Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck during the working visit to the Federal Court of Justice on December 6, 2016, in Karlsruhe:

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

6 October 2016 · Working visit to the Federal Court of Justice · Federal Court of Justice, Karlsruhe, Germany

Context
Gauck addressed the Federal Court of Justice in Karlsruhe during a working visit, celebrating the appointment of Vice President Ellenberger and reflecting on the rule of law.
Main themes
Rule of law, judicial independence, German Federal Court of Justice, dictatorship versus democracy, GDR experience, transformation societies, legal history, constitutional courts, judiciary under pressure, personal biography, law and justice
Duration
~10 min
36th percentile
Words
1,237
36th percentile
Sentences
58
38th percentile
Readability
53
72nd percentile
Grade
11.0
32nd percentile
Syntax
3.10
60th percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
14th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 74%74%
  • Ceremonial 21%21%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

58 sentences in 15 paragraphs

First of all, I would like to sincerely congratulate you, Mr. Ellenberger, on your appointment as Vice President of the Federal Court of Justice last Friday. I believe many are pleased, as this important position had been vacant for almost a year and a half. I am now glad that it has been filled with a worthy candidate, and I wish you much success in your new role.

It has surely already reached you why I am such a fervent supporter of the rule of law: I have been deprived of it for fifty years of my life. And that is also why I am happy to come to this "capital of law." The Federal Constitutional Court is based here – I have already visited it – as well as the Federal Court of Justice and the Federal Public Prosecutor, with whom I will be a guest this afternoon. At the beginning of my term, I made it a point to visit all the highest federal courts.

I have learned a great deal about the specific problems of the judiciary, specialized justice, refugee law, the workload of legal professionals, courts, and judicial administrations. With my visit to you now – so to speak, the pinnacle of ordinary jurisdiction – my court visits find a kind of crowning conclusion.

It is particularly important to me to gain a direct impression of your work, also because I know all too well how significant rule-of-law structures and independent courts are. And this has to do with my biography. Of course, experiencing a dictatorial and lawless everyday life makes one a disciple of the rule of law in a special way.

In the systems we refer to as dictatorships, there was, of course, also the administration of justice. They called it that, at least. And regrettably, there were also significant jurists in the Third Reich who were not deterred by their expertise and outstanding intellect from serving the Führer. I do not even need to name names, as you are well-versed in legal history, and these names are likely familiar to you. Among the older generation, it may even have been the case that some of these jurists played a role in their academic youth.

When we look back at those times: Of course, there was somehow always law, but it was damaged, misused, and abused law. When I think of the GDR era, there were only a few fundamental rights, hardly any state guarantees, and no constitutional court that would have actually granted citizens the rights promised to them by the constitution – by the way, there were also no administrative courts.

A petition system like in the past, when one could still plead for gracious leniency from the prince – that was everyday life. Somehow, people had gotten used to it, and then in those times, they did not rely on the law as much. The representatives of the law had little esteem. Ordinary people hardly knew any representatives of the law – the judiciary and the bar were permeated, and a great alienation arose.

The weapon of the oppressed in such times is less the law, as it is redefined from above as part of the power apparatus, but rather the morality of the oppressed. When these oppressed individuals actually manage to rid themselves of their oppressors, then their morality has triumphed. But their understanding of the legal system is not automatically born from that. They even distrust it because they have had an experience of alienation with this law. That is why it is the case that in many transformation societies – including in Eastern Germany – a process of acclimatization to the rule of law must take place. And everything related to mentality takes a long time to be internalized. This process is still not completed in large parts of Europe. This is peculiar because so many in dictatorship yearn for law – for law and justice.

Sometimes they are not even aware of how painful it was that independent adjudication was lacking or that there was no such thing as legal hearing. For this reason, I have become such an admirer of the diverse buildings of law. Moreover, I know how fundamental the task of law-making and law-abiding institutions is for our society and our coexistence.

I have great respect and admiration for your work. And I want to emphatically encourage you in your endeavors with my visit. I am also grateful for the passion you bring, for your commitment, and for your empathy – you fulfill tasks for all citizens. I am aware that the building of law is always a growing and changing one. Some things may seem static and may also be so. But as we have all experienced in recent decades, there are new areas of law that we must legally shape, which also lead to legal conflicts. And there are also new developments in civil and criminal law that lead us down new innovative paths. These are challenges that we must accept and that you are accepting.

In many countries, even here in Europe, the judiciary has also come under pressure. We see that the achievements of an independent judiciary, which is solely committed to the law and not to any government, ideology, or idea, are no longer regarded everywhere as indispensable. However, this fundamentally calls into question the rule of law – even if that is not immediately evident – and thus a fundamental value of our Western civilization, an indispensable cultural achievement. Democracy and the rule of law are indeed unimaginable without an independent judiciary.

When I now look a little at the edge of our European Union and see, for example, in Turkey how thousands of judges and prosecutors can be removed from office, suspended, or even arrested from one day to the next, it can only fill one with concern.

And when we also observe tendencies to restrict the rule of law in other countries, perhaps even in one or another member state of the European Union, I ask myself: Is it already forgotten how it was in Central Eastern Europe until 1989, when power controlled the law and the courts?

The view into the history of our country and the situation of the judiciary in several other countries shows me today a judiciary that deserves that name. It is a precious asset. With my visit here to the Federal Court of Justice, I want to honor the entire civil and criminal judiciary. Judges as well as the colleagues of the non-judicial judicial service – here in Karlsruhe, but also at the higher regional, district, and local courts! And I particularly want to mention the many honorary judges – they all perform outstandingly important tasks for our society, and they are all involved in the success of the whole. This also includes those who, as research assistants, do important preparatory work for the decisions to be made, those who work in administration, and finally those who take care of the buildings and properties, who are responsible for transport and security. I am visiting all of you today, ladies and gentlemen.

My visit is a working visit, so I do not want to prolong the speech any further. Rather, I seek the opportunity to engage in conversation with some of you. I look forward to the exchange of ideas, and I thank you for your warm welcome.