Interview with the President of the Government on the program "59 seconds," from TVE-1.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

24 April 2005 · Interview on the program "59 seconds" on TVE-1

Context
Zapatero participated in a TVE-1 television interview on April 24, 2005, reviewing his government's first year in office across key policy areas.
Main themes
First year government assessment, public approval ratings, opposition leadership, civil rights and immigration, social commitments, democracy and citizenry, economic policy, territorial policy, security and terrorism, foreign policy, media independence
Duration
~104 min
98th percentile
Words
12,480
98th percentile
Sentences
435
98th percentile
Readability
45
49th percentile
Grade
13.7
64th percentile
Syntax
3.28
80th percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
25th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

435 sentences in 183 paragraphs

Mamen Mendizábal .- Thank you very much for being with us. Good evening, Mr. President.

President .- Good evening and thank you for the invitation, of course.

M. Mendizábal .- We appreciate that you made the effort to come here.

Mr. President, at this point, I believe that almost everyone has already assessed the government's management: citizens, through surveys; journalists; political commentators, through various media; we too, in this program. But if you had to give a grade, how would you assess this first year of management?

President .- I am the one being examined, and it is the citizens who have the right to examine me, as well as the journalists; today here, in this program, by independent journalists, in an increasingly independent public television. That is the most important thing for me. It is the citizens. I assess myself, and the people, the citizens, give me the grade. Therefore, I think it would be a bit absurd for me to give myself a grade. Go ahead. Ask me and examine me.

M. Mendizábal .- We have been learning data from various surveys, including those from the CIS. It shows the wear and tear that comes with exercising power. According to this survey, in one year of government, the President's popularity has dropped from 67 to 49 percent. The government has justified this decline as normal in the exercise of government and compares it to what the previous administration suffered, which, according to CIS data, placed Aznar fourteen points below your current percentage. I don't know if you feel supported by the citizens as well.

President .- In the task of government, the most important thing, and what I would highlight today, after a year, is that I have felt the willingness of the vast majority of Spanish society to contribute to the government doing well, and therefore, to the country.

I am deeply grateful for the attitude of businesspeople, unions, non-governmental organizations, and media outlets, who exercise their criticism, who make us reflect and criticize, and also rectify, as we have known how to do on some occasions. Therefore, from that point of view, I feel the full willingness of Spanish society to collaborate, and I cannot help but emphasize and deeply thank that. Thus, governing is undoubtedly a much more exciting task of serving your country, seeing how there is a mature, strong, open, very responsible society that wants to collaborate with the government.

M. Mendizábal .- We will continue with the data, and then there will surely be time for opinions, because, according to the data from a comparative survey between the President of the Government and Mariano Rajoy -- provided to us by the Opina Institute -- José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero is better rated in effectiveness, honesty, sincerity, flexibility, authority at the head of the party, and I must tell you that even in sympathy, too. However, in the only aspect in which Mariano Rajoy is rated better than you in this survey is in preparation.

And if we assess this first year of government, we also have to assess the opposition, which, especially in these last weeks, seems to have become a bit more tense. Please assess this year of opposition and the leader of the opposition, Mariano Rajoy, of course.

President .- In a democracy, fundamentally, it is the government that must be judged, and that is the greatness of democracy; the opposition plays a counter-power role, like the media. The truth is that I do not want to make any judgment about the opposition's task. I wish them well in their ability to have a political project for Spain. It is good for our country.

It is not that I am making a statement of goodwill, but I do want to emphasize that perhaps the only thing I would point out is that the opposition -- and this usually happens in democracy, it also happened to us in the Socialist Party -- must have, above all, the ability to look forward and not be a slave to the past. Citizens, with each election they make, look to the future, and when they think about the next election, they are also looking to the future. That is the greatness of democracy. The citizenry has a great common sense and a lot of intelligence in that regard.

Perhaps the only thing I would dare to suggest is that they look a little more to the future and a little less to the past.

M. Mendizábal .- We have decided to organize this review of the first year of government into five areas: civil rights, security and terrorism, the economy, foreign policy, and of course, territorial policy. We will start with what you have described as one of the fundamental objectives of your management in this first year: the social commitments you made in your electoral program.

Consuelo Álvarez de Toledo .- Mr. President, immigration does touch on civil rights, as it has been one of the major controversies of the previous legislature, and you came to the presidency with a desire to resolve them. You approved a reform for the regularization of immigrants in Spain, a reform that was initially good. It turns out that this reform is starting to spring leaks and fail.

There is a lower affiliation to Social Security of immigrants than there are regularization files, which means that there is someone who is defrauding. There is a maintenance of exploitation mafias, and there is confusion in the municipalities, because now it is no longer clear which documents are valid for regularization. I think it is important for the government to combat the pockets of fraud by employers who abuse this cheap labor, and I also think that legal security is important.

Please tell me, Mr. President, what you are going to do to at least alleviate the chaos that has been created with the regularization.

President .- I will tell you that there is no chaos; I will tell you that what there is, is putting order where there was disorder, putting legality where there was illegality.

When we came to government, we discovered, as many people in this country thought, that there were hundreds of thousands of immigrants working illegally in our country; that is to say, they have jobs and are outside the law, neither they nor the employers are contributing. And we have opened a normalization process, which currently involves nearly 400,000 people, which will surely reach nearly 600,000, agreed upon by all the unions, by the employers, by non-governmental organizations, and with the support of all parties, except the Popular Party.

When these three months are over, we will have order where there was disorder, we will have legality where there was illegality, and we will maintain the essential principle that immigration must be linked to work, but that immigration entails rights for immigrants, legality, and, of course, that there will be no fraud or situations like those we have had to address.

In this process, I insist, everything, everything, has been agreed upon with employers and unions. And we are talking about hundreds of thousands of people who are normalizing their situation with the essential collaboration of employers, whom I deeply thank from here. When this process is over, we will have a much more orderly immigration.

The incidents that have occurred have been minimal compared to the volume of what we are talking about in addressing this process.

The modifications that have occurred for the proper accreditation process of residence and work contracts have been minimal and agreed upon by all, once the process started and it was detected that there was some failure.

We will have a country where immigration is taken seriously by the government, orderly and legal. Of course, we will apply the law with all the rigor that in this country to work from a position of immigrant, one must do so in accordance with the law; that in this country no one will defraud, neither employers nor workers, because the law applies to everyone. What is absolute cynicism and hypocrisy is knowing that there are hundreds of thousands of people working without papers, without rights, and failing to meet the obligations of employers and not addressing it thoroughly.

And I will add: this process, like the general process of immigration, is making important contributions to our economy. It is one of the clearest factors of our growth and progress. It must be done well, with the law in hand, in an orderly manner, and, of course, not looking the other way, as happened previously.

