Interview with the President of the Government on the program "La Mañana," of Cadena COPE.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

10 May 2004 · Interview on the program "La Mañana" of Cadena COPE

Context
Zapatero gave his first radio interview as Prime Minister on Cadena COPE's morning program on May 10, 2004, discussing democratic renewal and post-11-M electoral controversy.
Main themes
Democratic renewal, media pluralism and freedom, March 11 attacks and electoral legitimacy, governing for all Spaniards, Popular Party electoral defeat, citizens' voting rights, competition in television broadcasting, political opposition concerns
Duration
~92 min
98th percentile
Words
10,995
98th percentile
Sentences
515
98th percentile
Readability
54
75th percentile
Grade
10.9
31st percentile
Syntax
2.86
29th percentile
Vocabulary
2.24
58th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

515 sentences in 246 paragraphs

President .- Good morning first to Federico and to all the participants, and especially to all the listeners of COPE.

The truth is that my presence here is related to my commitment to democratic renewal. One of those commitments is to have an open attitude towards all media outlets, regardless of what they represent. And it is significant, I believe the listeners will understand us and the participants will too, that my first radio interview as President of the Government is with COPE and with you, Federico, which I sense will not be an easy interview.

F. Jiménez Losantos .- For me, no, certainly not, first because if I press too hard, I come off badly, like a rude person; if I press too little, I will be reproached for it. So by coming here, you have already won half the battle, which shows that Rodríguez Zapatero poses a tremendous danger, much more than some people think, at least for those of us who are not socialists, and besides, I confirm that he will not give the monopoly of local television to COPE.

President .- There must be plural television in all areas: local, state... Notice that in Spain we do not have many private television channels. We are one of the countries with the fewest private television channels, and I believe we need to promote competition to the maximum. Competition and freedom are what provide quality and good information.

F. Jiménez Losantos .- How I love to hear you! It reminds me of when you spoke to us about liberalism on "La Linterna," with a touch of "Keynesianism," you would say, winning me over, the then leader of the opposition, and I would say: ah! how nice! And then you would say: "my policy for Spain, that of Redondo Terrero in the Basque Country," and I would say: what a guy!, not even Sagasta. Then Paco came with the cuts, I don't know if it was Paco or Juan Luis; but, before that, one question: aside from past issues, present issues.

Regarding your presence here at COPE, you are undoubtedly aware that there is a significant part of the Spanish electorate, almost ten million votes, who, despite the 11-M, voted for the Popular Party and who have a consciousness, I don't know if of having their elections stolen, but in any case, that the electoral process and the result have been dramatically altered by the attack, by the massacre of 11-M, and by the way the Socialist Party, or part of the Socialist Party, or some leaders of the Socialist Party and some media presented it, who think that there was no fair play.

This reminds me -- and Pedro J. is here, who has recently recounted it in his chilling book -- of a long conversation, on the way back from America, with Aznar, who said: "I cannot declassify the CESID papers because more than nine million people voted for Felipe González, and people cannot think that I am going to govern against half of Spain." How are you going to prevent that half of Spain that feels like they have been robbed, even if it may not be true but they feel it, from having the impression that you govern against them, that you will be President of all Spaniards?

President .- You have raised many things in one question, some reflections, evaluations... Fortunately, elections in Spain, since we have a democratic Constitution, are free, as is the Spanish people. They are free, all have had the same validity, of course; but, moreover, I find it sincerely concerning that in some opinion sectors, and it is tacitly seen in the Popular Party, and it is even more understandable that it happens in the Popular Party, that there has been a direct impact and, therefore, a strange situation in those elections, for one reason: because citizens regard their vote as one of their most important treasures, a cultured, mature, democratically informed citizenry, and they are very protective of their vote.

It is very difficult to tell citizens that they have voted, manipulated, in quotes, or in a strange situation; very difficult. Whoever launches that discourse -- this is a personal opinion -- I believe will be mistaken, and the party, in this case the PP, that does not reasonably accept -- which is not easy, I understand -- a political defeat, as happens in democracy always -- we have had victories and defeats -- that will surely prolong the reflection process.

But all citizens lived through this legislature. If someone believes that the vote is decided at the last minute, they are very mistaken. It has been clearly demonstrated that it is a whole process of reflection that culminates at a given moment. The Popular Party clearly lost support from the citizenry in the last legislature, the PSOE renewed itself and managed to convey enough confidence to obtain the majority of citizens. The Popular Party must reflect on this.

Of course, I will be a President for all Spaniards. My goal is for Spaniards to feel that there is a Government that respects all citizens, regardless of whom they voted for, just as there is a Government that respects all media outlets, all journalists, regardless of what they think, say every morning, and express.

I believe that movement is demonstrated by walking. Federico, I have been President for barely three weeks, that is, 21 days; normally, a hundred days are given to any Government.

F. Jiménez Losantos .- That was before, now with the VAT...

President .- I see that some are very quick. They say the Government is moving quickly, but some, really, in criticizing the Government, are moving much faster. I believe we should have a time where the race is somewhat neutralized and let it be seen. It is true that we have made important decisions, but...

F. Jiménez Losantos .- That is what I was going to say. If you announce the withdrawal of troops from Iraq the day after the elections, which many media, not Spanish, but foreign, interpret as a victory for terrorism, and after the Investiture Debate, you say that the return of the troops is advanced, you will understand that the timelines accelerate so much for the support you seek, as is logical, as for the criticism.

President .- I already tell you, Federico, that you will have work, because this will be a Government that will make many decisions. I have a conception of a modern Government as one that has to work a lot, has to work at the same pace that society works, and today modern societies work intensely in any area: I don't care if it is in business, in the University, in professional sectors... Everyone works intensely, and the Government cannot be slowly contemplating what happens without giving immediate responses.

