Intervention of the President of the Government in the Plenary of Congress on the participation of a Spanish military contingent in Afghanistan and Haiti.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

5 July 2004 · Plenary of Congress on the participation of a Spanish military contingent in Afghanistan and Haiti · Congress

Context
Zapatero addressed the Spanish Congress in July 2004 seeking ratification of the Council of Ministers' decision to deploy military contingents in Afghanistan and Haiti.
Main themes
Spanish military participation in Afghanistan and Haiti, parliamentary oversight of foreign missions, UN mandate and international peace operations, Spain's history of peacekeeping contributions, humanitarian aid missions, defense and security policy, multilateral commitments, tribute to fallen servicemembers
Duration
~31 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,719
83rd percentile
Sentences
108
67th percentile
Readability
17
2nd percentile
Grade
19.4
97th percentile
Syntax
3.44
92nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.25
62nd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 65%65%
  • Institutional 21%21%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

108 sentences in 69 paragraphs

Mr. President, ladies and gentlemen of the Congress,

I appear before this Chamber to inform you about the Agreement on the participation of the Spanish military contingent in international operations approved by the Council of Ministers on July 2 and to request its ratification by Congress. I would like, beforehand, to make some general considerations that will help to properly frame the meaning and scope of this Agreement of the Council of Ministers and of this very debate.

In 1989, the Government of Spain made a momentous decision by ordering the participation of the Spanish Armed Forces in international missions carried out outside our borders. It was a decision that represented a substantial change in the dimension of our foreign policy. It meant, indeed, that Spain joined the dozens of countries that for several decades had been supporting the mandates of the United Nations Security Council with their Armed Forces in humanitarian aid missions, monitoring agreements, or peacekeeping.

By doing so, our country acquired a new weight in the world, equipped itself with a powerful instrument for the development of its foreign policy, and, most importantly, joined an advanced project for the protection of the lives of millions of human beings and for the guarantee and struggle for international peace and security.

On the other hand, the participation of Spanish Armed Forces in this type of operations abroad has decisively contributed to their preparation and modernization, favoring their integration into the defensive system of the International Community. And they themselves, the Armed Forces, have contributed to projecting an image of Spain as a peace-loving country, committed to human rights and dedicated to humanitarian aid for the civilian population affected by wars and conflicts.

Since then, peacekeeping and humanitarian aid operations have progressively taken on a primary and growing importance in Spain's foreign and defense and security policy. In total, in these years we have participated in more than forty peacekeeping and humanitarian aid operations, and nearly 55,000 members of the three Armed Forces and more than 3,000 police and civil guards have made them possible with their presence on four continents.

These operations have represented a significant effort for our country, which has dedicated more than 3 billion euros to cover their costs, and they have involved the assumption of high risks, the most painful and significant proof of which is the 108 men from the Ministries of Defense and Interior who have died in the line of duty in the tasks I have just mentioned. To them, to all of them, we must dedicate our tribute, and to all who have participated in these operations we must dedicate our recognition.

Mr. President, ladies and gentlemen of the Congress,

Spain's presence in international peace and humanitarian aid missions has been the result, in all cases, of decisions made by successive Governments. These decisions have been taken by the body that legitimately, in constitutional terms, was entitled to make them. However, they have never been submitted, beforehand, to debate in this Chamber.

The current Government wants, on the contrary, to initiate today a different procedure that ensures the real participation of Parliament in this essential dimension of our foreign and defense and security policy.

Ladies and gentlemen,

In my investiture speech, I stated that Spain would assume the international obligations that corresponded to it in defense of peace and security, and that it would do so always with one requirement: the prior decision of the United Nations or any other multinational organization of which we are a part. And I added: the participation of the Spanish Armed Forces in missions abroad would be agreed, in any case, with the participation of Parliament. The decision of the Council of Ministers on July 2 and the maintenance of this debate strictly respond, in the Government's opinion, to the fulfillment of these commitments.

Mr. President, ladies and gentlemen of the Congress,

The Government, in the meeting of the Council of Ministers on July 2, on the one hand, decided to renew and expand the Spanish military contingent in Afghanistan and, on the other, decided to deploy a humanitarian mission in Haiti.

Regarding Afghanistan, it is pertinent to recall that the International Security Assistance Force, known as ISAF, was established by the United Nations Security Council in its Resolution 1,386, of December 20, 2001. The mandate of ISAF, which was expanded by Security Council Resolution 1,510, dated October 13, 2003, is to create a security environment that allows for the successful completion of the consolidation process, political stabilization, and physical reconstruction in Afghanistan.