Vicente Jiménez .- I would like to delve a little into this issue. It is true that the process you are talking about, Mr. President, is about to conclude, and I believe it is a success if we manage to bring to light half a million foreign workers who were previously in illegality or at least in the underground economy. However, what measures does your government plan to take to prevent us from finding ourselves in a few years, as happened during the two legislatures of the Popular Party, with another million or half a million immigrants working in the underground economy?

President .- We need to take three essential types of measures.

The first of these is the control of borders and the legal requirements for entering our country, and to strengthen all the means, all the resources, that we have at our disposal, in collaboration with the European Union's policy.

The second measure is to strengthen and improve all agreements with the countries that have as their main destination, as their main objective, the arrival of immigrants to Spain. Much can be improved with Latin American countries or with countries like Morocco, which is where the largest number of immigrants come from, so that the annual agreements match supply and demand, because something was failing spectacularly if it turns out that there was work here, as is demonstrated, because there were many people working, and the number of immigrants who came by agreement between the two governments was minimal.

And, thirdly, this is, in the long term, the most important: the Western world must assume that either it makes the greatest effort to overcome misery, poverty, hunger, and despair in so many countries around the world, or it will be very difficult, very difficult, to prevent the arrival of immigrants.

That is why perhaps today the great challenge of 2005, which has been raised by all the non-governmental organizations in the world, is being posed as the Year of the fight against poverty and misery. That is why I am committed to ensuring that our country raises its percentage of development aid to 0.5 percent of Gross Domestic Product in this legislature, doubling what we had when we came to government, and we must demand that all developed Western governments meet the Millennium Goals and that this Alliance against Hunger, that the fight against poverty, be the great objective of the coming years for so many Western governments and not other policies, because there will only be orderly management of migratory movements if in the countries of despair, misery, and poverty there are expectations.

With the resources that Western countries have, they can eradicate, by meeting the Millennium Goals, poverty, change the conditions of education and health for millions and millions of citizens. That is the great challenge for the future, and, of course, our country will be at the forefront of that commitment.

Pedro J. Ramirez .- First of all, I want to congratulate you on the full recognition of the civil rights of homosexual citizens. I believe this was a pending issue in our democracy, but four religious confessions have jointly asked you to recognize those rights without altering a millennia-old institution, such as marriage. From a secular perspective, that is also what the Judicial Power Council, the State Council, and the main Academies asked you, and that is what some socialist leaders, as important as Jospin and Prodi, are also telling you. You have not paid much attention to them.

You said yesterday that the Popular Party should look into the eyes of homosexual citizens. I will not tell you to look into the eyes of the millions of Catholics who may feel offended, among other things, because I am not the one to represent them, but I will tell you to look into the eyes of those of us who love consensus, those of us who love legal rigor. Did you really, Mr. President, do everything possible to achieve a solution to this problem that would be satisfactory for everyone and that would not offend anyone? Did you really do everything possible through dialogue, through goodwill, or did you not?

President .- What the government has done, which has had the support of practically all parliamentary parties, except the Popular Party and Unión Democrática, is to fulfill an electoral commitment. Throughout the electoral campaign, I stated that it was my intention to extend the rights of citizenship in our country. Why? Because extending the rights of citizenship from a perspective of equality is the best way to ensure that a country progresses and advances. Those countries that are the most advanced in the world are where there are more individual rights and where there is more equality, for example, between men and women.

Homosexuals have faced historical discrimination, they have claimed their rights, and these are rights that extend to people who did not have them; to have a relationship of affection, of partnership, sanctified by the law, enshrined in the law; with an institution, with a designation, that is what we all recognize as natural: marriage.

Why are those people, who have rights, who live among us, who fulfill their obligations -- and we all know some homosexuals at work, in our families, in our friendships -- not going to have the right to the same conditions and the same legal regime as heterosexual people?

I will say one thing: those who today have opposed this recognition of rights, which, I insist, was an electoral commitment and, therefore, I believe that the least we can demand from a ruler is that they fulfill electoral commitments, are the ones who have normally been late to reforms, to the advancement of rights. Twenty-five years ago we were discussing divorce, and the conservative sector of our country opposed divorce and said it would lead to all sorts of evils. Now we have made another reform of divorce, to make it more agile, more modern, and less costly for citizens, and they have abstained. We have advanced, perhaps twenty years late, the conservative forces or opinions.

I have great respect for what Catholic confessions, Catholics, and other religious confessions say, and, of course, for all Catholics; but I want to remind you that we are in a society, in a country, secular, where religious values are personal, individual values, and the collective values and rights of citizenship are established by all of us, through Parliament and through the representatives we have elected.

And I want to add: no one loses, nor is restricted, nor has any right diminished with the extension of rights to other people, whether they are homosexuals or any other group. Absolutely not. Moreover, I will add: the more free people there are in a country, the more people, and I hope it is all of them, have all their rights on an equal footing, the better that country will be and the freer we will all be.

Margarita Sáenz Díez .- President, I am convinced that homosexuals have the right to adopt, of course they do, and of course they can be better parents than some heterosexual couples, whose way of being parents and mothers embarrasses the community of citizens who live with them. However, I believe that they have not paid attention to the details when addressing this issue, because -- let me explain -- I believe that an adopted child is a child different from others, because they carry a burden on their back that no other child carries, which is that they have been abandoned at least once.

So, I think that a moratorium of a couple of years or three should have been applied, no more, until society has naturally accepted and executed the cascade of homosexual marriages because, otherwise, the day after tomorrow we will see in schools or in exclusive schools how those children, who are adopted by homosexual couples, may be subject to discrimination that they do not deserve.

President .- I believe that Spanish society is an open and mature society.

On the issue of adoption, I want to make a clarification that I think is important, which is sometimes overlooked: with the legislation in hand today, the rights of children prevail in any adoption process and will continue to prevail above any other circumstance, as it should be. But with the legislation in hand today, a homosexual person can adopt and, in fact, there are homosexual people who have adopted children. And those homosexual people can live in a couple with other homosexual people. What we are doing now is simply transferring what can happen in reality and what happens to the Law, and there will always be more guarantees in the Law.

I will add: studies -- psychological studies of all kinds -- show that there is no impact on what represents in terms of the education and upbringing of a child what may be an adoption by a homosexual person.

What a child needs is affection, is love, and is support, and that can certainly be provided by a heterosexual person; but, in my opinion, it can also be provided by a homosexual person, if we understand that there is no element that can discriminate. The guarantees of children come first; making real and in the Law what can already happen today and, in any case, of course, contributing to all the work that in a free, democratic, and mature society we have to do so that no child, no person, feels discriminated against.

