Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck to open a panel discussion at the Lugar de la Memoria memorial site on March 21, 2015, in Lima:

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

31 March 2015 · Panel discussion at the Lugar de la Memoria memorial site · Lugar de la Memoria, Lima, Peru

Context
Gauck addressed a panel discussion at Lima's Lugar de la Memoria memorial site during a German state visit to Peru in March 2015.
Main themes
Culture of remembrance, rule of law, transitional justice, democracy, human dignity, victims' memory, Peru's democratic transformation, national identity, consensus-building, memorial site, German historical experience, civil society pioneers
Duration
~24 min
74th percentile
Words
2,888
74th percentile
Sentences
152
81st percentile
Readability
60
88th percentile
Grade
9.6
16th percentile
Syntax
3.00
47th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
23rd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 39%39%
  • Institutional 29%29%
  • Geopolitical 15%15%
  • Ceremonial 15%14%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

152 sentences in 22 paragraphs

Whoever visits this place high above the sea must cover a long distance from the entrance gate down there. A long distance until he reaches this impressive building, in whose rooms history and stories will be told in the future. The long path to remembrance is to be understood as quite symbolic. For remembering and commemorating do not happen overnight; they take time. I will talk about that later.

I just spoke of a long path. And in these days, I am experiencing a Peru that has mastered a long, arduous, and demanding journey. When we look at the entire country, we see today a fairly stable democracy, and for several years now, a dynamic economy. The result is that poverty is being effectively combated, even if it has not yet been completely eliminated. But there are significant successes to be seen, and it is also evident that people have found new hope, who have lived for decades in the dark valleys of hopelessness.

Today's Peru is an open-minded country. There are good reasons for the German President to be here for a state visit after more than 50 years. I have great respect for the achievements that Peru has made so far. If we imagine: The end of the tragedy that is to be discussed in this building is not long past. Peru emerged from the violent conflict within its borders 15 years ago, after tens of thousands of victims. And you, the citizens of Peru, did not give up, did not fall into anarchy, but created peace and strengthened democracy on this basis. You established a body, the "Acuerdo Nacional," which brings together and unites the political, economic, and civil society forces and which today makes the most important directional decisions by consensus. We will talk later about consensus and the difficulty of defining it. But I want to first acknowledge the work of this body, also in connection with the special greeting to Mr. Vargas Llosa.

Whenever a problem is recognized, not the entire society is yet affected by it. Whether it is the implementation of democracy, the rule of law, or a culture of remembrance – in the development of human communities, individuals and small groups always take the lead. And we do not know exactly when the rationale of these directional decisions made by individuals or small enlightened groups can sometimes change a stubborn "common sense" in society. Therefore, it is important that we approach the people who were pioneers in developments that a viable community needs with affection and gratitude, but also with support. Thank you to all of you who took on this task so early and so passionately to awaken society.

What societies undergoing a transformation process into a law-based democracy need is a deeper inner conviction, which in some South American countries has simply been expressed in two words: "nunca más." We do not want to have what we had ever again. But how does such a common conviction then lead to a new view of one's own nation? How does this identity arise, which differs from the previous identities of a nation – parcelled into friends and enemies, the upper and lower classes, clans and pre-modern loyalties? We know all these influences on the continent.

At the same time, we know the development towards this ideal case of a community of nations, where people freely choose and dismiss their governments and where they – very importantly – submit to the law, no matter how powerful they are and how strong the vote of the population has been for them. There is no future democracy without a strong framework of law. And what we do when we remember is not only to call the dignity of the victims to the memory of the nation, but also to lament a lack – namely the lack of the rule of law in institutions, the lack of humanity in ideological movements, but also the internal weakness of legal structures.

Therefore, this house will one day be a comprehensive place of learning for civilization. A place of learning for a politics that never knows only one perspective – I mean the perspective of those currently in power – but constantly includes the perspectives of the oppressed or the victims of society. And in all violations of rights, in all misguided actions – sometimes also by state bodies – it will help that the respective nation agrees out of respect for the suffering of the victims: We want to regain the dignity of the law alongside human dignity. That is why this place has a special significance for the visitor from distant Europe. For me, it is something like a monument, even though I cannot yet see the content of the exhibition here. But the approach expresses that what I have just reflected on with you finds its place here. And I promise you, if you fill this place with life in this sense, many other presidents and fighters for human rights from around the world will visit you here, paying you respect – but also offering help where they can provide assistance.