F. Jiménez Losantos .- I only need more news every day to be able to comment on them.

But, regarding the issue of the withdrawal of troops from Iraq, you had announced in the years of opposition and during the electoral campaign, and we all understood it this way -- the proof is that the next day it was news or was understood as news the different stance, I won't say otherwise -- that you conditioned an express mandate from the UN to our withdrawal of troops starting June 30; that is, that the UN had until June 30, and in the event that there was no mandate that included a certain political-military control, let's say, of the situation, then you would proceed to withdraw our troops. Hence the surprise that it caused us that for a month and a half, and the suspicion that with the European elections in between, in case this had something to do with it, our withdrawal of troops was advanced. I confess that the more it is explained to me, the less I understand it.

President .- It is quite easy to understand. The decision to withdraw the troops, for our troops to return home, had a suspensive condition: the suspensive condition was that by June 30 the United Nations would take charge of the political and military direction, that is, that the United Nations, with "blue helmets," would take charge of the security control of Iraq. I can assure you, and I believe this statement is easily understandable and assumable, that there is not the slightest possibility of that happening.

F. Jiménez Losantos .- And didn't you know or suspect that when you conditioned it to the UN?

President .- Well, no; first, because when I made that announcement and that suspensive condition, the situation in Iraq was not as bad as it has been subsequently warned; and, secondly, because it is evident that when one has won an election, one has the capacity to know directly from all the heads of Governments in the world what their plans and forecasts are. I can assure you that my first interview, on the day of the funeral for the victims of 11-M, here, with Tony Blair and Colin Powell, was already quite definitive, in the sense of what the expectations were...

F. Jiménez Losantos .- How many minutes did you make Powell wait?

President .- No, I didn't make Powell wait a single minute, because what happened, and it has been commented on a lot...

F. Jiménez Losantos .- I say that this recreates a lot for the common man.

President .- It is not so. The funeral was prolonged. It is true that it was a very emotional funeral and it especially extended because the Royal Family greeted and expressed condolences in a gesture, I believe, very, very important, to all the victims. After the funeral, I had arranged interviews with Chirac and Colin Powell, consecutively. As it was prolonged, we all had to wait for the meeting, first, that I had with Chirac and then with Colin Powell.

But I can assure you that Colin Powell was really sincere. It was a very cordial interview, including the comments he made to me about Perejil, which I have since seen reproduced in some media in the same direction, and there I was very clear that the expectation, evidently, was not, in any case, that the United Nations could take over the political and military direction on June 30.

In that situation, I believe it will be understood that it was absurd to prolong our troops for a few weeks in a situation of uncertainty, for their families, for our military commanders, who knew what the decision and intentions of the Government were, to ultimately order the return in an increasingly complicated situation where our troops could no longer perform a humanitarian task, because what they were really doing was practically a self-protection task.

F. Jiménez Losantos .- But precisely for that reason. Spain had an international commitment, had dates, which you, as the Leader of the Opposition, had committed to, and what some of us understand would have been correct is to respect, at least, the dates you had publicly given, even in Parliament, and from there, just as a legitimate Government sent the troops, a legitimate Government calls them back. This acceleration, certainly, has not favored you in the international press. In the French press, perhaps, but in the...

President .- There has been a mix.

F. Jiménez Losantos .- Yes. Certainly, in the American press, there have been those who have attacked you more and those who have attacked you less. And, certainly, important partners. It seems that the United States is a country of some importance, right?

President .- Yes, of course, extremely important, with which my Government will certainly have the best possible relationship, because we are natural allies and belong to the international community of free nations. That does not prevent us from disagreeing on a specific policy, and I believe that coherence obliges me to express what is my profound disagreement with the military intervention in Iraq, which, by the way, a little over a year later, I believe the balance supports more the theses of those of us who thought it was a mistake than those who defended that military intervention.

There is no more terrorism, there is less terrorism. There were no weapons of mass destruction. The regime of Saddam Hussein ended, but violence and rejection have increased against the forces that are there, and even, from an economic point of view, with the latest data on oil, it does not seem that things have borne fruit. And let’s not even talk about all the promises made regarding the situation between Israel and Palestine, which was another of the things that accompanied: "we are going to bring order to the Middle East, we are going to bring order to the Gulf region to give that a prospect of tranquility."

F. Jiménez Losantos .- I don't want to, let's say, make a monograph on this, because, besides, the experience, especially with Pedro J., is devastating; I mean, we can spend two hours and not get anywhere. But there is one issue that inevitably has to be raised, even in the case that it was a mistake: if all countries did like Spain and ran away from Iraq, do you think that would favor the stability of the area, improve the prospects for peace in the Middle East, and also improve the situation in the fight against Islamic terrorism? If the United States did the same as us or the British, do you think that would be good?

President .- There are many countries that did not go to Iraq, many Western democracies that did not participate militarily in Iraq, because they believed that that path and that option to pressure the regime of Saddam Hussein were not correct, because there was an expectation of being able to continue with the task of inspectors to verify whether or not there were weapons of mass destruction or links with terrorism, about which, certainly, no one has been able to put the conclusive data on the table.

If every time the International Community decides to carry out a military intervention against a dictatorial regime, undoubtedly odious, like that of Saddam Hussein, we will have to rethink the system of international legality, the system of the United Nations, because that is not in the San Francisco Charter. There is no authorization to do such things.

That is why I believed it was a wrong path, and normally, things that start badly tend to end badly.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- There is everything.

President.- Normally, that is the experience. And I will add: the United States and the government of Mr. Bush are the ones who have to make decisions about the situation in Iraq. Of course, Spain, as a member of the Security Council, will support anything that may be reasonable on the path to democratization, on the path to the return of sovereignty; but I believe we have the legitimate right, in accordance with the majority desire of the Spanish citizens, not to have military participation in the situation in Iraq.

And I would ask, and I have said this publicly on some occasions, what foreign policy or what international order is that which is not understood by the peoples in such an evident way, because...

F. Jiménez Losantos.- I would respond: for example, Churchill's in 1938.

President.- ...here in Spain, 80 percent of the population has nothing to do with it.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Yes, it has to do with it. People are afraid.

