Interview with the President of the Government on the program "Hoy por hoy," from Cadena SER.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

17 February 2005 · Interview on the program "Hoy por hoy" on Cadena SER

Context
Zapatero addressed counterterrorism policy and the ETA conflict in a radio interview on Cadena SER's 'Hoy por hoy' program on February 17, 2005.
Main themes
ETA terrorism and counterterrorism, peace process and ceasefire conditions, political unity against terrorism, rule of law, Popular Party criticism, risk-taking in government policy, Basque conflict, transparency and political communication, meetings with opposition leaders
Duration
~60 min
96th percentile
Words
7,176
96th percentile
Sentences
274
94th percentile
Readability
48
56th percentile
Grade
12.9
56th percentile
Syntax
3.23
76th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
32nd percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

274 sentences in 121 paragraphs

Iñaki Gabilondo .- Mr. President, good morning.

President .- Good morning.

I. Gabilondo .- When you said yesterday that you were willing to take risks, what are you willing to risk? Could you clarify that further?

President .- To risk everything that is within the reach of a government for a great objective, which is to see the end of violence, and that means having the rule of law fully operational, fully functioning, as is being demonstrated by the effectiveness of the State Security Forces and Corps, an effectiveness that I want to highlight and commend all its members for, because they are demonstrating excellent work. To risk means to unite all political parties in the vision and in the fight against terrorism. And to risk means to reiterate an essential and coherent principle of action, which is shared by the vast majority of Spaniards.

The violent, those who support or act in violence, will never be heard unless they cease the action of arms, of guns, of bombs.

I. Gabilondo .- But what does that risk? Before they hand over their weapons or before they abandon violence, would you be willing to make any move? That would be taking a risk.

President .- They have to abandon their weapons, they have to cease violence, and there has to be a clear principle and will to condemn violence by those who say they want to be in public activity and have been complicit, if not silent.

That is the horizon and that is the landscape we have. Something that seems very important to me, which I believe can yield very good results, in political terms, regarding the objective, is not to use the anti-terrorist struggle or what the government, by providing information and seeking maximum support from all political forces, can and should do. Not to use, as I certainly did not at any time as leader of the opposition, the anti-terrorist struggle; not to speculate, not to sow false ideas, to be a loyal collaborator, when one has, moreover, more information than ever about what the anti-terrorist struggle is.

I. Gabilondo .- It is just that in the line of not possibly confusing the verb "to risk" contributes to confusion. You have explained to us, let’s say, the canonical doctrine on action against ETA. By saying "to risk," one might suspect that you would be willing to do something different from the canonical. Is that not precisely something that can contribute to confusion?

President .- No. Notice that it is an important nuance, because we are hearing the same voices, that is, the Popular Party, which at one time referred to what we know or call the abertzale left as the "Basque National Liberation Movement" and sat down to negotiate with ETA. We are hearing them launch insinuations, warnings, admonitions, at this government that has carried out 150 arrests of suspected ETA members in ten months. I simply say that one should review what the action of the anti-terrorist struggle has been in recent years.

This is what is not serious, it is not serious, and therefore, I believe that the Popular Party and those who in some way express an opinion in one direction should -- it may be difficult, but at least they should try -- to have an attitude similar to the one I had on the issue of the anti-terrorist struggle when I was leader of the opposition and they were in government.

I. Gabilondo .- Yesterday Mariano Rajoy was with us and told us that he had not seen you since that famous meeting that took place here and did not know that there had been any change in the anti-terrorist line, but that he saw things that puzzled him. Not you, but people he trusts and important people. Has there been any news that you have not shared with Mr. Rajoy?

President .- Absolutely not. Moreover, I find it a bit striking, don’t you think? How little memory we all perhaps have! With Mr. Rajoy in these ten months that I have been President of the Government, I have met with him on five occasions. By the way, one of them was discreet and dedicated exclusively to the anti-terrorist struggle, in October. In January, I met with him twice, I have been on two occasions, and in all of them, the anti-terrorist policy and the situation of the terrorist group ETA have been discussed with the utmost information and detail. Every time there is an anti-terrorist operation, the Minister of the Interior informs in detail about everything that that operation entails.

