Press conference of the President of the Government after the North Atlantic Council meeting and the European Union-United States Summit.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

21 February 2005 · Press conference after the North Atlantic Council meeting and the European Union-United States Summit · Council of the Union

Context
Zapatero addressed press after attending a NATO Council meeting and EU-US Summit in Brussels on 21 February 2005, reviewing transatlantic cooperation.
Main themes
Transatlantic relations, NATO meeting, EU-US summit, Afghanistan stabilization, Iraq reconstruction, Middle East peace process, Arab-Israeli conflict, EU-Mediterranean dialogue, Barcelona Process, European Constitution ratification, Ukraine, Spain's foreign policy
Duration
~27 min
78th percentile
Words
3,238
78th percentile
Sentences
105
65th percentile
Readability
37
28th percentile
Grade
15.8
82nd percentile
Syntax
3.47
93rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
23rd percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

105 sentences in 45 paragraphs

President.- Good afternoon. Thank you very much for attending this press conference. As you know, today we held two meetings: a NATO meeting in the morning, held at the headquarters of this organization; and a second meeting held here, at the Council of the Union, between the European Union and the President of the United States, President Bush. Both meetings had a common denominator: the transatlantic relationship, a relationship that, as I have expressed on many occasions, must be based on dialogue and mutual respect.

I am convinced that a relationship of understanding and cooperation between Europe and the United States is key to maintaining peace and security in the world. From that perspective, today’s meetings are a step in the right direction.

From today, the willingness to strengthen the bridges between Europe and the United States has increased — that is the balance of the meeting — and for the bridges to be solid, they must be supported by two balanced pillars: one on each side of the Atlantic.

In the course of the NATO meeting, I informed about the actions and the willingness of the Government to maintain the commitment it is developing for stabilization, security, and progress in Afghanistan, in the terms that you already know and which will materialize starting next month with the deployment of a Spanish provincial reconstruction team in a region of the west of the country. This reorganization, as is known and which I want to reiterate today, does not represent in any case an increase in the military personnel authorized by the Spanish Parliament.

Regarding Iraq, which was also the subject of analysis in this morning's meeting, Spain has reiterated its commitment to collaborate in the reconstruction and consolidation process of that country, in the search for stability and the recovery of what means a situation of normality. To this end, we have decided, as is known, and as I have informed, to establish a group of forty experts to train judges, prosecutors, and lawyers in our country, and also Iraqi forces will be trained in demining tasks at the facilities that the Ministry of Defense has in the town of Hoyo de Manzanares; all of this in coordination and within the joint effort represented by the actions of the European Union.

In addition to these issues regarding the NATO meeting, the situation in the Middle East was also addressed in the afternoon meeting between President Bush and the European Union, the representatives of all the countries of the European Union, the window of opportunity that we unanimously believe exists regarding the Arab-Israeli conflict, and the willingness to combine the efforts of the European Union and the United States so that this window of opportunity for peace between Israel and Palestine advances and becomes a tangible reality. The shared will implies a pronouncement in favor of the security of Israel and a pronouncement in favor of a Palestinian state, and, of course, both the European Union and the United States will deploy all their diplomatic and political strength to achieve that objective.

In addition to that, in the meeting of the Council with the President of the United States, other issues were addressed. I made a statement regarding the dialogue with the Mediterranean, the EU-Mediterranean dialogue. As you know, this is a matter of utmost interest for Spain, but also of utmost interest for the European Union.

Ten years ago, we started what was known as the Barcelona Process, and it has been a process that has facilitated cooperation, economic development, and political dialogue between the European Union and the Mediterranean countries. This year, as you know, we will commemorate that tenth anniversary with a major meeting in Barcelona, under the British Presidency of the Union, and there is an objective that represents relaunching what means EU-Mediterranean cooperation, which is crucial for our security and is crucial for the development, modernization, and progress of all the countries located in the Mediterranean area.

Alongside this, we had in the dialogue with President Bush an explanation of how the development of the construction of the European Union is taking place, the moment we are living in regarding the ratification of the European Constitution, and the European Union's neighborhood policy towards the East. Logically, Ukraine has also occupied a significant amount of time, both in the morning, in the initial NATO meeting, and in the development of this afternoon's session.

In short, a broad agenda of topics. I have highlighted the most important ones. My assessment of the meeting is positive. I believe that the good climate between the United States and the European Union is of great importance for gaining spaces of stability, peace, security, and cooperation in all corners of the world.

Q.- I wanted to ask you, President, about this last issue. You say "good climate" and one could almost speak of an idyll between the United States and the European Union. Do you share the idea that relations have been rebuilt? Above all, French President Jacques Chirac has said that Europeans have not yielded regarding Iraq to create this good climate. What is your opinion on this?

President.- My assessment is positive. I believe that this is an opinion that all the Heads of Government and all the Heads of State who have been in the meeting will share. The climate has been a sincere one. There has been an express recognition from the President of the United States of the political and economic importance of the European Union, and there has been an express recognition of the need to dialogue more intensely, to act jointly, and to set common objectives. I believe that this is something enormously positive, certainly for the European Union, for the United States, and, I insist, for the objectives of peace, security, and stability.

