Interview with the President of the Government on the program "Protagonistas," from Punto Radio.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

13 February 2005 · Interview on the program "Protagonistas" (Punto Radio)

Context
Zapatero was interviewed on Punto Radio's 'Protagonistas' program on February 13, 2005, discussing the Windsor building fire in Madrid and the upcoming European Constitution referendum.
Main themes
Windsor building fire, emergency response and safety regulations, European Constitution referendum, European unity, citizen participation, skyscraper fire safety standards, Carmel neighborhood crisis, cross-party cooperation, Spanish government leadership
Duration
~92 min
98th percentile
Words
11,064
98th percentile
Sentences
421
97th percentile
Readability
48
56th percentile
Grade
12.8
55th percentile
Syntax
3.17
69th percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
29th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

421 sentences in 176 paragraphs

President .- Good morning and thank you very much for being here.

L. del Olmo .- We must refer, logically, to what is being discussed in Madrid, to what is being discussed all over Spain, that fire at the Windsor building, where you were yesterday, I imagine, and you were just telling me a moment ago, off the record, that it was shocking, that you have never seen anything like it. It looked like scenes from a movie that couldn't be real, right?

President .- Yes, indeed, what has happened is very impressive, how the state of the building has turned out, and also, very admirable the work that so many people did the night before last, in a very difficult situation. The firefighters, Municipal Police, National Police, and SAMUR made a great effort for the safety of everyone and for the good of all, and yesterday I was there expressing my gratitude and support to the mayor and the Community of Madrid. I believe there has been a good response, and it is indicative of a way that I want to carry forward in the work of the Government, without looking at political color. I did it a few days earlier in Catalonia, in the Carmel neighborhood, also with a difficult situation for many citizens, supporting the mayor of Barcelona and supporting the President of the Generalitat. I believe that is how citizens demand that we act.

I hope that normality is restored soon in Madrid. I believe that the technicians of the Madrid City Council will provide a satisfactory response and that citizens will understand that we will surely have a few days of difficulties.

L. del Olmo .- We will talk more about the Carmel neighborhood later, Mr. President; but now, and to finish, because we have many issues that I would like to discuss with you, regarding the Windsor building, do you think that safety regulations for skyscrapers should be changed, given what we have seen?

President .- We must have the highest standards, from the perspective of the competent administrations in the matter, in fire prevention and in emergency situations. It is true that a large city always has more risk elements, but I am convinced that the Madrid City Council will now proceed to review all situations.

We cannot forget that we are talking about buildings that are almost thirty years old and that, therefore, the demands and requirements of that time are lower than what is known today and can be updated. I believe it is necessary to carry out that review, and I am convinced that the local authorities will do so.

L. del Olmo .- Mr. President, I ask you to be brief in your answers, if possible, because, I insist, there are many issues I want to address in this conversation.

Let's go to what the background of this interview is indicating, and I see: Palacio de La Moncloa, European Constitution. According to the latest CIS barometer, and contrary to what was feared, the referendum on the European Constitution will have high citizen participation; if there are no changes, 68.3% of Spaniards will go to vote and, probably, about 5.7% will vote "no." With this data, I imagine you feel calm, at least initially, right?

President .- I hope and wish for high participation. It is an important decision, it is a historic decision. We have made an effort to disseminate the Constitution, we have distributed six million copies, there have been people who have collaborated in spreading the Constitution, like Luis del Olmo, and I want to publicly thank him. It is true that it is a long text and surely many people have not been able to read it in full, but it contains two things above all: an important Charter of Fundamental Rights and Social Rights, which reinforce those we already have as citizens with our Constitution, and how to organize the powers of a stronger political union among twenty-five countries.

Undoubtedly, this project is a very important step forward in the unity of Europe. The unity of Europe has been good for Europeans and, therefore, for Spaniards in all areas: in the economic and social, in the political, in collaboration, and in Europe's position on the problems of the world. Therefore, it is a positive step forward, and I believe we all have the opportunity, because it seems essential to me that citizens express themselves and give their support by voting yes to this step forward.

L. del Olmo .- You say it is a long text, indeed, and unknown to citizens. Indeed, according to surveys, nine out of ten voters do not know the text of the Constitution. It gives me the impression that they say, "I am going to vote, I am going to trust the politicians," because it is a bit like voting blindly, right?

President .- Everyone has a clear idea of what European unity is, of what that effort has been for several decades to overcome the confrontations and the terrible wars we suffered in the last century that resulted in 65 million deaths on European soil. Everyone knows that since there has been a European Union, European unity, there have been no wars or dictatorships on European soil. All countries that integrate into the European Union consolidate their democracy, their economic progress, and, moreover, have a great relationship with each other. That is the European relationship, and now, with the Constitution, we strengthen the European idea by becoming a more united political organization and taking a step forward.

It is true that knowing the specific articles is not easy, as it would require citizens, and I believe it is not reasonable to expect citizens, to know 400 articles on how the structures of the European Union are organized; but the idea, the objectives, the principles, the values, the balance, and what can be achieved on that path, with this step forward, I believe is perceived by the vast majority of citizens.

L. del Olmo .- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, I know you have a rally in Extremadura this afternoon. Just as we saw you in Barcelona with Chirac, why can't we see you together with Rajoy asking for a "yes" on the Constitution? Of course, after the onslaught you launched at him in Barcelona saying that Chirac's center-right is indeed a center-right and not what we have here, it has angered, and you know it, and it has upset Mr. Rajoy. Why did you launch that attack? Because it seems to me that you are like me: when your mouth gets heated, you let out what you have inside without knowing the consequences.

President .- No, that is not true. It is not true because I did not speak about Mr. Rajoy at all.

L. del Olmo .- You didn't mention names, but...

President .- I simply said that Mr. Chirac did not seem to be from the center-right, and it is true that he has very advanced positions on European unity, on social policies, on his well-known position in defense of peace, compared to some positions of the right in this country. It is true, history tells us that in this country there has been a part of the right in very integrist, very conservative positions, and it is very easy to contrast that there is a center-right in Europe that has much more advanced positions in many areas. That may explain why we historically arrived late to the entry into the European Union, why we arrived late to have a Constitution, and that, fortunately, Spanish society, the citizenry, has made up for lost time.