I will tell you: in these ten months I have had many more meetings as President of the Government to talk about the anti-terrorist struggle than in the four previous years that the former President had with me as leader of the opposition. Therefore, let us be serious in what is said and what is insinuated.

I. Gabilondo .- The conversations you had with Imaz or with Carod-Rovira, were they not disclosed for a reason?

President .- For no special reason because, as everyone can understand, when a President of the Government, in this case, when a political representative -- especially a political one, but also from the economic world, the business world, or the communication world -- asks to talk, if I can and my schedule allows, I receive them, because I have an open attitude towards dialogue.

I. Gabilondo .- Apart from with Carod and Imaz, have you had any other discreet conversation that has not come to light?

President .- With political representatives?

I. Gabilondo .- Yes.

President .- Yes, of course. I just mentioned that I had one with Rajoy and I have had meetings with other political representatives, which I find absolutely normal. I also had a meeting, specifically, one with Mr. Aznar, a discreet meeting that was also the basis on which the Anti-Terrorist Pact was built. So, I think...

I. Gabilondo .- Now that they are no longer discreet, but indiscreet, could you tell us what the matter was with Imaz and Carod?

President .- We talked, fundamentally, about what the situation represented as a consequence of the Ibarretxe Plan and, in the case of Mr. Carod-Rovira, also about the Statute of Catalonia, and some comments on the anti-terrorist struggle, how I saw the situation of ETA, what we were doing, and the medium-term perspectives.

I must say that, as everyone can perfectly understand, whenever I am in a meeting, whether official or institutional, with a representative of a political force or whether it is discreet, which usually responds to the request of the person who asks me for that meeting, the issue of the fight against terrorism always comes up, occupying more or less space, as it always appears in an interview that I have with any media outlet.

I. Gabilondo .- So, do you mean that the interviews with Imaz and Carod-Rovira were at their request?

President .- Yes, indeed.

I. Gabilondo .- In the meeting with Imaz, did you reach any kind of concreteness, or commitment, or semi-commitment, post-electoral of the Basque autonomous elections?

President .- Absolutely not. The only commitment we have, as the Socialist Party, regarding the elections in the Basque Country is to go to win the elections with a project of coexistence. It seems absolutely clear to me that we have the utmost interest in what will be the upcoming elections in the Basque Country.

We talked about the Ibarretxe Plan. These days I have heard, in light of the comments surrounding the meetings, that there was little transparency; but if what this government has done is design a whole policy of transparency and broad public debate precisely about the Ibarretxe Plan. Notice that some said that the President of the Government should not meet with Ibarretxe, that this should not be seen in Parliament, that it should not be debated in Parliament, and what the government has done is maximum transparency, maximum democratic debate, and that it is received in Parliament. It is an unassailable contradiction as a criticism.

I. Gabilondo .- Regarding the conversation with Carod, did you reach any kind of convergence of viewpoints on the reform of the Statute of Catalonia?

President .- We have the will for there to be a reform of the Statute of Catalonia and for it to be a reform with broad consensus, which includes from the Popular Party to all the political forces in Catalonia, both those in the Parliament of Catalonia and those that have representation here, which are all, including the PSC and the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party. That is the objective, and now the phase of dialogue and negotiation of the Statute will begin.

I. Gabilondo .- When you said yesterday that you were going to come out first -- you said it yesterday in Cornellà -- what do you mean by that?

President .- That there is a shared will for the reform of the Statute of Catalonia to be carried out, point one, and, two, to be done well and, therefore, not to have a process of difficulty, tension, or conflict. I think it is very important for what is a period in which we are talking about a reform of what is the territorial organization of the State in certain aspects that this Statute, due to its political importance, be reformed with a procedure of maximum consensus and with the possibility of deploying all the purposes for which we are making that reform.