It happens the same way as in other areas of collective life, of coexistence, of values or rights. Until very recently, sexist jokes were a fairly widespread custom in our country, they were common currency; practically among men, they were cheered. Fortunately, today, thanks to progress, to changes in society, and to the unstoppable equality of women in their rights, sexist jokes are now frowned upon. Moreover, they are absolutely intolerable in a democratic society for what they represent in terms of attempts at domination and exhibiting a discrimination that women have lived through, not only for years, but for decades and centuries in so many societies, including ours.

M. Mendizábal .- Let's talk about security and terrorism, because Spain has been marked for a long time by ETA terrorism, and the first year of the socialist government has also had to face the threat of Islamist terrorism, made evident after the 11-M attacks.

This afternoon you addressed the leader of the opposition, Mariano Rajoy, in a letter in response to another letter he sent you a few days ago conditioning the validity of the Anti-Terrorism Pact to the illegalization of the Communist Party of the Basque Lands. After this exchange of letters, as we could call it, I do not know if it is even possible to strengthen this Anti-Terrorism Pact, recover it, and strengthen it.

President .- For me, it remains in force, among other things, because the Pact has been a very important instrument in strengthening the Rule of Law and in the harassment and defeat of terrorism.

I want to make two clarifications that I think are appropriate: the first, in this year of government, fortunately -- I emphasize "fortunately" -- we have not had any terrorist attacks with fatalities. These are the first elections in Euskadi that have taken place, apart from those that occurred during the truce, in which there has not been a single terrorist attack.

In this year we have arrested, between the Spanish Police and the Civil Guard and the French Police, 140 suspected members of the terrorist group ETA, ten percent more than last year; among them, the one recognized as the "number one" of the ETA group; among them, decisive structures in the capacity to recruit people and operability for the terrorist group. We have great international cooperation.

This is, so far, the balance of the government's anti-terrorist struggle.

The Pact for Liberties and against Terrorism was proposed by me, allow me to remember that in December 2000. I want to recall why I proposed it, and how I proposed it. Surely we all remember that I was elected Secretary General of the Socialist Party in July 2000 and in the first months of my mandate as leader of the opposition, this country suffered some terrible terrorist attacks. I attended those funerals. For me, it was undoubtedly the great objective, and I asked myself what more I could do, as leader of the opposition, to end and fight against ETA terrorism. And I proposed that Pact with only one condition, with only one objective: to give all my support to the government in the fight against terrorism.

What the Pact states, the first commandment of the Pact, is "we leave the fight against terrorism out of political and electoral confrontation between the Socialist Party and the Popular Party."

I can proudly say that during the almost four years I was leader of the opposition, I always supported the anti-terrorist policy of Aznar's government, which had successes and which I have recognized time and again; that I never publicly criticized that policy; that I never exercised parliamentary control and that I supported all measures, even some -- I can mention it here as an anecdote, to see to what extent I supported -- For example, the Law of Parties, which we discuss so much today, I learned about it from a news agency's teletype on a Sunday night; for example, the illegalization of Batasuna, the initiative to illegalize Batasuna, was communicated to me by phone -- I was in Galicia, in August -- by the Vice President of the Government, at that time Mr. Rajoy -- the President of the Government, Mr. Aznar, did not even call me -- and I said: "yes." I didn't think about it for a minute, as I did with all, all, the policies regarding the fight against terrorism while I was in opposition.

That is the essence of the Pact. Four months later I proposed that Pact and for four years I faithfully complied, and now the PP has not been in opposition for a year and is using the element of political confrontation in the fight against terrorism.

My response will be the same: I will be faithful to what I did in opposition now in government and I will not engage in polemics with the Popular Party, nor with any democratic political force, about terrorism and the fight against terrorism. I will not give any satisfaction to the violent.

I want and wish for that Pact to continue, and for my part, I will make every effort. I have offered them a new meeting to inform, to exchange opinions, because that Pact is not, nor is it of the PP, nor of the PSOE, nor of the leaders who represent it; that agreement to unite forces and not make partisanship against terrorism is a value of democracy, it is a value of Spanish society, and we must be faithful and comply with it. I have done it and I will do it.

V. Jiménez .- President, however, citizens ask us what is the use of a Pact that we must constantly remind ourselves of its essence. What is the use of a Pact that was not convened in light of the largest attack in the history of this country, such as March 11? What is the use of a Pact, ultimately, that has become an instrument of battle, of political contention, every day? How can citizens trust that Pact?

President .- The best proof that the Pact is valuable and that it is a powerful instrument of Spanish society is that both parties claim the Pact, we request its validity. I simply want to add and contribute that, after proposing it, I have been faithful and loyal to its letter and spirit. And I will add one thing: when it really has merit to be faithful and loyal to the spirit and letter of the Pact is when one is in opposition, because it requires the opposition to support the government in the measures it takes in the fight against terrorism, to help. And the government of the PP, which was, knows how hard it is, as we know today and as the Police and the Civil Guard know, how hard it is to fight against terrorism and knows how appreciated it is to see the support of the opposition.

I gave it and now I believe I am entitled to demand it in the principle of trust that that Pact implies, which means that both parties recognize each other, what? We recognize that we have the same will to end terrorism, we recognize that we are willing to cooperate to end terrorism and we recognize that, as the letter of the Pact states, the anti-terrorist policy is directed by the government and dialogues and informs the opposition; but the government is supported, because it is the one that has the responsibility and the hard task.

It is true that this year that has happened but, as both parties consider it important, useful, that it has yielded results, I believe we must make the reciprocal exercise of rediscovering the principles of that Pact. And I insist: that Pact has more merit to fulfill when one is in opposition and, as I want to fulfill it also in government, I do not want to engage in polemics with the Popular Party.

I know they are again exercising parliamentary control over it, but I already inform the Popular Party and all citizens that I will not engage in polemics with the Popular Party to fight against terrorism. I will only thank them, do what they do and say what they say, that they also have the will, as they do, to end terrorism, which is what the government tries to do every day.

P.J. Ramírez .- Mr. President, on December 13, in your appearance before the 11-M Commission, you accused the previous Aznar government of nothing less than mass deception of all Spaniards. In a recent video, Mr. Aznar's Foundation says that you came to power through anti-democratic coercion. Do you not think that, as a tribute to the victims, you should set aside these accusations and collaborate in the search for the truth of what happened, for the whole truth? How is it possible that your party is intent on closing the 11-M Commission and how is it possible that you are vetoing appearances that may be very useful for clarifying the facts?

President .- I will make some clarifications. The first, and Pedro J. Ramírez surely knows this, the 11-M Investigation Commission is already, at this point, the longest-lasting in the history of democracy in our country.

Second, many people have appeared before that Commission, but there has been an exceptional fact: that a former President of the Government has appeared and the President of the Government has appeared. I appeared, being on the tragic day of 11-M simply the leader of the opposition, for fourteen hours to answer all questions. There have been 500 submissions of documentation that has been requested and I reiterate what I said that day in the Commission: the terrorist tragedy of 11-M is very clear. It comes from and its responsible parties were radical Islamist terrorists.

