Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck on Perspectives of the European Idea on February 22, 2013, in Berlin:

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

23 February 2013 · Perspectives of the European Idea · Berlin, Germany

Context
Gauck addressed a Berlin audience on February 22, 2013, delivering a major speech reassessing European integration amid the eurozone crisis and declining public trust in EU institutions.
Main themes
European integration, crisis of trust in the EU, eurozone crisis, democratic legitimacy, Franco-German partnership, austerity and economic hardship, European identity, peace and reconciliation, supranational governance, historical foundations of Europe, citizen disillusionment, future of Europe
Duration
~44 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,336
92nd percentile
Sentences
280
94th percentile
Readability
43
44th percentile
Grade
12.0
45th percentile
Syntax
2.96
42nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
33rd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 30%28%
  • Geopolitical 26%24%
  • Institutional 22%21%
  • Economic 12%11%
  • Ceremonial 10%9%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 8%

280 sentences in 69 paragraphs

"Europe: Renewing Trust – Strengthening Commitment"

Excellencies,

ladies and gentlemen!

So much Europe has never been! This is said by someone who looks into this hall with great gratitude, who is pleased to welcome guests from Germany and all over Europe! You are most welcome.

So much Europe has never been: Many people, especially in Germany, currently feel this in a completely different way, for example when looking at the morning newspapers. There, Europe often appears reduced to four letters – Euro – or as a case of crisis. There is constant talk of summit diplomacy and rescue packages. It weighs heavily. It involves difficult negotiations, even when they are successes, only partial successes, and there is always a lingering discomfort, even clear discontent, that cannot be ignored. In some member states, people fear that they will become the paymasters of the crisis. In others, the fear of ever harsher austerity measures and social decline is growing. Giving and taking, incurring debt and liability, responsibility and participation seem no longer properly and justly sorted in the community of Europeans to many citizens.

In addition, there is a list of criticisms that have been heard for a long time: the annoyance with the so-called Brussels technocrats and their regulatory zeal, the complaint about the lack of transparency in decision-making, the distrust towards a convoluted network of institutions, and last but not least, the unwillingness regarding the growing importance of the European Council and the dominant role of the Franco-German tandem.

As attractive as Europe is – too many citizens are left by the European Union with a feeling of powerlessness and lack of influence. I know it, I hear it, I read it almost daily: There is a need for clarification in Europe. In light of the signs of impatience, exhaustion, and frustration among citizens, in light of the surveys that show a population uncertain whether our path to "more" Europe is the right one, it seems to me that we stand before a new threshold – uncertain whether we should really proceed with determination. The crisis has more than just an economic dimension. It is also a crisis of trust in the political project of Europe. We are not only struggling for our currency. We are also struggling with ourselves.

And yet, I stand before you today as a confessed European and feel the need to once again assure myself together with you what Europe means, what it has meant, and what possibilities it still holds – as far as I can grasp today.

For me, this day is also an occasion to return anew and more critically to my euphoric statement shortly after my inauguration when I said: "We want to dare more Europe." I would probably not formulate it today as quickly and certainly as I did back then. This more of Europe needs at least an interpretation, needs differentiation. Where can and where should more Europe contribute to a successful coexistence? What should Europe look like? What do we want to develop and strengthen, and what do we want to limit? And last but not least: How do we find more trust for more Europe, more trust than we currently have?

Let us remember: The beginning was indeed promising. Just five years after the end of the Second World War, France's Foreign Minister Robert Schuman proposed to his European partners the establishment of the European Community for Coal and Steel. France and Germany became the great driving forces of European development – and former adversaries became partners. When we celebrated the 50th anniversary of the Élysée Treaty in January, we were once again particularly aware of how precious this friendship has become for Europe and how fortunate we are to be able to continue this friendship with a new generation, to shape it further.

Back then, in 1950, Jean Monnet was the visionary. His goal: to secure European peace through a "community" that promised rational benefits to its members at the same time. It was not only reasonable; it was also in their national interest. West Germany achieved its first rehabilitation in the international community through this integration. France and the other partner states satisfied their security needs through control of German coal and steel production. The idea was difficult to implement for a long time but was of great political foresight: When the economy merges, politics will eventually merge as well. By the way, Walther Rathenau said this back in 1913, exactly 100 years ago. Where once states fought over resources and hegemony, peace grows through mutual interdependence.