Now I come to what we have to contribute from our German experiences. I was very pleased to hear how intensively German politics and also German civil society – but here, German politics should be mentioned first – have financially supported this project. When I come here, I come without a euro. But I come with experiences. And these are experiences of different ways of dealing with the past that have shaped my country.

Many of you know that I lived in a dictatorship in East Germany and only entered politics in 1990 through a free election. At that time, I was part of the opposition in the first freely elected People's Chamber. But the opposition and the governing coalition jointly passed laws that were intended to promote an open and critical examination of the dictatorship. This was mainly evident in the Stasi files, that is, the files of the communist secret police. After the Peaceful Revolution, we found around 160,000 kilometers of files in the various offices of the Stasi, some of which had been destroyed. And in these files, we were able to trace the records of repression. They represented for us the knowledge of the dictators. And we faced the question: to open the files or not? Many said: "It cannot be done; it will lead to murder and mayhem in society." However, we had experienced a peaceful revolution, and thus we did not fear a civil war. And we said: No! We do not want to leave the ruling class of the past in a monopoly on the truth and thereby put the oppressed in a worse position when they seek rehabilitation. Therefore, there was a broad parliamentary majority across all political milieus to open these files. If the files had been placed under archival law, they would have been sealed for 30 years.

In many transformation societies in Europe, the same questions arose after the break: How do we treat the files? Are they state files? Do they really need to be protected for 30 years? Or are they files of a dictatorship that should be made available to us, the oppressed, rather than to any other specialists? And that is why we decided to open them. This was a favor to those who had been oppressed and arose from the change in perspective I spoke of earlier: Look at the situation of the victims, and you will find better political decisions. But why was Germany able to take such decisive steps in an enlightening historical policy in 1990? Because Germany had already gone through other phases.

Now let us look at the worse German dictatorship, the National Socialist one. It ended in 1945, in a military defeat. At that time, the very first victims from abroad who had been expelled from Germany returned. The families who had to mourn Hitler's victims could indeed name the actions of the National Socialists, and the powers that ruled Germany also promoted such publications. But the discourse about the victims of Nazi rule remained within narrow circles. It took place, but it did not reach society at large.

After the war, the German-Jewish philosopher Hannah Arendt returned to Germany for a visit. She looked around the country and noted: "There is a loss of reality." The Germans – when asked about the war and the causes of the war – begin to talk about the sins of others. And associated with this loss of reality, she observes a loss of empathy for the victims. Both losses are compensated: The loss of reality is compensated by an overabundance of opinions. And the loss of empathy for the victims one has caused is compensated by self-pity. Both phenomena are clearly recognizable in this first phase of dealing with victims as well as with guilt after the war.

I would now like to come to the core of my wishes and ideas that I have for this house. This form of dealing with the past, a limited acceptance or even denial of the facts, this empathy and sympathy with the victims, all of this did not simply remain in Germany, but it transformed. The enlightened milieus, the victims, science, and also the judiciary, with important war crimes trials, changed the mentality of the people. The next generation began in the late 1960s to talk with their parent generation about guilt, about their own guilt. Where were you when Hitler ruled? Where were you in the war? What did you do? Were you in Oradour? Were you in Lidice? In countless German families, like my generation, these discourses took place.

Step by step, this led to a great shock. In this process, scientists, psychologists, and engaged individuals from the middle of society played their own and important role before politics changed in toto. The last act of this political change was a famous speech by one of my predecessors, Richard von Weizsäcker, in 1985, when he finally named the end of the war as liberation. Many left-liberals had long understood it that way. But for wide circles of Germans, it was important that a conservative president could say: that was liberation, not just defeat. And he was able to speak of guilt and portray the non-recognition of the past as a damage to future prospects.

Thus, a process had come to a close, which had resulted in a refusal to face facts and to the fundamental human sympathy for the suffering of victims. And on this basis, on this politically and culturally identified identity of the – still West German – Federal Republic, the East Germans could build when they began in 1990 to come to terms with their dictatorship. This double experience of coming to terms with dictatorship has placed us Germans in a special role. That is why a German minister has offered you a financial contribution to this memorial site, because we Germans have deep and formative experiences with guilt, with the denial of guilt, and ultimately with the recognition and coming to terms with guilt. And I tell you: The nation did not lose itself when it spoke about its own guilt, but it came to itself in a very peculiar, unpatriotic way. It achieved an inner freedom when it did not derive the standard for coming to terms with the past from the word and concept of "nation." Instead, it reached this freedom when it was able to make universal human rights the standard of what we call memory politics and what memory means in the collective sense.