Furthermore, I will add: in an attack of such characteristics, of such magnitude, which can be compared to some of those that have occurred, the task of clarifying the truth and the investigation that has been carried out within our State Security Forces and Justice is unparalleled. Today we have a case file that runs to forty thousand pages, with ninety people charged and over twenty people in provisional detention. Practically everything is known.

From that case file, three clear things are established: first, all those responsible, authors or instigators belong to what we could call radical Islamist terrorism with links or inspiration from Al Qaeda; second, in an investigation reflected in more than forty thousand pages, there is not a single piece of evidence that allows for the hypothesis of any collaboration with another terrorist group; third, there has never been, never, since March 11, since the tragic attack, a single lead that did not lead to radical Islamist terrorism.

That is why I reiterate today, with even more strength, with more conviction, what I said in the March 11 Commission, regarding the tragic attack of March 11.

Now, it is true that some may ask for it to be extended indefinitely in search of a truth that does not exist, and in search of a truth that does not exist, how many years should we be with the Investigation Commission? One, three, five, a hundred? When we have all the overwhelming data of what happened, as overwhelming as the fact that from March 11 to March 14, the Government, with the information it had, did not tell the truth to the citizens of this country.

M. Sáenz Díez.- Mr. President, we are in an effective Rule of Law and, logically, and you have recognized it, the Government has information, good information, about ETA, and you as President must have it about the leftist abertzale that does not kill, but also does not condemn violence. You recently reiterated your refusal when asked if you maintain contacts or conversations with that sector of the leftist abertzale that does not condemn violence, but does not kill, because these differences are sometimes not made sufficiently clear. My question is why be so scandalized if one day you talk to that sector in the short, medium, or long term. Why such a scandal if you dialogue with a sector that, after all, will be key at some point in the search for peace? Why so many torn garments?

President.- There is one thing that is evident: for any Government in this country, of whatever political color, its first great objective, its first great desire, which is the absolute, majority desire of Spanish society, is to see the end of the terrorism that has caused us so much suffering for more than thirty years, and peace in Euskadi and in Spain.

I have said on some occasions that every day we are closer to seeing the end of terrorism and peace. And I have that conviction for something evident, which is that in Basque society every day there are more people who want peace, who fight for peace, and every day there are more people, those who may have looked the other way or had another idea, who are against and want to see the end of violence, and that politics should only be resolved with words and democracy.

I can say that I find it surprising to see leaders of the Popular Party making insinuations about dialogues or conversations with the terrorist group ETA. I want to reiterate that there are none. And I say that I find it surprising because in the collective memory of this country, the last negotiation that took place with the terrorist group ETA was made by the government of Mr. Aznar in 1998. With the best intentions? Certainly. In search of the end of violence? Certainly. By the way, with the support of all parties? Undoubtedly. Undoubtedly.

And now I want the Spanish people to reflect on this. Without the Government having any negotiation process with ETA, this Government is being criticized by those who did negotiate with ETA for supposedly opening an expectation of dialogue or negotiation with ETA. Believe me, I could say that this is a tremendous hypocrisy.

I want to call for responsibility and add to the entire citizenry, in light of this question, that the Government, my Government, because I believe it is the desire of all Spaniards, will do everything in its power, within the Rule of Law and what is politics, to see the end of violence; that those who kill, who extort, and who have caused terror will only be "heard," I repeat "heard," by democracy and by the Government if they are willing to leave violence behind and open a process of democratization, peace, and reconciliation in Euskadi, which I believe would be enormously satisfying for the Basques and for all Spaniards.

But, if there is the opportunity, my duty as President of the Government, my duty, is to make every political effort, as previous governments did. And I hope that, if that scenario arrives, all parties will rise to the occasion, as we did in other circumstances.

C. Álvarez de Toledo.- With all due responsibility, Mr. President, I will give you a very, very brief timeline: In November of last year, Batasuna, in Anoeta, asks to negotiate with the Government for self-determination and says that there are no shortcuts. In January of this year, Otegi, on the day you meet with Rajoy to negotiate, asks you to be the Spanish Blair because you are a statesman, and says that everyone must decide. On February 1, during the debate on the Ibarretxe Plan, you say that if we live together, we must decide together. Seven days later, ETA says that we are on the brink of a political change and limitless negotiation, and that it takes into account your words, but above all your actions.

After the elections in the Basque Country, you, the Socialist Party, the Government, say that there are no shortcuts, that there will be dialogue without exclusion, that we must know how to play the game, that we are in a new time to achieve peace, that this will be a long process and that we must take decisive steps towards the end of violence.

Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, Mr. President, is self-determination a limit? Is the amnesty of prisoners a limit?

President.- I will tell you one clear thing: the limit is the Constitution and democracy, and the limit is the rules of the game. No one will play in democracy if they do not respect the rules of democracy, no one will play in politics if they do not condemn and abandon, in their case, violence. Of course, the future of the entire Basque society and the future of our entire country will be decided by all of us together, the Basque society and the Spanish society to which it belongs. Those are the clear, forceful principles that I expressed on the day of the debate on the Ibarretxe Plan and that I will maintain with the best attitude, but with all firmness.

P.J. Ramírez.- Mr. President, Aznar said "Spain is doing well," and economically it was doing well; Zapatero says: "Spain is doing better." We already know that you are always very optimistic. There are economists who say that very difficult times are coming, because foreign trade is doing very poorly, because foreign investment is falling, because we are losing competitiveness, and because the inflation differential with the European Union is increasing while the growth differential is decreasing. Time will tell.

But I ask you a very specific question in front of this audience and in front of the viewers. Are you in a position to guarantee that, at the end of the Legislature, that is, in three years, Spain will continue to grow and create jobs, at least at the current rates?

President.- We are in the best conditions to continue growing economically and to create jobs. I simply want to make a telegraphic description of data.

P.J. Ramírez.- But commit yourself.

President.- Yes, yes. When we came to power, we were growing at 2.5 percent; now we are growing at 3 percent; in one year, 400,000 jobs have been created, and after a moment of depression, unemployment has begun to decrease again in our country.

I can say that 2005 is going to be a very good year for economic growth, that we will be at 3 or above 3 percent, and a very good year for job growth. We now have the great task of stable employment, which is within the framework of social dialogue. I hope that before the end of the year there will be a great agreement between employers and unions, which the Government will support, to convert much of the precarious employment that exists in this country into stable employment, which particularly affects young people.

We are in a position, and the Government commits to growing economically in the coming years, until the end of the Legislature, and to creating jobs.

And I will say: Deutsche Bank, which is the most important German bank, has just released a study on the projection for the next fifteen years of all developed economies and has said that the three best of all developed economies will be, in the next fifteen years, Ireland, the United States, and Spain.