For me, the fact that the President of the United States has met with the entire European Council has high symbolic value and, of course, I am confident that today represents the beginning of a new moment, a new stage, that leaves behind known differences and opens a stage of a more sincere and productive dialogue for all.

Q.- Apart from this immediate reading of what the two Summits have been, a reading in a more bilateral direction also seems necessary or imposed. In that sense, from what we have seen from the outside, it has been a very brief greeting, correct let’s say, a certain formality, and an even briefer farewell. I would like to know from you, from the inside, having experienced the situation from within, if there have been other contacts of another type that we have not seen, what is your assessment in that sense of this meeting and what do you expect for the future.

President.- There was a cordial greeting; in Spanish, moreover — President Bush had the courtesy to do it in our language — and there have been, throughout the day, as you can understand, many moments in which the dialogue, through what the meetings entailed, has marked the positions and the respect and cordiality that have presided over the entire day, both regarding the NATO meeting and regarding the European Council meeting.

Therefore, I want to reiterate that the assessment is a positive one. There was no bilateral agenda today, as is known; today there was an important multilateral agenda, certainly for the European Union and important for the United States, and from that perspective, I believe we can be satisfied.

Q.- President, allow me to insist a little on this issue, because the truth is that it is of utmost interest to us.

President Bush comes here with a desire to visualize reconciliation regarding Europe and makes very explicit gestures of reconciliation, even towards certain countries that, for example, do not make the slightest contribution in Iraq, nor the slightest contribution in Afghanistan. Spain, which is withdrawing its troops, and that does not sit well with the Americans, now makes a very important gesture and participates significantly in both countries, and yet we still find a lot of coldness between the President of the United States and the President of the Spanish Government. Do you think this is due to some kind of political strategy or that it falls into a simple personal vendetta, with a certain childish touch? I would like to know your opinion on this matter.

President.- The truth is that more questions are being asked than I ask myself about it, which is part of your job. I have insisted on many occasions that there is a relationship of normality and at this moment we are also working in that bilateral perspective between the Government of Spain and the Government of the United States on many common and joint tasks that affect different areas. Today we had a meeting that was a cordial, normal, and reasonable meeting, and from there, we will have time to do all the analysis that is wanted and all the interpretations that are possible; but, of course, from my point of view, I believe we are in a situation of political normality.

Q.- President, I would like to know, first of all, if you support the initiative, the proposal, launched by German Chancellor Gerhard Schröder, that it is necessary to reform NATO and adapt it to the new times and new missions.

Secondly, apart from the symbols, I would like to know if you have appreciated in President Bush's interventions that his messages are more multilateralist than they were in the past.

President.- I will answer the second question first. In the interventions I have heard from President Bush, in all of them, he has referred especially, both in the framework of NATO and in the context of the European Union, to a willingness to share: to share dialogue, to share decisions, and to share actions; all of this in a continuous and permanent tone of great respect. That is what I have heard and that is what I convey, and since that is what I have heard and that is what I convey, the assessment for me is favorable and positive.

Secondly, this morning also in the NATO meeting, as is almost always the case in NATO meetings, there was a moment, there was a part of the debate that addressed the historical moment that the Atlantic Alliance is experiencing and the future perspective. There is a very evident conclusion, which is the need to maintain the objectives of the Atlantic Alliance while adapting to the security needs that this new time is experiencing in the world, and also the convenience of that Atlantic Alliance, which undoubtedly represents a very powerful organization for security, having within it the most intense dialogue and the broadest consensus when it comes to setting objectives and developing those objectives. This obviously includes the European Union, with an intervention from Chancellor Schröder in that regard.

Q.- Returning, President, to bilateral relations. We were told that today you did not meet with President Bush because that meeting was not managed. I wanted to know if the Spanish Government is managing a bilateral meeting between the two Presidents.

President.- When that occurs, when we work in that direction, you will be duly informed in a timely manner, of course.

Q.- I wanted to ask you two questions. Your Government has been part, along with Germany and France, of what was once called old Europe, let’s say, the strongest opposition to a unilateral attitude. You, as an integral part of that group, what exactly do you expect in terms of a change in attitude from President Bush so that the multilateral tone is recovered and so that this materializes in what you mentioned earlier: rebuilding bridges again?

As a second question, and also somewhat related to the first, it is evident that there is a climate, I don’t know if media or call it what way, but the questions are what they are and there is coldness in the relations between you and President Bush. Have you at any time felt a bit abandoned by Germany and France? Have you missed any gesture from the two Presidents?

President.- I reiterate that the greeting I had with President Bush was a cordial greeting. I know that perhaps something else would have sparked more interest; but the greeting is cordial, that is how I experienced it and surely that can be perfectly noticed in the media.