I. Gabilondo .- One last question on this matter, before moving on to the European Constitution, Mr. President. If after the Basque autonomous elections a result were to allow a governance of the Socialist Party of Euskadi-PP, would that agreement be produced?

President .- When one goes to an election to win, what one can never do, evidently, is to be thinking about who one will have to pact or agree with.

I. Gabilondo .- You must have thought about that many times, Mr. President.

President .- Yes, but, you see, I have a bit of experience in this. I remember when in the electoral campaign, before the general elections, I said: I will only govern if we are the first political force. Many people said, "What a mistake he has made because he is closing the doors or because I don’t know what." And we were the first political force in Spain, quite broadly, in fact. Therefore, when one wants the vote of the majority of the citizenry, as we now want the vote of the Basque citizens, you have to be convinced that your project can and should be majority. And our project can and should be majority in Euskadi because it is a project for coexistence.

What is important in the upcoming elections in Euskadi is not the color of the government, it is the call for coexistence. That is what matters to us as the Socialist Party and I believe that is what matters to the majority of the Basques. I am certainly convinced that this can have a majority backing.

I. Gabilondo .- But you know that you have not answered me.

President .- You know that each one is the owner of the questions and, logically, one is the owner of the answers, as I think it is a game of equals, respectable, and we all agree.

I. Gabilondo .- Did you promote the discreet meeting with Rajoy or did he promote it?

President .- I promoted it, and moreover, to talk, I insist, exclusively about the anti-terrorist struggle and the information I had regarding what was happening with the terrorist group and in the context of violence.

Evidently, there is nothing new in that information; otherwise, I would have called Mr. Rajoy to inform him in detail about the content. But I was surprised by some statements he has made publicly.

Then, of all the operations, I insist, that are being carried out, which demonstrate the effectiveness of the State Security Forces and Corps, the Minister of the Interior informs the Popular Party exhaustively and diligently, as is reported, by the way, to public opinion.

I. Gabilondo .- The European Constitution awaits us on Sunday at the polls. Felipe González has said many times that he regrets having called the NATO referendum. Do you regret having called this referendum?

President .- Absolutely not. I believe that a historic decision such as voting on a Constitution that, you see, most of us will do once or twice in our lives... A Constitution, on average, is voted once or twice in a lifetime. A Constitution that represents the most innovative political project, the most committed to peace, the most committed to democracy, the most committed to solidarity in all the countries of the world, such as the European Union that is being constitutionalized and that will mean that for the first time we will have a form of political organization that is neither a new nation, nor a new state, nor a new country, nor a state of states; it is a political form of shared citizenship.

The sovereigns, this time, with this European Constitution are neither the flags nor the countries; sovereignty, more than ever, with a European Constitution is of the citizens.

I. Gabilondo .- Do you know what percentage is going to vote, approximately?

President .- I wish for the highest percentage of participation, and I wish that because every vote in this referendum decides, every vote counts and is very important for Europe and for Spain.

It is very important for Europe because with the European Constitution we are going to make progress in that great project of unity of Europeans, and very important for Spain because Spain will gain strength, leadership, and capacity for influence before the European Union and before everything we have ahead in that process of construction where Spain's interests are at stake if the Spaniards overwhelmingly support the constitutional text on Sunday in the referendum. Voting and voting "yes" is in Spain's interest, and it is also a democratic cause, it is a cause of commitment.

I remember those who voted for the Spanish Constitution of 1978. I voted for it. It was the first time I could vote; I turned 18 and I voted for that Constitution. Today, after quite a few years with perspective, I feel very proud to have voted yes to the Constitution of '78 because it gave us the best years in the history of our country, and I am convinced that those who vote on Sunday for the European Constitution in a few years will be able to feel very proud to say: "I was there, I voted for it, my ballot also counted and a lot."

I. Gabilondo .- Regarding participation, I was saying, Mr. President: if there is low participation, what does that mean? If participation is below 40 percent, for example, is that a failure?