We are in a very good moment from an economic point of view. We need to improve some things, such as foreign trade; we are pulling very strongly on imports, because there is a 9 percent growth in investments in capital goods, and when there is such a high percentage of investment in capital goods, it is a guarantee of medium-term growth. We need to improve our foreign trade, but I will point out one fact: it is the second best, despite the decline, in all of the European Union. And regarding foreign investments, I simply wanted to say that in 2004 they were better than in 2003 and to say that American investments in Spain have grown by 29 percent and have a very positive outlook for the future.

P.J. Ramírez.- May I show the President a headline? It will be the first time that the director of "El Mundo" displays a headline from the newspaper "El País." According to our colleagues today, Spain lost more than 10 billion euros in foreign investment last year. Therefore, at least on this point, all the newspapers said that foreign investment in Spain has fallen by 47 percent.

President.- It is less than what has fallen in the vast majority of the European Union, and in the data as such, we should distinguish between direct investments or portfolio investments. Direct investments are those that involve investing more than 10 percent of the shareholding of companies. I give the data because it is significant: American investment, an increase of 29 percent. The Government has also launched an agency for attracting foreign investments.

But, overall, we have an economy with solid foundations, which needs to improve its productivity and competitiveness, and we need to improve, above all, our technological capital, our research, our development, and our innovation. That is the great objective of the Government at this moment in economic matters.

And I will say that one of my objectives has been fulfilled, which is to see the director of "El Mundo" wielding a newspaper like "El País."

P.J. Ramírez.- I hope there will be reciprocity.

M. Sáenz Díez.- Mr. President, I will be very brief in this question, because Pedro J. has taken all the seconds available.

In this economic framework, there are still really starvation wages. When will there be a Minimum Interprofessional Wage that covers the minimum needs, and I say this redundantly?

President.- I simply want to give one piece of data: in the first year of this Government, this Government has raised minimum pensions and the Minimum Wage more than had been raised in a single year in the last twenty years of democracy: minimum pensions, between 6 and 8 percent, double the average increase in pensions. We will do this every year until we raise minimum pensions—affecting more than three million people, of which two million are women—throughout the legislature to reach a 23 percent increase in pensions.

The Minimum Wage has increased by 13 percent in just one year, this year, after having lost purchasing power in previous years. And we will reach the commitment, signed with the unions, of 600 euros, which brings us closer to the European average.

This country, by the way, has the economic merit it has and has the expectation of growth because Spaniards work a lot—we are the second country in the European Union, after Greece, in terms of hours worked—and because, fortunately, we have today a generation of young and mature people who are well-educated, well-equipped for talent, for knowledge, and with an evident capacity for commitment.

And we have, and we will improve every year, respecting public accounts, the lowest wages, and we will continue to increase scholarships, as we have already done in the first year—20,000 more scholarships—and better conditions for some scholarship circumstances, and of course, increasing the Minimum Interprofessional Wage. And all this while raising pensions as we have raised them, with the Social Security reserve fund, which in one year has increased by 50 percent, and at this moment we have almost 24 billion euros in the reserve fund of Social Security, in case there is any delicate moment to pay our pensioners, which is the first obligation, I believe, of all society and, of course, of the Government.

C. Álvarez de Toledo .- Let's talk about housing. The CIS says that housing is the only problem that you are going to fix worse than the previous governments, than the governments of the Popular Party. Setting aside demagoguery, ministerial housing, etc., etc., what I want to ask you is: Mr. President, is Spain not in an economic position to guarantee the right to housing with something more than housing solutions or 30 square meter apartments? Do you still have confidence in Minister Trujillo?

President .- Housing policy was a goal in the electoral campaign, in the electoral program, and it is a goal of the Government.

I want to say in what three lines we have acted, from a perspective that everyone understands, which is that a strictly political act of government will is not the same as, for example, withdrawing troops from Iraq, as mobilizing public land for housing construction, which takes time. I believe everyone sees it and it is absolutely understandable.

But I will simply provide some data: in the year we have been in government, as of March, there are 33 percent more homes that have public financing within the Housing Plan, approaching 160,000 homes that have some type of assistance as a result of the Shock Plan.

Second, this is the first government, and I say this emphatically, that has decided to mobilize the public land of the State, the land that the State has, clearly in favor of protected housing or public assistance housing in operations throughout Spain from the Ministry of Defense, RENFE, Fomento...; from what the Central Government has available. And there are very significant operations, such as, for example, the operation here in Madrid, in Campamento, where the Government is ceding a lot of public land, which belongs to Defense. The urban development process has already been set in motion after so many years of waiting, and where 70 percent of the homes that will result from that urban reform will be public promotion housing. The homes, obviously, after giving all that land, take time to be built.

Third, we are mobilizing rental housing, because Spain has the lowest rental data, and in the reform of the Housing Plan that we are going to present in just a few days, there will be an absolute priority for rental housing for young people and also, in the Plan, a priority for social groups that need more support, such as, for example, as a result of the Comprehensive Law against Gender Violence, women who have suffered gender violence or, for example, disabled people; all of this, I insist, in the next Housing Plan.

Finally, I will say that the expectation the Government has is that in the last year there has already been a slight moderation in the increase in housing prices.

But I want to reiterate here today that it is an essential commitment. The previous government, and for a long time, did not have a Ministry of Housing, because many of the competencies are with the Autonomous Communities, and the Central Government has taken on that commitment to contribute, to help, and to provide the Autonomous Communities and municipalities with more resources, more money, and more land so that there are more homes accessible to citizens.

Of course, I believe that when we have the balance of the Legislature on what is one of the most important social problems, which concerns the Government the most, which is access to housing, especially for young people and low-income families, we will see the results achieved by increasing resources and increasing the land that belongs to the State and that, obviously, will now be able to be developed in many Spanish cities, as is known in each of the places.

V. Jiménez .- Mr. President, it is true that there are economic indicators that invite optimism; others, and you have cited some, not so much. However, these days the Financial Perspectives for the Union until 2013 are being discussed in Europe, and those Perspectives contemplate a progressive loss of a fundamental element for the Spanish economy, such as the Cohesion Funds. My question is what measures your Government plans to adopt from this moment on so that the landing of the Spanish economy, that horizon without the aid of the Cohesion Funds, is not an emergency landing for citizens.

President .- We are undoubtedly going to have a difficult and complex negotiation regarding the Financial Perspectives 2007-2013, that is, what Spain and the other countries will receive from the European Union.

Everyone knows that Spain has been the most benefited country from the funds and cohesion of the European Union, and everyone knows that our growth, our Gross Domestic Product, our per capita income, has been growing and approaching the European average. With the enlargement, there are other countries that will receive more funds and more aid than we do.

