State visit to the Republic of India from February 4 to 8, 2014 – Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck during the visit to Jawaharlal Nehru University on February 6, 2014, in New Delhi:

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

27 March 2014 · State visit to the Republic of India · Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi, India

Context
Gauck addressed students and faculty at Jawaharlal Nehru University in New Delhi on February 6, 2014, during a state visit to India, reflecting on democracy and bilateral ties.
Main themes
German-Indian relations, democracy and democratic values, civil society and openness, women's rights and minority protections, globalization and economic ties, freedom of expression, religious freedom, child labor, resilience of democracy, India's diversity, civic life and free press, terrorism and security
Duration
~27 min
79th percentile
Words
3,253
79th percentile
Sentences
192
88th percentile
Readability
40
36th percentile
Grade
11.9
44th percentile
Syntax
2.78
20th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
22nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 29%29%
  • Economic 24%24%
  • Institutional 17%17%
  • Social 14%14%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Environmental 6%6%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

192 sentences in 41 paragraphs

Thank you very much for this warm, friendly welcome. When you walk through the streets of Berlin, you do not have to wait long to encounter a piece of India. It could be an Indian restaurant, a movie poster, or an advertisement for a yoga class. You will see Indian tourists, students, and businesspeople. And you will encounter more and more Indians in Germany every year.

For example, this year, 25 percent more Indians are studying in Germany than in the previous year. There is much more India in Germany than one might believe at first glance. Many German products contain software or hardware developed by brilliant minds in India. And last year, Indian companies created 26,000 jobs in Germany; the trend of investment is rising. While globalization may not shift our states, it has brought Indians and Germans closer together than ever before in our history.

Two things shape our German view of India: curiosity and respect. This was already true during the time when India was still a British colony. In this sense, I am also a very typical German: What I bring to India is— as you might guess—both curiosity and respect.

I know that many voices of the Indian nation predicted a quick end after independence—they were proven wrong. I also know how many voices of democracy gave no chance in your country, which is unmatched in diversity—these warners were also proven wrong.

As a resident of the former German Democratic Republic, a state that denied its citizens democratic rights and freedoms, democracy was a longing goal for me for decades. Today, in reunified Germany, strengthening democracy is still close to my heart. Democracies are dear to me, and democrats are dear to me. Therefore, I consciously chose India as the destination for my first longer trip to Asia: because I wanted to pay my respect to this most populous democracy—and I want to do so.

Of course, I also see some problems during my visit. That is just how it is in a democracy. Democracy does not create paradises. This is not the case in Europe either. A glance at your diverse and robust media is enough to convince oneself that not everything is perfect. For example, this morning I spoke extensively with representatives of civil society. The discussion mainly focused—but not exclusively—on the situation of women in India. A sensitive topic that is also viewed with great attention abroad. We quickly moved on to other challenges, such as child labor, religious freedom, and the protection of minorities, including those with different sexual orientations. It became very clear how difficult it is to implement the guaranteed rights that the country provides for all citizens in the face of widespread traditional mentalities.

By the way, my conversation partners did not mince words. The openness I experienced today with representatives of civil society is not common in all my visits abroad. Often, taboos complicate my encounters. My impression here in India is that there is little that foreign visitors could critically address that has not already been openly discussed by Indians themselves.

Today was a very special day. The courage, perseverance, goodwill, strength, and optimism of my conversation partners have made me and my delegation admirers of these people. We felt not only admiration but also inspiration. We would like to take some of that back to Germany. Because we also need courage and strength in our European political environment.

I would like to return to the openness. Seeing this powerful civil society that exists in your country has filled us with great joy. And you all can be proud of it. Not only of the products of your cutting-edge technology, not only of the results of your researchers, not only of the international recognition, but of this powerful civic life that has emerged in the heart of your society and is also reflected in a colorful and diverse press. It is indeed important for a democracy to give people the space to express what needs to be discussed regarding grievances or necessary changes. When it is spoken out, it becomes easier to shape change and transformation peacefully.

Dissent and open debates are part of democracy. And we all wish, those of us who want to build and improve democracy, that more and more countries are willing to allow this openness. This openness, of course, also has enemies. When discussions about changes are to be stifled in the bud in the name of cultural or religious traditions, then distrust is warranted. When dissenters are even physically attacked, the state is called upon to fulfill its responsibility to protect.

India has had many painful experiences with attacks on openness—both from within and from outside. A democracy must be resilient and at the same time always ensure that openness and freedom, which are to be defended, are not sacrificed in the name of security.

The promoters of terror and violence find it easy everywhere in the world where people feel hopeless, excluded, or treated unjustly. Therefore, it is so important to provide public goods such as education and health for as many people as possible, indeed for all people. How to achieve the right balance between individual initiative and state provision is a topic of ongoing discussion in Germany as well.

We have had good experiences with adding a strong social component to the market economy. We have a term for it: social market economy. This way of thinking is also rooted in India. I wish you good progress in your future development on the path of trying out and positively shaping this component of economic activity.