For a comprehensive cross-national policy, it was of course still too early in 1950. Only step by step should economic integration become political, and from ever larger fields of community, a common Europe should emerge – for some, this was a European federation, for others, a Europe of fatherlands. For a long time, this pragmatic method actually advanced the project of Europe. Today, however, we are forced to fundamentally rethink this approach. Because developments were allowed without sufficient political overall framework, the architects of politics have at times become driven by events.

Even at significant milestones, there was often a lack of political design in the past. After the collapse of the communist bloc, for example, ten states were admitted to the EU, even though the necessary foundation for such a large EU was still missing. And so, during this largest expansion of the EU, the questions of deepening remained unanswered in part. The introduction of the common currency also proved to be consequential. Over the years, 17 states adopted the Euro, but the Euro itself did not receive comprehensive fiscal governance. This construction error has brought the European Union into an imbalance that was only temporarily corrected by rescue measures such as the European Stability Mechanism and the Fiscal Pact.

However, it is clear to me: Even if individual rescue measures should fail, the overall European project is not in question. Its advantages are still clearly evident: We travel from the Memel to the Atlantic, from Finland to Sicily, without having to show our passport at any border. We pay in large parts of Europe with a common currency and buy shoes from Spain or cars from the Czech Republic without customs duties. We are treated in many places in Germany by Polish doctors and are grateful for it, as some practices would otherwise have to close. Our entrepreneurs increasingly employ workers from all member countries of the Union, who would often find no work or only jobs under much worse conditions in their own countries. And our seniors spend part of their retirement on the coasts of Spain, some also on the Polish Baltic Sea. More Europe has thus become a pleasing part of everyday life.

Therefore, the results of opinion polls are only seemingly contradictory. While skepticism towards the EU has risen sharply in recent years, a majority remains convinced: Our complex and increasingly global reality needs regulations in a cross-national framework. We all in Europe have great political and economic advantages from the community.

What distinguishes us as Europeans, however, what our European identity means, remains difficult to outline. Young guests here at Schloss Bellevue recently confirmed to me what many here in the hall may also know: "When we are out in the big wide world, we feel like Europeans. When we are in Europe, we feel like Germans. And when we are in Germany, well then as Saxons or Hamburgers."

We see how multifaceted identity can be. And we understand: European identity neither erases regional nor national identity; it exists alongside these. Just recently, during my visit to the Free State of Bavaria at the University of Regensburg in the Europaeum project, I met a young student who grew up as a Pole in Germany, raised Polish, with Polish as his mother tongue, and at sports events, he enthusiastically carried the Polish flag. But only when he studied a semester in Poland and his fellow students perceived him completely as a German did he become aware of these, his German aspects of identity. He could also affirm them without pain. He experienced what many do: Often we perceive our identity through the distinction from others.

"You only need to leave Europe, in any direction, to feel the reality of our cultural unity," summarized the Swiss philosopher Denis de Rougemont this experience already in the late 1950s. He said: "In the United States, in the Soviet Union, and without any doubt in Asia, the French and Greeks, the English and Swiss, the Swedes and Castilians are regarded as Europeans. (...) From the outside, the existence of Europe is obvious."

Is the existence of Europe equally obvious from the inside? Geographically, the continent is indeed difficult to grasp – does it extend, for example, to the Bug or to the Ural? To the Bosporus or to Anatolia? The identity-forming references have also undergone multiple changes in a long history. Today we know that they refer to a whole ensemble – starting from Greek antiquity through the Roman imperial idea and Roman law to the formative Christian-Jewish faith traditions.

But what does it look like today? What forms the unifying bond between the citizens of Europe today? From where does Europe draw its distinctive significance, its political legitimacy, and its acceptance?