L. del Olmo .- Mr. President, you are qualifying what you said the other day, but what you said the other day, I was there in the front row, and it is not what you are saying now. There are many ways to qualify it. You said that Mr. Chirac's center-right was indeed a center-right, not the one we have here. The truth is that Mr. Rajoy is furious. Take this opportunity to apologize to Mr. Rajoy.

President .- I do not have to apologize to Mr. Rajoy, because I did not...

L. del Olmo .- He is the head of the center-right.

President .- ...I did not launch any criticism at him at any time. Throughout the referendum campaign, I have not even referred to him; moreover, twice since we held the first campaign event, I have expressed my gratitude for the position of the Popular Party. If that, as they say, is to help the Government, welcome it. For me, above all, the position of "yes" to this Constitution is to help Spain and the European Union.

From there, we also need to have a little margin of tolerance. We are in an electoral campaign, we are holding rallies, and it is normal that in political debate there is always some spice when addressing citizens, because, evidently, the position of being in favor of the European Constitution in a way, from my part, absolutely clear, and also from the Popular Party, makes it less attractive at times.

L. del Olmo .- Would it be possible, on your part, before the 20th, for a rally between the two of you, between Mr. Rajoy and you, or is that impossible, is it asking for pears from the elm?

President .- It has been possible on my part, because I invited Mr. Rajoy to participate in a joint event, which had a rather institutional character, with President Durao Barroso, and the response was not favorable. I respect that. I interpret that we can be together in what can be the defense of "yes" to the European Constitution; but the Popular Party understands that it is fine to be together but not mixed, and I find that respectable.

L. del Olmo .- Mr. President, and you who do not go to mass precisely, but get along very well with the Church, how do you understand, how do you interpret, that the Church will not vote with the majority? Perhaps to make things difficult for the Government, because the Church certainly does not forgive you for the history of the union of same-sex couples, abortion, secular education...?

President .- I believe that the majority of people who have a Christian faith in our country will freely choose to support a European Constitution that, surprisingly, has had from the very beginning the backing of the Pope, who is a convinced European; that this Constitution respects the essential principle of religious freedom; that this Constitution establishes and enshrines the collaboration and defense of different religious confessions, and that, therefore, it is a Constitution within the parameters of societies where that guarantee of freedom exists, any type of freedom, and also religious freedom.

L. del Olmo .- Mr. President, I will give you one minute to promote the "yes" for the Constitution. Take advantage of it. Give me three reasons in one minute for Spaniards to vote "yes."

President .- The first of these is that the European Constitution, just as the Spanish Constitution of 1978 did, will sit very well for Spain. Spain has benefited from the Constitution, and it has benefited from Europe. Therefore, now we have a European Constitution at the same time, and it will sit well for Spain. Spain is a country that wins when it is in a framework like the European Union, in a framework of economic, political freedoms, and in a framework of social cohesion like that of the European Union.

Secondly, a stronger, more united European Union is a guarantee of peace for the world, because the European Union is governed by those values.

And thirdly, every generation has its Constitution. Now there is a young generation that will be the protagonist of carrying forward the project that the European Constitution represents. That Constitution and that generation, just as in 1978 we gave ourselves a Constitution, will be the protagonists of a Constitution that erases borders, limits, that unites flags into a great flag that is the European flag, while respecting all of them. It is a historic Constitution, because it is the first time in the history of political civilization that a Constitution will be born for four hundred and something million Europeans who have different cultures, who belong to different countries, with different languages, under the idea of unity and cooperation.

L. del Olmo .- Before changing the subject, clarify a doubt for me, Mr. President, regarding the Constitution. A country that enters this Constitution, after a while, if it wishes, can it abandon it?

President .- The Constitution, once ratified by all countries, commits all countries, and there is no provision regarding what could be, at the time of ratification, a contrary position from a country. What there is, logically, is the desire and will of all countries for ratification by the 25 to occur and for Europe to acquire a cruising speed in its construction, because we are all convinced that it is good for each country and, above all, it is good for all citizens.

There is an evident fact: the European Union started in its germ with five countries, today there are twenty-five countries, and there are many countries that want to join the European Union. No one who has entered the European Union has considered leaving, because it has been beneficial, and yet many countries have been entering, and more and more countries want to be in the European Union.

L. del Olmo .- Let's also briefly talk about the Basque Country. What do you think, Mr. President -- it sounds like a threat, doesn't it? -- that Batasuna has made to the PNV and the Spanish Government, and to you very specifically -- that elections in the Basque Country on April 17 will not take place if they do not participate? Specifically, and these are Otegi's words, they ask you to exercise responsibility. What would you respond to Mr. Otegi?

President.- Mr. Otegi must be answered very clearly. There is no room for challenges in the rule of law, there is no room for challenges in democracy. There is a Political Parties Law and there is an authority, which is the Supreme Court, that will decide on the lists, and I am sure it will decide by applying that Political Parties Law. There is no room for challenges to the rule of law. The only challenge that could be made is the challenge to the consciences of those who support, who remain silent, or who support violence.

That is what Mr. Otegi and what we know as Batasuna should do: to have a shred of courage to condemn violence; to say that it is abhorrent to kill anyone for defending a political idea, aware, as the entire Spanish society is, that the rule of law and democracy allow and guarantee the defense of all, all, ideas, as long as it is done democratically, that is, with words, with democratic action, and that, of course, it does not allow in any case, and will apply the full rigor of the law and the rule of law, to defend any idea with violence.

The fate of violence, of the violent, of bombs and pistols is prison, and the political fate of those who do not condemn violence is silence in the institutions and their absence in democratic institutions.

L. del Olmo.- Mr. President, do you confirm that your party rules out a government pact with the PNV after the Basque elections?