President.- That is tantamount to comparing Saddam Hussein with Hitler, and, really, intellectually and in historical terms, it is very debatable. Let's leave it there, because I want to stay in this endearing tone we have today; but, please, Saddam Hussein did not represent, nor did he represent, the threat to the world that the Hitler regime did. That is evident and notorious.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Hitler certainly scared the English more than Saddam Hussein, but well...

President.- This consideration I mentioned is important, that it is very difficult to carry out a foreign policy, security, and an international order if you do not have the support of the citizens.

Look, when there were massive demonstrations around the world against a military intervention in Iraq, against a regime like that of Saddam Hussein, my reflection was that people sensed—and people usually have a great intuition about where things are going—that this was going to be a wrong path; otherwise, it is not explained that there was such a massive response.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- The last question, apart from the assessment of why we went to war, what has been done, the situation that exists, and so on, which is of course debatable and we will not agree on... Pedro and I have not agreed, so it will be difficult for you and me to agree. You and Pedro, yes, I think you are too much in agreement.

President.- Does that worry you?

F. Jiménez Losantos.- It worries me for the newspaper sales. But there is one issue. In many media, it has been interpreted that the change in Spanish policy, that is, relying on Paris—not that I will say supporting Paris, but relying on Paris—instead of Washington, opting for a return, let’s say, to a situation of privileged relations with France instead of the Atlantic link, opting for the Franco-German axis instead of that alliance of Great Britain, Portugal, Spain, and Italy, which had somehow been designed in recent years; it is a success, of course, of Chirac and Mohamed VI, but also of the terrorists.

That interpretative psychological element, probably unfair, but which in any case you know will be made, how are you going to combat it? That is to say, accepting that we are already facing a series of accomplished facts? I believe it would have been correct to wait a month more, which was not so much, but these are the things, there they are. Now, the idea that Spain is weak against terrorism is the worst. For us, it is the worst and for terrorism, the best. How are you going to combat that idea of weakness, that we have been hit by a bomb, we have changed government, and we have changed position?

President.- No, it is precisely the opposite. I believe that no government or political project should be affected by a terrorist attack. I had a commitment to the Spanish citizens regarding the troops, regarding our foreign policy, regarding Iraq, before March 11, and what would have been to change and, therefore, yield, modify a policy, would have been if it had changed as a consequence of the brutal terrorist act of March 11. The reflection, simply, I believe is the opposite.

I will touch a bit on Paris and Washington. Spain has, as a great priority, as a great state strategy, since the democratic transition, its European vocation. Is it normal that with those countries with which we have built nothing less than the Economic and Monetary Union; with those countries with which we share currency, which is the most substantial change that has occurred in a historical project of union of countries, like the euro; with those countries with which we are going to share, I hope in a short time, a common defense system as will be the European Union, we do not have the best possible relationship, regardless of who governs in Paris, Berlin, or any of the European capitals? Without a doubt, it is our great option.

It would be absurd for Spain not to have a very good relationship with the main European countries, and I will say more: those countries, especially Germany and France, were determining countries in supporting our democratic transition and have been determining countries for our development, for our progress, and for our well-being, because in recent years, as a consequence of the cohesion policy of the European Union, they have been contributing 1 percent of our Gross Domestic Product to build roads, to build dams, to build schools, and to carry out training policies for workers. One percent of our Gross Domestic Product comes from European funds; that is, money from the French, especially Germans, and Belgians, because Europe is a project of cohesion and solidarity as we are now going to have to do with the ten Eastern countries.

From here, I proclaim the gratitude that I sincerely believe Spanish society should have towards all the countries of the European Union, which have helped so much to democracy and the economic well-being of Spain, as today I want all of Europe to help democracy and the economic development of the ten countries of the enlargement. This is perfectly compatible with having good relations with the United States, with which we have an alliance and with which, logically, the transatlantic link is important; but, forgive me, first, Europe, the vision of the world from Europe; then, our historical links with Latin America and the Mediterranean, and then, the Atlantic link. I also believe that this is the majority position of the Spanish people.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- I cannot disagree with you more, but... By the way, do you have shares in the stock market?

President.- No.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Why? Do you not trust the market? Or do you invest your money in real estate?

President.- I have a small pension plan.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Is your house paid off?

President.- No, I still have a mortgage.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Ah! So, you invest in real estate?

President.- Of course, but it is my first and only home.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- How is it the first? And that shack you have now rented out?

President.- First, no, because I had one in León and I sold it. I mean, it is the home that I dedicate solely not as an investment, but as... Now I am in another home that is, obviously, owned by the State, which is La Moncloa.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Which has ghosts.

President.- Really? It seems to me that it is an enormously pleasant place to be.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Do you think? Is it not already haunted?

President.- At least, my experience is that it is a more than dignified home, a very good home, which has a pleasant environment, with gardens and trees, and it is a privilege to live there.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- This, Mr. José Luis, as you are the first President to say it, I have to recover, because everyone has always complained about La Moncloa, from Adolfo Suárez to you.

President.- It is a privilege, and I am willing to invite a group of randomly chosen Spaniards to see it.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Will you not reopen the "bodeguilla"?

President.- No. It is quite abandoned, by the way. I was looking at it on Sunday and...

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Fortunately, because you have seen how horrible it was, right?

President.- Well... Yes, it is a space. We must respect everyone's tastes. I also respect the tastes of the things that Aznar did there, and I think what he did is fine.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- So, the upholstery.

President.- No. There was a paddle court, I believe.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Ah! Pedro, take note.

After this debate, we could say, regarding the troops, Iraq, and our foreign policy, issues on which fortunately we have not reached any agreement, however, the discussion continues, which is the good thing. Let's talk a bit about the economy.

Throughout the electoral campaign— a little before, but especially during the electoral campaign—when the star of Miguel Sebastián was shining, there was talk of changing the economic growth model of the Popular Party which, in terms of employment, has been the best since the Cortes of Cádiz: 50 percent more jobs than those Aznar found when he arrived. The word, I don’t know if magical but in any case that was used a lot, was "productivity."