President .- This reminds me of when it is always said, also in electoral processes, "what if this happens?" Let's allow the citizens to vote. It is true that there are so many people saying that people do not want to go vote that it surprises me, because it seems that those are the ones who are, in one way or another, encouraging people not to vote.

To those who say "there hasn't been time to read the Constitution, the referendum was called too soon," I say: this referendum has been called on the date and in the manner agreed upon by all political parties. All political parties voted for it in Parliament, and six million copies of the European Constitution have been distributed to homes. And beyond the knowledge of a specific text that has four hundred articles, we are voting for what the Constitution represents for European unity, which represents, in light of History, since the birth of the European Union, peace and freedom.

No country that has approached or joined the European Union has experienced a war on its territory or a dictatorship. The European Union and the Constitution are the seal and guarantee of freedom and peace.

Therefore, I believe it is good that Spaniards can vote first. Because many Europeans will be watching us, we will set the course, and we will demonstrate that it was not true, that it was not our responsibility, to arrive so many times late to History, as we arrived late to Europe, as we arrived late to democracy, or as we arrived late to the Constitution compared to other countries. It was not the responsibility of the people; it was the responsibility of some powerful individuals, of the elites who never trusted the people.

Hearing now "people haven't read it, they don't know..." reminds me of those elites. I have full confidence in the citizens of this country, and I have full confidence because they have shown ample willingness to develop our country democratically, to well-being and wisdom when they have been allowed to be free. If you allow me, we were without the ability to vote for so long, to decide for ourselves and not let others decide for us, that the fact of being able to decide on a Constitution that will undoubtedly be historic in the evolution of political forms of Humanity is a great opportunity.

I. Gabilondo .- In the campaign, the Popular Party has called for a "yes." However, some have observed a somewhat reluctant "yes," saying: I would like to know how you have observed it. Today "Mister Data" gives us a little note saying that on the Popular Party's website there is a huge majority saying to vote "no" and that they say you should be punished as if it were a second round of March 14. I would like to know how you perceive that. Mariano Rajoy told us yesterday that he, of course, has campaigned in favor of the "yes," that he sincerely believes in favor of the "yes." That is not the doubt; the question is how you have perceived the "yes" from the Popular Party.

President .- What is important is not how the President of the Government perceives it, but how the citizens perceive it. Citizens have seen each political force asking for "yes" or "no" in this referendum, and they have seen it with their reasons and convictions. What I want to say is that it is not the same for "yes" to come out than for "no" to come out. It is very important that many people vote and very important that a very majority "yes" comes out; but very important not only for Europe, it is very important, I insist, for Spain, because Spain has to be strong in Europe, Spain has to have confidence and has to give the image to the whole of European citizenship that it has that will to go together with others who, by the way, have helped us a lot.

I want to remind you that since we joined the European Union, we have received aid like no other country in the history of Humanity has received from other countries. Not even the Marshall Plan represented for a single country what Spain has received from the European Union: sixteen trillion of the old pesetas, sixteen trillion for our roads, to create jobs, for our educational centers... That has been done by Europe, it has been done by European countries, which some, by the way, criticize so much, like Germany, like France, or like Belgium; the net contributors.

There is no political model remembered for more cohesion or more solidarity. If we have gained so much Gross Domestic Product or so much per capita income, if today we have a much lower unemployment rate, that is, to a large extent, thanks to the European Union, and I, of course, want to be in a political model that works with those principles.

I. Gabilondo .- Binding, what does that mean? I know it is not binding, but you said: I will understand it as binding. It is not the same for "yes" to win than for "no" to win, that is evident; but translate what you mean by "I will understand it as binding."

President .- It is quite evident. If "yes" wins, we will be in the European Constitution, within the whole ratification process; but if "no" wins, it is clear that the Government will not bring the formal ratification process of accession to the Treaty of the European Union to Parliament. That is what it means to be binding.