President.- I confirm that the Socialist Party is going to the Basque elections to be the alternative to Mr. Ibarretxe's government; an alternative of coexistence, an alternative of progress in self-government, and a positive alternative after the blockade represented by the Ibarretxe Plan and after Mr. Ibarretxe and the Basque Nationalist Party have not convinced what is essential to convince a society, which is to unite it to have a political statute. We are going into this campaign and, logically, as it cannot be otherwise, the Socialist Party is going with the intention of winning those elections.

L. del Olmo.- And with the PP, would you rule out a pact in the event that the sum of both gave an absolute majority in the Basque Country?

President.- The last thing to do when going into an electoral process is to rule out what could be a formula for government. More than a formula for government, what the Socialist Party is going to propose to the Basques is a formula for coexistence in respect for democratic freedoms, in respect and progress in their self-government, and in respect and support for what represents the identity, the strong identity, of the Basque people, which I understand and respect; that this is possible in the plural and democratic Spain that the vast majority of Spaniards want, and that this is not only possible, but also grows with the Constitution and the European Union.

L. del Olmo.- If I may clarify the question, you know that the rest of the Spanish people would welcome the idea that -- I insist on the question -- in those Basque elections the PP would join forces with the Socialist Party of Euskadi and the Socialist Party of Euskadi would unite its forces with the PP to access the government in the event that the votes were sufficient and gave a majority to both.

President.- This is not the time to say with whom we are going to add the votes we need to obtain. This is the time to ask, when the campaign arrives, for votes from the citizens. And I say: it reminds me of something that happened to me directly when it was the electoral campaign for the general elections. I made a solemn commitment that I would govern if I was the most voted party, and I have fulfilled it. I believe that one should never go into an election saying that one will or will not make a pact with any other political force. We are going to make a pact with the citizens from a clear commitment, of course.

The Ibarretxe Plan, if it depends on the Socialist Party, or the ideas that the Ibarretxe Plan has will also be defeated in the Basque Parliament and that semi-sovereign, free association, sovereignist project will not only face our rejection but will also have an alternative for coexistence in Spain and in Europe with that great identity of the Basque people and with that solid and serious progress in self-government.

L. del Olmo.- President Rodríguez Zapatero, you know that in the rumor mills and in the media it is said that something is moving in the government environment, in the environment of ETA, whether there are negotiations or not. I ask you a very specific question: if the conditions were ever met to undertake a negotiation with ETA, would you tell the country?

President.- I will tell you two things regarding this. The first of them, I have reiterated on many occasions, and today I reiterate publicly, that Spanish society and the government are only willing to listen, which is a previous step to what could be dialogue or negotiation, to the violent if they cease radically in violence.

Second point. In democratic history, there have been two negotiation processes with the terrorist group ETA and both led to failure. That experience is in my consideration of all the circumstances that may arise: one was led by the government of Felipe González and the other by the government of Mr. Aznar. At that time, all political forces supported the respective governments that were in place.

At this moment, I simply want to emphasize that without any process, I emphasize, neither of listening, nor of dialoguing, and less of negotiating with the terrorist group ETA that continues to commit attacks as we well know, there are some political forces that generate concern about the government's attitude and that hint at comments that are not, in my opinion, either responsible or serious when it comes to a matter of state such as the fight against terrorism. And I will say something more: in the ten months that this government has been in office, almost ten months -- we are close to 300 days coinciding with this interview -- there have been more than 140 arrests of alleged members of the terrorist group ETA, some of them of people, or terrorists, or alleged terrorists, of great importance in the organization. We can look back, but that is the balance to date.

L. del Olmo.- Mr. President, to conclude with the issue of ETA, because it is a topic that tires the listeners, and I logically understand that it tires the listeners, but sometimes there is no other remedy, I would like to know your opinion regarding the Basque government's decision to send two observers to attend the National Court trial against the youth wing of the ETA group, to ensure that the procedural guarantees of the accused are respected. I put that "to ensure" in quotes because...

President.- I find it inappropriate because the guarantees in our rule of law are absolute in what are the judicial instances and in what is the action of the State Security Forces and Corps to whom we owe so much and to whom I want to congratulate very closely for the fight they are having to detain alleged violent individuals and, surely, save lives. Of course, with my conviction that in this country democracy is defended with the best values, I am radically convinced that we have a rule of law that respects all guarantees and, in the responsibility I have, I would not allow at any time even the slightest slip in what is the defense of guarantees for all, including of course also those who are alleged members of a terrorist group.

L. del Olmo.- Echevarría, President of the Basque Business Circle, has publicly commented that in the debate on the Ibarretxe Plan held in Congress, no one denounced the terrorist blackmail to which businessmen are subjected. Put yourself, if you can put yourself, in the shoes of a Basque businessman, what would you do? On one hand, the ETA members asking you for the safety of your family and your business to cough up the money, and on the other hand, your conscience. What would you do in the shoes of a Basque businessman?

President.- I have had the opportunity to speak with many Basque businessmen about this situation and other issues, and I have conveyed the full support and backing of the government so that they do not yield to blackmail. We are certainly talking about a difficult, complicated situation; but the government can offer maximum support for security and the relentless fight against all those who may make any expression of blackmail. My expression is that they must have confidence in the rule of law and not yield to blackmail.

L. del Olmo.- Yes, but one must put oneself in their shoes. Not yielding to blackmail is always... I imagine you also think "I put myself in the shoes of..." and at first you come up with a "no, they are not going to get a dime"; but, on the other hand, if one thinks about the safety of the business and especially the safety of the family...

President.- It is difficult, yes, but one must trust in the rule of law.

L. del Olmo.- We are talking about the economy, Mr. President. This week the bases for tax reform will be set. Definitely, Mr. Zapatero, will there be cuts in deductions for home purchases, pension plans, and in the Corporate Tax?

President.- There will be a simpler, more simplified taxation, in what is today a complex regulatory framework that does not precisely facilitate some decisions for citizens; there will also be a reduction in what can be tax pressure on labor income; there will be a reorganization of deductions that will not essentially affect housing, which we will maintain; there will be a reorganization in what can be deductions on pension plans and there will be a decrease in the Corporate Tax rate.