How can a productive model that has created five million legal jobs, plus whatever there is in the underground economy, which there must be something, that has functioned in such a spectacular way breaking that kind of vicious circle; how can it be changed by decree, as Alberto Recarte said yesterday in a comment? It is a bit difficult to change the economic model that, in some way, responds to the choices of millions and millions of people who put their money into a mortgage, do not put it in the stock market, or did before and do not now. Is there not a kind of absurd dirigiste fantasy there? Would it not be more reasonable to preserve the substantial aspects of the economic model of the PP, which has worked so well, not in all aspects, but certainly in job creation?

President.- What we want is to improve the foundations of our economic growth, and improving those foundations means that this country has to gain competitiveness in the international economic context, and for that, we need to improve the productivity of the Spanish economy. Therefore, in the coming days, I intend to meet with the representative of the employers and the representatives of the unions to initiate a dialogue that concludes in a great agreement for competitiveness and stable employment in our country.

Can Spain improve its economic foundations from the point of view of competitiveness? Yes. What do we need for that? To improve in technological capital and improve in what is called human capital, that is, in the training of our entire population. That is the improvement we want to talk about. Is that a change of orientation? I don’t care what we call it. Of course, we believe that job creation in these years has been important; it is no less true that there is a lot of what is called "precarious" employment, which we have to address, that things can be done, and that our companies deserve and can gain competitiveness if we make a significant injection of investment effort, both in the public and private sectors, of technological capital, of Research, Development, and Innovation.

This is what we want to discuss with the unions and with the employers, and reach an agreement, as there were other agreements in the past that also bore fruit for a time.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Regarding innovation, there is enormous concern in business circles, to put it mildly—I will not say a Moorish anger, because it could be interpreted differently—because there were 2 billion euros in Industry, precisely for innovation in leading companies, and that has been transferred to Education for the rectors to distribute. Of course, the businessmen think that they would have done it better and that it was the money that was there and who knows...

President.- In what there seems to be a general consensus is that the Ministry of Science and Technology designed by the previous government was a failure.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- I will concede that.

President.- We have changed the model, and part of the previous Ministry of Science and Technology has returned to Education, because we understand that there must be a greater linkage of basic research with applied research, and part of what was the Ministry of Science and Technology has remained in Industry. In any case, both ministries have to work together.

The great challenge of our process of applying basic research is a much more powerful interaction between the University and the company, which is what has not been achieved in recent years and is the challenge that both ministries have. Of course, there was a deep discontent in the University, there was a deep discontent in basic research, and it has now regained a space in researchers of all colors, rectors of all profiles...

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Almost all are from the same one, eh!, Mr. José Luis. Let’s not deceive ourselves.

President.- Yes. But I believe that the Popular Party contributed a lot to that...

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Without a doubt. It is sheer naivety!

President.- ...because it implemented an electoral system that clearly benefited --we saw it coming but, of course, that’s why it didn’t seem bad to us-- progressive candidacies.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- But that doesn’t usually coincide much with the attempt to collaborate with industry; rather, progressivism in the University is...

President.- There are good examples and appropriate paths, which are some very good technology parks that have been created in recent times in our country, which are a reference, and that has to be the ground. Certainly, the University and business have to deepen their work every day.

In the next State Budget, the allocations related to R&D+i will have a substantial increase. We have committed around 20-25 percent, and Spain needs to be a country much more focused on science, to support its public researchers much more and those in the private sector. I believe that is what makes the most powerful economies in the world today stronger and more capable of maintaining growth and creating jobs. We are not going to compete with low wages, we are not going to compete, there are many countries...

F. Jiménez Losantos.- What do you mean we are not? How can we not compete?

President.- No, we are not going to compete.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- That was one of the elements of competition we have. Lower than France, for example.

President.- No. Today, the competition for industrial location is no longer based on low wages; it is based on the education of the population, on the educational system, and it is based on the technological capacity of a country. That is what is decisive.

The countries that show the highest influx of investments are those that have better technological capital and better human capital. And now we have a challenge of great importance, because the ten countries of the enlargement have a very high level of education in their population; they have well-trained human capital...

F. Jiménez Losantos.- And they have very low wages.

President.- And also. I’m not saying it doesn’t influence, but it is not the determining factor. If our country advances in the educational system, in the improvement of education, and in strengthening technological capital, it will have many more chances of being economically strong.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- The economic structure of any country, and especially for the actions of any Government, depends on the fiscal model. At this moment, there is the model we have known in recent years, which, despite the two tax cuts --as limited as they may be, but two cuts-- has increased revenue, it has been quite streamlined. Earlier, we gave good news, which is probably the first good economic news of your Government, which is that the change of Government has not been felt. I mean in the matter of Treasury, and in Treasury, the results of the last month are good.

President.- There are those who think that the economy is going to improve, even.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- It’s possible; I’m not saying it’s not. I would love it.

President.- I think it is good to highlight that the business sector, the companies in this country, welcomed this Government in a frankly positive way.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- But don’t pay attention. Solchaga, who ruined everyone, was also applauded. So, don’t trust Cuevas and company.

But there is a question --I was saying-- of substance, which is regional financing. These days we have had statements for all tastes: with Mr. Sevilla, who I don’t know if in the end he won the battle against Miguel Sebastián or if they both lost to Solbes --that you will know in your heart--... But we have heard and read that there will be no change in regional financing, that the famous seventeen Tax Agencies will not be established, as a possibility, and that yes, that it was not until the next legislature and that it will be in this one. Sevilla has gone so far as to say, with just a few hours apart --it is true that in Barcelona and in Madrid; they are different and distant cities-- two different things.

For you, who undoubtedly has more authority than Jordi Sevilla, what is going to happen with that regime? Is the model of regional financing, the seventeen Tax Agencies, for now, for this legislature, or for the next?

President.- At this moment, public spending --it is important to know a very important fact-- is distributed in our country as follows: approximately, 56 percent corresponds to State spending, plus Social Security, and around 44-45 percent is the spending of Autonomous Communities and Local Corporations, basically Autonomous Communities, as a result of the enormous process of transferring basic public services.