I. Gabilondo .- Before this conversation ends, we will return to the topic, so that you can also conclude, as our other guests have done in previous days, with a direct request for a vote; but now we are talking about something else. Bush is coming to Europe this weekend and he is expected with great interest. Today the Financial Times said that he arrives with the intention of courting Europe, but we do not know if he intends to court Spain. Do you have any news about this visit? Will you be able to meet with him? Will you not be able to meet with him?

President .- I will see him and I am sure I will talk, because it is easy to understand that if we are going to be several hours in a room, first, in what represents the NATO meeting, and then, the Council and a meal in between, and there are twenty-five of us, we will talk at more than one moment. There is no expectation of an official, formal meeting in a separate room, among other things, because the agenda is what it is; but I do want to say that relations with the United States are at a moment of normality. We have collaboration in different instances and we have a fundamental disagreement, as is known, which was everything that affects Iraq; a disagreement that is a factor that must be respected by democratic, free countries -- and I hold the United States of America in high regard from a democratic point of view -- and that in other aspects of what is the international vision or cooperation in many areas and facets there is a common and shared outlook.

I. Gabilondo .- Although it is possible that some minor aspects not related to the doctrine of our country, which can of course have the divergences it deems appropriate with any other, do you consider it a mistake, for example, to encourage from Tunisia other countries to also withdraw their soldiers from Iraq? Can you make, let’s say, a self-critical analysis of some gestures that may not relate to the core of Spanish foreign policy, but are gestures that could have been avoidable?

President .- It seems to me that the one who should make the self-criticism regarding Iraq is not precisely, in this case, the one who has maintained such a clear position and I believe that, in light of the facts and the evolution, quite evident. But I think what matters is to look to the future.

I. Gabilondo .- I say this regarding the United States, not regarding Iraq; some gestures, some comments...

President .- Regarding the future, what matters is that things can go well in Iraq after an electoral process, and no one should understand that the position that the Government of Spain has had regarding the war in Iraq, regarding the withdrawal of troops, could be a position intended to provoke any country, not at all.

The decisions and what I have conveyed regarding the war in Iraq is nothing more than a faithful reflection, one, of the majority will of the Spanish people and, two, of my deep convictions. And regarding my deep convictions, which are very important principles of how to understand public life and the world, I will certainly maintain my positions.

I. Gabilondo .- I wanted to ask you a question regarding an issue that in recent days has also become a very intense topic, let’s say; of fierce debate: the protest of media companies against the Government's audiovisual reform. I would like you to tell us, sincerely, if that is moving forward, if you are going to meet with the companies that have expressed reservations and protests, and if you have anything to say regarding the accusation of partiality in favor of a media group.

President .- Of course I will talk or representatives of the Government will talk and will dialogue. It may be that we do it discreetly or publicly. We will also accept questions, all the questions that are asked of us regarding this issue, and we will provide all the explanations.

The Socialist Party presented itself with an electoral commitment to the citizens, a commitment in two directions: one, to reform to depoliticize public television, to make it plural and independent, and this coming week the report from the experts will be known. There is already a notable change in television towards plurality, towards greater independence. This is the great first commitment.

The second commitment is that we want more freedom in this country, more plurality, more voices, more televisions, if technically that is possible. Who wins? Those to whom the Government is accountable: the citizens. Are there groups, in this case four, that maintain a position and maintain their interests? They are legitimate, but the Government has to defend the interests of the vast majority of citizens.

I. Gabilondo .- Trying to resolve it urgently was not contradictory to the will to dialogue and clarify things?

President .- Urgency allows, in a way, due to deadlines, to dialogue without any problem. The legislative procedure is a long procedure, and that is why many regulations the Government requests urgently. It almost has, to a large extent, a procedural aspect and that is not the essential issue.

Therefore, of course we are willing to dialogue and of course we are willing to listen to what the reasoning may be; but I believe that the principle is a principle in which the vast majority of citizens agree: more voices, more plurality, more television channels, if technically possible, advancing what is called digital television, which is, as we all know, what represents having many more programs and facilitating information as freely as possible. If in addition to having more televisions, we make them or contribute to making them of higher quality, much better, starting, as is the Government's obligation, with public television with the model we are going to implement.