Therefore, there will be a tax reform to facilitate better management by citizens of their obligations to the tax authorities, to improve taxation as a whole and, above all, which is what matters most to us, to make it fairer and contribute to economic growth, growth that we have on a fairly positive horizon for 2005 as we closed 2004.

L. del Olmo.- Mr. Solbes seems calm because the SACYR assault has not harmed BBVA. Allow me to ask you a very specific question: are there maneuvers to remove Francisco González from the presidency of Banco Bilbao Vizcaya?

President.- Absolutely not. Neither in BBVA nor in any large company in this country. What I committed to the citizens is that what happened with the previous government, which carried out a genuine process of appointing people of its trust in large companies in the wake of privatizations, would not happen again. This government defends economic freedom, business freedom and has neither in its plans nor in its intentions to remove any of the situations of large companies that, I insist, most of their presidents were sponsored and proposed and appointed due to their closeness to the previous government.

L. del Olmo.- Where your arrival at La Moncloa has been most noticeable... By the way, today marks eleven months since you arrived at La Moncloa.

President.- Ten months. Yes, because the elections were in March, but I arrived in April and we are around February.

L. del Olmo.- I say that the shift imposed in international policy has been noticeable, above all. Do you see in the near horizon an interview -- because you know that the street also asks this question -- of our President with Mr. Bush? Do you see that as close or far away?

President.- One should not have a forecast. It is evident that I will see him on the 22nd at the meeting we have, first, of NATO and then of the European Council. I think we need to have a broader perspective that relations with a friendly country, such as the United States, develop in a context in which we agree on many things and in which we agree on some things. We have disagreed on some important matters.

I referred a moment ago to what these ten months have been and it is true that in these ten months we have done many things. We have resolved some of the pending problems or we are resolving them. The first problem I resolved was to return to Spanish society its will regarding what had been the Iraq war by withdrawing the troops. The Spanish people did not want Spain to be in that war and I returned their will and my commitment.

But we are also resolving other problems such as disordered immigration with a very high number of people working irregularly, and we have launched a process to resolve that problem, to bring order where there was disorder.

We have resolved the problem of the Izar shipyards, which had been accumulating in a very difficult process for six years, with many illegal aids, and after many things that have been said, the future of the shipyards has been guaranteed with the three premises to which I committed: maintenance of the workplaces, agreement with the unions, and that no worker would be left at the mercy of a circumstance that was not one of assistance.

In these ten months, in addition to addressing some pending fundamental issues, we have essentially done two things: extend citizenship rights and social rights. We have extended citizenship rights by better protecting women against gender violence; we have extended citizenship rights by implementing a modern, agile divorce law and recognizing marriage rights for same-sex couples. And we have extended social rights: we have restored the lost purchasing power of those who only receive the Minimum Interprofessional Wage, we have increased minimum pensions by four points above the inflation forecast, and therefore they will gain purchasing power, we have increased scholarships, and we have substantially increased the number of homes that will receive public assistance.

L. del Olmo.- You have reminded me of the positive things in these ten months, but be a little self-critical. What have you failed at? Tell me two things, two black pages, from your Government in these ten months.

President.- Black pages?

L. del Olmo.- Well, black pages... Pages that you have not fulfilled or have not been able to implement.

President.- Regarding the objectives of the Legislature, I believe that the pace and direction of fulfilling the program is on the right track in the central issues in which I committed to change things in this country, and also in maintaining those that were going reasonably well and that my goal is to improve. For example, the economy. I always said it was going reasonably well. Can we improve the economy of this country? Yes, because we need to gain competitiveness by being more productive. That is why we are about to launch, to implement, a plan of liberalizing measures and reforms to gain productivity.

But we have maintained what was reasonable, trying to improve it, we have addressed serious problems such as immigration, and we have extended citizenship rights.

That said, in being self-critical, which I think is appropriate, I believe there have been some examples. When we had a major cold wave and snowfall, there were some hours when citizens on the Burgos highway went through some hours that, perhaps, we could have made more effort to prevent. I made the self-criticism, I said that the citizens were right, I met with all the responsible parties demanding maximum diligence. By the way, they have fulfilled it because in the next cold wave the truth is that the response from the entire Public Administration was very satisfactory.

I have a great concern for anything that may affect the safety of Spaniards on all fronts. Of course, essential security against terrorism, but also security against risks, against disasters, or against any type of circumstance. I believe that a modern state, a functioning state, is a state that is agile, capable, and strong in the face of difficult situations and risks to the safety of the people.

L. del Olmo.- Returning to international relations and to finish, let me ask you a question, I have a curiosity. Your predecessor, José María Aznar, do you think he would support you if you asked him, in the name of Spain's interests, to pave the way for you to go to the White House and lay the foundations for a new dialogue with Mr. Bush?

President.- I am convinced that Mr. Aznar would help me in any circumstance. I am as convinced as most Spaniards are of that idea; but this in relations between governments is not usually the most useful path. The relationship between governments is direct, there is a whole set of diplomatic officials, and overcoming moments that are not close is forged. In that sense, I want to say that my option, my position, is to have a reasonable, positive relationship with all democratic governments in the world and, of course, with the United States; but my option is also that the political positions of Spanish society, of the Spanish people, on major international issues are what I will prioritize because we are a free country, we are a sovereign country, and we set our foreign policy.

L. del Olmo.- You know, President, that this program, which I know you listen to from time to time, Punto Radio, "Protagonistas," moves. The other day we were doing the program in Tenerife on the occasion of the Carnivals, last Friday we did it from Andorra, and precisely a listener, and regarding what we are discussing, told me, and the rest of the listeners are witnesses: "I know that on Monday you are going to interview Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, ask him this question." And I ask you that question: if the circumstances of the Armed Forces parade were to repeat themselves—this listener told me—today, as President, would you remain seated before the passing of the American flag?

President.- It is a question that requires an explanation, because it is evident that the Armed Forces parade is organized by the Government and I would not have organized a parade in which without warning...