Where is, from my point of view, the problem we have as a major debate for the coming years that affects the model of regional financing, because it affects a basic public service managed by the Autonomous Communities? It is in Health.

Fifteen or twenty years ago we believed that the financing problem of the Welfare State would be situated in public pensions, in the Social Security protection system, and fortunately, time has disproved some of those theses. But where we have a financing problem, which affects all Autonomous Communities, and some in a very particular way, such as Catalonia and Madrid, which have very notable deficits in public health --you just have to take a look around the hospitals or see what the citizens say-- is in health.

Therefore, my first major objective regarding what could be a debate around a new model of regional financing, which in any case, one, needs a calm debate, great consensus; the goal is that the Autonomous Communities have financial sufficiency and, of course, the maintenance of the principle of cohesion and solidarity.

But I am understanding, and I believe we all have to be, in light of the financing problems that some Communities have, especially regarding Health. That is where we want to start working, beyond the Tax Agencies, which for me is a minor issue, because I believe that this formed an excessive debate at the beginning. The Tax Agency is nothing more than an organizational model of what the Administration represents, in tax matters, that the Autonomous Communities have; it is an organizational model. Is it convenient to better define the areas of management, collection, and inspection that the State and Autonomous Communities have? I believe so, and it is also good that the fiscal spaces are well defined so that citizens know which fiscal space corresponds to each one.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Who collects and who spends.

President.- Exactly. And then, in practice, there has to be a mixed tax administration. Why? Because there is a part of the taxes that the Autonomous Communities collect and that, therefore, they have formative power over; there are others that are ceded; and they have to inspect, and the inspection, if done jointly, in a consortial or mixed manner, will work much better.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- But, Mr. José Luis, there is a problem here. Everyone interprets politically that Catalonia weighs a lot and, above all, weighs a lot in this Government; because of Maragall and the allies of Maragall, who are also yours. The model that Catalan nationalism, both Esquerra and PSC, painted, was more about paying by income and receiving by population, and we understood that you initially embraced that model. That for my home Community, Aragón, and also for a good part of yours, which is Castilla y León, is lethal, because there is a large city, in the case of Aragón, Zaragoza, that contributes a lot, and in the case of Castilla y León, some cities, the case of Valladolid, the case of Burgos, León, etc., that pay a lot but the population is very scarce and, therefore, we are going to pay and not collect, which means we are making a loaf like some cakes. That socialists come to give more to those who have the most, although liberals have always suspected it, you will recognize is a bit disheartening.

President.- I believe there is some conceptual error in the debate. The first thing we should keep in mind is that the State of Autonomies, if it has been anything, is solidarity. The evolution of the regions, of the Autonomous Communities, in the last twenty-five years, with slight exceptions, what has it shown? It has shown that the less developed regions have been approaching in income and Gross Domestic Product to the more developed regions; that is, the gap has been closing.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- But because we have all risen.

President.- No, no. In relative terms.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- It’s not that some... Except for the Basque Country, which has decreased.

President.- Obviously, I am speaking in relative terms. But regarding the distance that existed between Extremadura and Catalonia thirty years ago, it is today less than it was thirty years ago.

Therefore, the State of Autonomies has been solidary, it has especially benefited those territories that started from a worse situation, from the point of view of their wealth and development. This represents something very important, which is that citizens must know that autonomy has been equal to solidarity, that the regime where there were more regional differences in income, in product, and in development was the centralist and authoritarian regime we had with General Franco, because there was authoritarianism and centralism.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- There was also economic development that we had never had in our lives. I mean, here to each their own. That has nothing to do with it.

President.- Well. I know that there may be attachments to certain things, but I want to tell you...

F. Jiménez Losantos.- No, no; attachments to the truth. Or do you deny that in the 1960s Spain did not grow more than it had grown in fifty years?

President.- Yes, but I am not talking about development; I am talking about the development of one region versus another. I think it is understood. That is to say, autonomy has walked at the same time as solidarity. Those who have had, let’s say, in relative terms, the greatest benefit have been Extremadura, Andalucía, Castilla-La Mancha, and Castilla y León, which have gained ground in their approach to the national average, and, however, other Autonomous Communities have not followed that pace of those that were historically more developed. Why? Because there are very powerful instruments of cohesion and solidarity in the State of Autonomies.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- But is it for this year or for the next legislature?

President.- For this legislature. The debate is going to take place in this legislature, without a doubt.

I insist: essential concern, financing of Health, because it is where the Government warns that the Autonomous Communities, some of them, and in general the system, are going to have to make a singular effort; second, maintenance of the principle of cohesion and, third, let’s not forget, which is an important part that sometimes does not appear in the debate, that beyond the financing model that tries above all to guarantee the financial sufficiency of the services provided in Education, in Health, each Autonomous Community, the State then has a significant part of investment that is normally a part that also makes a greater effort of solidarity. Why? Because that part is very significant in Autonomous Communities that have a lower degree of development.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- One of the elements of solidarity that people saw embodied as a national project was the National Hydrological Plan. It was a model, let’s say, of how to distribute something that is scarce, that is valuable, and that is common to all Spaniards, such as water. You announced the halt of the Ebro transfer, and the other day Minister Narbona surprised us by asking the European Union to give us the money that the European Union had already budgeted for the Ebro transfer when we are no longer going to do the transfer. I confess my perplexity. But what are you going to do, what is your Government going to do, with the National Hydrological Plan?

President.- Fulfill the electoral commitments.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Which ones, because in some regions they have said one thing and in others, another?

President.- You can read the electoral program perfectly and what I have expressed on more than one occasion. The Socialist Party never supported that great transfer of the Ebro. I don’t know if it is a solidary policy; what I do know is that it is an old and expensive policy in management and in the conception of water. What we have no doubt about is that the financing for hydraulic infrastructure works and for the capture and generation of water, such as all the processes that are increasingly advanced in desalinating water, will be financed by the European Union.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- If it’s not even more expensive.