Joaquín Estefanía .- Mr. President, about the Constitution. I seem to remember that of the twenty-five countries, around ten are going to ratify it by plebiscite and the rest will do so in Parliament. Is there a plan B? What happens if, for example, two or three countries drop out of this?

President .- It is true that there are a few countries that are going to ratify it by referendum, which affects the majority of citizens of the Union, and others that are not, and even there are countries where the referendum is prohibited for historical reasons.

We are working with the hypothesis that it will be ratified by all 25. I believe that is the hypothesis we must work with. I believe that having a Constitution for twenty-five countries and four hundred fifty million inhabitants is a great historical opportunity.

The example we have had these days of seeing Durao Barroso, of seeing Schröder, of seeing Chirac, of seeing today François Hollande, as I will surely be in France, supporting the referendum is a very eloquent example of what the historical significance of what we are voting on Sunday means, of what millions of Europeans will vote in many referendums and in Parliament.

Let us work with the hypothesis that no country will say "no," and if that were not the case, there are undoubtedly constitutional clauses provided, and there will also be political will that this does not mean any halt to the European project.

Román Orozco .- Mr. President, you had the support of millions of Spaniards precisely because of your anti-militarist position and against the war in Iraq and preventive wars. In the Constitution, there is a very controversial phrase that talks about the prevention of conflicts, which many interpret as the presence, once again, of preventive wars. What would you say to those people who trusted you because of your attitude towards Iraq on this specific point of the Constitution?

President.- This concept has been used in the opposite sense to what it means. Conflict prevention implies intervening beforehand through political and diplomatic means to avoid having to resort to military intervention, to the use of force. It is a doctrine that has been particularly emphasized by many non-governmental organizations and many specialists in the field of Public International Law.

Europe is the great house of peace, and Europe is the engine and reference of peace in the world. How many countries, how many citizens from any continent, including North America, but let’s not forget South America, Asia, or Africa; how many millions and millions of citizens would wish to live with a model of life and well-being like that of the countries of the European Union? I believe that practically the vast majority.

It is the countries of the European Union that are making the essential process for a just international order, which is to unify all their foreign policies. In not many years, we will see embassies where only the flag of the European Union represents twenty-five countries, a common European foreign service, and a policy in all multilateral organizations, starting with NATO, where the common debate of the European Union has already been opened. That is the most powerful support for peace that has been known, certainly, in the last two centuries of our history.

R. Orozco.- Excuse me, in that article 41 it says that the European Union will be authorized to use military means for that conflict prevention; that is to say, we are not talking about preventing peace, but about using armies, and using the army is war.

President.- I insist, the concept is one of political prevention of conflicts, including what military presence may represent. The doctrine of preventive war that has been upheld by American neoconservatives is an absolutely rejected doctrine in what it means for the European Union and, moreover, it has been discussed in the security strategy developed by Javier Solana, explained one hundred times. The European Constitution does not support, does not endorse, and does not back what we have known as preventive war. Surely everyone can understand that I could not support a hypothesis of that nature.

Eduardo San Martín.- Although other controversial issues have come up here, such as the topic of the latest Digital Television Law, in which, in some way, those of us here asking are relatively involved, I prefer to stick to the script and talk about the Constitution.

President.- But you can ask.

E. San Martín.- Well, I am going to ask you a very short question and then I will ask you about the topic of the European Constitution.

Do you really believe that pluralism is promoted by raising the level of concentration of broadcasters in a radio demarcation?

President.- The expansion of concentration is limited. A limit is set, but for any chain, for anyone, because the curious thing is that it seems to have names and surnames. No, no; it is 50 percent for one or the other. Is it a reasonable limit? It can be debatable like everything; but precisely the norm is limiting: that is the maximum, up to 50 percent of broadcasters in a specific area, in a given constituency.