The Security Council Resolutions clearly enumerate the political and humanitarian objectives of the international intervention: first, support for the Afghan Transitional Authority and its successors for the maintenance of security, primarily in Kabul and its surroundings, but also, gradually, in the rest of the country; second, the protection of Afghan authorities, the personnel of the United Nations Assistance Mission in Afghanistan, known as UNAMA, and the personnel of other international civil organizations, including international Non-Governmental Organizations present in the country, so that they can carry out their important work in a safe environment in support of the political transition process established by the Bonn Conference, the coordination of physical reconstruction efforts, and the distribution of humanitarian aid.

Against this backdrop, the Atlantic Council decided on April 16, 2003, to deploy NATO troops in Afghanistan to work under the mandate of ISAF, whose command was assumed by the Atlantic Alliance on August 11 of last year.

We are, therefore, facing a multilateral initiative fully endorsed, from the outset, by international legality; an initiative that is also backed by a strong political consensus for which the maintenance and success of ISAF constitutes its first priority at this time.

This political consensus is also reflected in the unanimous and continued support for the international intervention in Afghanistan by the European Union, so that almost all EU member states currently maintain military contingents in Afghanistan. This is the case with Germany, the United Kingdom, France, Italy, Belgium, the Netherlands, Greece, Denmark, the Czech Republic, Poland, Estonia, Hungary, Portugal, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Slovakia, Slovenia... Even the four member states that maintain a policy of neutrality, namely Finland, Sweden, Ireland, and Austria, also have troops deployed in Afghanistan, as do the countries that aspire to join the European Union, such as Bulgaria, Romania, Croatia, the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, and Turkey.

It is, therefore, evident that the Government's decision to maintain the Spanish military contingent in Afghanistan is fully shared by our closest allies.

International operations in Afghanistan also have the full acceptance of the Afghan authorities and main political forces, who were the ones who requested the creation of ISAF at the Bonn Conference in December 2001, organized by the United Nations.

In this regard, both Afghan President Hamid Karzai and United Nations Secretary-General Kofi Annan have requested the reinforcement of ISAF, particularly to support the electoral process scheduled for the end of September, emphasizing the risk that the progress made to date could be jeopardized without greater international effort.

There is also no doubt about the validity of the reasons that led the International Community to intervene in Afghanistan. As you know, the intervention was born as an immediate and direct response of the International Community to the prior, brutal, and unprecedented attack carried out on September 11, 2001, in New York City. It was an attack designed by a terrorist organization based in Afghanistan and actively protected by the Taliban regime. And, as you also know, Al Qaeda continues to maintain its main organs in Afghanistan.

The Government is determined, as it has expressed on many occasions, to maintain the fight against international terrorism as one of the priorities of Spanish foreign policy, particularly after the attacks of March 11. It is a priority that I am sure you fully share as long as we comply with the requirements of national and international legality.

As I had the opportunity to say at the recent NATO Summit in Istanbul, the fight against terrorism should not be confined exclusively to military and police action against terrorist organizations, but should go further, with the aim of deactivating the elements that create the breeding ground in which terrorism develops.

In this sense, the continued support of the International Community for the political transition process in Afghanistan is an essential condition to prevent this country from becoming a base and refuge for international terrorism again, as it was under the Taliban regime.

The priority must continue to be the consolidation and strengthening of the new Afghan political institutions, so that political stabilization and a safer environment allow for the improvement of the conditions of the Afghan people and the respect for human rights in that country.

It is also essential to continue making progress in the process of disarmament, demobilization, and reintegration of the militias of the "warlords," and it is also important to improve the results of the fight against drug trafficking, given Afghanistan's central position regarding the production of opium and the connections between drug trafficking and international terrorism.

In short, the international presence in Afghanistan aims to facilitate a dignified future for the Afghan population and to guarantee them minimum conditions of peace and stability in which they can freely develop their own institutions, institutions that are in line with democratic principles while respecting local traditions.

In this context, the upcoming electoral process will be a fundamental element for legitimizing the new Afghan government institutions. Hence, a large part of the temporary reinforcement of our presence in Afghanistan will be precisely aimed at ensuring that the elections can be successfully carried out despite the current political and security difficulties.

It is evident that a more stable, safer, more democratic, and freer Afghanistan is in the interest of Spain and the rest of the International Community. In this sense, the prospects for a more dignified political and economic future are the best guarantee, the best antidote, so that future Afghan generations do not feel the temptation to embrace religious fundamentalist extremism or engage in opium cultivation, as has been the case in recent years.