President.- No, no; it is cheaper, because no one has said what a gigantic transfer would cost each farmer in investment, with a very high energy cost, because several elevations would have to be made for it to reach the lands of Almería, Valencia, and Alicante over a course of hundreds of kilometers.

We are going to undertake infrastructure works, desalination plants, with funding from the European Union, which will, of course, finance this model with much more interest than that large transfer process from the Ebro, because the policy of large transfers is a policy that, from the most advanced environmental perspectives, is not recommended. We must respect the natural course of water as much as possible, we must environmentally protect many spaces, and it is an electoral commitment.

You know that I try to fulfill electoral commitments. We said we were going to halt the Organic Law of Education...

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Yes, by the way, a disaster.

President.- ... and we fulfilled it.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- But that, indeed, you have fulfilled, unfortunately.

President.- We said we were going to implement a new water policy, and we are going to implement a new water policy. We said there would be an independent Director of Radio Televisión Española, and there is an independent Director of Radio Televisión Española. We said there would be an independent Attorney General, and there is an Attorney General... At least, he has an initial endorsement.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- And we will see it, just like Cafarell. We will see it.

President.- The Attorney General has an initial endorsement, having participated in a certain judicial resolution that was certainly not very favorable to some very important leader of the Socialist Party. And we are going to make public television plural and independent in the terms that the Reform Council, the Council of Wise Men, sets, which will be adopted by the Government and transformed into a bill. We are going to fulfill our commitments.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- One question, Mr. José Luis. Apart from the fact that there may be a majority, for example in Valencia, Murcia, and Almería, that expresses to you that the transfer was the best, which will raise, as always, the issue that governing is choosing and choosing is inevitably pleasing some and displeasing others; but let’s not get ahead of ourselves. I think it’s very good that you maintain that issue.

However, regarding competitiveness, I am surprised by some statements from Minister Montilla, who I don’t know if he understands competitiveness differently than the common person. He says that large stores open a lot on Sundays and that he is going to open less. This will undoubtedly seem great to the existing large stores, always with the excuse of small commerce, but who defends us consumers? Is this improving productivity, closing more holiday days?

President.- This is an eternal and passionate debate between liberal economists and less liberal ones.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- The less liberal one is Montilla, right?

President.- Perhaps. But I believe that, fundamentally, the Autonomous Communities have a significant volume of competencies when it comes to regulation. We need to reach a balance. Of course, the perspective of the consumer, productivity, and economic freedom should prevail; but we also need to consider what small commerce is. Can there be a balance? I believe there can be a reasonable balance. Obviously, the lifestyles in large cities are not the same as those in small and medium-sized cities in terms of consumption habits, for countless reasons...

F. Jiménez Losantos.- In the towns, it is always open.

President.- Evidently. The Autonomous Communities are not the same as each other, and we need to have a peaceful perspective on this, that it is perfectly possible to harmonize the interests of both sectors, and, above all, the interest of the consumer.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Oh, Mr. José Luis, I don’t understand how the supermarket can be open and closed on the weekend; it is either open or closed. That is, can the lady who works five days a week go on Saturday and Sunday or not? It is either closed or open.

President.- But it is not the same for that to happen in a large urban area, like Madrid, than in Teruel.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Tell that to the lady, whether she is from Móstoles or Teruel. The problem is the same.

President.- It is not the same, one; and two, today we have a system whereby there are a number of holiday days when it is open. That can be analyzed, it can be expanded or reduced...

F. Jiménez Losantos.- If what Montilla wants is to reduce.

President.- That’s why it can be expanded or reduced. Obviously, the perspective that should prevail is that of the consumer, but I also believe that small commerce has its voice and a sensitivity that the Government must attend to. I sincerely believe that large stores can be in a comprehending attitude, especially...

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Well, those that are already established..., wonderfully.

President.- Yes, but, look, those that have been established in these years, in which there has been a liberal government...

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Well... Not to exaggerate.

President.- I say it with ellipses.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Quite liberal.

President.- What has happened is a great concentration in the distribution sector and in the large stores sector, spectacular.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- True. Hence, we ask for more openness.

President.- It would be good to review how few hands control fifty-something percent of distribution in this country, because I make you a challenge from here: when this legislature ends, you will see that in this country there is more economic freedom than we found in important, strategic sectors, like the ones we have all been debating: energy...

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Also in telecommunications?

President.- Telecommunications, of course; distribution...

F. Jiménez Losantos.- And in media?

President.- ...and in media.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- You leave me almost like on the eve of Christmas. I no longer believe in the Three Kings, but if I were to believe in something, I would almost believe in Rodríguez Zapatero.

President.- I advise you to do so. Sincerely, I advise you.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- We are receiving many questions from our listeners. I will pose one briefly, because there are many, and I also think you are in good form today.

By the way, do you know that Ronaldinho might not continue at Barça?

President.- I heard the rumor this morning, and it did not excite me. I think he is a great player, and everyone knows I am a Barça fan. My loyalty to Barça costs me some displeasure, but...

F. Jiménez Losantos.- But in the tripartite, it won’t have done you any harm, because there, if you are not a Barça fan, you don’t get placed.

President.- But yes, because many people tell me: "don’t say you are a Barça fan because there are many people...". It is true that I received a letter one day from a citizen, he was older, judging by the handwriting, very old, and he told me: "I have always been a socialist voter all my life, but if you say again that you are a Barça fan, I will think about it." This was a year before, and it worried me a bit; I showed it to Rubalcaba...

F. Jiménez Losantos.- And then he said: "this is my grandfather, who is deceiving you."

President.- The letter had absolute authenticity and sincerity.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Yes, heartbreaking.

President.- Not heartbreaking, but well... I think one of the things that is very good in public life and in political life is that people are sincere. Everyone knows I am a Barça fan.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- You did not orchestrate the crisis of Madrid.

President.- No, no.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- But it is a coincidence that it has coincided.

President.- There is a temporal coincidence that I remember, and it is that Madrid started losing matches after I saw Butragueño in a photo with Rajoy. But I don’t want to attribute bad luck to Rajoy...