I want to recall what the circumstances were. Sometimes this is not known, is overlooked, or is intentionally forgotten. In that parade, it was not announced nor was it in the official program that there would be a representation of the flags of the countries that were in Iraq with Spain. I found it unprofessional and I thought that in a parade, a situation of exaltation or support for an issue like the Iraq war, which had divided Spaniards so much, could not occur. More than dividing, it had made the vast majority of the people, of the citizens, say that they did not agree with that war.

I thought it was a mistake by the Government not to include it in the program, without telling anyone, and hence my reaction to remain seated, which was, on the other hand, a reaction that can only be compared to those who stood up enthusiastically to applaud. But what was parading there, more than the flag of the United States, to which I have all the respect, as to all the flags of all countries, was the support, the presence, of the countries that had initiated the military action in Iraq.

I believe this is very well understood, and, of course, I can assure you that in a parade organized by my Government, that would not have happened under any circumstances and even less without having announced it, included, in a program.

L. del Olmo.- Don’t interpret me as a nuisance. If the circumstances were to arise, and I repeat the listener's question, if those circumstances were to arise, would you remain seated?

President.- Obviously, what I did, I did with full awareness, and I cannot give my applause to a parade of the Armed Forces of our country, which are the Armed Forces that are logically at the service of our citizens, and that this parade be used by the then Government to give support, to exalt, to what was the Iraq war, to which, as everyone knows, I opposed with all my strength and around which I still think exactly the same.

L. del Olmo.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, we will continue talking about Carmel, which gives me the impression that, more than Carmel, it is a bitter candy for your party. How did you feel about a political partner of the Socialist Party, like Mr. Carod-Rovira, comparing your visit to the Carmel neighborhood with the movie "Welcome, Mr. Marshall"?

President.- I don’t know if it was very original. If it was an attempt at criticism, I find it unoriginal; but the truth is that, as President of the Government, you have to have a wide capacity to listen to the criticisms made by the different political forces with serenity and to downplay their value and importance.

I went to the Carmel neighborhood with a program of aid, both for families, for the neighborhood itself through the City Council, and for merchants, because that is my way of understanding the task of a Government for all. Of course, in that neighborhood, there are many people who are currently in need, and I believe that citizens must feel the Government, the State Government, the Government of Spain, whether in Catalonia, whether in Madrid, whether in Extremadura, or whether in Murcia, where the Vice President of the Government has been twice showing solidarity and then bringing measures of support to the people affected by the earthquakes that that Community has experienced.

That is my way of understanding the Government, and if I were a political leader in Catalonia, I would see it well that the State Government supported, combined efforts with the Generalitat and the Mayor in a difficult situation where citizens deserve and have the right to the maximum possible aid.

L. del Olmo.- We will return to Carmel shortly, but first, President, regarding Carod-Rovira, will we ever find out about the conversation you had with Mr. Carod-Rovira?

President.- Yes, whenever you want. Right here, in this interview, of course.

L. del Olmo.- That interview that seems to be super secret or has been super secret.

President.- No, not at all.

L. del Olmo.- Did you talk about ETA in that interview?

President.- The norm with all the political leaders I meet is that they ask me some questions about the fight against terrorism and that I express what my objectives are and what my principles are when acting in the fight against terrorism. But it was by no means the issue to which we dedicated the most time; rather, we spent more time on the political situation in Catalonia, the future of the Statute, the reform of the Statute, and the issues that were politically current.

But I do want to make a statement because I have seen that in recent days there has been... and this is the first opportunity I have to do so. Since I became President of the Government, I have had a very high number of meetings with leaders of different political forces in this country. It is my commitment to govern with the maximum possible dialogue. I believe I have set a record in that sense for meetings with parliamentary spokespersons and with presidents of Autonomous Communities. Normally, I always pick up the phone to a President of an Autonomous Community or a leader of a political party. The vast majority of the meetings have been formal, institutional, and therefore public, and I have also had, as everyone can understand, more informal meetings, of pure conversation, that did not have an institutional character, and therefore there were no cameras or photos.

I do this habitually, moreover. In Parliament, for example, many of the Wednesdays when I go to answer questions, there are political leaders from other parties who say: "President, can I talk to you for a while?" And we go into the office I have in the Congress of Deputies to chat about issues of varying degrees of importance.

But I am a person in that sense who understands the Presidency of the Government as being open to being able to talk to me and also being open to the character being informal, relaxed, as happens absolutely in political life among all.

You see, I had some discreet meetings with the previous Government President, Mr. Aznar. I never thought that was secret. It is normal among political leaders and, curiously, transparency is questioned when I believe the Government has made the maximum effort for the exercise of transparency regarding the debate on the Ibarretxe Plan.

L. del Olmo.- When Carod-Rovira asks you—I don’t know if he asked you this question or made it known to you—"President—I say that Mr. Carod-Rovira must have told you—Esquerra Republicana what they are asking for is the independence of Catalonia no matter what," what do you respond?

President.- That I respect that they defend any idea but that, evidently, that is not going to happen in any case and that, of course, the Government understands that a plural Spain with a strong Catalonia and with significant self-government is the best for Catalans and, of course, for the entire Spanish citizenry. Each one can have a maximum program or a utopia as a political project, which is, I insist, respectable; but from there to acting in the context of politics and the destiny of public life, there is a very important gap.

L. del Olmo.- Returning to Carmel, Mr. Piqué told me the other night at an Andalusian party in Catalonia that Alvarez Cascos was asked for his head over that small hole they found in the AVE Zaragoza-Lleida line. And he said: "Can you imagine, Luis, if the responsibility for Carmel were with the PP?" What would have happened? What heads or resignations would you have asked for?

President.- The only thing that can be stated is that in the eight years of the Popular Party's Government, no responsibility was assumed in any of the complicated circumstances. That is, so far, what we have confirmed. We will see now in the stage, both of the Generalitat Government and of the Socialist Party Government across the State.

Of course, I believe that citizens have the right to have the maximum information. In the case of Carmel, I am convinced that the Generalitat Government will provide all the information when it has absolutely determined the causes of the errors.