E. San Martín.- But it is raised from 30 percent to 50 percent. I mean, if what is intended is pluralism, the logical and reasonable thing would have been to lower that limit and, therefore, there would be more broadcasters or more chains in each of the demarcations. That is what I understand by pluralism.

President.- Pluralism is about setting limits. I will tell you one thing simply: in these months, one more broadcaster, one more radio chain at the national level, has been born, which is starting or developing its journey. The other day I was in an interview on that chain. There is already more pluralism in radio in these months than we had, and there will be more, without a doubt.

I. Gabilondo.- There is one aspect that I would also like to raise, even if briefly, which constitutes a concern expressed by many sectors, which has to do with the so-called territorial debate, specifically situated in Euskadi, Catalonia, etc. But I would like to ask you in a more or less general manner. You know that there is this concern not only in opposition party sectors but also in sectors of your own party.

The process and its possible loss of control are observed with unease. And this is the nature of the question: is there a risk, when starting this process, that the matter could slip out of hand? For example, in the matter of financing. All the Catalan leaders we have spoken to have told us, being the definition issues important, that where a decisive battle will be fought is in the matter of financing. In some sectors of your own party, this issue is seen as an important, delicate matter. Doing it well is necessary; doing it poorly could provoke a significant derailment. Are there risks of loss of control in this process or not, Mr. President?

President.- I believe we should have a somewhat longer-term perspective, if I may say so, of what we have achieved in these twenty-five years in our model of territorial development of making a very decentralized country and that, despite all the forecasts that existed -- many of the things, said differently, about what could be the reform of the Statute of Catalonia or a reform of the Constitution I heard in the years 77, 78, 79, 80 or 81, when the LOAPA had to be made, which the Constitutional Court later largely repealed -- has been a success. Let’s start from that idea.

The profound territorial decentralization in Spain, self-government, has been a success; it has contributed to the success of our country in the economic field, in the improvement of public services, in bringing decisions closer to citizens. We must start from that idea.

Therefore, reforming, improving, perfecting, increasing, if I may, self-government goes in the positive direction for what I find most important, which is the citizens, not the prejudices, not the concepts that are largely outdated, let’s speak clearly, especially when we have a project like the European Union.

Autonomous financing. In all countries that are deeply decentralized or in all models where there is a set of instances, of parts, that are in something superior like the European Union, for example, financing is discussed periodically in an intense manner and debated. Now we have ahead of us in the European Union the debate on the Financial Perspectives between 2007 and 2013. Of course, there are conflicting interests; it is normal. There are models that can be more or less supportive; there are historical circumstances where some territories, some Communities -- in this case thinking of the Spanish State -- may have a greater or lesser financial need; but let’s keep in perspective that regarding the financing model, regarding what affects the financing of the center and the Autonomous Communities, there will always be a periodic debate.

It must be taken with absolute normality, and sometimes a series of fiscal responsibilities, taxes will be ceded; at other times we will modify the Interterritorial Compensation Fund; at other times we will have to make certain Communities participate, from the point of view of financial responsibility, in new policies such as immigration... We have that State, and what is absurd is that every time we are going to address a debate, that debate appears as transcendental.

I. Gabilondo.- You are an anthropological optimist, but there are anthropological pessimists and there are anthropological skeptics.

President.- Allow me to say that, for the moment, reason is more on the side of the optimists, because what supports that optimism is what Spaniards have managed to do together in these twenty-five or thirty years while respecting their identities. We have achieved what very few countries have achieved in such a short time in history: to be a country with remarkable economic development, with an ever-increasing social protection, with infrastructure development, with researchers and the training of our young people absolutely comparable to any European country.

We are at a moment -- I say this regarding optimists and pessimists -- but I make a very brief reflection on another issue. One experiences it, but almost as soon as I arrived in Government, we had sectors of the right and the Popular Party saying "the economy, wow!, is at serious risk because confidence is going to decline, we are going to enter unemployment, waste...". It is there, in the archives, and today we have an economic moment that is not the result of the Government; it is the result of society, of workers, of entrepreneurs.