F. Jiménez Losantos.- No, to Rajoy, no; in any case, to Butragueño.

President.- ...or any of these things. I have told Florentino this on some occasions.

It is a joke, obviously. It is a matter of coincidence.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Things that make people less happy. Many people understand that from the beginning the Socialist Party has expressed a kind of, let’s say, if not animosity, at least little sympathy for everything related to the Church, concerted education centers, the subject of Religion, and it is even raised, because there have been rumors about it or unofficial statements, about a revision of the Church-State or Vatican-Spain agreements, if you will, from another point of view. If this question is not asked on COPE, it will not be asked anywhere.

President.- Evidently. But let’s distinguish the areas. I am going to make a declaration of principles. My Government has the interest, and it will be so, to have a very good relationship with the Episcopal Conference and, of course, with the Vatican. I believe it is something that has been part of the entire democratic process, that there is an implicit constitutional mandate to have that special relationship, and therefore, the agreements...

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Implicit and explicit.

President.- Explicit. To have that singular relationship with the Catholic Church...

I want to remind you that it was a socialist government that initiated the entire process in concerted education to guarantee the freedom of the right to education by parents; I want to remind you that for many years we have had a reasonable system for the practice of the right to receive religious education, which is a quite reasonable system, and that is that the public system, independently of the private one, guarantees that children study Religion. Of course, I am going to guarantee from the Government that this happens and that parents who want their children to study Religion in the public sphere will have it guaranteed.

But the previous Government in the last phase introduced a change that broke, let’s say, I believe, a status of normality that we had had for many years, which is that Religion was also an evaluable subject. We do not agree on that and we want to change it. We want to return to the normal situation of fifteen years of democracy. Furthermore, I want to discuss it, of course, with the Episcopal Conference, just as I have explained in Parliament, and we are going to carry it in the reform and in the application of the Organic Law of Education.

As for the rest, I believe we will have a good relationship, I am convinced.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Mr. José Luis, I do not doubt your will, yours; but, however, 75 percent of parents last year requested Catholic religious education. It is much higher, even, than the current support for the withdrawal of troops from Iraq. Perhaps that should lead you to review...

President.- I do not want to enter into discussions, but it seems to me that, to this day, support for the withdrawal of troops exceeds 75 percent.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- It doesn’t matter. I’ll leave it at half and half; neither for you nor for me.

President.- But that right will be guaranteed.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- But I mean that there is a much greater backing than what the Government apparently has.

President.- Well. We have not questioned that. Furthermore, my daughters study Religion in a public school. I have freely decided that they study Religion in a public school, but that has nothing to do with whether that subject is evaluable and counts for a person to become an architect, after passing through the entire educational process of Primary, Secondary, and Baccalaureate. I believe that is the point of reasonable balance.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- In any case, you are the President of the Government and, of course, you do what you believe you have to do. I am not going to give you lessons; I pose that question.

President.- It is my electoral commitment. I think there is something that is very important in democracy, and that is, contrary to what that old saying attributed to Enrique Tierno says, I believe it is very important that governments fulfill electoral promises. In this is the PHN, the reform of the LOCE, the troops, the policy of democratic renewal, which to a large extent this act we celebrate today, in this interesting interview, is part of...

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Although you did not say we celebrate. You would get into trouble.

President.- I was about to. All of these are political commitments that the citizenry must verify are fulfilled.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- And housing? Because how many houses were going to be built? 180,000?

President.- They are going to be built. And I want to clarify one thing from here: first, it is very important that the construction sector continues with the dynamism it has; it is very important for the economy, it has been one of the bases of our growth. But it is also very important that many families, many young people, many families with lower incomes, can access housing, and with the prices that housing has today, they will not be able to access it. I do not think we will take more than fifteen days to approve the shock plan regarding access to housing, and it will be a plan for concertation with Autonomous Communities, with Town Halls, but also with the private construction sector.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- You will easily concert that one, because there are things that are easier than others. Another thing is to lower prices when demand continues to exceed supply.

President.- If there is good management of public land, of course it is possible to create affordable housing. In fact, there are municipalities here, near Madrid, such as Fuenlabrada and Alcobendas, where there has been a concerted promotion between the private sector and what a City Council represents, providing public land facilities, with very affordable housing prices.

But, in addition to that, we want, above all, to promote rental housing. This is a country that has very little rental housing, has a lot of empty apartments, and for that we are going to create a public rental agency that will legally guarantee...

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Another bureaucracy.

President.- No, it is an agency with very few people. We will see the data in the end, but a socialist government—I have always proclaimed myself a socialist—will surely have a smaller organizational structure than the so-called liberal government that was the Popular Party, and we will surely have lower current spending, as will be seen in the next budget exercise, than the current spending that the Popular Party had.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- If you achieve that, I will be the first to applaud you.

President.- For example, it will be very striking in the reduction, which is current spending, in everything that means the budget for advertising, propaganda, and campaigns that the Popular Party government had. When the figures are provided, it will be particularly striking in some ministries, such as the Ministry of Labor and Social Security.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- We are running out of time for the interview, and there is one last question I would like to ask you, going back to the beginning regarding the sensitivity of a substantial part of Spanish public opinion, which, moreover, if you want to last in government, you will have to rely on in one way or another because, if you do not win over a part, let’s say, of that sensitivity, of those ten million votes from the right, it is difficult, first, to have stable agreements with the first and practically only opposition party, and, in addition, for you to be able to expand your electoral base and not have this majority a bit, I won’t say meager, because a majority is good, but...

President.- Many meager majorities like the one that is currently in the Socialist Party would be welcome. I say this sincerely.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Do you think that the "bitter victory" is better than the "sweet defeat"?

President.- I want to provide a piece of information that is sometimes forgotten. The Socialist Party obtained 42.6 percent of the votes in 2004; Felipe González, in 1989, had 175 deputies, an absolute majority, with 39 percent. This is one of the best results the Socialist Party has achieved in its history.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- And the second best for the Popular Party, we should not forget that either. I mean, everyone has improved here.