L. del Olmo.- The first thing the Generalitat Government has to do is to let the media in to inform, right? That was what they did not do.

President.- I believe there was a day when, for security reasons, an indication was given to the media or a request was made to act in a certain way, which was quickly corrected. I am always in favor of maximum information and facilitating the work of all media outlets.

But, I repeat, I am convinced that the Generalitat will provide maximum information when it has the full study of the errors that have occurred and will not spare any responsibilities that may arise. I am convinced of this because I know the conviction, the will, and the democratic style of the President, Pasqual Maragall.

L. del Olmo.- Should someone resign over Carmel, Mr. President?

President.- In my opinion, as of today, there are no objective elements to establish a direct political responsibility. Above all, we should leave... That is what the work being done is for, and the commitment of the Counselor to provide maximum information about what has happened, where it comes from, and at what moment the decisions that may have been wrong and have led to the consequences we all know were made.

L. del Olmo.- By the way, I don't know if Mr. Maragall has contacted you or called you, but how has the Generalitat reacted upon learning the conditions that the central government has imposed on the reform of the Catalan Statute? For example, no new Cupo, like that of the Basque Country; reminding the Generalitat that it is not mandatory to speak Catalan, etc., etc. Has Mr. Maragall spoken to you?

President.- I spoke with Mr. Maragall this weekend by phone. I don't know if this is a discreet or non-secret meeting, but, as I do with many political leaders, I also talk to them on the phone in conversations...

L. del Olmo.- Regarding the reform of the Catalan Statute?

President.- Fundamentally, regarding Carmel. But I must say that we are not yet at the time of negotiating the Statute of Catalonia. The Statute of Catalonia is being drafted, dialogued, negotiated, within the framework of the Parliament of Catalonia, and once the Parliament of Catalonia makes progress, there will be a phase of dialogue about the Statute of Catalonia with the central government and with the other groups.

I can say from here that my commitment to carry forward and to ensure that a new Statute for Catalonia is approved in this legislature is firm; that I am convinced that this Statute can improve self-government, update competencies at a social moment where there have been changes, and, of course, establish what should be a model of good relations in a plural Spain between Catalonia and the whole of the State.

For my part, there will be a new Statute for Catalonia.

L. del Olmo.- Do you not want to make any reference to the new Cupo that the Generalitat is asking for, like in the Basque Country?

President.- I believe we are in a debate, which is sometimes premature, about what a financing model could be and about what could be done to meet the needs that I know and share in some aspects of financing in Catalonia, especially regarding healthcare and especially regarding the impact of immigration. But the advances and reforms in the model of autonomous financing and healthcare financing will be made by all of us.

My goal is for all autonomous communities to have financial sufficiency for the management of the public services they have. There are two particularly important ones that the communities carry out, healthcare and education, and as a government, I will make the utmost effort to ensure they have the greatest financial sufficiency.

The second great objective of autonomous financing and of the whole State: solidarity. Living together in a political community means living under the principle of solidarity so that those territories and, above all, those people who have the most have a part of solidarity with the territories or with the people who have the least.

L. del Olmo.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, you know that any negotiation that the central government has with Catalonia is scrutinized by the rest of the country. What do you think of the Generalitat's proposal that widows in Catalonia receive 72 euros more than those in the rest of Spain?

President.- I believe that one of the fundamental elements of solidarity and sustainability of the system is what we know as the "single box" of Social Security; it is the great factor of solidarity. The Autonomous Communities can, in my opinion, establish minimum supplements in what we know as non-contributory pensions; but if there is a government and a will from the whole, as is the case with the government I preside over, to raise the minimum pensions of the system by up to 25 percent in these four years of the legislature, the Autonomous Communities should dedicate that effort they wanted to make in terms of care for the elderly to other policies that can benefit the elderly, such as policies related to healthcare or dependency care.

I believe we must preserve the great structural principles of our Social Security system, principles that, by the way, have allowed us, since the Toledo Pact until now, to enjoy a good moment in Social Security and to have the greatness, as a country, to know that this is the great instrument of solidarity, because here there is no distinction between territories. Here, those who contribute, who pay into the system are the people, the employers, the workers, and then those who receive are all the people who have worked throughout their lives, who have the right to a pension that allows them to live with dignity and what the system does is favor those who have the least pension, helping more those who have the least pension.

Without a doubt, it is a powerful instrument of solidarity because many of those who have the lowest pensions live in certain communities in this country: for example, Extremadura; for example, Andalusia. When we make an effort to raise minimum pensions, we are also making the great effort of territorial solidarity in favor of those regions, of those communities.

L. del Olmo.- The issue of immigrants, without a doubt, is something that also concerns the average citizen. The other day I read a summary of a survey on immigration, and it said that as many immigrants should be regularized as labor is needed. Would you emphasize that?

President.- It is evident. Immigration must be linked to work, the possibility of work, the possibility of being in another country legally and with rights, without underground economies, without fraud, because all citizens want immigrants who are working to contribute to Social Security. Because they are here obtaining an economic return, they must contribute to Social Security, which, in addition, contributes to the strength of our pension system. And they also want, of course, that the employers who have an immigrant working for them do so legally, that this immigrant has the rights of workers and that this employer also contributes to Social Security.

What we are doing is putting order where there was disorder, bringing to light and regularizing a situation of legality. That is why the unions have supported it, that is why employers are supporting the regularization process, and that is why a survey yesterday said that over seventy percent of Spaniards supported it, and, surprisingly, the only ones who do not support it are the Popular Party, under whose government in Spain more than a million, surely, illegal immigrants have entered, and hundreds of thousands of them are working irregularly. They oppose this; that is, they want irregularity, fraud, lack of rights to continue, and for people who work and people who receive a benefit for work, the employers, not to contribute to Social Security.

This is not having a project either for government or for the reality of what society is in which we live. That is why in this area the Popular Party has been left alone.

L. del Olmo.- But that is difficult to fix, I see, because you have not fixed the flow of citizens entering through the boats or at the Spanish-French border either. How can that be solved? Would it be necessary now more than ever for Europe to compensate? Will Europe compensate with the help of our police and humanitarian efforts?

