Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck on the occasion of the award of the Honorary Prize of the Friedrich August von Hayek Foundation to former Federal President Roman Herzog on November 22, 2015 in ...

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

5 December 2015 · Award of the Honorary Prize of the Friedrich August von Hayek Foundation to former Federal President Roman Herzog

Context
Gauck delivered a laudatory speech honoring former Federal President Roman Herzog upon receiving the Friedrich August von Hayek Foundation Honorary Prize on November 22, 2015.
Main themes
Freedom as creative potential, Roman Herzog's life work, liberal principles and rule of law, trust in open society, Friedrich August von Hayek's thought, freedom and security balance, constitutional law, democratic state, spontaneous order, counterterrorism and civil liberties
Duration
~18 min
60th percentile
Words
2,128
60th percentile
Sentences
102
64th percentile
Readability
45
49th percentile
Grade
11.9
43rd percentile
Syntax
3.06
55th percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
52nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 32%30%
  • Ceremonial 24%23%
  • Economic 23%22%
  • Institutional 13%12%
  • Geopolitical 8%8%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

102 sentences in 18 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Weidmann, dear Mr. Di Fabio, my heartfelt congratulations on being honored today for your contributions to freedom.

I now have the pleasure of honoring an entire life's work dedicated to freedom. However, in the few minutes available, I can only offer remarks or, let us say, highlights of a great life's work. The work of a constitutional law scholar, statesman, and European who ranks among the greats in the history of the Federal Republic – I am speaking about the life’s work of my predecessor, Professor Roman Herzog.

Esteemed, dear Mr. President, I extend my warmest congratulations to you with great gratitude!

This award recognizes your decades-long work in and for our democratic state: as a constitutional lawyer, as a politician, as a judge of the Federal Constitutional Court and court president, as head of state, and finally as an "elder statesman." As a supporter of the Hayek Foundation, you have worked for the penetration and enforcement of liberal principles. If we were to add up what you have thought, written, decided, and presented on issues of freedom – we would indeed arrive at a remarkable body of work. However, today I will limit myself to one facet. What I would like to talk about is the creative potential of freedom, and indeed, despite or precisely because of its ambivalence. For we know, whether from the history of subjugation and exploitation or from our current experiences: Humanity also carries destructive potential within itself. It is hard to believe that humans are fundamentally and inherently good, wise, and rational. I strive every day to believe this. You, dear Mr. Herzog, are already skeptical! And despite this skepticism, despite the danger of the "misguided will," as you say, you have consistently advocated for the idea of freedom, because freedom – and now I quote one of your formulations that we should use much more often – because freedom is the "element of life" for humans. It has not given us a perfect society, but it has indeed provided us with the best societal order we know. Therefore, allow me a few words on the creative power of freedom.

The creative potential of freedom enables us to develop our talents and ideas, to discover new opportunities, new possibilities, and to open new spaces. What Friedrich August von Hayek wrote about this more than half a century ago – and what Roman Herzog then picked up and continued in his writings and speeches – has lost none of its relevance. Thus, we read in Hayek's "Constitution of Liberty": "Because each individual knows so little and especially because we rarely know who among us knows something best, we trust that the independent and competitive efforts of many will produce the things we will desire when we see them."

It is important to emphasize that this is not about certainties, but about trust. This is what Hayek advocates so urgently: trust in the positive forces of spontaneous order, trust in the constructive dynamics of open discourse, and trust in the creative potential of liberal plurality. In short: confidence and trust in the open society. The word "trust" probably captures it even better than the word "confidence," which is so shaped by personal feelings and our personal sphere.

However, the message of the creative power of freedom must, as Hayek emphasized, be reformulated for each generation. The words that Roman Herzog found in 1997 have lost none of their validity to this day: "Freedom is the flywheel for dynamism and change. If we succeed in conveying this, we hold the key to the future in our hands." These are core statements from your famous speech "A New Beginning in the 21st Century." As the "Jolt Speech," it has entered history.

The "jolt" has also become a catchphrase, a synonym for the striving to break open crusts, to overcome stagnation, and to develop enthusiasm and momentum for the new – not an easy task in the country where we love to live. For from experience, we know: It is the interplay of freedom rights that offers us the best chances to mobilize the necessary forces to tackle political, economic, and social challenges.

However, this interplay cannot function if the state were to rely solely on the power of spontaneous orders. It must be capable of protecting and enforcing freedom rights. For the rule of law is the guardian of freedom and at the same time the guarantor of security. Even for Hayek, who developed his own understanding of law, the prevention of violence was a fundamental condition for the preservation of freedom. Now, legal scholars may debate whether there is a fundamental right to security, but one thing is clear: The state has a duty to protect against threats to the life, freedom, and other fundamental rights of citizens. And it is also clear: Freedom and security must always be rebalanced. How difficult and controversial this is, especially when it comes to protecting the population from terrorists, we know not only from today's debates but also from earlier ones. However, today we can be helped by what Roman Herzog has repeatedly emphasized: Our state is a service state, its ability to enforce is not an end in itself, but serves solely the citizens and their freedom to develop as well as their security.