When the European Union received the Nobel Peace Prize in December, the speakers described Europe as a peace project, celebrated and honored it. We then think of how unforgettable it was when Winston Churchill, in his famous speech to the youth in Zurich in 1946, called for the "recreation of the European family." Unforgettable that at that time the conviction of politicians and the population could be expressed in three words: "Never again war!" Unforgettable also how 700 politicians and intellectuals came together in 1948 at the European Congress in The Hague, such diverse personalities as Bertrand Russell or from Italy Ignazio Silone or from Germany Konrad Adenauer, Walter Hallstein, or Eugen Kogon.

"Whether eternal peace on this earth is possible, no one knows," summarized the French philosopher Raymond Aron later the intentions. "That the limitation of violence has become our common duty in this violent century is beyond doubt."

However, at that time, Europe soon became a concept only for Western Europe. During the Cold War, the continent split into two political camps. But while Eastern and Central Eastern Europe were cut off for over 40 years, its inhabitants lived in spirit in Europe. They had never really left it. For them and for me, 1989/90 was our convinced yes to the free, democratic, prosperous Europe something like the second founding act of Europe, a belated accession for that part of the continent that simply could not be there from the beginning. It was at the same time a qualitative expansion for Europe. Just as Europe had been primarily a peace project after the Second World War, it became primarily a freedom project after 1989.

The young generation, born in the 80s and later, sees Europe again with completely different eyes. Their grandparents and great-grandparents, who experienced Berlin, Warsaw, and Rotterdam in ruins, managed to rebuild Europe; in the West, they were even able to pass on prosperity to their children and grandchildren.

I know, dear students in the hall, you received your first pocket money in euros, you learn at least two foreign languages, you go on class trips to Paris, London, Madrid, perhaps also to Warsaw, Budapest, Prague. And when you graduate, Erasmus scholarships or vocational training programs like Leonardo are available to you. Often you are already learning together in Europe, rather than just learning something about each other. And you celebrate together: at European music festivals or in the vibrant metropolises of Europe. No generation before you had such delightful opportunities to say: We are Europe! And you are indeed experiencing "more Europe" than all previous generations!

Nevertheless, it is true, as is often criticized: Europe lacks the great identity-forming narrative. We do not have a common European narrative that unites over 500 million people in the European Union around a shared history, that reaches their hearts and encourages their hands to shape. Yes, it is true: We Europeans do not have a founding myth in the manner of a decisive battle, in which Europe could confront an enemy, win or lose, but in any case preserve its identity. We also do not have a founding myth in the sense of a successful revolution, in which the citizens of the continent would have jointly accomplished an act of political or social emancipation. There is no single European identity, just as there is no European demos, no European citizenry, or a European nation.

But nevertheless, Europe has a source of identity – a timeless canon of values that connects us in two ways, as a confession and as a program. We gather in the name of Europe not around monuments that derive the glory of one from the defeat of another. We gather for something – for peace and freedom, for democracy and the rule of law, for equality, for human rights, for solidarity.

All these European values are a promise, but they are also enshrined in treaties and guaranteed in laws. They are reference points of our common republican understanding – the foundation for all citizens to participate equally in social and political life. The European values open the space for our European res publica.

Our European community of values wants to be a space of freedom and tolerance. It punishes fanatics and ideologues who incite people against each other, preach violence, and undermine our political foundations. It creates a space where peoples live peacefully together and no longer go to war against each other. A war like the one that recently occurred in the Balkans, where European soldiers and civilian forces still have to secure peace today, must never again become a bloody reality.

People who have migrated from other continents often appreciate the preciousness of Europe in a very special way. They know poverty, unrest, unfreedom, and injustice in other parts of the world. They experience Europe as a space of prosperity, self-fulfillment, and in many cases also as a safe haven: from press censorship or state internet blocks, from torture, from the death penalty, from child labor or violence against women, or from the persecution of those who live in same-sex relationships.

Our European values are binding and they connect. Even if European states occasionally violate Europe’s rules, these can still be enforced in European courts. While there may always be occasions to accuse Europe or Germany of a contradictory approach to human and civil rights, Europe guarantees an ever-present critical public and free media that can advocate for the persecuted and oppressed, especially in dictatorial and authoritarian states.