President.- Yes, it is compensating. It helps us control our borders. They need to be improved. The problem is not the boats, as long as the boats represent an attempt by a relatively limited number, very dramatic because we know what happens with a good part of the boats.

L. del Olmo.- Very limited. Tell that to the Canary Islanders.

President.- Humanly it is heartbreaking, but the most significant volume of immigrants in our country does not occur through the boats; it occurs through seemingly regular channels, and there must be a much greater effort from the European Union in control, in the requirements for entry, and, of course, a much greater effort from all that is the public administration apparatus.

But I simply say: we are going to experience what this government's period will be like regarding immigration. We already know that in recent years there has been a massive entry of irregular immigrants. I simply say that by doing things better, this will be slowed down. We will not only put order in the immigration that is working here irregularly today, but we will also slow down what represents a massive entry of immigrants into our country. Those who can work must enter, and that is good for the immigrant, good for the country they come from, because they send remittances, and it is also good for our economy.

L. del Olmo.- Changing the subject, some data from the resolutions of the Committee of Wise Men of Televisión Española have been leaked; for example, that the State should assume the debt of Televisión Española, which amounts to 7.5 billion euros, and that advertising should be cut. Before Pedro Solbes has a fainting spell, do you plan to heed them?

President.- I believe we must heed not the leaks, but the moment when the report is officially presented.

What I can assure you is that I commissioned the Committee of Wise Men to establish a model of plural, advanced, modern, independent public media television and to analyze its financial viability. I will know the work of the Committee of Wise Men, as it will be known by the vast majority of citizens, on the day they make it public. We have a known problem regarding the financial situation of public media, especially television, which the government is willing to address with the principle of a plural, free, independent television; a television that belongs to the citizens.

I believe that we have already shown in this ten-month period that there is a return of public television to the citizens. There is much more plural information, much more independent information. There are debates, open debates, political and social debates on public television, and of course that is more than the first step, because we want the guarantee of that plurality to be not only the will of a government, but that this guarantee be institutional, either from the Parliament or from a Council of Audiovisual Media.

But Spaniards want and deserve plural, independent, modern public media, and a higher quality television, as, for example, in the line we have decisively addressed regarding programming in children's hours to eliminate certain content from those time slots that, of course, go in the opposite direction of what should be good education and good references for our children and adolescents.

L. del Olmo.- Regarding television, it seems that this government intends to advance the "analog blackout," on one hand, and at the same time, grant more analog licenses. Since the time and investment needed for a new television channel to be viable far exceeds the five years until the "analog blackout," the only channel capable of incorporating itself tomorrow with the entire structure is Canal+. I ask you: is this a measure to promote the pluralism you referred to a moment ago or to favor a specific media group? I am not saying, like Paolo Vasile, who says "giving an open channel to Polanco would be like staging a coup," but I would like to know your opinion.

President.- Mr. Vasile's opinion, this Italian citizen, is very respectable to me, but I believe he should measure, moderate, his terms a bit after what I read today in the interview.

The philosophy regarding communication that the government has in the private sphere is exactly the same as in the public sphere: we want pluralism, we want freedom, and that, for everyone to understand, is summarized in the more televisions in analog, in digital, or in whatever system may exist and be invented, the better. That is freedom. Why should we limit freedom in the media when we are defending freedom in all areas? More freedom and more plurality mean better information for citizens.

I am not going to make any decision, nor is the Bill we have brought to Parliament aimed at one group or another; it is aimed at ensuring that citizens have access to more televisions, both analog and digital; that we advance the transition to the digital system because that means more freedom for everyone, more right to information, more competition, and from more freedom and more competition in the media, the ones who benefit are the citizens.

I do not know if one group will win or lose, but that is not the general interest. The general interest is that citizens win.

L. del Olmo.- In the Draft Law on Current Measures to Promote Digital Television, reference is made to this medium we are in, radio, and it is regulated that a single operator, whether a natural or legal person, may hold 50 percent of the radio concessions in the same territory, with a maximum limit of five frequencies. You know the degree of concentration of radio stations in the hands of Unión Radio-SER and Grupo PRISA, given that the Supreme Court ruling prohibiting the merger of the former Antena 3 radio with SER has never been executed. Don’t you think, President, that this measure, rather than promoting pluralism in radio, actually blesses the situation of concentration of stations in the hands of a single operator, SER?

President.- It resolves a problem that has been pending for years and that no one had solved: the objective difficulties of applying a ruling. But let me give you an example: this project also includes a measure that affects the ownership of this station, Grupo Correo, because it establishes compatibility between having a stake in digital and analog television. In short, no one has said... And I can assure you that the Government has not taken this initiative to benefit this group, just as it has not taken the initiative regarding what the ruling affecting Grupo PRISA represents to benefit it, but to solve a problem and do something reasonable.

This is a Government with full autonomy and independence that wants, first, maximum plurality for the benefit of citizens, maximum freedom, and that wants to solve problems that may be pending.

L. del Olmo.- Speaking of plurality and equal opportunities, which is what we aspire to in this new European Constitution, that everyone has them, I will give you another example, and let it be clear that I have nothing against SER, as it has been and continues to be one of the leading companies, of course, and sometimes exemplary. But I will give you an example, speaking of frequencies. Do you know the frequencies that Cadena SER has in Barcelona and in Catalonia? I will tell you: five frequencies plus two that it is about to launch: SER conventional-medium wave; Radio Barcelona-Cadena 2; 40 Principales; Cadena Dial; Máxima FM; Radio 80, plus two other channels that it seems it has already bought -- this has come out in the newspapers -- Ona Catalana and Ona Música.

In other words, I give you an example, the closest example because I live there, in Catalonia. Cadena SER in Catalonia has eight frequencies and the rest of the chains... Cadena Onda Cero, for example, has one frequency; Cadena COPE has two, and I do not want to talk about mine, because mine is a new project, which has one frequency. Do you think there is plurality with one chain that has eight frequencies and the rest have one?