Ladies and gentlemen,

The Agreement approved on July 2 by the Council of Ministers regarding the Spanish military contingent in Afghanistan has several components:

First, the reinforcement of the Spanish contingent provided for in the Agreement involves the deployment of a field hospital equipped with operating rooms and specialists capable of attending to and treating the population, with six intensive care beds and twenty normal hospitalization beds, which could be increased to a total of fifty beds. The medical unit will also have the function of stabilizing and evacuating casualties, which will be ensured by the deployment of the necessary transport elements: four helicopters and two C-130 Hercules transport planes. The deployment of this component, which is clearly humanitarian in nature, is accompanied by the deployment of a support unit of 135 personnel.

Second, the Government's Agreement provides for the deployment of a light Infantry battalion for a duration of three months with the specific objective, requested by the United Nations Secretary-General, Kofi Annan, in a letter dated June 25, to facilitate the successful conduct of the elections in a secure framework. As you know, the planned electoral calendar establishes that the elections should take place at the end of September or the beginning of October. In any case, the Spanish support battalion will be deployed in Afghanistan once the definitive date of the elections is set and for a maximum of ninety days, after which it will return to our country.

Third, under the Agreement, Spain is withdrawing from Operation "Enduring Freedom," which implies the repatriation of the frigate "Numancia" and its 217 personnel who have been deployed in the Indian Ocean, considering that the objectives of such deployment are basically fulfilled and that the most useful and appropriate contribution that Spain can make at present should be aimed at improving the humanitarian situation and supporting the electoral process.

Finally, within the framework of the European consensus on the appropriateness of maintaining international presence in Afghanistan mentioned earlier, we must add to all of the above the increase of about 115 Spanish troops resulting from the decision of the Eurocorps --formed, as Your Lordships know, by France, Germany, Belgium, and Luxembourg, in addition to Spain-- to take charge of the ISAF Headquarters in Kabul starting this August, responding to the demand to replace the NATO command structure, which is currently in charge of the Headquarters.

In summary, the Government Agreement provides for a net increase in our military presence in Afghanistan of a maximum of 500 troops, so that the deployed Spanish forces do not exceed a total of 1,040.

The reinforcement of Spanish military participation in Afghanistan agreed upon by the Government illustrates Spain's commitment to the International Community in a threefold manner: on one hand, humanitarian, by improving the living and security conditions of the Afghan people; on the other hand, political, by supporting the transition process and facilitating the necessary conditions for free elections to be held; finally, security, by being concretized in specific areas where Spain has the necessary means to cover some of the shortcomings identified by ISAF for the success of its mission, thus contributing to international peace and stability.

All of this is done under an explicit mandate from the United Nations Security Council, within the framework of a solid initiative from the Alliance and with the full political support and participation of the European Union.

Regarding the deployment of a humanitarian mission in Haiti, also the subject of the Council of Ministers Agreement, Your Lordships know that the United Nations Security Council decided on April 30, through Resolution 1,542, to establish a stabilization mission in Haiti, which came to replace the Multinational Interim Force established urgently after the resignation of President Aristide by Resolution 1,529 of February 29.

The stabilization force, known as MINUSTAH, has a dual civil and military component, and its mandate is to establish a secure and stable environment in which the political and constitutional transition process in Haiti can develop, assisting local authorities in maintaining the rule of law, security, and personal protection for United Nations members.

Therefore, the criterion of international legality is fully met in this case as well. The international mission aimed at ensuring peace and stability in Haiti also has the full political backing of the Organization of American States and the Caribbean Community.

In this context, my Government has made the principled decision to make a contribution to the stabilization force in Haiti in response to the request made by the country leading it, Brazil, a close ally of Spain. Our contribution will add to those already made by several of our Latin American partners, such as Argentina, Chile, Uruguay, Paraguay, and Peru.

The Government will finalize the details of our contribution to Haiti in the coming weeks, during which we will continue to maintain contacts with the United Nations to assess the needs of MINUSTAH, as well as the specific conditions of the Spanish contribution, including the quantification of the number of troops for this mission and the setting of the date for their deployment.

Mr. President, ladies and gentlemen Members of Parliament,

As I recalled at the beginning of this intervention, since my investiture speech I announced my open and determined commitment to Spain's fulfillment of its international obligations. I only established one requirement, the explicit formulation of which was particularly necessary after the experience of the last fifteen months in our country: the fulfillment of these international obligations would be subject to the prior authorization of the United Nations, respect for international legality, and respect for what Spain's international commitments entail.

When I announced on April 18 the return home of Spanish troops in Iraq, I reiterated the Government's willingness to contribute to the International Community's fight against terrorism while strictly respecting international legality, and I repeated our determination to fulfill our country's international commitments and, very especially, those related to our participation in international peace and security missions.

I must say, in brief but emphatic terms, that both demands are absolutely concurrent, without any nuance, in the two operations subject to the Council of Ministers Agreement.