The European canon of values is not bound by national borders and is valid across all national, ethnic, cultural, and religious differences. This is evident in the example of Muslims living in Europe. They have become an integral part of our European coexistence. European identity is not defined by negative differentiation from the other. European identity grows with togetherness and the conviction of people who say: We want to be part of this community because we share the common values. More Europe means: more lived and united diversity.

All that we have had to learn and continue to learn intergovernmentally to secure peace among peoples, we must also learn and secure within our society, to achieve balance among increasingly diverse groups. We experience it every day: We are also Europe when we stay at home. In Germany, we meet restaurant owners from Italy, nurses from Spain, football players from Turkey. At universities and in businesses, on stages, in shops, more and more people work who have their family roots in other countries and who, if they are religious, go to different places of worship than Protestant and Catholic Germans. Europe has long been more. Diversity has become everyday life in the center of our society.

Fortunately, hardly anyone in Europe questions our canon of values. The institutional framework that Europe has established so far, however, is currently being intensely discussed. For some, the European federal union is the only chance for the continent, while others aim for corrections to the existing institutions – such as the introduction of a second chamber or the desired expansion of the rights of the European Parliament. Some consider it sufficient to maintain the status quo if its possibilities were actually utilized with more political will. And the Euroskeptics would prefer to reduce the European level.

But even prominent supporters of Europe are asking whether everything that is currently regulated from Brussels really needs to come from there. So we are right in the middle of this discussion and not at its end. And we will find it easier to agree on the institutional arrangements, on the institutional framework, if we have jointly and thoroughly discussed the fundamental questions regarding the future of the European project.

Necessary adjustments in the economic and financial policy area in the Eurozone have fortunately been made by politics under pressure. However, we all know that Europe is facing further challenges. At the beginning of my speech, I spoke of a threshold: We pause to mentally and emotionally prepare for the next step, which demands something new from us.

Once, the European states were great powers and global players. In today’s globalized world with the large new emerging countries, a united Europe can, at best, assert itself as a global player: politically, to be able to make substantial decisions and to advocate worldwide for our values of freedom, human dignity, and solidarity. Economically, to remain competitive and thus secure our material safety and inner societal peace in Europe.

So far, Europe is too little prepared for this role. We need further internal unification. Because without a common financial and economic policy, a common currency can hardly survive. We also need further unification of our foreign, security, and defense policy to be equipped against new threats and to act uniformly and more effectively. We also need common concepts on ecological, social-political – keyword migration – and last but not least demographic levels.

It is the task of all who feel connected to the project of Europe to convey this patiently and prudently. Uncertainty and fear must not drive anyone into the hands of populists or nationalists. The guiding question for all changes should therefore be: What can a democratic Europe look like that alleviates citizens' fears, grants them opportunities for participation, in short: with which they can identify?

Those who think that European unification is something like an artificial construct and incapable of bringing together its different citizens from soon 28 nation-states should be reminded that national states are also not something naturally grown and not eternal, and that their citizens often grew into them very slowly. When Italian unity was created in 1861, the writer and politician Massimo D'Azeglio declared: “We have created Italy, now we must create Italians.” Less than ten percent of the citizens spoke Italian at that time, and the majority only knew dialects.

However, unlike in the 19th century, when the German Empire also emerged from a patchwork of kingdoms and principalities, we cannot and do not want to decree a European unification from above. We now have strong civil societies. Without the consent of the citizens, no European nation, no Europe can grow. The pace and depth of European integration will ultimately be determined by the European citizens.

At this point, I would like to take a look at Great Britain. With great interest, I have heard the statements, the double message of the Prime Minister: The yes to British tradition and British interests, which should not be a no to Europe. It is indeed the business of the British alone to decide about their future, but perhaps they are willing to at least listen to one wish from Schloss Bellevue. It is:

Dear English, Welsh, Scots, Northern Irish, and new citizens of Great Britain! We would like to have you with us! We need your experiences as a country of the oldest parliamentary democracy, we value your traditions, but we also need your sobriety and your courage! You helped save our Europe in World War II with your commitment – it is also your Europe. Let us continue to walk the path to the European res publica together, even if we may argue along the way, but only together are we equipped to face the future challenges. More Europe should not mean: without you!