President.- Surely the map in some regions and others is unbalanced in favor of more frequencies for some than for others. I am convinced of that.

L. del Olmo.- No, that example in Catalonia works exactly the same throughout the rest of Spain.

President.- There will be everything, there is everything. But I understand that there can always be a point of criticism against those who have leadership in a particular medium. This also happens in political life. I understand it. Normally, who receives the most criticism in the political arena? The winning party, the party that leads, the party that is in first position usually receives criticism from all the others. It tends to be that way when there is a competitive scenario. It is normal.

L. del Olmo.- But I am not talking about leadership. I am talking about possibilities and plurality, because I have given you the case of Catalonia, but I could give you the case of any other Community.

President.- Yes, but Luis, rest assured that there are -- if we now go to the Community of Madrid and to the concessions, and so on -- examples for all tastes, because there are regional governments of the most different colors.

L. del Olmo.- May I ask a question and not take it the wrong way? It is a question and a doubt: Is the President of the Government in debt to Cadena PRISA?

President.- Absolutely not. I only have one commitment, which is to the citizens and to a political program that, I insist, is fully autonomous and fully independent. Moreover, this is so easily explainable and I feel so comfortable in the debate about the media in this country. Telling citizens and taking steps to ensure there is more plurality in all areas is so easy to explain and to convince that this plurality... Whenever there is more competition in all areas, whenever there is more competition, logically those who are already in a position in a scenario that occupies a certain number of positions and so on have to adjust to a new situation of more competition; but, normally, those responsible for what the media are are defenders of private enterprise, defenders of freedom, defenders of competition, and competition logically has these consequences.

But my obligation as a Government is to think about having in a country an informative plurality for the benefit of citizens, and there will be things and decisions that at a given moment will please some media more or less than others. And I do not want to refer to it, but there have been editorials from the newspaper group you refer to, the PRISA group, that have also criticized, as is normal, the Government regarding the content of the Bill and as it will surely be.

L. del Olmo.- President, in the last interview I did with you, speaking of digital radio, you told me that you were committed to making digital radio a reality soon. The day digital radio becomes a reality, all those strange things will indeed come to an end and there will be plurality for everyone...

President.- And digital television because it will be a wide spectrum for everyone.

L. del Olmo.- Yes, but in digital radio we will all work with the same device, with the same machinery. The concessions are distributed and each company has one or two concessions at most, not seven or eight. I have taken the liberty of bringing you a digital radio device, President, that sounds very good, to encourage you because the programs we have on all radio stations sound very good. By the way, it was built by the Chinese. The day you commit, I am sure, and talk to the major automotive manufacturers and through those car radios incorporate digital radio, digital radio will become a reality.

Everyone will have the opportunity to tune in to their stations without interference. They will be able to listen to stations in Cádiz and on the way to Lleida without losing the signal, but lend us a hand, all of you. When I say all of you, I do not mean the professionals in the medium, but all listeners so that digital radio is a success.

President.- Of course. We are fortunate that the modernizing future horizon in technology, which is the digital landscape, will allow for maximum freedom, maximum plurality, and maximum competition. In any process of opening up to competition, logically the different groups have to make their plans and set their objectives. But we are heading towards a better stage for pluralism, for freedom of information, and, above all, for the right to information of citizens, who are the only owners of information, and to have the possibility of listening to as many voices as possible; the more stations, the better; the more television channels, the better for everyone. I can assure you that this will be the case and will continue to move forward.

L. del Olmo.- Would you dare to give a date on when we will have digital radio in Spain?

President.- No, I do not dare to give a date, because it surely depends on a technical process.

L. del Olmo.- The technical process is resolved, President.

President.- I mean technical from the market perspective and the capacity to enter certain segments; but I can assure you that we will put all the political will into it and, moreover, I commit to you, Luis, to periodically provide you with a report and an update on the steps we will take in that regard.

L. del Olmo.- President, we are finishing. After eleven we have another interview with Baltasar Garzón. Now that the judge is leaving the National Court, what is the President of the Government's opinion of Judge Baltasar Garzón?

President.- I respect his career. He has had very important responsibilities in certain judicial processes of great significance. I have a lot of respect for Baltasar Garzón, but I want to maintain what should be the position of a Government, which is also respect for the independence and the assessment of those who have had to issue rulings of great significance. Personally, I have a lot of respect for Mr. Garzón.

L. del Olmo.- President, today is Valentine's Day. Are you very much in love with your wife?

President.- Yes. It is true that very much. I congratulated her this morning and I must confess that I came to this interview thinking that I need to make some time to give her a small gift today. But yes, I am very much in love with Sonsoles. I am very fortunate. I have been very fortunate in life with the partner who has wanted and wants to share with me, above all, this very exciting adventure and in which I am very satisfied, which is being the President of the Government.

L. del Olmo.- Congratulations, Mr. Zapatero.

This is indeed my last question. My fellow townspeople from my town, which is yours too, Ponferrada, tell me: "take the opportunity and ask the President about the project to make Ponferrada the Capital of Energy." Will my fellow townspeople see that?

President.- Yes, they will see it, and moreover, we are going to have very defined, very concrete steps, almost certainly in the next month of April when I will be in León and also in Ponferrada. There I will talk about projects for both León and Ponferrada. I will go in April because I am going to receive the Leonese of the Year Award, which is perhaps the recognition that gives me the most intimate satisfaction, because it has prestige among our land and because having recognition from your fellow townspeople, in this case, the people of León, gives me a lot of strength, a lot of encouragement, and I am very, very grateful. And also in what concerns you, Luis.

L. del Olmo.- And on April 2 will you be receiving the "Golden Microphone" from the Radio and Television Association in Ponferrada?

President.- We can make everything coincide and have that capacity; but you know that normally, when you have called me or summoned me to something, I have almost always been there.

L. del Olmo.- President, thank you for being here on this young station, Punto Radio, which I imagine you listen to from time to time.

President.- Of course. I really like radio. I listen to more radio than I spend time watching television, without a doubt. And I always enjoy listening to you.

L. del Olmo.- Thank you, President.

President.- Thank you very much.