I have always expressed that there is neither old nor new Europe, that there is a strong, united Europe, today more than ever, because we are in a process that will culminate in a European Constitution for twenty-five countries and 450 million inhabitants; which marks an advance in common foreign and security policy, in defense policy, and in a broad chapter that will make the European Union much stronger as a power in the world. As is well known, the Government of Spain has a very intense relationship, which we have seen throughout the development of the campaign for the referendum on the European Constitution, with France, with Germany, with their Governments and with the Chancellor and the President of the French Republic.

From there, for that necessary multilateral vision, in my opinion, at this historical moment we are living, a United States-European Union relationship is essential, fundamental, in a dialogue, I insist, based on respect and balance. Two, from my point of view, and this has also been the subject of analysis in the development of the meetings, the reform and strengthening of the United Nations are fundamental. Ultimately, we all belong, those of us who are part of one organization or another, to an organization of organizations, to an organization of countries, which is the United Nations. It is the ultimate responsible party and guarantor of peace and security; it must be, it must be stronger, and for that reason we have convened in September to try to achieve a reform that strengthens the United Nations as the great guarantor of peace.

Secondly; it has been present in this afternoon's meeting in several interventions that the agenda of the great objectives of the international order between Europe and the United States, and between any country, must include development, must include the fight against poverty, must include the battle against misery, and must include the fulfillment of the Millennium Development Goals. Surely the countries that were in this room today, Europe and the United States, represent approximately one in ten inhabitants, about 10 percent, perhaps a little more, but we certainly represent 50 percent or a little more of the world's wealth.

This reflection must be present, because it relates to the extension of freedom, to the extension of democracy, and also to security.

Q.- Mr. President, regarding what you mentioned this morning at NATO about Spain's contribution to the stabilization of Iraq, you first referred to the issue of the forty experts for the training of judges and police; you also mentioned the military base in Hoyo de Manzanares for demining issues; but you did not comment on the military base in Morón de la Frontera. We have been told that this base is included in the package you presented this morning at NATO, and I wanted you to confirm that first, and secondly, what implications it would have.

President.- Not at all. That information is not correct, simply.

Q.- Sogecable has formally requested the Government this afternoon for permission to broadcast Canal + 24 hours a day. I wanted to know if the Government plans to give a positive response, as the Vice President pointed out a few days ago, and in what timeframe, if applicable.

President.- The Government will study, from a fundamentally legal point of view, the request made by the group you refer to, and at the moment it studies it, it will make a decision. Logically, there is no set timeframe regarding this.

Q.- Mr. President, in 1994 President Clinton asked Europeans for an effort to integrate the continent, and very recently we have just welcomed ten countries with an average income that does not reach 40 percent of the community. A few days before the NATO Summit in Istanbul, President Bush told Europeans that Turkey should someday be a member of the European Union, and we have committed this year to open negotiations. I wanted to ask you if you interpret that from President Bush's reference to Ukraine at NATO, and here today, it is anticipated that someday Ukraine, perhaps within ten years, will be a member of the Union.

President.- I think it is going too fast regarding that eventuality. It is true that this morning the President of Ukraine expressed a clear European will, but I think it is going too fast. As you know, the European Union is undergoing an enlargement process: we have Romania, Bulgaria, and Turkey. The European Union is a successful project because it constantly has applications for membership, and certainly, everyone who joins the European Union is in agreement, is comfortable, their countries gain development and gain well-being.

Therefore, we are in that process of enlargement. Beyond the position of the United States regarding this, there are many governments that have traditionally been favorable to Turkey's incorporation into the Union, and I think we should take all opinions into account, logically.

Q.- I wanted to refer to an issue of domestic policy. The High Court of Justice of the Basque Country has decided to reopen the issue of prosecuting the President of the Basque Parliament, Mr. Atutxa, for the non-dissolution of Sozialista Abertzaleak. My question is whether you do not think that the Attorney General is somewhat slighted, because at the time he decided not to appeal what a First Instance Court decided.

President.- I believe we must have respect, and much more from the Government, for the decisions of judicial bodies, just as I expressed respect for the decision made by the Attorney General of the State, who, according to what I have expressed on many occasions, is the Government's desire to act with maximum independence.

Q.- Mr. President, you mentioned that at the meeting of the European Union with Bush, the current status of the European Constitution was discussed. I would like to ask if specifically there was any discussion or if anyone commented on the referendum held in Spain, and I would also like to hear your personal experience of how you feel the result of the referendum has been received.

President.- Indeed, at the beginning of the meeting with President Bush, the President of the Council, President Jean Claude Juncker, congratulated the Spanish Government — which I interpret as a congratulation to the Spanish people — for the result of the referendum on the European Constitutional Treaty, which we held on Sunday.

I can comment that all the Heads of Government or Heads of State of the European Union congratulated me throughout the day; a congratulation that, I insist, I interpret as a congratulation to the Spanish citizens for having made such a determined and clear commitment to the European Constitution. It has been, logically, the subject of analysis and comment, with a fairly shared reflection: the vote of the Spaniards so favorable to the European Constitution will be a stimulus and will help the processes of popular consultations that must be held in the different countries of the Union.

Thank you very much.