However a state balances the various interests—economic participation is, for me, an indispensable pillar of a successful democracy. Political participation alone does not bring prosperity. Without a noticeable improvement in living conditions, it is easier for opponents of open societies to stir up discontent. India made a significant step towards greater economic participation with its economic reforms of 1991. The consequences have changed the country and thus the world. I can only encourage you to continue to focus on participation and openness in the economic sphere.

"Freedom and power bring responsibility," said Jawaharlal Nehru on the eve of Indian independence. Our two countries, Germany and India, possess both: freedom and power. Both do not see themselves as globally dominant superpowers, but must seriously ask themselves: What can we do to fulfill our international responsibilities?

The starting point for joint action seems good to me: Since the year 2000, there has been a strategic partnership. It exists not only on paper but also in reality. The cabinets of our countries meet regularly—for us, a sign of mutual appreciation and closeness, a special form of partnership that we maintain only with very few countries outside Europe.

I am well aware of the different sizes of our countries. But I speak not only as a German but implicitly also as a European. And as a European, I say: Germany accepts its responsibility for the well-being of Europe on this increasingly integrated continent, and it plays a central role in solving the European crisis. We are aware of this responsibility. Like the Indians, we Europeans do not hide our problems from the outside world. We do not sugarcoat anything. But at the same time, I would like to ask you: Do not be deceived by alarmist portrayals in this area.

Do not see Europe solely through the lens of Euroskeptics, even if the most beautiful works of apocalyptic prognostication are currently appearing in English. Europe has the opportunity to reorient itself through this crisis. Ireland, for example, is the first Euro country that was supported with loans from the European Union and the International Monetary Fund and has now returned to the market. Other countries will follow.

Europe is on a good path. And we are resolutely committed to the common European currency. We are currently seeing how unbalanced and fragile the global economic development still is. Whether Europe or India: Instead of hastily drawing conclusions from symptoms of crises, we should rather analyze structural problems and their causes soberly. We are experiencing anew in these years how difficult it is to implement reforms. They require political will, they require societal acceptance, and they also require time to take effect. Democratically structured societies are accustomed to mediating between different groups and negotiating compromises. This may initially seem to delay the reform process, but it helps to anchor it later in society.

You in India also have this wealth of experience in implementing changes and reforms through democratic discourse. We all know that India also faces further significant economic challenges, that much more needs to be done for a healthy economy, solid finances, and a stable currency.

Every country should contribute to overcoming structural weaknesses and promoting stable economic development. Germany advocates a consistent stability policy in international bodies such as the G20 and the International Monetary Fund. India has made significant progress in recent decades, and I am confident that India can continue its course of modernization.

My confidence is based on the conviction that openness, internal participation, and democracy are the prerequisites for development and progress. Therefore, we should also advocate these principles as cornerstones of the international order.

I am pleased that important Indian thinkers, such as Nobel laureate Amartya Sen, point to the Indian roots of self-governance, co-determination, and also the separation of powers. Democracy has many faces worldwide. Democrats are united by the fundamental idea of responsible individuals wanting to take their fate into their own hands and to be able to co-determine the fate of their nation. I welcome it when India internationally affirms its values and stands up to those who label democracy exclusively as a "Western," somehow foreign idea. Indian thinkers participated in the formulation of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. A declaration that still binds us all today.

So how can we support democracy and human rights worldwide? I have great understanding that India, given its colonial experience, has a very fine sense when, in the name of values, the will of other countries is to be imposed. At the same time, however, we have seen for decades that dictators or authoritarian rulers relativize or even negate the universal validity of human rights by referring to their supposedly "Western" origins. Therefore, our two nations could think even more together about how to advocate globally for democracy and the universality of human rights, also about how to support those who often risk their lives for what citizens of our countries may take for granted. And finally, about how these standards can be upheld, not just when it serves realpolitik interests. I know this creates problems when encountering some state leaders. But the decades-long experience of people who have lived under the rule of Soviet communism shows me how important moral support is for those who fight for freedom, even in countries where that is not part of the principle of society.

I am following the development of the BRICS countries with great interest. It is quite remarkable how a term coined by a single British analyst at an American bank could become a worldwide political grouping, whose glue sometimes seems to be not similar interests but criticism of existing global institutions. But even in that, the countries are not in agreement—I only think of the reform of the Security Council.

I can understand the criticism of outdated structures very well. But would it not be better to work together to remodel the global house so that as many as possible can feel comfortable in it, rather than building a new house next door?

Remodeling this global house will require compromises from the architects and craftsmen on all sides. In the design, Germany and India will be able to play an important role. I would like to mention three areas: security, development, and climate protection.

Germany is committed to global security within the framework of the United Nations. "To maintain world peace and international security," as stated in Article One of the UN Charter – we support this goal as the third-largest contributor and troop provider.

India's engagement in United Nations peace missions is also significant. Time and again, there are casualties to mourn, most recently in South Sudan, where three Indian soldiers serving in the UN mission were killed. These young men have paid the highest possible price for peace far from home. Given that India is in a significantly less secure environment than Germany, I have great respect for this commitment.

