47th percentile
Words
1,616
47th percentile
Sentences
81
53rd percentile
Readability
43
44th percentile
Grade
12.1
46th percentile
Syntax
2.98
45th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
34th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 52%51%
  • Social 34%33%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Institutional 3%2%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

81 sentences in 20 paragraphs

Much of Europe is here in this room. We call these gatherings the Bellevue Forum, and when they take place under a European star, I imagine it as a European Agora, which I spoke of earlier, that I wish for and which, to a large extent, is not sufficiently present. Consider our meeting as a small element of such a European Agora. You are especially welcome, ladies and gentlemen, and especially you who are participating today – because this Europe is currently overshadowed by clouds.

Before you stands not only an eager and discussion-loving president but also a concerned host. When I think back to when I became an active European, I would have to name the year 1990, the year of German reunification. I cannot recall a time in these past 26 years when an intense European dialogue was more necessary than today.

Of course, we have experienced crises in the European Union before; just think of the failed constitutional treaty or the sovereign debt and financial crisis or the looming exit of individual members from the Union. Nevertheless, many people feel that the European Union is currently being tested in a new and particularly fundamental way. The crises both within and on the periphery of the Union are following one another more rapidly, and they overlap. At the same time, comprehensive responses to the current crisis, the refugee crisis, are necessary.

People are seeking protection in Europe from war and persecution, or they come to us because they hope for a better life. More than 856,000 men, women, and children arrived in Greece via the Mediterranean last year – many lost their lives in the attempt to get there. And no one can say for certain how many will seek asylum in 2016. This development is unsettling; it polarizes entire societies. There is neither a consensus in Germany on how our country should behave nor among the member states of the European Union.

For decades, we have experienced the Union as a great success story: Europe – a place of peace, freedom, law, a promise of prosperity, a continent without border controls from the West deep into the East. For many migrants, it remains to this day: a destination of their hopes.

And now? Let us look around: Germany has so far found hardly any allies for a common European solution to the refugee issue; some governments do not want to support solutions they have not explicitly agreed to. Across Europe, the refugee crisis is also giving additional momentum to xenophobic and illiberal parties and movements. National unilateral actions are increasing, as are regional agreements. Fundamental achievements such as the abolition of border controls in the Schengen area are being called into question. More than previous tensions, the refugee crisis threatens to destabilize the fundamental structure of Europe – this is truly a disturbing development.

That is why I have invited you to this Bellevue Forum: "Refugees – a Challenge for Europe." Here in the hall sit people from various European states, people with different backgrounds and perspectives. And I warmly welcome all of you, our speakers from a total of nine countries, from all corners of our continent! I hope that we can discuss in an open conversation how the other, the neighbor, the European partner, how the friend thinks. That we understand why we think so differently in Europe on a question of such great significance.

What matters to me is the why. In the newspapers, we are currently reading mainly about where the disagreements have led: Germany is disappointed by insufficient or absent solidarity, while other states are annoyed by what they perceive as Germany's moral imperative policy. However, what we read much less often are ideas and possible compromises. One thing has become clear to me in light of the developments of the past months. The refugee crisis demands new discussions and new reflections, reflections that should not take place solely within the respective national framework. If misunderstandings or particular interests are not to prolong and deepen this crisis, then we Europeans must know more about each other, discuss more with one another, and strive more intensively than before for a new consensus.

Let us discuss together today in this spirit: Two keynote speeches and two panel discussions await us – opportunities to learn from one another and to understand each other better. Almost every member state has headlines and images that make it into the newspapers and television channels of neighboring countries. But we rarely engage in a genuine European discourse. We also ask less frequently about the underlying motives, know little about the serious domestic political problems and the national characteristics and attitudes of our neighbors.

For example, why are the countries of Central and Eastern Europe, which so impressively brought the European idea to life after 1989, now so reserved towards Brussels? Why is the German government currently finding it so difficult to find supporters for its position? And why is the protection of the external borders so inadequately achieved? Why are we risking the freedom of movement in the Schengen area? If there is no comprehensive political and mental basis on the refugee issue: Yes, what solutions can then be developed?

These are questions we hope to discuss today. We should not hesitate to name our dilemmas as well. For we have long known that in the effort to help as many as possible, it may also be necessary not to help everyone. How many refugees and immigrants a country considers manageable and what that means for our coexistence in the Union – this will certainly be debated controversially on our panel. It is about finding the right measure, which each country must of course strive for itself.

At the same time, however, there are also common principles. And this should not be completely forgotten or ignored in the national discourses. With the Geneva Refugee Convention, all European states have committed to the protection of refugees. Individuals, movements, parties, and governments that instrumentalize refugees to incite xenophobia – regardless of which European country – do not conform to the humanitarian and legal foundations of our European community.

We do have different historical experiences in Europe – in dealing with minorities, in dealing with the foreign. Western Europe and also West Germany have been able to undergo a cultural transformation towards diversity over decades. East Germany and Eastern Europe were denied such experiences, such life worlds. Yes, this is, for example, one of the differences that could explain a different willingness to accept.

However, this does not mean that governments may simply follow fears and demagogues. And for the populations that protest against a supposed over-foreignization, it means above all one thing – and I want to emphasize this strongly to some compatriots here after the recent incidents: Direct your dissatisfaction and your anger not against those who are much weaker and much more vulnerable than you are! Isolate the inciters, the arsonists, the perpetrators! If you want to protest, then respect the rules!

By all means, be loud towards your mayors, representatives, or ministers, but then also listen to what they have to say to you. And above all: Those who live on the fact that laws protect them and that solidarity supports them when they are in trouble must not break the law and must not withdraw their solidarity with others.

It is no longer just about solving the refugee crisis. We understand that beneath the controversies and debates lies a deeper fear and anxieties, poorly defined, related to the fact that there is a fear of boundarylessness in many populations, a fear of learning a new role. It is not only about the refugee crisis and how to solve it. Rather, the various tensions that are now breaking out within the European Union are stronger than ever before, and we must respond to that. The dispute over distribution quotas, willingness to accept, and securing the external borders is intertwined with the dispute over the role of nation-states and their relationship to the European Union, and thus it also concerns the relationship between the member states. The honest will for togetherness is currently simply weak. And as a result, the European Union is weak.

But do we really want to accept that the refugee crisis is tearing the European Union apart? Do we want to fall back into the niche existence of individual nation-states instead of facing the challenges of the globalized world with united forces? Should we shirk our responsibility for what can only succeed together? A Europe that does not pool its resources will not be able to support refugees either on the European continent or close to their homeland as necessary, indeed as it should be possible. And a Europe that does not unite its political weight will also not be able to make an effective contribution to addressing the root causes of flight and combating those who cause flight.

And let me add one last observation: In these days, we in Germany are concerned about the fact that some countries have adopted a regional delimitation strategy to protect their interests. This can be criticized, even rejected. But it is also not unthinkable that European and regional solutions can complement each other.

It may be that a compromise solution emerges that seems unsatisfactory to us and some other Europeans, but at least we would remain together.

So I sincerely wish that we can honestly and constructively explore today how we can jointly meet the current challenges. For it cannot, no it must not be, that the European Union dismantles itself and that the unification project of decades collapses over the refugee issue.