I am concerned when Germany's role in the European process currently provokes skepticism and distrust in some countries. Yes, it is true, Germany has also benefited significantly from the Euro. It has made Germany strong. And that Germany rose to become the largest economic power in the center of the continent after reunification has frightened many. I am shocked at how quickly perceptions have distorted, as if today’s Germany were in a tradition of German great power politics, even of German crimes. Not only populist parties have portrayed the German Chancellor as a representative of a state that today supposedly wants to impose a German Europe and oppress other peoples just as it did before.

But I assure all citizens in neighboring countries: I see no one among the political leaders in Germany who would seek a German dictate. So far, our society has proven to be mature and rational. In Germany – and for that, I am grateful – no populist-nationalist party has found the support in the population that would have brought it into the German Bundestag. From deep inner conviction, I can say: More Europe does not mean a German Europe in Germany. More Europe means for us: a European Germany!

We do not want to intimidate others, nor do we want to impose our concepts on them, but we stand by our experiences and would like to convey them. It is not even ten years since Germany itself stood before the eyes of the world and our citizens as the “sick man of Europe.” The measures that led us out of the economic crisis then bore fruit – despite the severe domestic political conflicts that accompanied them. At the same time, we know that there are different economic concepts and that there is not just one way to the goal.

If some German politicians have occasionally shown too little empathy for the situation of others or if rationality sometimes appeared as cold-heartedness or know-it-allism, this was certainly the exception and not the rule and may also be explained by the necessary debate about the right path. However, if critical comments have expressed contempt or even disdain, this is not only grossly hurtful but also politically counterproductive. It complicates or even blocks the self-critical discourse that has already taken on clear contours among at least a minority in all crisis countries. But we in Germany should be clear that those who trust their arguments do not need to provoke or humiliate their counterpart.

It is worth reminding all 27 partners in our community of the promises with which the monetary and economic union was once launched. This union is based on the idea that rules are followed and rule violations are punished. This union is a give and take; it must not be a one-way street for anyone. It follows the principles of reciprocity, equality, and equal obligation. More Europe must mean: more reliability. Reliability and solidarity stand and fall together.

I am convinced: If everyone in Europe remains committed to this principle, then inner-European solidarity can even grow to reduce the great inequalities on this continent in the long term, to create living conditions where they need to be improved, where people still have no perspective in their homeland, but urgently need one.

More Europe demands: more courage from everyone! Europe now needs no naysayers, but banner bearers, no procrastinators, but doers, no driven ones, but shapers.

You, Excellencies, who are present here today, you know that even with the best pro-European attitude, some efforts at shaping can still fall flat. I do not wish to overlook such difficulties today. One of the main problems in forming a closer European community seems to me to be the inadequate communication within Europe. And by that, I actually mean less the level of diplomacy, but rather the everyday life of the population, or more accurately, the populations. To this day, each of the 27 member nations perceives the same European treaties often in very different ways. Media reporting occurs almost exclusively from national perspectives. Knowledge about neighbors is still low – apart from a comparatively small group of students, business people, intellectuals, and artists. Europe has not yet developed a common European public that could be compared to what we describe as public life at the national level.

First, we simply lack a common lingua franca. In Europe, 23 official languages are recognized, and countless other languages and dialects are added. A German who does not also speak English or French will hardly be able to communicate with a Portuguese, nor with a Lithuanian or Hungarian. It is true: the younger generation is growing up with English as a lingua franca. However, I believe we should not leave linguistic integration to the course of events. More Europe means not only multilingualism for the elites but multilingualism for ever larger groups of the population, for more and more people, ultimately for everyone! I am convinced that in Europe both can coexist: a home in one’s mother tongue and its poetry, and a practical English for all situations and ages.

With a common language, my vision for the future Europe could also be more easily realized: a European agora, a common discussion space for democratic coexistence. This agora would be even more comprehensive than the one students might know from history books, as it was in ancient Greece, the central meeting place, a site of worship and court, a place of public debate where the struggle for orderly coexistence took place.