What is the Government's objective? The Government's objective is, without a doubt, to improve the proposal of the Commission that it found when it came to power. I want to say that there has been a positive data in recent days, because the proposal that Juncker, the Prime Minister of Luxembourg and President of the Council at this time, has just made public is a proposal that improves the situation for Spain and, above all, recognizes that there is a singular problem for Spain.

Certainly, the Government will only approve Financial Perspectives that allow us to maintain the level of development in terms of investments, in terms of roads and in terms of high-speed rail in a reasonable time, with our best economic growth and with our best public accounts. I want to remind you that we will have in 2005 a scenario of budgetary surplus of our country, and having resolved issues such as the debt of RENFE, or the Izar shipyards, or as we now propose to address the debt of public broadcasting.

Therefore, that is the Government's objective: that the decrease in the aid we receive from Europe, which is absolutely normal, logical, and that no one can dispute will happen, be a reasonable decrease in time, which allows us to maintain our economic growth vigor. My opinion is that this objective can be met.

M. Mendizábal .- From the European Cohesion Funds we are now going to talk about the foreign policy of your Government, because this area is one of the areas where the Executive has most clearly shown its differences with the previous Government.

M. Sáenz Díez .- Mr. President, I assume, and if not correct me, that when you wake up in the morning you do not think, "Will today be the day when President Bush finally has a gesture towards the President of the Government of Spain?" That said, what seems certain is that your attitude towards the President of the United States, apart from the substantive issues, has a certain electoral echo; that is to say, there is a sector of citizens in this country who, how should I put it? enjoy, they like the thrill, that the President of their Government stands up to the President of the United States. Do you think that is a good thing or do you think that, in reality, it is a small deviation that should be corrected and that will ultimately be corrected when you meet with him?

President .- I simply have to say in this regard that Spain's foreign policy is decided by the Government of Spain receiving the popular mandate from the citizens, and the majority of Spaniards expressed in the streets and at the polls that they did not want to be in the war in Iraq. I limited myself to doing what I wanted and had committed to the citizens, which was to withdraw from the war in Iraq.

This, evidently, did not sit well with President Bush. I do not reveal any secret if I affirm that the "feeling" that President Bush and I have is not better, but rather worse, than that which Mr. Aznar and Mr. Bush had. It is evident. But I will add: what is the relationship of concrete matters in the task between the governments of the United States and Spain works normally. We have had in a very short period of time four visits to the United States from four Ministers of the Spanish Government; in the fight against terrorism, in particular. In these hours we are coordinating policies and actions regarding the crisis in Ecuador, and things are functioning normally.

But it is evident that there has been a fundamental disagreement regarding what was a decision about the war in Iraq and the withdrawal of troops, which I would do again today. I would make the same decision again and I will always prioritize, above anything else, the interests and will of the Spaniards in foreign policy, and not the will of any people or any foreign power or any country.

C. Álvarez de Toledo .- Mr. President, in the world, and you know this very well, there are women who cannot exercise their rights. Women in the Western world are a little better; we are not completely well, but we are better. But there are other worlds, other cultures, where women cannot study, cannot vote, cannot show their faces and worse things happen: sexual exploitation, clitoral mutilation; in short, horrible things. Coincidentally, this usually occurs in cultures that are not Western. You, who have advocated for the alliance between cultures, for the Alliance of Civilizations, would you be in favor of alliance or belligerence with these civilizations?

President .- I am in favor of an alliance of civilizations and I fully agree with the speech you make about the absolutely unacceptable role that women have in many countries of the Arab world, of the Islamic world. So much so that on March 22, when I was invited by the Arab League, one of the essential things I stated in the speech before all the Heads of State and Government of the Arab world was that the equality of men and women was essential to live in democracy, to progress, and to achieve well-being.

What do we have to do? We have to push, force, demand, and ensure that with economic development, with development, dialogue, and cooperation, the values of modernity, secularization, and, of course, above all, the value of equality of women in relation to men advance, because the societies that live best, that are freer, are those where there is more equality, and those that live worst are where women have been in a worse situation.

But I want to say that our culture has also had, at many moments in its history, an attitude of domination and discrimination against women. The truth is that it was not resolved with violent actions, but by resorting to dialogue, modernization, and cooperation.

We cannot confront civilizations; what we need to do is improve the civilization that marginalizes women where there is still no full democracy, force it, pressure it, incentivize it. That will be the future; otherwise, we will be facing the prophecy of the clash of civilizations that will lead to confrontation and violence. It is about understanding the historical moment of the other and helping them to open the paths to reach democracy and equality between men and women. The other path, as we know from history, only leads to misfortune, war, and suffering.

V. Jiménez .- Mr. President, Spain was the first European country to ratify the new European Constitution in a referendum. That referendum was, in a way, a personal endeavor of yours, and we now find ourselves with the fact that in France another referendum is going to be held in a short period of time, and the polls indicate a victory for the "no." My question is twofold: what will happen to the future of Europe if that negative vote is confirmed in the French referendum? And, secondly, what will you, the European leaders, do in the event that "no" occurs?

President .- What is happening in France with its referendum produces three considerations: the first, satisfaction, deep satisfaction, for how the Spaniards, by a majority of more than 70 percent and with a significant turnout, said "yes" to the European Constitution project.

Second, we must have an attitude of expectation until the French citizens vote. I, of course, am going to contribute my small grain of sand and I am going to France to ask for the vote for "yes," because it is good for Europe, for our well-being, and for France as well. I believe that it is not the right path to set the stage for what will happen the next day.

Europe has never stopped; Europe, in its history, has always advanced, at some moments with more speed and at others almost at a slow pace, and there have been difficult moments. Certainly, I am fully convinced that Europeans will rise to the occasion of what the European Union entails, and I still have the expectation of seeing what happens in the referendum in France when the time of truth, the time of voting, arrives. Do not make me remember that polls are often very wrong.

Therefore, let us not think about what will happen in the next match of the Champions League until the one that is currently being played, which is the French referendum, is over. Let us wait for the referendum.

P.J. Ramírez .- Mr. President, you just said that you would withdraw the troops from Iraq again, and you know very well what my opinion is on that matter. But in foreign policy, gestures are also very important, and that is why I want to ask you two very specific questions, and please answer me, if possible, also in a concrete manner. If you could turn back time, would you behave in front of the American flag the same way you did on October 12, 2003? Second question, would you make statements, like the ones you made in Tunisia, urging other countries to withdraw their troops from Iraq, as you did on September 9, 2004?

President .- Like everything in life, it requires nuances. First, regarding the flag, which has been much talked about, I want to remind you what happened that day, as I have explained to American authorities on more than one occasion, who were evidently unaware.