Conflicts between states are only part of what we can see as a threat to peace and security in today's world. Many conflicts occur within states. There are abuses by state security forces, but also human rights violations by non-state actors.

Each situation is different and must be considered independently. I am aware that new concepts like the Responsibility to Protect are not yet fully developed and therefore not accepted everywhere. We find ourselves in the tension between will and ability, between realpolitik and double standards. "Responsibility to Protect" must not be an excuse for a new interventionism. On the other hand, in a globalized world, the responsibility of all is growing – there are no longer any white spots on the map when human rights are massively violated.

It would be nice if Indian experts would also engage more in discussions about what the international community could do together in advance of crises to prevent escalation. The greater the international consensus, the more effectively we can remind governments of their responsibility to protect their own populations.

At home in Germany, I advocate for Germany to take on more responsibility in the world. Germany and India share the hope for a reform of the United Nations Security Council. The body should reflect the realities of today's world, not those of 1945. It would be an important sign for the legitimacy of the United Nations to make progress on this by the time of its 70th anniversary.

Now to the second point: development. The Indian government points out to me the continuing enormous challenges in combating poverty. During my stay, I will take the time to gain an impression of life outside the major cities. The reports and figures speak a clear language: nearly 70 percent of Indians live on less than two dollars a day, according to the World Bank. In the Global Hunger Index, which deals with undernutrition among adults and children as well as child mortality, India's situation is classified as "serious."

Therefore, it is only understandable that for India, the framework conditions for development and poverty reduction play a central role. Germany is one of the most important donors worldwide – only the USA and the UK provide higher contributions. Without a doubt, we will continue to engage in development cooperation. We will also continue our bilateral cooperation with India. Germany is the second-largest bilateral donor after Japan. In addition, there are the German contributions to European Union programs. The new Federal Minister for Economic Cooperation and Development is accompanying me on this trip – a sign of how important our cooperation with India is to us.

For India to develop, international trade is important, even more so than transfer payments. It is encouraging to see that the Ministerial Conference of the World Trade Organization has finally reached an outcome after a long standstill. Our countries should work in further rounds to shape world trade in such a way that different interests are also taken into account. Transparent, fair, and, if necessary, enforceable standards to which all parties adhere are important. Our common goal should be an open trading system with free access to resources for all involved actors, not a division into exclusive spheres of interest.

When it comes to exports and imports, India is increasingly looking to the East. This is understandable given the potential gains. At the same time, the European Union remains India's most important trading partner after the United Arab Emirates. Would it not be appropriate to give new momentum to the free trade agreement with the European Union? I am accompanied on this trip by a high-level business delegation. The interest of the German economy in India is great, and there are also many traditional connections. We still have much common potential. But to fully exploit this potential, we hope for a strengthened position for India. Companies look closely at the size of the market and production costs in their engagement, but also at legal certainty, patent protection, and transparent administrative procedures.

Now to the third topic: climate protection. The possible consequences of global warming threaten people in India very directly. It is hard to imagine what will happen if the number of floods and droughts continues to increase. Even today, they are a bitter reality for many Indians. The main contributors to climate change are not historically found in India, but India's emissions still carry weight globally. And they will grow. Given India's significant challenges in combating poverty, I understand that India does not want to impose too tight constraints on its economic development. However, an internationally binding system will not succeed without the participation of your country. It has the third-highest emissions worldwide. The world can only keep climate change somewhat in check if there are binding rules for all. It is therefore extremely important that we work together on solutions here. And I am also grateful that our development cooperation has set important and ambitious goals in this area.

Germany, as a highly industrialized country, is taking an ambitious and difficult path by planning to phase out nuclear energy in the medium term while significantly reducing pollutant emissions. Some outside our borders criticize this step. However, we believe that sustainable economic activity and growth do not have to be mutually exclusive – on the contrary, we see it as a recipe for success for the future. Even today, the sector creates many jobs. Renewable energies and energy efficiency are an important component of the Indo-German agreement on development cooperation concluded during my state visit. It offers India the chance to avoid mistakes that others made in dealing with resources in the past. The creativity and ingenuity of the best minds from our countries can help ensure that the remodeled global house, which I mentioned at the beginning, is built to passive energy standards.

I came to political office late in my life, and therefore I am strongly influenced by experiences other than those of democracy. When I observe that both domestic and foreign policy today are shaped not only by state actors, I appreciate that citizens are using the spaces to advocate for their visions of a fairer and better world. The people who participate as civil society actors are, for me, an essential part of any lived democracy. I also appreciate it when engaged individuals build connections across national borders, break down prejudices, and forge alliances, for example, to protect the climate. The well-being of the world is too important to be left solely in the hands of those in power.

We meet today at a university. Students have always been important sources of national change. Through global networking, they can also provide important impulses internationally. Whether later in a government office or as engaged citizens, you can all contribute to improving and renovating the global house, even without having studied architecture. I am convinced that many joint German-Indian components will do this house very well.