We cannot shape individual memories, but a state can do a lot to ensure that this remembering, guided by humane values, indeed includes my own guilt and my own misdeeds. And I repeat the core message: Germany did not lose itself on this difficult path, in which initially much conflict arose between the camps, but it won itself. It gained its own identity, it was able to believe in itself and trust itself. And now we come to a key word of transformation societies. Not only here in South America, but everywhere where new democratic structures are to emerge, it does not start with happiness and abundance, but it begins with confrontation. The value of trust in such phases is so eminent that it is truly hard to surpass. That is why I strongly advocate for the role of law in a reforming society.

What does this mean for you in your specific situation? I cannot, of course, say what is exactly right; I am not familiar enough with the situation. But the presence of various ministers at this event and the very intense conversation with President Humala strengthen my belief that it will be possible for you, for the Peruvians, to move from a fragmented memory to a collective culture of remembrance. There will still be phases when those from the military and police, who once defended the state and the citizen, will say: We are heroes, we did everything to fight the terrorists. That may be true for many, but you all here know that in this just struggle for the authority of the state, many serious mistakes were made and, yes, guilt has also arisen.

And I can imagine that within the military leadership, there is a progressive process in which the generals are asking themselves: What kind of tradition should shape this country? What traditions does a democratic military need? And then one will be able to distinguish justified acts of defense from what must simply be called crimes or state terrorism. In the struggle, we often lose our values. But why should we not talk about it? Are all soldiers and officers guilty? Did they stage a coup against the Republic? They did not.

So we will talk about how we, when thinking of state institutions, have served the law and our state and democracy, and when we have strayed from the path of law. That hurts. But at the moment when a group is capable of giving such testimony, the victims become incredibly generous. Victims become gracious when the perpetrators do not flee from the truth. And the truth is something that sometimes hurts, but ultimately heals. In the New Testament, there is a religious saying in the Gospel of John that can certainly apply to politics: "You will know the truth, and the truth will set you free." I can also say this in a very political way, with the words of a great poet and president, namely Václav Havel, when he spoke of a way of life that is called: living in the truth. One can make life in society cheaper, one can conceal, imprison, repress, or not name the truth. But we do not serve ourselves with that; we may serve the name of my family, but not the honor of our nation.

And now I speak about the other camp. Back then, when the Shining Path was recruiting, it was often the sons and daughters of citizens who rushed from the cities. They had strange, partly romantic notions of the liberation of the masses, and they wanted to do this not through debate, but also through military violence. Some of the idealism, some of the liberation pathos was indeed genuine. And step by step, this develops into a terrorist calculus, as we have always known from the liberators in history, since the Jacobins, but especially since the Moscow and Beijing model, to bring people's rule as so-called communism to the people. Wherever this has happened, it has been associated with massive loss of life, with the restriction or cessation of the rule of law, and has brought neither political nor cultural progress. In this camp, those who once began a so-called liberation struggle with idealistic ideas will be asked: When did you betray your ideals? How many people did you have to kill to show that you wanted to lead the world to a better future? And I tell you: that is just as difficult for them as it is for many military personnel.

I do not come here very often. Therefore, I have allowed myself in this speech to approach the current conflict situations a bit more closely and a bit more densely, and please do not misunderstand me. I want to show you: Our experience has not destroyed our nation, but strengthened it. I wish for further exchange between Peru and Germany on these issues. Let us discuss together how these dialogue processes, which must then arise in a society, can be intensified. And how to first bring the facts and thus the truth to the table. And then, on the basis of these facts, to initiate a sometimes ruthless but ultimately satisfying discourse.

We Germans want to stand by your side. In exactly the same way that we stand by you when it comes to strengthening infrastructure or improving statehood or making the rule of law more secure. All of these are levels of encounter that I consider important and beautiful. But there is also an encounter of the burned children. And if they remain true to their real reality, then there is a future from truth.