Speech by the President of the Government at an event organized by the General Council of the Bar Association on the European Constitution

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

14 February 2005 · Event organized by the General Council of the Bar Association on the European Constitution · Academy of Fine Arts

Context
Zapatero addressed a Bar Association event in Madrid on February 14, 2005, urging support for the upcoming Spanish referendum on the European Constitution.
Main themes
European Constitution, Spanish legal profession support, constitutionalism and democracy, citizenship and democratic peace, politics and law parallels, transnational governance, European Union, rule of law, civic engagement, George Washington symbolism
Duration
~18 min
61st percentile
Words
2,199
61st percentile
Sentences
69
45th percentile
Readability
34
24th percentile
Grade
16.2
85th percentile
Syntax
3.31
83rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.24
58th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 38%38%
  • Geopolitical 30%30%
  • Ceremonial 29%29%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

69 sentences in 31 paragraphs

Allow me, first of all, to thank all of you for your presence at this event, an event that I could consider as a narrative of successes:

A success for the chosen venue for its celebration. We are in an Academy of Fine Arts, we are in a house of creativity, in a house of open and always welcoming space. Therefore, I want to thank, once again, its director for his constant willingness.

A success because the legal profession has expressed, with its support for the European Constitution, a position that has rejuvenated the Spanish legal profession and has once again demonstrated that knowing how to be present at crucial moments is essential, just as it was during that memorable Congress of León at the height of the democratic transition in our country.

A success because in that campaign and at this event, graphic humorists have participated, whom I congratulate on their work and to whom I also say that they are very fortunate: the fortune that Juan Fernando López Aguilar is now dedicated to politics and previously to teaching, because they have in him a competitor that is hard to beat.

A success also because in this place, in this Academy, there is a portrait of George Washington, one of the few and finest portraits of George Washington, undoubtedly considered the symbol of the foundation, of the Constitution, and of the independence of North America, which gave the world its first constitutional text and represents a treasure for that country, a country that, as we well know, knows how to spread its values with passion and commitment.

In that portrait of George Washington that is located in this house, various objects appear. There is a waxed paper next to George Washington, symbolizing legislative provisions, and at his feet, there are two books that symbolize both the acts of Congress, popular sovereignty, and the Constitution. It is, therefore, an exceptional painting full of references to the traditional symbols of constitutionalism, law, and democracy. That is why this place houses, and this event, many successes.

President of the legal profession, thank you. Thank you for allowing me once again to address the legal profession. I have a great memory of my speech at your last Congress in Salamanca, and believe me, I do not exaggerate when I say that I feel at home.

When a profession carries out five hundred events to promote and support the European Constitution, when it distributes a million brochures throughout Spain and takes to the streets, it is not enough to thank them. It is only fair to say that those professionals, and you, who represent them, have understood that facing this new century, the great professions will only strengthen if they are capable of assuming, embodying, and defending the concerns of citizens, the changes that will strengthen our coexistence and that always come hand in hand with the law.

If you allow me a personal biographical reflection, which I have already made public on another occasion, I believe that my way of understanding politics has been forged in the heat of the law and the practice of advocacy. My passion for politics, for the "res publica," is closely related to the passion for the law that is lived in my family: long, very long hours of dialectical exercise; tireless search for arguments for the case; a zeal for reason.

Yes, politics and law know each other, resemble each other, and respect each other. The parallels are evident. For example, in these days I feel like a lawyer for the European Constitution. I defend it with all my conviction, I exhaust the arguments and refute its weaknesses. However, our pleadings, those of politicians, are not presented in the noble halls of the courts of justice; they are exposed in Parliament and at public events. In politics, the sentences are dictated by the entire citizenry, and in law, the sentences are issued by judges.

I do not want to commit you at this event, and therefore I do not intend to ask you which sentences you consider to be the most just, no. This event has a different meaning; this event is also a plea in favor of law and legislation, and a recognition of the high civic task of the men and women of the law, of lawyers, whose only weapons are words and reason for a fight as essential as it is elevated: the defense of the rights of citizens.

That is why I understand well the support that the Spanish legal profession, always at the height of the times, is giving to the European Constitution, because the text that we will decide on next Sunday is, above all, the supremacy of the notion of citizenship and democratic peace, the only and true peace possible.

This Constitution surpasses the classical constitutional movement, with the permission of Professor Cruz Villalón. It is the first transnational, supranational Constitution; it is the first Constitution that is founded on several nations and states at the same time. However, the European Union is not a new nation, the European Union is not a new state, the European Union is not a state of states, nor even a union of states; the European Union is a new form of political organization; the form, in my opinion, the most elevated that has been known so far in the history of the political forms that we have given ourselves.

The thought, the constitutional idea, thus reaches a new stage in its historical evolution: universalism, which is directly linked to the universal idea of the rights of man and citizen. For this reason, I understand this moment as transcendental.

History has been written and explained as an encyclopedia of the different forms of domination. The European Constitution opens a stage in History for its explanation through citizenship and universal rights. The prius of the European political order is citizenship, which emerges above nations, states, and flags; it is the recognition that what is real, human beings, are the essential end of all political forms, above the ideological constructions that man has elaborated.