Today, we need an expanded model. Perhaps our media people, our media landscape could produce a kind of Europe-promoting innovation, perhaps something like Arte for all, a multi-channel with internet connectivity, for at least 27 states, 28 of course, for the young and the experienced, online and offline, for pro-Europeans and Europe skeptics. There should be more broadcast than just the Eurovision Song Contest or a European crime scene. For example, there should be reports about entrepreneurs in Poland, young unemployed people in Spain, or family support in Denmark. There should be discussion rounds that would bring the feelings of our neighbors to our attention and make it understandable why they might assess the same event quite differently than we do. And in high politics, after a crisis summit, the doors would open, and the camera would not only seek one face but would show the entire round at the negotiation table.

Yes, whether with or without such a TV channel: we need an agora. It would convey knowledge, help develop a sense of European citizenship, and also serve as a corrective when national media fall into nationalist tones, reporting on neighbors without sensitivity or expertise and fostering prejudices. I know that many media companies are already trying to stimulate the European public, with supplements from other countries, with thematic focuses on Europe, and many good ideas. I know that. But please, more of that – more reporting on and more communication with Europe!

We are currently talking about communication. Communication is not a secondary issue in politics for me. A sufficient explanation of the topics and problems is, in fact, politics itself. A politics that takes into account the maturity of the actors in the agora and does not dismiss them as subservient, uninterested, and ignorant.

More Europe means for me: more European civil society. I am therefore pleased that 2013 is the European Year of Citizens. I would not go as far in all details as the authors of the "Manifesto for a New Foundation of Europe," but I have great sympathy for the headline they placed over their manifesto and under which supporters gather. It reads: "Do not ask what Europe can do for you, ask instead what you can do for Europe!" We all know that this is an adaptation of an even more famous sentence, but this attitude would propel us forward significantly. The European Gauck has – when he now asks himself what he wishes in this situation – written a few answers on a list.

First

: Do not be indifferent! Brussels may seem far away, but the topics that are negotiated and decided there concern everyone. We must not be indifferent to how the EU influences standards that then become effective in our children's rooms or on our dining tables. We must not be indifferent to the criteria we apply to foreign, security, environmental, and development policies that also take place in our name. We must not be indifferent to how the EU treats people who have to leave their country for political reasons.

Second

: Do not be complacent! The European Union is complicated, indeed, but it must also accomplish very complicated tasks. It deserves that its citizens show interest and inform themselves. It deserves more than 43 percent of eligible voters participating in the European elections. And it does not deserve to be made a scapegoat, especially where national interests or national failures have caused misdevelopments.

Third

: Recognize your power to shape! A better Europe does not emerge if we always see the responsibility lying with others. There are so many opportunities for us as well. Those who want to initiate something or prevent something can use a European Citizens' Initiative. Those who want to establish or build something can submit a funding application. And those who want to do good and get to know their neighbors can apply for the European Voluntary Service. Everyone can find a reason for the sentence: Yes, I want Europe! Who knows this sentence, this wish better than you here, who are sitting in this hall today? Who knows it better?

My thanks today go to so many, starting with the European ambassadors here in the hall and outside, to the Europe activists in education, science, and society, to the particularly imaginative caregivers of bilingual daycare centers in the Euroregions. I thank all those who connect Europe in a thousand ways economically, socially, and culturally. I also want to express my gratitude to our German politicians who have linked their national responsibilities with our European commitments. I especially thank those, and I particularly thank them, who have not only been driven by concern for the possessions of the wealthy when it comes to the concept of solidarity.

We Germans know deep in our hearts that there is something that connects us with Europe in a very special way. After all, it was our country from which everything European, all universal values, were to be destroyed. It was our country that the Western victorious powers nevertheless granted solidarity and assistance right after the war. We were spared what could have easily followed after our hubris: an existence as an outcast outsider outside the family of nations.

Instead, we became – which seems all the more unexpected and wonderful from today’s perspective – we became invited, received, and welcomed. Partners!

We came to the joyful experience that we could respect ourselves and be respected by others when we did not want to be "above or below other nations." Thus, we connected with Europe; we promised ourselves to Europe.

And today we renew this promise.

We will pause before a threshold, we will rethink. But then we will renew trust with good ideas and good reasons, strengthen commitment, and continue to build what we have built – Europe.