When the Socialist Party came to power, we were growing much less than we are growing at this moment, which has closed the year at 2.7 percent. When the Socialist Party came to power ten months ago, we were destroying jobs, and now we are creating jobs. When the Socialist Party came to power, investment in capital goods, which is fundamental, was practically at a minimum, and now it is growing at 10 percent.

Of course, I am on the side of the optimists, because this is a country of optimism, it is a country of success, and moreover, I can assure you, one only has to be, as happens to me, traveling around the world every so often, being with other governments, with other peoples and with other societies, and they admire us. They admire us for what we have done and, above all, for what we can do. It is so easy, and one feels so proud to be able to represent Spain, thinking about what they think of us, that honestly it would be unforgivable not to be optimistic.

I. Gabilondo.- I remember once that a person I valued very much told me one day: "do not trust pessimists, they also make mistakes."

One thing regarding the report of the State School Council. It asks for religion to be removed from the curriculum, to be taken out of school hours, not to be evaluated for academic purposes, to have no alternative of any kind, and also to denounce the Treaty with the Holy See. Just before you arrived here, we were talking about this issue, and they said: perhaps, with all due respect to religion, this is a matter that has not been directly addressed, looking it in the face and confronting it in a very straightforward manner, but rather making more or less feints to try to maintain balances, and it would be a matter of knowing if with this Council...

President.- The State School Council has given an opinion that is respectable, and in this we have a wide range of opinions: there are those who want Religion not to be in public school and those who want Religion to be mandatory in public school. I will say what my position is, that of the Government: Religion is a right to be studied in public school, a right of parents; it is not mandatory, but it is a right, and those parents who want their children to study Religion as a subject in public school will have that right guaranteed.

In my opinion, that subject should not be evaluable, because it seems that it does not make much sense for the grade in Religion to determine a curriculum, a scholarship, or what could be access; but the right of parents for their children to study Religion is a right that, in my opinion, must be guaranteed, and the Government will guarantee it.

I. Gabilondo.- A couple of pending things, returning to the issue of ETA. Today the newspapers mention the long list of objectives that were pursued, and one is already clearly pointed out. For example, "La Vanguardia" says: Rita Barberá. I don’t know if you are in a position to provide any clarification regarding ETA's objective?

President.- It is evident that I have the information that the Minister of the Interior has transmitted to me; but I believe we must be, and much more so the President of the Government, extremely prudent about what a detention represents and what is extracted from that detention; very prudent. I believe that in this, with all due respect, everyone should be very prudent.

What is really important is that the Police and the Civil Guard are demonstrating great effectiveness, great effectiveness that we must applaud and that the Government stimulates and encourages every day and every minute so that no one who may be trying to plant a bomb, use a gun, to kill can walk freely in our country, but is where they should be, which is at the disposal of Justice and, if applicable, in prison.

I. Gabilondo.- The instruments of barbarism when democracy, with its own, calls us to the polls next Sunday.

President.- But what has always destroyed barbarism, what has always triumphed over barbarism, is democracy, which is the exaltation of reason and coexistence.

I. Gabilondo.- I would now like to ask you to address directly, as Rajoy did yesterday and as Llamazares did the other day, our listeners, to directly ask for their vote.

President.- I would ask all Spaniards to know that on Sunday they can and must decide. They can and must decide in favor of a united Europe, and they can decide, above all, in favor of something that is above any historical moment, and I have explained this many times in these days: 60/70 years ago, the youth of Europe and the youth of Spain were called to war; today we have a generation of young people who are called to the polls, to peace, and to a good education. Only that justifies, above anything else, that on Sunday Spain says a majority "yes" to Europe, to its Constitution, and to its future of peace.

I. Gabilondo.- One more thing, President, China has said it will put the logo of its Games on the Barça shirt; "La Vanguardia" says so today. Could you have had something to do with it?

President.- No, not at all, although it is true that everything related to Barça attracts and interests me. Everyone knows what my colors are in the football field.

I. Gabilondo.- Thank you very much, President.

President.- Thank you very much.