Citizenship is rights defended by law, by legislation. Indeed, several states, different nations, diverse languages that communicate and decide with a single language: the language of law. That is the greatness of the European ideal because, as has been keenly observed by a renowned specialist, it is not only that the European Union is subject in its actions to the principle of legality, which is simply the transposition at the supranational level of the rule of law clause, but that the European Union achieves its objectives only through law. It has renounced any temptation of violence against its member parts; its only strength is its law.

In these days, I have also been affirming that this Constitution strengthens Europe and Spain. Ortega y Gasset, interpreting the feelings of many Spaniards, saw Spain as a pit of errors and pains. In the same article, written almost a hundred years ago, in which that eloquent image is contained, Ortega emphasizes a classic quote that takes on all its meaning when collected in its entirety. Ortega said: "regeneration is the desire, Europeanization is the means to satisfy it." Truly, it was clear from the beginning that Spain was the problem and Europe the solution.

Well, I believe we could agree today that Spain, far from being the problem, is already part of the solution; that this time we have the opportunity to be precisely us, and I will not tire of insisting on this, who contribute significantly to Europe taking a new step in the process of building its political unity.

The approval of the European Constitution has a value that I would particularly like to highlight here, before this audience of jurists. If the founding Treaty of the European Community already allowed us to speak of a community of law, with much more reason we can do so now when the European legal order founds its legitimacy in the new constitutional text.

The European Constitution, responding to a healthy codifying impulse, refounds and systematizes the existing Treaties until now. Furthermore, it formally enshrines the principle of the primacy of European law and reorganizes and simplifies the system of sources, placing the Law, the so-called European Law, in the central position that corresponds to it in any rule of law. By the way, I can imagine the anxiety of many lawyers and jurists before this new category: European Law.

If we had historical perspective, we could probably venture that we are at the dawn of one of those stages in which law is called to play a role that transcends its meaning as a technique for resolving conflicts, to become a powerful cultural force that serves as a channel for the dissemination of values, of the values in which we Europeans believe.

We are, therefore, before the Europe of law, the one that recognizes itself as the heir of Roman law, but also of the Germanic, Napoleonic, and Anglo-Saxon traditions; all of which are destined to converge and nourish a "ius comune," a common European law in its fullest sense.

When at the beginning of the 16th century Raphael decorates the "Stanza della Segnatura" in the Vatican, and Tomás y Valiente draws attention to it in his "History of Law," he paints on one of the walls the School of Athens, symbolizing the triumph of philosophical and scientific reason; on another, the Parnassus, the triumph of poetry; on the third wall, the establishment of the Eucharist; and on the fourth, he represents Justinian delivering the Digest to the jurists as a manifestation of the triumph of reason in the field of law. It is a beautiful metaphor of the traditions on which Europe has been building its own identity and that particularly highlights the importance of the legal tradition.

A community of law requires, to be such, the active service of a community of jurists, of jurists -- allow me to express it this way -- increasingly less national and more European, faced with the challenge of knowing well both their own legal order and the community one. This reality raises the need for us to ensure good training, increasingly demanding training for Spanish lawyers, which the Government interprets -- and I did not want to fail to mention it here today -- as an additional argument in favor of regulating access to the profession, the study of which, by the way, the Ministry of Justice has already advanced significantly.

That Europe be a community of law is the best guarantee that we can preserve among ourselves the enjoyment of freedom and peace. Law, freedom, and peace form an inseparable triad.

If the Constitution deserves to be qualified as such, it is, to a large extent, because it includes its own charter of rights that gives legal density to the Statute of European Citizenship and offers us all, the citizens of the Union, a renewed promise of freedom. And it is unnecessary to highlight to what extent this Charter of Rights calls upon those who must become its procedural defenders, you, the lawyers.

I am also convinced that this Constitution is a great bulwark for peace; for the peace of Europe, of course, but also for the peace of the world. The European Constitution opens the most solid path that History has known towards that ideal of perpetual peace.

A few days ago, we commemorated the liberation of the extermination camp of Auschwitz, and in May we will do the same with the liberation of Mauthausen, where, by the way, so many Spaniards died. Our generation and the generations of democracy have also been the generations of peace, surely the only ones in a long period that have not suffered the terrible consequences of a war. I fervently wish that we can pass on this privilege to our children, and for that, the best formula is a strong and united Europe and a Spain integrated and supportive with it.

I will conclude these words by quoting and taking the liberty of making one of the recitals that figures in the Declaration that the representatives of the Spanish, Italian, and German legal professions signed in support of the European Constitution my own: "Considering that the involvement of lawyers is fundamental for the right of citizens to free and independent defense and advice throughout the European Union, and also for citizens to know the influence of the constitutional text in their lives."

Considering it, indeed, in this way, I feel very honored to have participated in this event. I want to sincerely thank you for the great effort that the Spanish legal profession has made in promoting the European Constitution project, while I also want to express at this event my recognition of the permanent task of lawyers; a task that fundamentally consists of zeal, of commitment; a task that could well make us consider that the lawyer never gives up, that the lawyer contains utopian aspirations in their profession. And it is worth never giving up when we are talking about the defense of the rights of our fellow human beings.

Thank you very much.