We were at a parade of our Armed Forces in commemoration of October 12. Suddenly, without it being on the program, in the midst of the most heated debate about the war in Iraq in our country, the previous government, the government of Mr. Aznar, decided that the flags of the allied countries with Spain in the war in Iraq would parade, without announcement, as a surprise and in an act of homage and recognition, not to one flag or another, but to what those flags represented, which was the offensive of the Iraq War. Of course, I will never applaud nor did I applaud what was that military intervention against the will of the majority of Spaniards and many societies in all countries.

Therefore, I did not act in a disrespectful manner towards the American flag, to which I have all the respect, as I do for all flags, especially in a country like North America, as the director of "El Mundo" knows very well, where freedom reaches the point where the Constitution protects the burning of the American flag itself. I have a deep...

P.J. Ramírez .- I hope you are not proposing that policy for Spain.

President .- No, not at all.

But as an example of my admiration for the culture of freedom and democracy towards the United States.

I did not stand up to applaud the war in Iraq; that is what I did. By the way, I had an attitude of respect towards the flag. What happened is that in the stand where we were—there were almost all members of the Government—when it was announced over the loudspeaker "and here parades a representation of troops and the flags that are in the war in Iraq," how would I have seen myself and how would the citizens have seen me applauding what was a tribute to those who were in the war in Iraq?

P.J. Ramírez .- You could have stood up.

President .- One only stood up when applauding. That is the important nuance.

Secondly, regarding the statements in Tunisia. I want to clarify, and I said the other day in an interview, that I could have made them more fortunate, it is true. But I will simply add: of course, if I am asked whether other countries should withdraw, because there had been an announcement of troop withdrawal from Iraq from one country, how can I criticize a country, another country, for withdrawing—many have withdrawn, by the way, and several have announcements of withdrawal at this moment—their troops from Iraq? At no time did I want to make a call, because I respect those who have gone and taken troops to Iraq, just as I ask for respect for this Government that withdrew the troops from Iraq. I ask to be respected, because I have respected all countries, and I have a very good relationship with all countries and leaders who have wanted to be in Iraq. Respect for respect.

But, to get to the point, I could have been more fortunate in the statement.

M. Mendizábal .- After talking about foreign policy, we will return to talk about national policy, because the reform of the Statute of Catalonia or the Ibarretxe Plan in the Basque Country have occupied a large part of the territorial debates this year. These are some of the topics we want to address in this last section dedicated to territorial policy.

C. Álvarez de Toledo .- Mr. President, five years ago—you will remember—at the Hostal San Marcos in León, I interviewed you, by the way for "El Mundo"—I was then at "El Mundo"—where you told me that Almunia and the PSOE had lost for not knowing how to defend a "certain idea of Spain" and you then demanded an imperative agreement with the Popular Party. You were in opposition, and now we are in the opposite situation: you are in government but do not want to negotiate with the PP the reform of the Statutes and do not seek agreement. How is it possible to build that Spain without counting on the other half? How is it possible to break the constitutional consensus? How is it possible to ignore that the Constitution was based on the great agreement between the Socialist Party and the UCD of that time, the center-right?

President .- I am going to refute some of your assertions that presuppose a conclusion. The first of them, as President of the Government, I must say that the balance of autonomous Spain is a balance of successes. The intense process of political decentralization and recognition of identities has been very good.

Second, in that process there have been agreements and disagreements. There have been Statutes of Autonomy that were not supported at the time by Alianza Popular, now the Popular Party, the heir in name. The constitutional process was not supported by some sectors, also of the right in some parts. Therefore, it is not true that there has been agreement at all times.

That said, the structure of the State, the reforms that may be proposed in the area of the Statutes or the Constitution, as the Government has proposed some—regarding the territorial aspect, the reform of the Senate—must have the maximum agreement and consensus possible. That is my will, and that is why we are going to work.

In the reform of the Statutes? In most places, there must be agreement between the PP and the PSOE, because they are the two political forces that are in the regional parliaments. There is a Statute reform underway in Valencia, promoted by the Valencian government of the PP, which is being negotiated with the PSOE; there is a Statute reform underway in the Canary Islands, governed by Coalición Canaria, which is supported by the PP and the PSOE; and there is a Statute reform in Catalonia.

What conditions does the Government impose? From a perspective favorable to reforms, because whoever reforms the Statute, like whoever wants to reform the Constitution, is living in the Statute and living in the Constitution.

Twenty-five years later, can things be changed? Of course. Can self-government be improved? Of course. Are there new aspects of social reality where the Autonomous Communities can do new things? Of course. Do we need to strengthen mechanisms of cooperation and dialogue? Of course. For example, in the previous stage, it was very strange and rare to see the President of the Government meeting with the regional Presidents; now dialogue is guaranteed with the Conference of Presidents and, of course, with bilateral dialogue.

Therefore, is there a reform of the Statutes, which is at the initiative of the Autonomous Communities? Yes. Two elements, two clear principles: maximum consensus—I am in favor of two-thirds for consensus in the reform of the Statutes, which some require and others do not, just like for the reform of the Constitution—and, of course, respect for constitutional principles.

But let us have a positive perspective. The reforms we have ahead can still help self-government, and therefore the development of each Autonomous Community, or each nationality, or each region, and can strengthen this Spain, fortunately plural and diverse, that we have, which has the richness of different languages and has an evident plurality.

C. Álvarez de Toledo .- But is the agreement with the PP still imperative?

President .- Autonomous Spain has been favorable, above all, to the less developed territories in historical terms, to those who never had a voice; to regions like Extremadura, like Castilla-La Mancha, like Andalucía, which thanks to autonomy and self-government have had a voice and have narrowed their differences in development, in growth, or in Gross Domestic Product in relation to the more developed Communities in these twenty-five years.

That is the balance of autonomy in our country, which is not only favorable to the identity of each one, but also has a permanent background of solidarity and cohesion. And that will continue to be the case, because it is the will of the vast majority of Spaniards.

V. Jiménez .- Mr. President, I believe I will not discover anything if I say that you have a certain taste for risk when making some decisions, and I think that is evident in the withdrawal of troops from Iraq or the issue of same-sex marriage.

Continuing along this line of somewhat risky decisions, you have said, and you have reiterated here just now, that you are willing to endorse those statutory reforms that reach the Spanish Parliament with broad consensus and, moreover, are respectful of the current legal framework. My question is: will you endorse, and will the party that supports you, a reform such as the Catalan one that could reach the Spanish Parliament with broad consensus but that proposed the modification or reform of four organic laws, with a specific financing proposal? Are you willing to endorse such a reform?

President .- In such a serious matter as the reform of the Statute of Catalonia or any Statute reform, allow me to say that we cannot, and less so the President of the Government, be pronouncing all day about a specific proposal that is in the reform process.

The work of the commission of the Parliament of Catalonia has not yet finished. It has to go through the Commission and has to go through the plenary of the Parliament of Catalonia, if it reaches the two-thirds majority, to come to the national Parliament.