Both, indeed, are provided for and ordered by repeated Resolutions of the Security Council; Resolutions, by the way, that do not allow for any biased interpretation and that, furthermore, grant legality and legitimacy to these operations from the very beginning of the crisis and do not respond, therefore, to the model of Resolutions adopted midway through a process to achieve some kind of ex post legitimization.

Both, finally, are also backed by decisions of regional political organizations.

ISAF, moreover, is an operation with strong European prominence; MINUSTAH, for its part, is an operation with strong Latin American prominence. In both, therefore, the two priorities of our foreign policy are present; in both, therefore, our most important partners, allies, and friends are present.

ISAF is, finally, an operation initiated under the previous Government that found the absolute support and backing of the Socialist Party.

Mr. President, ladies and gentlemen Members of Parliament,

In my investiture speech, I also committed to ensuring that the participation of the Spanish Armed Forces in missions abroad would be agreed upon with the participation of Parliament. The commitment to agree with Parliament on military missions abroad finds its rationale in the Government's desire to facilitate the maximum possible political consensus on Spanish foreign policy and the reinforcement of what our soldiers' commitment abroad represents.

This consensus must extend beyond this Chamber, so that public opinion, the Spanish people, fully supports Spain's democratic foreign policy. This will allow our Armed Forces and civilian cooperators to feel at all times that their sacrificial work abroad is backed by the citizens' sentiment.

The bases for the consensus that this Government wants to articulate regarding the deployment of Spanish troops abroad can be summarized in three fundamental principles: first, scrupulous respect at all times for international legality; second, a willingness to contribute to multilateral initiatives aimed at ensuring international peace and stability; and, third, solidarity in the face of injustice, the violation of human rights, or humanitarian disasters. All of this, of course, within the limits of our military and material capabilities.

It is about deciding on long-term issues that deserve, consequently, the participation of all institutions and, especially, of those who hold the representation of popular sovereignty, because they affect decisive elements of our foreign policy, defense, and security; because they involve the assumption of high responsibilities and, in some cases, certain risks; and because they imply significant contributions to the definition and defense of international legality, to multilateralism as an appropriate procedure for resolving conflicts, and to the extension and protection of the rights and freedoms of all human beings.

These are issues that deserve a different treatment from that which has been followed so far to adopt the corresponding decisions: a treatment that implies a model of co-responsibility in which the Government and Parliament participate in decisions that affect Spain's strategic interests and the security of our Armed Forces and Security Forces; a treatment, finally, in which the Government and Parliament exercise their respective constitutional competencies: one, to direct foreign action and the defense of the State; the other, to subject to political control any decision of the Government.

Today we do not have instruments that regulate the intervention of the Chamber in this type of decisions. The purpose of the Government, as we have reiterated, is to open a path to make them possible.

Not all operations in which our Armed Forces and Security Forces participate or may participate in the future are the same. They are not the same either in terms of the number of men and women called to participate in them, nor in the inherent risk, nor, above all, in the type of mission to be developed. If they are not the same, neither can nor should the procedure we adopt to agree on them be the same.

In all cases, the Government will ensure detailed information to Parliament. We did so last week with the appearance of the Minister of Foreign Affairs and Cooperation and the Minister of Defense. In some cases, the Government will have to submit to parliamentary debate the decision it has made in the exercise of its powers; in others, the Government will have to request the Chamber's political conformity to adopt them.

In the Government's view, the framework in which these different forms of intervention should be regulated must be that established by the Organic Law of Basic Criteria of National Defense, since it is in it that the role to be played by each of the constitutional bodies is established. In this regard, I announce, therefore, that the Government will submit a Draft Law to reform the currently in force one in the next parliamentary session, in order to open the participation instruments of the Chamber to those I have referred to.

My appearance today, beyond the specific decision that motivates it, has the ultimate sense of advancing the Government's commitment to the new and crucial role of Parliament in this matter.

Your Lordships,

I want to conclude by highlighting the political importance of this appearance, in strict compliance with my democratic commitment to agree with this Chamber on the deployment of Spanish troops on peace missions abroad.

I wish that, after the debate, and I ask the Chamber to do so, it ratifies my Government's Agreement to send military contingents on mission to Afghanistan and Haiti. This is a decision that is absolutely in line with international legality, politically appropriate given the support of the International Community, and beneficial for the peoples of both countries.

And I trust, therefore, that this Chamber will ratify it in a vote that, although not legally binding, this Government will assume as fully binding from a political point of view. For our troops, it must be confirmed, and for all Spanish society, that they will only be sent to Afghanistan, or to Haiti, or to any other place, if my Government's decision has the support of this Chamber. It has not been done so far, but with my Government it will always be this way from now on.

Thank you very much.