President.- Evidently. With the percentage of votes we have had, we have not had a number of seats... The distribution with the D'Hondt Law has not favored us. That is evident.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Yes, but that’s what I’m getting at. The two nationally established forces have enormous weight, 90 percent of the vote. However, the feeling is that you are more willing to dialogue and engage amicably with Esquerra or with the communists than with the PP, and many people find it impossible to maintain national criteria, really national policy, relying on groups that are not national, that are openly separatist, and not on the other great national party.

After June 13, because before the elections it would be an excessive miracle for politicians not to seek votes, do you think you can redirect those currently nonexistent relations with Rajoy between those two parties that are the two wheels on which Spain can function? If one is punctured or taken out, it doesn’t roll, it’s over.

President.- The wheel on which Spain functions is fundamentally the citizens and Spanish society, which normally gives lessons to politicians and parties, as represented by the lesson around March 11, and today, by the way, we mark two months since that tragic attack. Facts are worth more than words, and in politics and in serious matters such as anti-terrorism policy, behaviors and trajectories matter much more than temporary disagreements.

I have been the leader of the opposition for nearly four years. I proposed the Anti-Terrorism Pact and for Freedoms. I had no obligation to do so; I did it to help the government and from a state vision that, united, the PP and PSOE would end terrorism sooner, which was essential. I proposed it, there was even some initial irony, and now this Pact is blessed, praised, and cherished by the Popular Party. I will tell you: I am glad that it is so.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Yes, but you govern with those from Perpignan.

President.- One moment, let me finish my reflection. I am glad that it is so because the Pact will continue; I will commit to the Pact as the previous President of the Government did not, and I will attend the Pact tomorrow. Never did Mr. Aznar attend a meeting of the Anti-Terrorism Pact, and I will do so as a symbol of my direct and personal commitment to that Pact, before Mr. Rajoy and the Popular Party.

In the development of that Pact and in anti-terrorism policy, I have had an attitude of commitment to the government; I have to say it like this, because commitment to the government is, as I did, providing support for the Law of Parties with a phone call, providing support for the illegalization of Batasuna with a phone call, which the previous President of the Government did not do, and I was not even sometimes put through when I called him on the phone. That will not happen again while I am President of the Government.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- You see what happens with the ghosts of Moncloa.

President.- That is why we must learn from the mistakes of others to avoid making them because, of course, to Mr. Rajoy, whenever he calls me on the phone, and to any political leader, I will respond out of respect for what they represent. And I will go to the Pact tomorrow, I will defend the Pact, I will maintain the Pact, I will provide all the information to the Popular Party, and all measures to strengthen the fight against terrorism will be shared with the Popular Party. It is my commitment; you will be able to verify it in these years, and in addition to that, I also want to provide information and listen to all political groups in anti-terrorism policy. There is a before and after March 11, unfortunately for our country, because international terrorism emerged brutally and...

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Why don’t you call it Islamic, by the way? It’s not Buddhist; it’s not Catholic either. Why do you call it international?

President.- Just as I do not like to call ETA terrorism Basque terrorism, for exactly the same reason: out of respect for Islam, because there are millions of people who practice the Islamic religion, who are the vast majority, peaceful, who want democracy and have their religious ideas. Evidently, what is common to the characteristic of this terrorism? That it is international; that it acts, unlike other movements, concertedly in many countries to provoke global effects; or we can call it Al Qaeda terrorism because, in the end, it is all Al Qaeda.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- That is a franchise, yes, but we can...

President.- Just as we talk about ETA terrorism, and not Basque terrorism, which would be horrific, unjust, and I think this is important. Today I also heard an Islamic representative speak and ask that we not talk about Islamic terrorism. I, of course, whenever I talk about terrorism...

F. Jiménez Losantos.- I understand. An Islamist, what is he going to say?

President.- But there are millions of Islamists in the world, I insist, peaceful, who practice their religion, who have their culture, and therefore, with whom we must understand.

And in the anti-terrorism struggle, to return to close the argument, I want to count on the vast majority of political parties. Today marks two months since we experienced the brutal attack of March 11, and what I want to convey to all listeners and all citizens is that the government has three priority objectives: first, to provide all support to the victims, to the families, economically, morally, socially, and affectionately; second, to maintain an implacable struggle to stop and bring to justice all those who committed this barbarity, and in that we are redoubling all efforts of the Police, the Civil Guard, and our intelligence services; and third, that political parties do not argue about the issue of terrorism, unite all political parties in the fight against terrorism.

I believe that the best tribute we can give to the victims, the best tribute we can give to Spanish society, which responded exemplary to March 11, is that political parties have a message of unity and understanding.

I can say that the capacity for dialogue with the Popular Party has not been broken at any time; it remains alive, and I believe that tomorrow's meeting of the Anti-Terrorism Pact will reaffirm that joint will that, as President of the Government, I intend to care for in a very direct and special way, because it is extremely important for this country.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Mr. José Luis, thank you very much. You also know that while you are President, well, of the Government is fine, but while you are President of the Government of Spain, of course, you will have a forum here to explain everything you want, as long as you are willing to explain it, and that in these fundamental issues we may not be the same, but we are loyal to a series of things, two or three, fundamental. We have always been that way, whatever the government, and we will continue to be: nation, Spanish.

President.- Nation. That is a concept that would take us...

F. Jiménez Losantos.- That’s for next time.

President.- ..., it would take us, yes, very far. For example, sovereignty, which I believe is a concept that has changed a lot today...

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Have you convinced Maragall of that yet?

President.- Yes, totally. ...and that it requires a willingness to live in a common project that we call Spain, total and absolute, with a vision, and that what those who govern Spain must do is have the greatest integrative attitude. Demand loyalty from everyone, but have an integrative and understanding attitude towards diversity, which I know is not a term that you are very fond of from what I heard this morning, but well...

In any case, Federico, you know that I will always be willing to share dialogue, debate, and interviews here, at COPE.

F. Jiménez Losantos.- Thank you very much, Mr. President of the Government.

President.- Thank you very much.