I do want to say that I am in favor of the highest level of self-government for the Communities in this country and that, as favorable and flexible as I am, I will be absolutely firm and resolute in maintaining the constitutional elements of cohesion and sovereignty in what represents the national Parliament; that is, the sovereignty of all Spaniards to decide on the future of all, which is that of each of the Communities and that of the whole.

P.J. Ramírez .- Yes, Mr. President; but since you have been at the head of the Government, the Telecommunications Commission has moved to Catalonia, the Salamanca Archive is going to be fragmented to go to Catalonia, the Meteorological Service is going to fragment part of it for Catalonia; even films will have to be dubbed in Catalan, apparently mandatorily; and the Valencians and Murcians will not receive water from the Ebro because Catalonia does not want it. But what is happening, Mr. President? Do all Spaniards have a huge historical debt, even the poorer Communities, with rich Catalonia? Or are your partners from Esquerra and the PSC holding you more tightly than it seems?

President .- Ah! I thought you could say... I believe we should have a vision and an adequate understanding of what the State of Autonomies and the State is.

First of all, that the Telecommunications Market Commission is in Catalonia means that there is a presence of the State in Catalonia. That is a decision that the Government has made, like others from other agencies that are going to be established in the territory of our country and not only in the capital, because everything is State and wherever there is a State agency, the State is there and Spain is there. That is a good policy of cohesion and unity. I do not care if it is in Catalonia, as in Castilla y León, where a National Institute of Communication Technologies is going to be established, which is obviously from the central Government, as in other places in the territory of our country this Government practices and wants to carry out a decentralizing policy.

Secondly, Catalonia has a profound will for self-government, an identity, and moreover, it is a Community that has contributed and continues to contribute modernization, development, and growth to our country. And I want to say, and I say it here, in Madrid, because this is to make a reasonable explanation of our coexistence and to alert against the demagogy of those who wield one flag against another flag or one territory against another territory, that Catalonia, the Catalan citizens, contribute a lot to the whole of what public accounts of the State represent, and that should be the case. But if that is the case, at least let us say it clearly and not engage in demagogy, neither with flags, nor with languages, nor with territories and the different identities.

If we have autonomous flags and identities, it is for the good of this country, and the flags are there to be displayed, to demonstrate, not to be put against others. If we have languages, a wealth of languages in this country, in addition to the great value of having Spanish, it is to understand each other and not to confront each other. And if we have a plurality of identities, it is to enjoy that plurality among all, knowing that there is a country, a State, that guarantees the common project and that also guarantees solidarity.

I will make a nuance that I think is also important: economic solidarity, let’s say, between territories and people in a state like ours is not primarily discussed in the economic financing model, where the margins are small to meet the needs of each government in education, in health care, etc., etc.; the great solidarity of our political system is the public social security system, it is the pension system, it is the unemployment system.

Notice to what extent it is solidarity: when we made the decision this year to raise minimum pensions above the average, by 8.3 percent, do you know who that primarily benefits in a state policy? It benefits the less favored territories, because that is where the lowest pensions are. Against a 50 or 55 percent that there may be of pensioners with minimum pensions in Extremadura, in Álava there may be 15 or 20 percent.

That is the great instrument of personal and territorial solidarity and that, as it is known, is a public system for the whole country...

P.J. Ramírez.- The issue of demagogy would not be directed at my question, Mr. President.

President.- No, obviously. What I have said is that, and I want to say it here today, before you and as many citizens are watching us, I have a deep distrust, in general, of those politicians, to whom I was referring, who wield the territorial confrontation of identities or languages in the public debate. They are instruments of coexistence, of great collective coexistence, which since we have been free, that is, since we have democracy, we have known how to forge, enrich, benefit from each other; to have the pride of having the Extremaduran flag, the Extremadurans; the Catalan identity, the Catalans...

And, so that you don’t tell me that I am leaving something out, regarding the "Salamanca papers" I want to say two things about it: first, what are the funds, the Archive, remains 100 percent in Salamanca, except for 3 percent of the originals; second, those "papers" were seized from a legitimate and constituted institution, which was the Generalitat of Catalonia during the time of the Second Republic, and they were seized precisely to carry out certain actions that, of course, cannot fill us with pride as Spaniards in our most recent history.

P.J. Ramírez.- There are many things that do not fill us with pride; many things, Mr. President.

President.- Those funds were seized illegally and it is good that to recover what is the sense of things and memory they are in the institution from which they were seized.

Moreover, I know, and I am convinced, yes, I am convinced, that this decision is a decision that advances in the good understanding of what represents a common project. They are state funds -- I say state or central government -- that are in Salamanca that were seized from a Generalitat at a time of legitimacy, in a coup process that later ended in the dramatic Civil War of our country.

M. Sáenz Díez.- Do you know what I am telling you, President? That, frankly, all those who try to assimilate an Autonomous Community of this country with pencil pushers, bloodsuckers, usurpers of the poorest or sweeping for themselves, are really going to make the story of the bogeyman true because, by constantly saying "the bogeyman is coming, the bogeyman is coming," it is later demonstrated that this bogeyman does not exist. It is a personal reflection that I wanted to convey at this moment.

But since we are, I suppose, talking about Catalonia, I would like to ask one thing regarding the Catalan President, Pasqual Maragall, because yesterday, precisely, his Minister Jordi Sevilla, the head of Public Administrations, expressed, I believe, a reflection that seems very sincere to me, but I wanted to know your opinion. Sevilla said yesterday: "Pasqual Maragall has had the courage to voice what many thought in whispers and, in fact, did not dare to." Do you share this opinion?

President.- Yes. I believe that everyone can confirm that Pasqual Maragall is a person who exercises freedom of thought and freedom of expression actively and continuously, who has expressed on many occasions his fidelity and loyalty to a common project called Spain, and who has expressed on many occasions that he wants to see Catalonia in the command position of what is Spain; that he wants to influence, that he wants to weigh in, and that he wants to be an important part of development and progress, as, by the way, and legitimately, all the governments of Autonomous Communities want. This is my experience and -- it could be the President of a Community like Valencia or La Rioja -- everyone wants to have an impact and everyone wants to weigh in.

And I add more: in this country, from my experience as President of the Government, to govern it harmoniously, it must be done by counting on the autonomous governments. By counting on the autonomous governments, in an open dialogue, where things are discussed, undoubtedly there will be better progress. And the state, which is primarily represented by the central government, is and will always be the guarantor of cohesion and solidarity, that is, of the principle of equality of Spanish citizens, regardless of where they are born and where they live.

M. Mendizábal.- Mr. President, this interview has come to an end. I thank you, to begin with, for submitting to the questions of such a diverse range of opinions as were represented here today and, of course, for attending this appointment with "59 seconds."

President.- I am willing to return.

M. Mendizábal.- We appreciate it very much.