Our democracy, however, also thrives on the recognition of freedom rights as personal opportunities, that they are accepted and also perceived in this way. This naturally includes economic freedom rights. Time and again, you, dear Mr. Herzog, have made it clear that the market and democracy belong together: that the principle of competition – in politics as well as in the economy – while not a guarantee, offers the greatest prospect of seizing opportunities and solving problems – especially in the social market economy, which deviates quite a bit from Hayek's ideas. Why is it social despite some weaknesses? Because it links individual freedom with enabling social balance better than any other economic system, thus allowing individuals to make use of their freedom in fair competition.

We live in a landscape where people have a secret love for being taken care of. Some of them find powerlessness even better than active shaping and independent responsibility. This is certainly connected to many historically formative experiences. And that is why it is so important to me that especially in such a landscape, which is so familiar and where one can rely on the caring element of a preventive state, that in such a landscape the idea and power of freedom is recognized, asserted, and defended as the more original. We can certainly name the dangers posed by the extremes. An excessive freedom has a nexus to the overburdening of the many and to the favoring of the few gifted and capable. But there is also another danger. That is a nexus of care to the disempowerment of the many. And the idea of freedom assumes that we do no harm to people, but rather good, when we appeal to their potentials, to the power that lies within them. This includes, alongside the longing for freedom, the creative potentials that reside in us and that we see, whether in the economy, in politics, in art, in science, in culture, in sports, indeed everywhere. We thrive on the fact that we do not deny the challenges we face, but that we accept them. That we, even when they seem overwhelming and we have not yet recognized the final solution, accept them as something that belongs to us. Therefore, it is important that we repeatedly sing this song of freedom. And we must always remind ourselves that the model of social balance in our social market economy is unconditionally linked to the idea of freedom. Otherwise, the power contained in this model is lost.

When you hear me speak like this, I am of course also a student of my predecessors. Roman Herzog would not be the critical spirit and thinker and admonisher that we honor today if he had only constantly praised the virtues of the social market economy. You, dear Mr. Herzog, have clearly named misdevelopments: the constraining of independence and initiative through too much state regulation and, conversely, an expectation and entitlement attitude towards the state, which you described with the words "longing for care." You have vigorously demanded a change in thinking here and have emphatically called for reforms and a change in attitudes.

In fact, society has learned. Politics has also proven to be capable of learning. We have seen powerful changes, some of which were highly controversial, such as the Agenda 2010. But not least because of the reforms at that time, the German economy recovered from the financial crisis faster than many other industrialized countries. In doing so, the balance between market-based incentives and social security mechanisms has been maintained. And while high unemployment alarmed us until a decade ago, we now rejoice in record employment. This means: Politics is also capable of learning.

These are many good news. But when we hear them, we must not fall into complacency; we cannot afford that. For there are still burdens in this country that need to be lifted. We still have too many long-term unemployed. And people here still find it so difficult to take the step into self-employment that many even speak of a "founding and entrepreneur misery." However, we need people who dare to take risks, for competition will continue to increase with advancing globalization and digitalization. We need a lasting willingness to change in order to continue to fulfill the promise of prosperity, individual participation, and opportunities for advancement, which must be an unbreakable part of the social market economy – and to extend it in further development to those who come to us anew.

We urgently need critical observers and shapers – personalities like Roman Herzog, who help us prepare our open society for the future. How can this succeed? With the "enthusiasm for great ideas," paired with "notorious pragmatism." These are the apt words of another, a royal laudator, it was King Juan Carlos of Spain, to whom I align myself here. And let us also recall what Roman Herzog himself has repeatedly demanded: Let us mobilize our creative forces! Let us seize the opportunity for renewal! Let us resist narrow-mindedness and sluggishness! We are currently experiencing this particularly in one area: among the many citizens, including many entrepreneurs, who are helping newcomers to our country in a previously unknown way. This civic engagement reminds us of something that Friedrich August von Hayek encapsulated in the simple sentence: "Freedom and responsibility are inseparable." And this interplay – freedom as responsibility – is also inseparably connected to the work of Roman Herzog.

This also describes the core of my own understanding of freedom, and you, dear Mr. Herzog, speak to my heart when I read from you: "It is not about freedom from, but about freedom to responsibility." I always say: Responsibility – that is the freedom of adults. And you speak equally to my heart when you emphasize that the proper and responsible handling of freedom does not come naturally; it must be acquired through education and communication. Malice can be done alone, virtue must be acquired, a wise man, it was Wilhelm Busch, once said. This means we are faced with a complex process of shaping freedom; we are faced with a lifelong task. How existential this task is can be seen in the devastation that enemies and opponents of our Western societal model inflict.

Dear Mr. Herzog, you have always spoken plainly: the idea of freedom is not a guarantee of freedom. But it is an eminently humane idea because it takes into account the immense potentials that lie within every person – whether obvious or hidden – an idea that attributes to them the ability and dignity to become the master of their own fate. We have learned from history that there are powerful obvious or latent desires for relinquishing the heavy autonomy of the adult citizen, indeed that even an unspoken but lived Yes to political powerlessness of large majorities has turned entire societies into dominated political deserts. We have experienced this. But we have also become witnesses to that great movement that has changed our Europe since 1989. From the longing for freedom of a few, the political program of many has emerged. And from that program, open societies have indeed arisen.

Dear Mr. Herzog, not only as a witness of the times but as a shaper in the realm of politics and law, you have shown us the way to the unfolding of freedom. I am pleased that I can and may express my heartfelt thanks to you today.